The Hedgerow
Maisie Thornbury's father plans to tear out the ancient hedge that splits their two biggest fields, so the farm can use a larger harvester and pay its debts. Maisie sets out to count everything that lives in the hedge, but the more she learns, the harder it becomes to decide who is right.
5th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerFarm · Nature2913 wordsAbout 30 minutes
In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.
Words to know
- hedgerow
- a long line of bushes and small trees planted to divide fields
- survey
- a careful count or study of something, like the plants and animals in a place
- species
- a group of living things of the same kind that can breed together
- debt
- money that a person or business owes and must pay back
- stewardship
- the job of taking care of something valuable for the future
Chapter 1: Thirty Paces
The hedge had been there before the Thornburys. That was the first thing anyone learned about it.
It was not a garden hedge, neat and square. It was a true hedgerow, the old kind.
It ran down the middle of the farm like a green spine, separating Long Meadow from Top Field, a tangle of hawthorn, hazel, blackthorn, and holly so thick that in summer you could not see through it. Badgers had dug tunnels under its roots. Blackbirds argued in its branches. In autumn it was heavy with red haws and purple sloes, and in spring it foamed with white blossom as if someone had thrown lace over it.
Maisie Thornbury, who was twelve, had never thought of it as anything except the hedge. It was simply there, the way the sky was there.
Then, on a gray evening in March, she heard her father say, "It has to come out."
She was on the stairs, halfway down, and she stopped. The kitchen door was open a crack. Her father and mother sat at the table with a pile of papers between them, the kind with red numbers. Red meant debt.
"We can't afford the small harvester anymore, Jen," her father said. "It's thirty years old and it breaks down every August. The new one is twice as wide. It can't turn in those little fields. If the hedge comes out, Long Meadow and Top Field become one field, and we save two days of harvesting and a fortune in fuel."
"The bank will lend us the money for the harvester?" her mother asked.
"Only if I show them a plan that works. This is the plan."
Maisie came down the rest of the stairs louder than she needed to. Both her parents looked up.
"You can't take out the hedge," she said. "It's ancient."
Her father rubbed his eyes. He looked tired in a way she had not noticed before, as though someone had let some of the air out of him. "It's a hedge, Mais. Hedges get taken out. Your great-grandad took out three of them after the war."
"Then that's three too many."
"Maisie," her mother said, in the voice that meant not now.
Maisie went back upstairs, but she did not go to bed. She lay awake thinking of the badger tunnels and the blackbirds, and also, though she did not want to, of the red numbers on the papers.
The next afternoon she walked across the lane to see Mrs. Okonjo-Price, who had moved into the old mill cottage two years before. Mrs. Okonjo-Price was seventy-four, wore enormous rubber boots in every season, and had spent forty years as a scientist studying the countryside. She was the only person Maisie could think of who might know whether a hedge could be important enough to save.
"Ancient," Mrs. Okonjo-Price repeated, pouring tea. "That's a big word. Do you know how old it is?"
Maisie admitted that she did not.
"There's an old rule of thumb," the scientist said. "It's called Hooper's rule, after the man who came up with it. You walk thirty paces along a hedge, and you count how many different species of woody plant you find: trees and shrubs, not grasses or flowers. Roughly speaking, each species stands for about a hundred years. A hedge planted from one kind of bush slowly collects others as birds drop seeds and the centuries pass."
"So if I count five species..."
"Your hedge may be about five hundred years old. It isn't exact. It's a clue, not a proof. But clues add up." She set down the teapot. "If you want to argue with your father, Maisie, you will need more than feelings. You will need evidence. Feelings are where an argument starts. Evidence is what makes other people listen."
So Maisie went home with a notebook, a pencil, and a borrowed book about trees, and that weekend she began her survey.
She paced out thirty steps along the hedge, starting at the gate, and tied a piece of orange string to a branch. Then she began to count. Hawthorn, with its small, deeply cut leaves. Blackthorn, with long, sharp spines. Hazel, with round, soft leaves. Holly. Field maple, its leaves like little hands. Then, almost hidden, something she had to look up three times: a spindle tree, with stems that were faintly square.
Six species. Six hundred years, roughly. The hedge had been growing when knights still rode across England.
Maisie stood in the cold wind and looked at the hedge as if she had never seen it before. In a way, she hadn't.
