📚 Reading Quest
🔴

The Cave on Arsia

On Mars, the settlement of Arsia Station is running short of water, and the only easy source is a frozen lake deep inside a lava cave. Twelve-year-old Zara Haddad and her little exploring robot go in first. What they find on the cave wall could be the most important discovery in human history, or the end of the settlement's hopes.

5th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerSci-fi · Exploration2729 wordsAbout 30 minutes

Read it in the app 🚀

In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.

Words to know

microbe
a living thing so small it can only be seen with a microscope, such as bacteria
contamination
making something impure or unclean by adding something harmful or unwanted, such as germs
protocol
an official set of rules for how something must be done
sterile
completely free of germs and living microbes
rationing
limiting how much of something each person can have, because there is not enough

Chapter 1: Forty-One Days of Water

On Mars, everybody knows exactly how much water they have. At Arsia Station, it was written on a screen in the main corridor, in big blue numbers, updated every hour.

On the morning Zara Haddad turned twelve, the number said: 41 DAYS.

That meant that if nothing changed, the settlement had enough stored water for forty-one more days. After that, the recyclers, which cleaned and reused every drop of water the two hundred and six settlers used, from their showers to their sweat to their breath, would not be able to keep up. The recyclers were good, but not perfect. A little water was lost every day. It had to be replaced.

For six years, it had been replaced by mining ice from beneath the red soil around the settlement. But the ice there was running out faster than the engineers had predicted, and the next supply ship from Earth wouldn't arrive for eight months.

"Which is why," said Zara's mother, the station's chief geologist, at breakfast, "we're going to the cave."

Zara nearly dropped her spoon.

Everyone knew about the cave. It was a lava tube, a long tunnel left behind when hot lava had flowed under the surface of the volcano Arsia Mons, millions of years ago, then drained away. A hole in its roof, a skylight, opened about four kilometers from the station: a dark circle a hundred meters across, dropping straight down into blackness. Satellite scans had shown that deep inside the tunnel, out of reach of the sunlight and the thin, freezing wind, there was ice. A lot of ice. Maybe a whole frozen lake.

"Enough water for fifty years," said her mother. "If it's really there."

"Can I come?" Zara asked.

"Absolutely not," said her mother. "But Beetle can."

Beetle was Zara's robot. It was about the size of a backpack, with six jointed legs, a camera head that swiveled in every direction, and lights that could illuminate a room. Zara had built it with her father in the station's workshop over two years, from spare parts and a kit, and taught it to climb, to map, and to collect samples. It could crawl over rocks and squeeze through gaps where a bigger rover would get stuck. Last year, it had won the junior prize in the Mars Settlements Science Fair, which had seven entries, but still.

"The big rover can't get down the skylight," her mother explained. "The engineers are going to lower a camera drone on a cable first. Then they want something small and nimble to crawl along the tunnel floor to the ice and send back pictures and a sample, so we know what we're dealing with before we send people. Beetle's the best small explorer we've got." She smiled. "If you're willing to lend it."

Zara was willing. Zara was more than willing. Zara was so excited she forgot to eat her breakfast.

But before the mission, there was the protocol.

The protocol was an old set of rules, written on Earth before anyone ever came to Mars. It said that any equipment sent into a place where life might exist had to be sterile, completely cleaned of every Earth microbe, so that nothing from Earth could accidentally contaminate it. Contamination, the protocol said, could never be undone. Scientists had been arguing about it for decades. Some said there was almost certainly no life on Mars, and the rules were a waste of time. Others said that if there was life, even tiny microbes, and Earth germs got there first, we might never be able to tell the difference. We might destroy the most important discovery in history without even knowing it.

So Zara spent two days helping the lab team clean Beetle, part by part, with special chemicals and heat and ultraviolet light, until the lab technician, a cheerful old Brazilian named Dr. Paulo, declared it "cleaner than a surgeon's hands."

"Is there any chance there's really something alive down there?" Zara asked him, as he sealed Beetle into a sterile bag.

Dr. Paulo shrugged. "Probably not. Mars is cold and dry, and the surface is blasted by radiation. But a deep cave is different. Protected. Ice. Maybe a little warmth from the volcano, long ago." He winked. "I've been looking for Martian life for thirty years, Zara. I have learned not to say never."

Check your understanding

  1. Cause and effect Why does Arsia Station urgently need a new source of water?

    1. The settlers are using too much water for fun
    2. The recyclers lose a little water each day, the nearby ice is running out, and the next supply ship is eight months away
    3. A meteor destroyed the water tanks
    4. The water has become poisonous
  2. Key details Why is Beetle chosen to explore the cave?

