5th Grade Writing Prompts
102 writing prompts for fifth graders. Each one follows a story, so kids start with ideas instead of a blank page. Read the story first, then write.
Leo had to choose between speaking up for himself and protecting his friendship. Was his final choice the right one? Explain your opinion using at least three pieces of evidence from the story, and describe what you might have done differently.
From the story ๐๏ธ Two Names on the Cover ยท Level 1 ยท Friends ยท Art
Ruby had to balance her grandfather's wish to be independent with her mother's wish to keep him safe. Whose side were you on during the story, and did that change by the end? Use evidence from at least two chapters to explain your thinking.
From the story ๐ The House That Said Yes ยท Level 1 ยท Humor ยท Robots ยท Family
Sigrun's grandfather says that "a place you love doesn't stop being yours when you leave it." Do you agree? Use details from the story and from your own life to explain your answer.
From the story ๐ง The Puffin Counter ยท Level 1 ยท Animals ยท Islands ยท Family
Kasia decided to graft the trees without asking her father first. Was that the right choice? Explain both sides, using details from the story, and then say what you would have done and why.
From the story ๐ The Grafting Knife ยท Level 1 ยท Farm ยท Family ยท Nature
Tavita didn't want her grandmother's patterns used "just as decoration." Explain why this mattered so much to her, using evidence from the story. Then describe something from your own family or culture that has a meaning other people might not know.
From the story ๐จ The Village Cloth ยท Level 1 ยท School ยท Art ยท Culture
Ruth's choice cost her team a trophy. Some people might say it was the wrong choice because it hurt her teammates. Others would say it was the only right choice. Explain both sides, then give your own opinion with evidence from the story.
From the story ๐๐พโโ๏ธ The Hill at Mile Two ยท Level 1 ยท Sports ยท Forest ยท Family
At the start of the story, Ji-woo is embarrassed by her grandmother. By the end, she chooses her as a family hero. Explain what caused this change, using at least three events from the story as evidence.
From the story ๐ The Sea Women's Whistle ยท Level 1 ยท Ocean ยท Culture ยท Islands
Darius chose to join Silver Harmonics, but he did it in a careful way. Do you think he made a good decision? Explain your answer with evidence from the story, and describe a time when you had to choose between something new and something familiar.
From the story ๐ฅ The Panyard on Carib Street ยท Level 1 ยท Music ยท Culture ยท Islands
Wes's dad says, "Both of those things are true. That's what makes it hard." Choose a problem from the story or from real life where two people both have good reasons. Explain each side fairly, using details, and then say what solution you think is best.
From the story ๐ฆ Four Notes in the Dark ยท Level 1 ยท Nature ยท Forests ยท Family
Ingrid could have hidden the chalk mark, but she chose not to. Was this a brave choice, a risky choice, or both? Use evidence from the story to explain your answer, and describe what you think you would have done.
From the story ๐ข The Chalk Mark ยท Level 1 ยท History ยท Journeys ยท Family
Ravi chose the buyer who offered less money. Was that fair to his family? Explain both sides, using evidence from the story, and then say what you would have done and why.
From the story ๐ช The Long Walk to Pushkar ยท Level 1 ยท Animals ยท Journeys ยท Culture
Kofi had to decide what to tell the museum board. Do you think he handled it well? Using evidence from the story, explain what he did, what else he could have done, and which choice you think was best.
From the story ๐ผ๏ธ The Crooked Frames ยท Level 1 ยท Mystery ยท Art ยท Islands
Do you think Seedling Unit Nine was really "learning," or was it only copying Nadia and her grandfather? Use evidence from the story to support your opinion, and explain whether it matters.
From the story ๐ฑ Seedling Unit Nine ยท Level 1 ยท Sci-fi ยท Robots ยท Forests
Tilelli's grandmother says she misses the long walks to the well, even though they were hard. Why might someone miss something difficult? Use evidence from the story and an example from your own life to explain.
From the story ๐ซ๏ธ The Fog Catchers ยท Level 1 ยท Village ยท Science ยท Family
The Wind-Keeper says, "Strength is easy. Knowing when not to use it is the hard part." What do you think she means? Use examples from Isa's journey and from your own life to explain your answer.
From the story ๐ The Wind-Keeper's Bell ยท Level 1 ยท Fantasy ยท Islands ยท Journeys
Imani had to choose where to live, knowing either choice would make someone she loved sad. Do you think she made the right choice? Explain why, using evidence from at least three parts of the story.