Check your understanding
Key details According to Hooper's rule, how does a person estimate the age of a hedge?
- By measuring how tall the tallest tree is
- By counting the woody species in thirty paces, with each species standing for about a hundred years
- By counting the rings inside a cut branch
- By asking the oldest person in the village
Cause and effect Why does Maisie's father want to remove the hedge?
- He thinks the hedge is ugly and full of pests
- A neighbor has complained about it
- The farm needs a wider harvester that cannot turn in the two small fields
- He wants to build a new house there
Inference What does Maisie notice about her father that she "had not noticed before"?
- That he is angry at her for listening on the stairs
- That he is worn down and worried about money
- That he secretly agrees with her about the hedge
- That he is feeling ill
Theme Mrs. Okonjo-Price says, "Feelings are where an argument starts. Evidence is what makes other people listen." What idea does this introduce for the rest of the story?
- Feelings are useless and should be ignored
- Caring about something is a beginning, but convincing others requires facts and careful study
- Scientists are always right and farmers are always wrong
- Arguments are best won by whoever is loudest
Chapter 2: What Lives in the Dark
Over the next three weeks, Maisie learned that a hedge is not a wall. It is a city.
She went out at dawn before school with Mrs. Okonjo-Price's binoculars and wrote down every bird she saw. Yellowhammers, bright as egg yolk, singing a song that sounded like a-little-bit-of-bread-and-no-cheese. Wrens, tiny and loud. A pair of long-tailed tits building a nest out of moss, spider silk, and feathers, shaped like a little bottle. She learned that many birds that nest in hedges will not nest in the open, because the thick thorns keep away cats, crows, and foxes.
She went out at dusk with a borrowed bat detector, a box the size of a phone that turned the high, silent clicks of bats into sounds people could hear. Standing beside the hedge as the light faded, she heard it begin to crackle and pop like frying bacon. Pipistrelles, Mrs. Okonjo-Price told her, the smallest bats in Britain, each one light enough to post in an envelope. They used the hedge the way a driver uses a road, flying along its edge in the dark to find their way from their roost to the river.
"If you cut the hedge," Mrs. Okonjo-Price said, "it's a bit like removing a road from a map. The bats don't simply fly across the open field. Many of them get lost, or won't go at all."
Then, near the end of April, Maisie found the dormouse.
Mrs. Okonjo-Price had helped her nail a few wooden nest boxes to the hazel stems, low down, facing the hedge. Dormice were rare and secretive, she warned, and Maisie should not expect anything. But when they lifted the lid of the third box, there it was: a ball of golden fur the size of a plum, curled up asleep, its fluffy tail wrapped over its nose.
Maisie held her breath. The dormouse did not wake.
"Hazel dormouse," Mrs. Okonjo-Price whispered. "They've disappeared from about half of the places they used to live in England. They hardly ever touch the ground. They travel from tree to tree through the branches, and a hedge like this one is their whole world." She closed the lid gently. "You've just found something important, Maisie. They're protected by law. Disturbing their home without a licence is a crime."
On the walk home, Maisie felt like she was carrying a trophy. This is it, she thought. This is the thing that will stop him.
At supper, she laid out her notebook on the table. Six woody species. Twenty-two kinds of birds. Three kinds of bats. And, underlined twice, one hazel dormouse, protected.
Her father read every page without speaking. Her little brother, Alfie, who was eight, tried to read upside down. Her mother watched her father's face.
Finally he closed the notebook.
"This is very good work," he said. "Really, Maisie. It's careful and it's honest."
She waited for the next part.
"And it means," he said slowly, "that I'll need a special licence, and a survey by a proper ecologist, and probably a delay of a year or more before I can touch that hedge. Which means I can't show the bank a plan in time. Which means no new harvester." He handed back the notebook. "I hope the dormouse enjoys the farm. I'm not sure we'll still be on it."
He got up, put on his coat, and went out into the dark yard.
Maisie sat very still. She had wanted to win. She had not thought about what winning would cost.
"Is Dad angry at me?" Alfie whispered.
"No," their mother said. She was quiet for a moment. "He's frightened. That's different. Sometimes it looks the same from outside."
Check your understanding
Main idea What is this chapter mostly about?