    1. It is the biggest rover on Mars
    2. It is small and nimble enough to crawl along the tunnel floor where larger rovers can't go
    3. It is the only robot that can swim
    4. Zara's mother built it
  3. Vocabulary Why must Beetle be "sterile" before entering the cave?

    1. So that it won't break
    2. So that no Earth microbes contaminate a place where Martian life might exist
    3. So that it can work in the dark
    4. So that it is light enough to carry
  4. Inference What does Dr. Paulo mean when he says, "I have learned not to say never"?

    1. He is certain there is life in the cave
    2. Even though life is unlikely, he knows science can surprise people, so he keeps an open mind
    3. He has forgotten what he was looking for
    4. He thinks Zara should stop asking questions

Chapter 2: The Green Wall

The mission took place on a cold, clear Martian morning, with the small, pale Sun rising over the shoulder of the great volcano. Zara watched from the control room at the station, sitting beside her mother, with her hands clenched in her lap.

The engineers lowered Beetle on a thin cable through the skylight, down eighty meters of darkness, swinging gently, its lights sweeping over smooth black walls of ancient lava. Then it touched the floor of the tunnel. Zara took the controls.

"Walk," she said, and pressed forward on the joystick.

Beetle walked.

It crawled along the floor of the lava tube for nearly three hours, around fallen boulders and over ridges, its camera sending back pictures of a world no human eye had ever seen. The tunnel was enormous, twenty meters high in places, its walls ribbed and smooth like the inside of a giant throat. The farther Beetle went from the skylight, the darker and colder it got.

Then the temperature sensor flickered, and Beetle's lights caught a glint ahead.

Ice.

It covered the floor of the tunnel ahead like a frozen river, pale blue-white, stretching away beyond the reach of Beetle's lights. Everyone in the control room started cheering. Somebody hugged Zara. Her mother had tears in her eyes.

"That's fifty years," someone said. "That's fifty years of water."

"Bring Beetle up to the edge," said her mother. "Let's get a sample."

Zara walked Beetle carefully to the edge of the ice. It was then, turning the camera head to check the tunnel wall beside it for a safe route, that she saw the color.

It was on the wall, just above where the ice met the rock. A thin, patchy layer, almost like a stain. Under Beetle's white lights it looked faintly greenish-brown. It was arranged in thin wavy bands, layer upon layer, like the rings of a tree or the pages of a closed book.

"Mom," Zara said quietly. "What's that?"

The cheering in the control room died away. Her mother leaned forward and stared at the screen. Then she said, in a strange, tight voice, "Somebody get Dr. Paulo. Now."

Dr. Paulo arrived out of breath. He looked at the screen for a long time without saying anything at all. Then he asked Zara to zoom in as close as Beetle's camera could go. Then he asked her to switch to the ultraviolet light. Under it, the greenish bands glowed faintly.

"Can Beetle take a specimen?" he asked. His voice was shaking a little. "From the wall. A tiny scraping. Into the sterile sample tube. Very, very carefully."

Zara did it. It took her twenty minutes. Her hands were sweating inside her gloves the whole time.

When Beetle came back up through the skylight that evening, Dr. Paulo took the sample tube straight to the lab and locked the door.

He came out at four in the morning. Zara was still awake. Nobody at the station was asleep.

"I can't be certain yet," he said. He looked exhausted and dazed, like someone who'd been hit by something. "It will take months of tests. Maybe years. Other scientists will need to check. But the structures in that sample..." He stopped, swallowed, and started again. "They look like microbial mats. Layers built up by microbes, over a very long time. And at least some of them appear to still be active. Alive. Maybe." He let out a long breath. "It might be life. Martian life. On the wall of the cave above the ice."

Nobody said anything. Zara felt as if the floor had dropped away beneath her.

Then her mother asked the question that everybody was thinking.

"Paulo. If we mine that ice—"

"If we mine that ice," said Dr. Paulo quietly, "with drills and heaters and people and machines, we will bring Earth microbes into that cave, no matter how careful we are. We can clean a little robot. We can't clean a mining operation." He looked around the room. "We might destroy it. Whatever it is. Before we even know what it is."

On the corridor screen outside, the blue numbers said: 39 DAYS.