From the story ๐ The Long Way West ยท Level 1 ยท Family ยท Journeys
Halcyon says it does not want to be "smuggled away" but would rather end with "the light still on." Do you think it was right to accept being shut down? Explain your opinion with evidence from the story, and consider both Wren's feelings and Halcyon's.
From the story ๐ผ The Keeper of Gannet Rock ยท Level 1 ยท Sci-fi ยท Robots ยท Islands
Eli was afraid that telling the truth would get the bear hurt, but the truth turned out to be what saved her. Was Eli right to tell his mother what he had done? Use at least two details from the story to explain your answer, and describe a time when telling the truth was hard but important.
From the story ๐ปโโ๏ธ The Bear in the Shed ยท Level 2 ยท Animals ยท Polar
Mr. Pruitt acted grumpy about the fire department, but his secret donation told a different story. Why do you think some people hide their kindness? Use evidence from the story to explain Mr. Pruitt's reasons, then tell whether you think it is better to give openly or secretly, and why.
From the story ๐ถ The Dog Who Ran for Mayor ยท Level 2 ยท Humor ยท Village
Hana had a chance to let her rival fail, and she chose to help him instead. Do you think she made the right choice, even though it may have cost her first place? Give at least two reasons from the story, and explain what you would have done in her place.
From the story ๐ The Second-Best Invention ยท Level 2 ยท Friends ยท Inventors
Josie's grandfather told her, "The team is only as fast as the dog that's hurting." What do you think he meant, and how does this idea apply to people as well as dogs? Use details from the story and one example from your own life or a team you know.
From the story ๐ท The Dog at the Front ยท Level 2 ยท Sports ยท Polar
Wayra's father and grandmother both had good reasons for the way they farmed. Explain each of their points of view, using evidence from the story. Then decide which ideas from each side the family should keep, and explain why.
From the story ๐ฅ The Potato That Makes You Cry ยท Level 2 ยท Farm ยท Culture ยท Ancient Civilizations
Leah's grandfather kept his failing eyesight a secret, and Leah had to decide whether to keep it too. Was Leah right to tell her mother, even though her grandfather asked her not to? Explain both sides, then give your opinion with at least two reasons from the story.
From the story ๐งญ The Snowdrifts Point Home ยท Level 2 ยท Culture ยท Polar ยท Family
The village had to choose between bright lights that would bring more visitors and a dark cave that would protect the olms. Ana found a third way. Explain the problem from both sides, then describe Ana's solution and decide whether you think it was fair to everyone. Use details from the story.
From the story ๐ฆ The Dragon in the Dark ยท Level 2 ยท Nature ยท Caves
Each narrator in this story told the truth but left something out. Choose one narrator and explain what they left out and why. Then explain why the author might have chosen to tell this mystery through three different people instead of one.
From the story ๐๏ธ Three Witnesses and a Broken City ยท Level 2 ยท Mystery ยท School
Grandpa Hiro believed for many years that sea otters were the enemy, but he learned he was wrong. Explain how the otters, the urchins and the kelp are connected, using details from the story. Then write about why it can be hard for people to change their minds, and what helped Grandpa change his.
From the story ๐ฆฆ The Forest Under the Waves ยท Level 2 ยท Ocean ยท Family ยท Nature
Rosa's father and the other workers built something beautiful that almost nobody ever saw. Why do you think Rosa hid the tile with her father's name? What does the story suggest about the people who build cities? Use details from both Rosa's and Kwame's chapters to support your answer.
From the story ๐ The Ghost Station ยท Level 2 ยท Cities ยท History ยท Mystery
The clay envelope protected the truth because no one could change the words inside without breaking it. Why do you think people needed ways to protect written records? Think of a way we protect important information today, and compare it to the clay envelope. Use details from the story.
From the story ๐ The Tablet Inside the Tablet ยท Level 2 ยท History ยท School ยท Ancient Civilizations
Most people in 1854 believed that bad air caused cholera, and many did not believe Dr. Snow even after he showed them his evidence. Why do you think it can be hard for people to accept a new idea, even when the evidence is strong? Use at least two examples from the story to explain your answer.
From the story ๐ฐ The Handle of the Broad Street Pump ยท Level 2 ยท History ยท Mystery ยท Cities
Lola Pilar chose to let her brother put his name on her invention. Mara first thought this was a terrible unfairness, but later she saw it differently. Do you think Lola Pilar made the right choice? Explain what she gained and what she lost, using evidence from both the letters and Mara's chapters.