- Maisie learning to use a bat detector
- Maisie's survey revealing how much life depends on the hedge, and the painful effect her discovery has on her father
- Alfie trying to read Maisie's notebook
- Mrs. Okonjo-Price's career as a scientist
Vocabulary The author writes that "a hedge is not a wall. It is a city." What does this comparison suggest?
- The hedge is full of buildings
- The hedge is noisy and crowded with people
- The hedge is home to a whole community of living things that depend on it and on each other
- The hedge should be turned into houses
Inference Why does Maisie feel "like she was carrying a trophy" after finding the dormouse?
- Because the dormouse is worth a lot of money
- Because she believes the protected dormouse will force her father to keep the hedge
- Because Mrs. Okonjo-Price gave her a prize
- Because she plans to keep the dormouse as a pet
Character What does Maisie realize after her father leaves the table?
- That she was wrong to do the survey at all
- That her father does not care about nature
- That winning her argument could hurt her own family
- That Mrs. Okonjo-Price tricked her
Chapter 3: The View from the Tractor
Will Thornbury had been driving tractors since he was ten years old, and he did his best thinking with an engine rumbling under him.
The morning after supper, he drove the old tractor slowly along the edge of Long Meadow, alongside the hedge. He had not told his daughter how many times he had walked this field as a boy with his own father, or how his grandfather had once pointed at that very hedge and said, The best thing about this farm is that nobody owns it forever. We just borrow it.
He had not told her, either, about the letter from the bank in his coat pocket, or the sum written on it, or the way his hands sometimes shook when he added up the bills at midnight.
He stopped the tractor and climbed down. A yellowhammer sang from the top of a hawthorn bush. A-little-bit-of-bread-and-no-cheese. He had heard that song every spring of his life and never once wondered what bird it was until Maisie wrote it in her notebook.
He was proud of her. That was the strange part. He was so proud of her he could hardly stand it, and at the same time he wanted to take that notebook and throw it in the river.
"You look like a man having an argument with himself," said a voice.
Mrs. Okonjo-Price was standing in the lane in her enormous boots.
"Did she send you?" Will asked.
"She doesn't know I'm here." The old scientist leaned on the gate. "I've been worried I've caused your family trouble. I helped her because she asked good questions. But I didn't help her think about your side, and that wasn't fair to you."
Will laughed without much humor. "My side is very simple. Food doesn't grow itself, and nobody pays farmers to keep hedges."
"Actually," said Mrs. Okonjo-Price, "sometimes they do."
He looked at her.
"There are government schemes," she said. "Stewardship schemes. They pay farmers to look after hedgerows, plant wildflower margins, leave space for birds. They don't make anyone rich. But they pay. And there are grants for some things, too, such as laying hedges the old way, or planting new ones." She paused. "I don't know if it would be enough for you. I don't know your numbers. But I know the forms, and I'm very good at forms. Forty years of filling them in."
Will was quiet for a long time. Then he said, "The new harvester still can't turn in Top Field."
"No," she agreed. "So perhaps the question isn't hedge or no hedge. Perhaps it's what's the smallest change that solves the real problem?"
He looked down the length of the hedge, really looked, the way his daughter had taught him to. It ran for nearly four hundred meters. The harvester did not need four hundred meters of open ground. It needed a wide gap to pass through and turn, at the narrow end near the old gate, where the hedge was thinnest and full of brambles rather than old hazel.
"A gap," he said slowly. "Twenty meters. At the bottom end. If the ecologist agreed there were no dormice there."
"It might work," said Mrs. Okonjo-Price. "It might not. But it's a question worth asking, isn't it?"
That evening, Will Thornbury knocked on his daughter's bedroom door. She was sitting on her bed with the notebook in her lap, and her eyes were red.
"I owe you an apology," he said. "That remark about the dormouse enjoying the farm. That was unkind."
"You were right, though," Maisie said. "If you lose the farm, the hedge doesn't matter."
"I don't think either of us is completely right," he said. He sat down on the end of the bed. "That's the trouble with real problems. In stories there's usually a villain. Here there's just a hedge and a bank and a lot of people trying to do their best."
Then he told her about the gap, and about the stewardship schemes, and Maisie listened with her mouth slightly open.
"Will you need help with the forms?" she asked.
"Mrs. Okonjo-Price says she's very good at forms," her father said. "But I imagine she could use an assistant who knows how to count woody species."
Check your understanding
Character How does Will feel about Maisie's survey?