Check your understanding

  1. Sequence What happened right after Beetle found the ice?

    1. Dr. Paulo locked himself in the lab
    2. Zara turned the camera to find a safe route and noticed strange colored bands on the wall
    3. The engineers started drilling
    4. Beetle fell into the ice
  2. Inference Why does the cheering in the control room stop suddenly?

    1. Beetle's battery runs out
    2. The adults realize that the bands on the wall might be something extremely important, perhaps life
    3. The ice turns out to be fake
    4. Zara makes a mistake with the controls
  3. Main idea What is the main dilemma introduced in this chapter?

    1. Whether Zara can keep Beetle
    2. Whether to mine the ice the settlers need for survival, even though it might destroy possible Martian life
    3. Whether Dr. Paulo should sleep
    4. Whether the cave is too cold for people
  4. Vocabulary Dr. Paulo describes "microbial mats" built in layers "over a very long time." Which comparison in the chapter helps describe these layers?

    1. A frozen river
    2. A giant throat
    3. The rings of a tree or the pages of a closed book
    4. A pale, small Sun

Chapter 3: The Council

The settlement council met the next evening in the big dome where the settlers ate their meals, because every single person at Arsia Station wanted to be there. Children too. The station's rule was that anyone over ten could speak at council, though they couldn't vote.

The director, a tall, quiet Kenyan engineer named Mrs. Wanjiru, laid out the facts. There was not enough ice left near the station. The cave ice was the only large, reachable source. Other possible sources had been detected, including a buried glacier in a crater about forty kilometers away. But getting to it would mean building a road, setting up a new mining camp, and hauling ice back across rough ground, and it might take longer than thirty-eight days. If it took too long, the settlement would run dry.

"So the question before us," said Mrs. Wanjiru, "is whether we mine the cave."

People began to speak.

Mr. Okoye, who ran the greenhouses, said that the colony's first responsibility was to its own people. He said that two hundred and six human lives had to come first. They hadn't come all this way, risking everything, to die of thirst out of respect for some slime on a wall. If the microbes really were alive, there were probably more of them elsewhere on Mars.

Dr. Paulo said that "probably" was a very dangerous word. This might be the only place. They had no idea. And if they destroyed it, humanity would have traveled across the solar system, found the first proof that we were not alone, and wiped it out to fill their water tanks.

A young astronomer named Lin Fei asked whether they even had the right to decide. This wasn't just their discovery, she said. It belonged to everyone on Earth, and maybe to Mars itself. Shouldn't Earth be asked?

"Earth is twenty minutes away by radio," said Mr. Okoye, "and eight months away by ship. Earth isn't thirsty. We are."

Somebody asked how much water they could save by rationing. The engineers ran the numbers. If everyone cut their water use as much as possible—no showers, recycled water for everything, the greenhouses cut back to essential crops—they might stretch the supply to sixty days. Maybe sixty-five. It would be miserable. But it might buy enough time to reach the crater glacier.

"Might," said Mr. Okoye. "And if it doesn't?"

Nobody had an answer to that.

Zara sat at the back, between her mother and her father, holding Beetle on her lap. She had not planned to speak. But as she listened, she found herself thinking about the green bands on the cave wall. Layer upon layer. Thin as pages. She thought about how long it must have taken them to grow down there, in the cold and dark, while the volcano went quiet and the planet dried up above them. Millions of years, maybe. They had survived all that, alone.

She stood up. Her legs were shaking. Everyone turned to look at her.

"I'm the one who found it," she said. "So I've thought about it a lot." She swallowed. "I think Mr. Okoye is right that people matter. I don't want anyone to die. I don't want me to die." A few people laughed nervously. "But we came to Mars to explore. That's what we always say. We're explorers. And explorers on Earth used to find new places and just... take them. Use them up. Not care what was already living there, because it was in the way. We learn about it in history class, and everyone always says how terrible it was." She looked around the dome. "If we do the same thing here, the very first time it's hard, then what did we even learn?"

She sat down. Her face was burning. Her mother squeezed her hand.

For a long moment, nobody spoke.

Then Mr. Okoye stood up again. He looked at Zara for a while.

"I don't want to be that kind of explorer either," he said heavily. "But I need to know my kids will have water."

"So do I," said Zara's father quietly. "So let's work out how to get it from the crater. All of us. As fast as we possibly can."

Check your understanding

  1. Key details What other water source do the settlers know about?

    1. A river on the surface
    2. A buried glacier in a crater about forty kilometers away
    3. Ice on the Martian moons
    4. Water stored in the greenhouses
  2. Character How would you describe Mr. Okoye's position?