From the story ๐ง๏ธ The Rain Latch ยท Level 2 ยท Family ยท Inventors ยท History
The adults on Halcyon Station thought the knocking was an attack, but Tavi discovered it was a warning. Why do you think the adults misunderstood the creatures? Write about a time when someone's actions were misunderstood, and explain how listening carefully could change what happens. Use details from the story.
From the story ๐ช The Knocking Under Europa ยท Level 2 ยท Sci-Fi ยท Ocean ยท Polar
Both Undermere and Arlo's village told frightening stories about each other that were not true. Why do you think people created and kept these stories? Explain how the stories once helped and later harmed both peoples, using evidence from the story.
From the story ๐ The City That Forgot the Sun ยท Level 2 ยท Fantasy ยท Caves
Ayesha never learns why the tiny fish was carved under the hoof, but the reader knows. Why do you think the author chose to tell the story in two time periods? What does Ayesha understand about the past by the end, even without the answer? Use details from both girls' chapters.
From the story ๐ฆ The Fish Beneath the Hoof ยท Level 2 ยท Ancient Civilizations ยท History ยท Cities
Captain Brekke kept part of his plan secret from the crew, and Nils had to decide what to do when he found out. Was the captain right or wrong to keep the secret? Was Nils right to go to the captain instead of the crew? Use evidence from both the diary and the journal to explain your opinions.
From the story โต Frozen In on Purpose ยท Level 2 ยท History ยท Polar ยท Adventure
Arif's father and Siti's mother both had good reasons for what they wanted. Do you think the compromise at the end was fair to the family and to the orangutans? Use at least three details from the story to explain your answer, and describe one thing each side gave up.
From the story ๐ฆง The Orangutan Corridor ยท Level 3 ยท Animals ยท Farm ยท Rainforest
The dam would bring good things and bad things to Ban Pak Huay. If you lived in the village, would you vote for the dam? Explain your choice using at least three facts from the story, and explain what you would say to someone who disagreed with you.
From the story ๐ฃ Before the Water Rises ยท Level 3 ยท Village ยท Rivers ยท Culture
Kiri and Oskar sail in very different ways. Which sailor do you think is more like you, and why? Explain how each of their styles helps and hurts the team, using at least three examples from the story.
From the story โต Sailing into the Wind ยท Level 3 ยท Sports ยท Sailing ยท Friends
Jada believes news should be fast and free online. Grandma Bea believes someone must slowly check facts and attend the "boring" meetings. Which of their ideas do you think matters more for a town, or do you think both are needed? Give at least three reasons from the story.
From the story ๐ฐ The Last Edition ยท Level 3 ยท Family ยท Newspapers ยท Mystery
Dolma's teacher says the ice tower helps with the effects of climate change but doesn't fix the cause. Do you think the village was right to build it anyway? Explain your opinion with at least three details from the story, and describe what else people could do.
From the story ๐๏ธ The Ice Tower of Shara ยท Level 3 ยท Culture ยท Climate ยท Nature
The Ortega family chose not to drill a deeper well, even though it meant losing part of their orchard. Was this the right decision? Explain both sides of the argument, then give your opinion with at least three reasons from the story.
From the story ๐ฐ The Windmill That Ran Dry ยท Level 3 ยท Farm ยท Family ยท Climate
The council had good reasons to want to cut the Old Quarter loose, and Abuela had good reasons to want to stay. Imagine you are on the council. What would you vote for, and why? Use at least three details from the story, and explain how you would answer the people who disagree with you.
From the story ๐ The Drifting Quarter ยท Level 3 ยท Sci-Fi ยท Ocean ยท Climate
The leaders of New Orleans believed breaking the levee was necessary to save their city. The people of St. Bernard believed it was unfair. Using at least three details from the story, explain both points of view. Then explain what you think the leaders should have done differently.
From the story ๐ช The Day They Broke the Levee ยท Level 3 ยท History ยท Rivers ยท Culture
Uncle Rafa decided to take the last golden frogs out of the wild and into the Frog Ark. Some people thought this was wrong. Explain both sides of the argument, and then say what you would have done, using at least three details from the story.
From the story ๐ธ The Frogs That Waved ยท Level 3 ยท Mystery ยท Rainforest ยท Animals
Amira made a call that hurt her best friend's team. Was it more important for her to be fair or to be loyal? Explain both sides, and then give your own opinion with at least three reasons from the story.