- He thinks it is careless and childish
- He is deeply proud of it but also upset because it threatens his plan to save the farm
- He doesn't care about it at all
- He is jealous that she found the dormouse
Inference Why does the author switch to telling this chapter from Will's point of view?
- To show that Will is the villain of the story
- To explain how tractors work
- To let readers see the worries and memories he has hidden from Maisie, making his side easier to understand
- Because Maisie has left the farm
Key details What does Mrs. Okonjo-Price tell Will that he did not know?
- That the hedge is worth a lot of money as firewood
- That there are stewardship schemes that pay farmers to look after hedgerows
- That the bank has forgiven his debt
- That dormice are not really protected
Theme Will says, "In stories there's usually a villain. Here there's just a hedge and a bank and a lot of people trying to do their best." What does this suggest about the problem?
- Will thinks the bank is the real villain
- Real disagreements often involve good people with competing needs rather than a simple bad guy
- Stories are more important than real life
- Nobody should ever try to solve problems
Chapter 4: Laid Hedge
It took the whole summer, and it was not a fairy tale.
A professional ecologist came in June, a quiet young man named Rhys with a clipboard and a beard, and spent four nights with a light and a net and the nest boxes. He confirmed the dormice. There were at least six, he said, possibly more. Most of them lived in the old, hazel-rich middle of the hedge. The bottom end, near the gate, was mostly bramble and elder, and he found no sign of dormice there.
"A gap down there would be the least harmful option," Rhys said. "Not harmless. Nothing is harmless. But least harmful. And if you plant a new stretch of hedge somewhere else to make up for it, the farm could come out ahead."
The bank was a harder conversation. Will went twice, in his good jacket, carrying a folder that Maisie and Mrs. Okonjo-Price had spent three evenings preparing at the kitchen table. The folder had numbers in it: what the stewardship scheme would pay for caring for the hedgerows each year, what the grant would cover for new planting, how much fuel the harvester would save with only a twenty-meter gap instead of a whole new field.
The first time, the bank said no.
Maisie took the news badly. She went out to the hedge and sat under the hawthorn with her back against the trunk and cried, which she had not done since she was nine. A wren scolded her from a branch a meter above her head, furious that she was sitting near its nest.
"Sorry," she told it. "Everyone's having a bad day."
The second time, a different person at the bank looked at the folder, made a phone call, and said yes, with conditions. The farm would have to be careful for several years. There would be no holidays and no new car. The old tractor would have to keep going.
"We'll manage," her mother said, and she meant it.
In October, after the harvest, a hedge-layer came. His name was Bert Pennock, he was nearly eighty, and he had been laying hedges since he was younger than Maisie. Laying a hedge, he explained, was the old way of keeping one healthy. You cut most of the way through each tall stem near the ground, then bent it over sideways, so it lay along the line of the hedge, still alive, still attached to its roots. From the cut, new shoots would grow straight up, and the hedge would grow thick and strong from the bottom, instead of tall and thin and gappy.
"Takes a hundred years off it," Bert said, slicing through a hazel stem with a curved blade. "Makes an old hedge young again."
He laid the stretch near the new gap. Maisie helped, carrying stakes and weaving long, flexible hazel rods along the top to bind it, the way Bert showed her. At the bottom end, the brambles came out, and the gap was cleared, twenty meters wide and no more. Rhys came back to check every stem before it was cut.
And along the far side of Top Field, where there had never been a hedge at all, the Thornburys and Mrs. Okonjo-Price planted a new one: three hundred small whips of hawthorn, hazel, blackthorn, field maple, holly, and spindle, each no taller than Maisie's knee.
"Six species," Maisie said, pushing the last one into the cold ground. "Right from the start. Some scientist six hundred years from now is going to count these and get completely confused."
Mrs. Okonjo-Price laughed so hard she had to sit down on an upturned bucket.
In the spring, the new harvester arrived, gleaming and enormous. Alfie named it Godzilla. On its first day it rumbled through the gap between Long Meadow and Top Field with nearly a meter to spare on each side.
Maisie watched from the gate with her father. Behind them, the ancient hedge was already greening, the laid stems sending up hundreds of new shoots. A yellowhammer sang from the top of it.
"Do you think we did the right thing?" she asked.
Will Thornbury thought about it for a long time, which was one of the things she loved about him.