    1. He doesn't care about science at all
    2. He is deeply worried about the settlers' survival, especially his children's, and believes human lives must come first
    3. He wants to protect the microbes no matter what
    4. He wants to return to Earth immediately
  3. Inference What point is Zara making when she mentions explorers on Earth?

    1. She thinks history class is boring
    2. She warns that destroying life on Mars to meet their needs would repeat the past mistakes of explorers who took and used up places without caring what lived there
    3. She wants to go back to Earth to explore
    4. She believes the microbes are dangerous
  4. Theme Which idea about fairness does Lin Fei raise?

    1. That the discovery may belong to everyone, not only the settlers, so they may not have the right to decide alone
    2. That only scientists should vote
    3. That children should not attend the council
    4. That Earth should send more ships

Chapter 4: Forty Kilometers

The council voted at midnight. It was not unanimous. But by a wide majority, they voted to leave the cave untouched, to begin strict rationing at once, and to throw everything they had into reaching the crater glacier.

Zara would remember the next fifty days as the hardest of her life.

Nobody showered. Everybody washed with damp cloths and dry shampoo and smelled, as her father said, "like a locker room on a long journey." Drinking water was measured by the cup. The greenhouses were cut back to beans, potatoes, and lettuce; the strawberries, everyone's favorite, were allowed to die. People were tired and thirsty and short-tempered. There were arguments in the corridors. Two families, furious, sent formal complaints to Earth.

But everyone worked.

The engineers built the road across forty kilometers of rock and dust, working in shifts around the clock, with both rovers and every spare machine. Zara's mother mapped the safest route. The children, even the little ones, helped in the workshop, sorting parts and cleaning filters. Zara and Beetle scouted ahead on the route, Beetle clambering over boulders to check whether the ground was solid enough for the rovers.

On the screen in the corridor, the blue numbers fell: 30 DAYS. 20 DAYS. 12 DAYS.

On day forty-seven of the rationing, with the numbers reading 9 DAYS, the first load of ice from the crater glacier rolled into Arsia Station on the back of the big rover, dirty, rough, and beautiful. The whole settlement came out into the airlock bay to see it. Mr. Okoye stood next to the rover with his hand resting on the frozen block, and he was crying, and so were a lot of people.

By the end of that year, the crater camp was producing enough water for the settlement and more. The blue numbers on the screen climbed back up, and then, one morning, they were replaced with a single word: SECURE.

The strawberries were replanted. People took showers again, which everyone agreed was the best day in the history of Mars.

And the cave on Arsia was left alone.

The settlers sealed off the skylight with a light dome, not to keep anything out exactly, but to mark it: a place where no one would go without the strictest precautions. Over the next years, scientists studied the samples Beetle had collected, and sent tiny, perfectly sterile probes into the tunnel, and argued and checked and argued again. Eventually, after years of tests, the answer came back, confirmed by laboratories on two planets.

Life. Tiny, strange, and slow. Not related to anything on Earth. Alive on the wall of a cave on Mars, where it had been living, scientists believed, for longer than there had been humans, or dinosaurs, or flowers.

Zara was seventeen by then. She was invited to Earth, along with Dr. Paulo, her mother, and Mrs. Wanjiru, to speak about the discovery. People asked her the same question everywhere she went: What did it feel like, to find it?

She always said the same thing.

"Finding it was easy. A robot did that. It took about three hours." She would pause. "The hard part was what came after. Two hundred and six thirsty people deciding to leave it alone. That took fifty days, and it was the bravest thing I've ever seen."

Beetle sits in a glass case in the Arsia Station common dome now, retired, with a small brass plaque. Underneath it, somebody, Zara never found out who, taped a handwritten note to the glass. It says: The first to find them. And the first to leave them be.

Check your understanding

  1. Sequence Which event happened last?

    1. The council voted to leave the cave untouched
    2. The first load of ice arrived from the crater
    3. The screen showed the word SECURE
    4. Scientists confirmed that the microbes were alive and unrelated to Earth life
  2. Vocabulary The vote "was not unanimous." What does this mean?

    1. Everyone agreed
    2. Not everyone voted the same way
    3. No one voted
    4. The vote was secret
  3. Inference Why does Zara say the hard part was "what came after," not the discovery itself?

    1. Because she didn't enjoy driving Beetle
    2. Because choosing to sacrifice comfort and accept risk to protect another form of life required far more courage than finding it
    3. Because the discovery was a mistake
    4. Because she disliked speaking on Earth
  4. Theme Which theme is developed across the whole story?