From the story ๐ฉ The Flag on the Line ยท Level 3 ยท Sports ยท Friends ยท Family
Ligaya chose not to report Dodong to the council and found a different way to solve the problem. Do you agree with her choice? Explain what might have happened if she had reported him, and give at least three reasons from the story for your opinion.
From the story ๐ The No-Take Zone ยท Level 3 ยท Ocean ยท Village ยท Family
The dragon says, "A river that never floods is a river that is dying." Explain what she means, and whether you think the people of Highweir were wrong to build the dam. Use at least three details from the story to support your answer.
From the story ๐ The River Dragon's Bargain ยท Level 3 ยท Fantasy ยท Rivers
Desmond's "On One Hand, On the Other Hand" column became popular because it explained both sides fairly. Choose a question that people in your school or town disagree about. Write a short column in Desmond's style, giving the strongest reasons on each side, and then explain which side you lean toward and why.
From the story ๐ The Great Gnome Debate ยท Level 3 ยท Humor ยท Village ยท Newspapers
June's mom believed the family channel helped her family and brought joy to viewers. June believed she deserved privacy. Explain both points of view. Then write three rules you think families should follow before sharing videos of children online, and explain why each rule matters.
From the story ๐ฅ The Red Light ยท Level 3 ยท Family ยท Media
Sam's class first wanted to buy rainforest land, but later decided to support Yaku's community instead. Explain both ideas and the good intentions behind each. Which do you think is the better way for people far away to help protect rainforests? Use at least three details from the story.
From the story ๐ณ The Acre We Bought ยท Level 3 ยท School ยท Rainforest ยท Culture
Nora's father argued that the dam made clean energy, and Wren's family argued that the river and the salmon needed to be free. Explain the strongest reason on each side. Then explain whether you think removing the dam was the right choice, using at least three details from the story.
From the story ๐ When the Salmon Came Home ยท Level 3 ยท Nature ยท Rivers ยท Friends
Don Efraรญn and Marisol had to decide whether to broadcast the dam rumor before they knew if it was true. Explain the risks of broadcasting it and the risks of keeping silent. Then describe what they finally decided and whether you think it was the right choice, using at least three details from the story.
From the story ๐ป The Voice on the Mountain ยท Level 3 ยท Climate ยท Newspapers ยท Family
Priya says that "it worked for me" is not the same as proof. Do you agree? Explain the difference between a story about one person and a fair test, and use at least two examples from the story to support your answer.
From the story ๐ซง The Great Hiccup Outbreak ยท Level 4 ยท Humor ยท School ยท Medicine
Aibek's father and grandfather disagree about whether the family should keep herding or move to the city. Explain each side's best reasons. Then tell which choice you think the family should make, and support your answer with details from the story.
From the story ๐ The Summer Pasture ยท Level 4 ยท Farm ยท Animals ยท Mountains ยท Migration
Hana's teammates argue about whether visiting runners should be allowed in the local race. Give the strongest reason for each side. Then explain what you think, using examples from the story and your own experience.
From the story ๐๐พโโ๏ธ Thin Air ยท Level 4 ยท Sports ยท Mountains ยท Health
The people of Playa Luna argue about whether the beach lights should be turned off. Explain the strongest argument for each side. Then decide what you would vote for at the town meeting, and give at least two reasons from the story.
From the story ๐ข Lights Out on Playa Luna ยท Level 4 ยท Ocean ยท Animals ยท Migration ยท Village
Should children translate for their parents at the doctor's office, or should a professional interpreter always do it? Explain both sides using evidence from the story, and then give your own opinion with reasons.
From the story ๐ซ The Olive Tree on the Balcony ยท Level 4 ยท Culture ยท Family ยท Migration ยท Health
Nico had to argue for a side he didn't agree with. Choose a question that people disagree about in your school or town. Write the strongest argument you can for the side you disagree with, and then explain whether doing this changed your mind.
From the story ๐ก The Cable Car Question ยท Level 4 ยท School ยท Mountains ยท Friends
Mingma had reasons to be afraid of the vaccine, and Sunita had reasons to trust it. Explain each person's point of view. Then explain what finally changed Mingma's mind, and whether you think that was a good reason to change it.
From the story ๐ง The Cold Box ยท Level 4 ยท Medicine ยท Mountains ยท Village
The town council argued about whether to tear down the old tower or spend money to save it. Which side would you choose? Use at least two facts from the story to explain your reasons, and explain what the people on the other side might say.