"I think we did a fair thing," he said at last. "We gave something up and so did the hedge. Nobody got everything. Maybe that's what a compromise is: everybody is a little bit unhappy, and nobody has to lose."
"Grandad said nobody owns a farm forever," Maisie said. "We just borrow it."
Her father looked at her in surprise. "Who told you that?"
"Mrs. Okonjo-Price. She said you told her."
He smiled and shook his head. Across the landscape, the old hedge and the new one ran like two green lines, one six hundred years old and one six months old, waiting for the generations still to come.
Check your understanding
Sequence Which event happened first?
- The new harvester drove through the gap
- Bert Pennock laid the hedge
- Rhys confirmed that dormice lived in the middle of the hedge
- The family planted a new hedge along Top Field
Key details What does "laying" a hedge involve?
- Pulling the whole hedge out by its roots
- Spraying the hedge with chemicals so it grows faster
- Cutting partway through stems and bending them over so they keep growing and the hedge thickens from the bottom
- Planting flowers in front of the hedge
Inference Why does Maisie joke that a scientist in six hundred years will "get completely confused"?
- The new hedge will die and leave no trace
- Because the new hedge already has six species, Hooper's rule would wrongly suggest it is six hundred years old
- Because the scientist will not know how to count
- Because the hedge will be cut down again
Theme Which statement best expresses the theme developed across all four chapters?
- Nature should always come before people's needs
- Farmers know best and should not listen to children
- Hard problems often have no perfect answer, but careful evidence, listening, and compromise can lead to a fair solution
- Banks always say no the first time
Spelling words
These 12 words all appear in the story.
- hedgerow
- ancient
- survey
- species
- hawthorn
- dormouse
- debt
- harvester
- landscape
- generations
- compromise
- stewardship
Writing prompt
Maisie and her father both had good reasons for what they wanted. Should a family be allowed to remove something on its own land that has value for everyone? Argue your position, using at least two pieces of evidence from the story and explaining the strongest point on the other side.
Reading skills practiced
Key details, Cause and effect, Inference, Theme, Main idea, Vocabulary, Character, Sequence.
Answer key for grown-ups
- By counting the woody species in thirty paces, with each species standing for about a hundred years Mrs. Okonjo-Price explains that each woody species in thirty paces stands for roughly a century.
- The farm needs a wider harvester that cannot turn in the two small fields Joining the fields would let the new, larger harvester work and save fuel and time.
- That he is worn down and worried about money He looks "as though someone had let some of the air out of him," a sign of stress about the debts.
- Caring about something is a beginning, but convincing others requires facts and careful study This idea pushes Maisie to begin a careful survey instead of only protesting.
- Maisie's survey revealing how much life depends on the hedge, and the painful effect her discovery has on her father Her survey succeeds, but the success creates a new problem for her family.
- The hedge is home to a whole community of living things that depend on it and on each other Like a city, the hedge contains many residents, roads, and homes.
- Because she believes the protected dormouse will force her father to keep the hedge She thinks the law protecting dormice will settle the argument in her favor.
- That winning her argument could hurt her own family "She had wanted to win. She had not thought about what winning would cost."
- He is deeply proud of it but also upset because it threatens his plan to save the farm He is "so proud of her he could hardly stand it" and yet wants to throw the notebook in the river.
- To let readers see the worries and memories he has hidden from Maisie, making his side easier to understand We learn about the bank letter and his grandfather's words, which Maisie does not know.
- That there are stewardship schemes that pay farmers to look after hedgerows She explains that government schemes sometimes pay farmers to care for hedges.
- Real disagreements often involve good people with competing needs rather than a simple bad guy Both Maisie and Will want good things, which is why the problem is hard.
- Rhys confirmed that dormice lived in the middle of the hedge The ecologist's survey in June came before the bank, the laying, and the planting.
- Cutting partway through stems and bending them over so they keep growing and the hedge thickens from the bottom Bert explains that laid stems stay alive and send up new shoots.
- Because the new hedge already has six species, Hooper's rule would wrongly suggest it is six hundred years old Hooper's rule assumes species collect slowly over centuries, but this hedge started with six.
- Hard problems often have no perfect answer, but careful evidence, listening, and compromise can lead to a fair solution From the survey to Will's chapter to the gap and new hedge, the story shows people working toward a fair solution in which nobody gets everything.