    1. Survival always justifies any action
    2. Exploration brings a responsibility to protect what we find, even when doing so requires sacrifice
    3. Robots are better explorers than humans
    4. Science should never be shared with others

Spelling words

These 12 words all appear in the story.

  • settlement
  • colony
  • microbes
  • contamination
  • protocol
  • rover
  • sterile
  • specimen
  • rationing
  • astronomer
  • unanimous
  • responsibility

Writing prompt

The settlers of Arsia Station had to choose between their own needs and protecting life they barely understood. Did they make the right decision? Use at least two pieces of evidence from the story, and explain what you would have argued at the council meeting.

Reading skills practiced

Cause and effect, Key details, Vocabulary, Inference, Sequence, Main idea, Character, Theme.

Answer key for grown-ups
  1. The recyclers lose a little water each day, the nearby ice is running out, and the next supply ship is eight months away The screen shows only forty-one days of water left.
  2. It is small and nimble enough to crawl along the tunnel floor where larger rovers can't go The big rover can't get down the skylight, so they need something "small and nimble."
  3. So that no Earth microbes contaminate a place where Martian life might exist The protocol requires equipment to be completely free of Earth microbes.
  4. Even though life is unlikely, he knows science can surprise people, so he keeps an open mind His thirty years of searching have taught him to stay open to possibilities.
  5. Zara turned the camera to find a safe route and noticed strange colored bands on the wall She saw the "color" while checking the wall beside the ice.
  6. The adults realize that the bands on the wall might be something extremely important, perhaps life Her mother's "strange, tight voice" and the call for Dr. Paulo show the sudden seriousness.
  7. Whether to mine the ice the settlers need for survival, even though it might destroy possible Martian life Dr. Paulo explains that mining would bring in Earth microbes and could destroy the discovery.
  8. The rings of a tree or the pages of a closed book Zara compares the wavy bands to tree rings or book pages.
  9. A buried glacier in a crater about forty kilometers away Mrs. Wanjiru mentions the crater glacier but warns it might take too long to reach.
  10. He is deeply worried about the settlers' survival, especially his children's, and believes human lives must come first His arguments are practical and protective, not cruel.
  11. She warns that destroying life on Mars to meet their needs would repeat the past mistakes of explorers who took and used up places without caring what lived there She asks, "If we do the same thing here... then what did we even learn?"
  12. That the discovery may belong to everyone, not only the settlers, so they may not have the right to decide alone She asks whether Earth should be consulted, suggesting a wider responsibility.
  13. Scientists confirmed that the microbes were alive and unrelated to Earth life Confirmation took years of testing, long after the water was secured.
  14. Not everyone voted the same way A wide majority agreed, but some disagreed.
  15. Because choosing to sacrifice comfort and accept risk to protect another form of life required far more courage than finding it She calls the settlers' decision "the bravest thing I've ever seen."
  16. Exploration brings a responsibility to protect what we find, even when doing so requires sacrifice From the protocol to the council and the fifty days of rationing, the settlers choose responsibility over convenience.

More 5th grade stories

🌿

The Hedgerow

Maisie Thornbury's father plans to tear out the ancient hedge that splits their two biggest fields, so the farm can use a larger harvester and pay its debts. Maisie…

5th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerFarm · Nature16 questions
📷

The Attention Score

When Westbrook Middle installs smart cameras that give every student a live "attention score," Nadia Rahman is delighted, because her score is the highest in the class.…

5th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerSci-fi · School16 questions
🛶

Wayfinder

Kaimana has always felt like the least useful person on her grandfather's voyaging canoe. On a training voyage across open ocean with no compass and no screens, a…

5th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerOcean · Culture16 questions
🧵

The Turn-Out

In 1836, eleven-year-old Abby Fletcher changes bobbins in a roaring cotton mill in Lowell, Massachusetts, where her older sister Hannah is a weaver. When the mill…

5th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerHistory · Justice16 questions
🦴

What I Saw at the Museum

On a class trip to the natural history museum, a 450-million-year-old trilobite fossil goes missing from the touch table, and Owen Pryce is absolutely certain he saw…

5th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerMystery · School16 questions
🚴

The Climb to Alto del Sol

In the mountains of Boyacá, Colombia, twelve-year-old Valentina trains every morning to climb like the great Colombian cyclists. Her cousin Andrés is suddenly flying up…

5th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerSports · Family16 questions