From the story ๐ฐ๏ธ The Leaning Clock Tower ยท Level 4 ยท Mystery ยท Architecture ยท Friends
Amara's classmate Tobi argues that robots should explore space instead of people. Amara's mother explains why she believes people should go. Which argument do you find more convincing? Use evidence from both storylines to support your answer.
From the story โ๏ธ Letters to the Asteroid ยท Level 4 ยท Space ยท Family ยท Sci-fi
The city had to decide whether to widen Canal Street or keep its trees. Explain the best argument each side made. Then explain how Zainab's measurements changed the debate, and whether you think measuring something you can't see is a good way to settle an argument.
From the story ๐ณ The Lungs of Canal Street ยท Level 4 ยท Nature ยท Health ยท City ยท School
Nana Afua and Nurse Boateng each had knowledge the other one needed. Explain what each woman knew that was valuable, and what each one learned from the other. Then explain why you think the story ends with the two of them planting a garden together.
From the story ๐ฟ The Healer's Garden ยท Level 4 ยท Village ยท Medicine ยท Culture ยท Family
Maribel's father felt blamed by the scientists, but in the end he changed what he did. What do you think finally persuaded him? Explain the arguments on both sides, and describe how the way people talk to each other can make it easier or harder for someone to change.
From the story ๐ฆ The Shadow of the Condor ยท Level 4 ยท Animals ยท Mountains ยท Health ยท Family
Kaveh's father wanted a modern house, and his grandmother wanted to keep the old windcatcher. Explain the best reasons on each side. Then explain what the story suggests about when people should keep old ways and when they should try new ones.
From the story ๐๏ธ The Windcatcher ยท Level 4 ยท History ยท Architecture ยท Family ยท Health
The Guild of Stone Singers argued about whether apprentices who can't sing should be allowed to stay. Explain the arguments on both sides. Then explain how the story shows that a group can be stronger when it values different kinds of talent.
From the story ๐ชจ The Stone Listener ยท Level 4 ยท Fantasy ยท Architecture ยท Mountains
The people of Ashcombe had different reasons for being afraid of the cowpox treatment. Choose two characters with different opinions and explain each one's reasons. Then explain what kind of evidence finally changed people's minds, and why you think it worked.
From the story ๐ The Milkmaid's Hands ยท Level 4 ยท History ยท Medicine ยท Farm ยท Village
The workers in the story disagreed about whether to go on strike. Explain the strongest reasons on each side. Then explain whether you think the strike was worth it, even though the workers did not win what they asked for, and support your answer with details from the story.
From the story ๐ต The Tea Carrier ยท Level 4 ยท History ยท Migration ยท Mountains ยท Health
Rafi had to choose between going to Mars with his family and staying on Earth with his grandmother. Explain the strongest reasons for each choice. Then explain how รlodie changed during the story, and what you think she learned about friendship.
From the story ๐ The Last Launch Window ยท Level 4 ยท Sci-fi ยท Friends ยท Space ยท Migration
Maisie and her father both had good reasons for what they wanted. Should a family be allowed to remove something on its own land that has value for everyone? Argue your position, using at least two pieces of evidence from the story and explaining the strongest point on the other side.
From the story ๐ฟ The Hedgerow ยท Level 5 ยท Farm ยท Nature
Should schools use technology to measure how well students are paying attention? Write an argument for or against, using at least two examples from the story. Then explain one way the technology could be changed to be fairer.
From the story ๐ท The Attention Score ยท Level 5 ยท Sci-fi ยท School
Kaimana's grandfather says that knowledge that lives only in a machine can be lost when the machine fails, but knowledge that lives in people must be passed on or it disappears. Do you agree? Explain using evidence from the story and an example from your own life of knowledge that is passed from person to person.
From the story ๐ถ Wayfinder ยท Level 5 ยท Ocean ยท Culture
The turn-out of 1836 did not win right away, yet Abby believes it mattered. Can a protest be worthwhile even if it doesn't succeed? Use evidence from the story to support your answer, and explain why someone like Hannah might have disagreed.
From the story ๐งต The Turn-Out ยท Level 5 ยท History ยท Justice
Owen was sure he was telling the truth, but he was wrong. Explain how his assumptions about Rafael shaped what he "saw." Then describe what you think a fair person should do before accusing someone, using evidence from the story.
From the story ๐ฆด What I Saw at the Museum ยท Level 5 ยท Mystery ยท School
Valentina chose to speak to Andrรฉs first instead of reporting him to the race officials. Was that the right choice? Explain your reasoning with evidence from the story, and describe what you would have done if Andrรฉs had refused to confess.
From the story ๐ด The Climb to Alto del Sol ยท Level 5 ยท Sports ยท Family
Pemba and Dawa both loved their village but disagreed about the road. Choose one of them and write a speech they could give at the village meeting. Then write two or three sentences explaining the strongest point the other sibling would make in reply.
From the story ๐๏ธ The Road to Sangu ยท Level 5 ยท Village ยท Culture
The godwit needs healthy places in three different countries to survive. Whose responsibility is it to protect a migrating animal? Write an argument using at least two pieces of evidence from the story, and suggest one action people in different countries could take together.
From the story ๐ฆ Eleven Days Without Landing ยท Level 5 ยท Animals ยท Nature
The people of Ashgrove trusted the Truthscale because it seemed perfect and fair. Why might people prefer to trust a machine or a magic object instead of a human judge? Is that a good idea? Use evidence from the story and an example from the real world in your answer.
From the story โ๏ธ The Truthscale ยท Level 5 ยท Fantasy ยท Justice
Dez collected a lot of "evidence," but he interpreted all of it wrongly. Choose two clues from the story and explain how Dez misread each one and what it really meant. Then explain what this story suggests about how people can be fooled by their own expectations.
From the story ๐ต๏ธ My Substitute Is a Spy ยท Level 5 ยท Humor ยท School
Ana forwarded the llama picture to only one person, but she later decides she was partly responsible for how far it spread. Do you agree? Explain how much responsibility each person in the chain had, using evidence from the story, and suggest a rule your class could follow about sharing images.
From the story ๐ฑ Copy, Paste, Send ยท Level 5 ยท Friends ยท Technology
Bร Ngoแบกi told a gentler version of her story for many years. Was she wrong to do so? Explain your opinion with evidence from the story, and describe why people might change the way they tell painful memories.
From the story ๐ถ The River Grandmother Remembers ยท Level 5 ยท Family ยท Culture
Ma Liang's teacher says that records are "how the future argues with the past." Why is it important to keep records of history, even parts that make a country or a leader look bad? Use evidence from the story and give an example of your own.
From the story โต The Treasure Fleet's Last Voyage ยท Level 5 ยท History ยท Exploration
Isla says she is "fine" many times in the story, but her actions show something different. Find three moments that show what Isla is really feeling and explain each one. Then explain how the whale fall helps her understand her grandfather's death.
From the story ๐ Whale Fall ยท Level 5 ยท Ocean ยท Family
The settlers of Arsia Station had to choose between their own needs and protecting life they barely understood. Did they make the right decision? Use at least two pieces of evidence from the story, and explain what you would have argued at the council meeting.
From the story ๐ด The Cave on Arsia ยท Level 5 ยท Sci-fi ยท Exploration
The wind farm made clean energy, which helps fight climate change, but it also harmed the herders. Can something be good for the world and unfair to some people at the same time? Explain your answer using evidence from both รilu's and Ingrid's points of view.
From the story ๐ฆ The Wind and the Reindeer ยท Level 5 ยท Culture ยท Nature
Some people in Cedar Bend wanted to leave the past alone, while others wanted the full story told. Which side do you agree with, and why? Use evidence from the story, and explain how Clara's discovery about her own ancestor made her choice harder.
From the story ๐ The Name Under the Paint ยท Level 5 ยท Mystery ยท History
Ines chose to restore a painful memory instead of living without it. Was that the right decision? Argue your position using at least three pieces of evidence from the story, and explain what the story suggests about the connection between memory, pain, and who we are.
From the story ๐ง The Letter in My Handwriting ยท Level 6 ยท Sci-fi ยท Family
Hari believed at first that only force could defeat an unjust law, but he changed his mind. Using evidence from the story, explain why nonviolent protest was powerful in this situation. Then discuss one difficulty or cost of nonviolence that the story shows honestly.
From the story ๐ง A Handful of Salt ยท Level 6 ยท History ยท Justice
Rae's father refused to make the last run even though the community needed the fuel. Was he right? Use evidence from the story to defend your position, and explain who you think should be responsible for solving the problem of the disappearing ice roads.
From the story ๐ Forty Centimeters ยท Level 6 ยท Nature ยท Exploration
Niko never tells a direct lie in the story, yet he misleads the reader. Find at least three places where he hides the truth through what he leaves out or how he describes things, and explain how each one works. Then explain why you think he finally tells the truth.
From the story ๐ค The Detective's Assistant ยท Level 6 ยท Mystery ยท Friends
The villagers believed the forest "gives," but the original bargain said it "lends." Explain the difference between a gift and a loan, and how that difference changes the way people should treat the natural world. Use evidence from the story and connect it to a real environmental issue.
From the story ๐ฒ What the Forest Lends ยท Level 6 ยท Fantasy ยท Nature
Should lynx be brought back to Scotland? Write a balanced argument that gives the strongest points on both sides, using evidence from the story. Then explain your own view and how you think the decision should be made.
From the story ๐ The Lynx in Glen Arrin ยท Level 6 ยท Animals ยท Farm
Is it fair for a runner with a prosthetic blade to race against runners without one? Write an argument using evidence from the story. Consider the science, the purpose of school sports, and what "fair" should mean. Explain how you would decide cases like this one.
From the story ๐ The Unfair Advantage ยท Level 6 ยท Sports ยท Justice
Tomasz says he "didn't exactly decide to cheat." Where do you think the line is between getting help with writing and having someone, or something, write for you? Use evidence from the story to explain where Tomasz crossed that line and what made his final choice difficult.
From the story โ๏ธ The Essay That Wasn't Mine ยท Level 6 ยท School ยท Technology
Luz's family is divided: her father fishes from a small boat, and her brother works for the fishmeal factory. Who do you think has the strongest claim to the anchoveta: the small fishers, the industrial fleet, the seabirds, or someone else? Use evidence from the story and explain how the fish could be shared more fairly.
From the story ๐ The Silver Fish of Chimbote ยท Level 6 ยท Ocean ยท Justice
Grandma Efua refused to send her DNA to a company, and Rupert thought she was being old-fashioned. Was she? Explain the privacy concerns raised in the story and whether you think the benefits of DNA testing outweigh the risks. Then explain what the story suggests makes up a family's identity.
From the story ๐งฌ Eighty-Seven Percent Beagle ยท Level 6 ยท Humor ยท Family
Seydou's grandfather says that a griot "can praise without lying." Explain what he means, using the song Seydou sings at the wedding as evidence. Then describe a situation in modern life where people are paid to tell stories about others, and explain what rules you think they should follow.
From the story ๐ช The Griot's Apprentice ยท Level 6 ยท Culture ยท History
The village of Kisima considered several ways to share the electricity: by ability to pay, by lottery, by need, and by what benefits everyone. Which method do you think is fairest, and why? Use evidence from the story, and explain one weakness of the method you choose.
From the story ๐ก First Light in Kisima ยท Level 6 ยท Village ยท Justice
Who should own buried treasure: the person who finds it, the person who owns the land, or everyone? Use evidence from the story and the rules of the Treasure Act to support your answer, and explain why Ellie's choice to tell the truth was so difficult.
From the story ๐ช The Silver Under Barrow Field ยท Level 6 ยท Mystery ยท Friends
The European eel's survival depends on people in many places: pumping stations, fishermen, smugglers, buyers, and scientists. Choose two of these groups and explain how their choices affect the eel. Then argue for one action that would help the most, using evidence from the story.
From the story ๐ The Eel's Long Way Home ยท Level 6 ยท Nature ยท Ecosystems
Should humanity reply to a message from another civilization? Write a speech for the world assembly that takes a clear position, uses evidence from the story, and responds to the strongest argument on the other side. Explain who you think should decide.
From the story ๐ก Forty Light-Years ยท Level 6 ยท Sci-fi ยท Exploration
Who was most in the wrong, Efua, Kojo, or their mother? Or was nobody truly wrong? Take a position and support it with at least three pieces of evidence from the story. Then explain how Efua's way of telling the story affected what you believed while reading.
From the story ๐ช The Door Across the Hall ยท Level 6 ยท Family ยท Mystery
At the end of the story, Highmere agrees to release the clouds every other day. Is this a fair solution, or should Highmere give up more? Take a position, give at least three reasons with evidence from the story, and explain how both Ysolde's and Daru's viewpoints shaped your answer.
From the story ๐ง๏ธ The Weather Thief ยท Level 6 ยท Fantasy ยท Justice