The Ghost Station
Every morning, Kwame Mensah's subway train rattles past a dark, abandoned station that isn't on any map. One day, through the window, he sees a word in the old tiles that shouldn't be there. Told by Kwame today and by a girl named Rosa in 1931, this is the mystery of a station that closed before it opened, and the secret message hidden in its walls for ninety-five years.
4th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonCities · History · Mystery2291 wordsAbout 30 minutes
In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.
Words to know
- mosaic
- a picture or pattern made from many small pieces of colored tile, glass or stone
- abandoned
- left behind and no longer used
- Depression
- a time in the 1930s when many businesses closed and millions of people lost their jobs
- immigrant
- a person who moves to a new country to live there
- signature
- a person's name written in their own special way, or a mark that shows who made something
Chapter 1: Kwame
Every morning at seven-fifty, the Number 6 train leaves Grand Market Station and carries Kwame Mensah under the city to school. And every morning, about two minutes later, it passes the ghost station.
Most people don't notice. They're looking at their phones, or sleeping, or reading. But if you stand at the very front of the first car, where there's a window in the door, you can see it. The train slows down for a curve, and for about four seconds, the dark tunnel walls open up into something else: a long, curved room, like the inside of a giant seashell. There's a platform with no people on it. There are arched ceilings covered with cream and green tiles in swirling patterns. There are old glass chandeliers, dusty and dark. And on the wall, in a mosaic of tiny tiles, there's a name.
ASH STREET.
There is no Ash Street Station on the subway map. Kwame has checked. There is an Ash Street up above, a short, quiet street of brick apartment buildings and one laundromat. But no station.
Kwame was eleven, and he had been riding past the ghost station every school day for two years. His family had moved to the city from Accra, in Ghana, when he was eight. Back then, everything about the city had seemed enormous and strange, the noise, the crowds, the buildings that blocked out the sky. The ghost station was the first thing in the city that he'd felt was his. A secret only he knew about.
Then, one Tuesday in March, the train stopped.
It stopped right in the curve, just past the ghost station, with a long squeal of brakes. "We are being held momentarily by the train dispatcher," said a crackly voice. "We apologize for the inconvenience."
Usually, the train had already passed the station by the time Kwame could see much. But this time, it had stopped with the front car right at the end of the dark platform. Kwame pressed his face to the window. The train's headlights lit up the far wall.
He could see the tiles clearly for the first time. The swirling patterns. The arches. The big ASH STREET sign, in green letters on cream. And below it, near the floor, almost hidden by the edge of the platform, there was something else. A small square of different tiles. Darker. Blue.
He squinted. The headlights flickered.
It was a word, made of tiny blue tiles, so small that you would never notice unless you were exactly here, at exactly this angle, with exactly this light.
PAPA.
The train jerked and started moving again, and the station slid away into the dark.
All day at school, Kwame couldn't stop thinking about it. Who would put the word PAPA on a subway wall? Why so small? Why in a station that didn't exist?
That afternoon, he went to the public library on Ash Street and asked the librarian if she knew anything about a subway station under the street. The librarian, a tall woman with silver earrings named Ms. Pryor, looked at him for a long moment.
"You've seen it," she said. "The ghost station."
He nodded.
"It's one of the city's great mysteries," she said. "It was built in 1931. All finished, tiles and chandeliers and everything. And then it never opened. Not for a single day." She lowered her voice. "Do you want to know why?"
Check your understanding
Key details How does Kwame see the ghost station?
- He walks down a secret staircase
- Through the front window of the train, for a few seconds, when the train slows for a curve
- On a school field trip
- On a map in the library
Vocabulary The station "never opened. Not for a single day." It is abandoned. What does abandoned mean?
- Brand new and shiny
- Left behind and no longer used
- Very crowded
- Painted green
Inference Why did the ghost station feel special to Kwame when he first moved to the city?
- He liked old chandeliers
- The city felt huge and strange, and the ghost station was a secret that made him feel the city had something that belonged to him
- His father worked on the subway
- It was the only quiet place in the city
Cause and effect Why is Kwame able to see the word PAPA on this particular day?
- He brought a flashlight
- The train stopped right beside the platform, and its headlights lit up the wall
- Someone had cleaned the tiles
- He was riding a different train
Chapter 2: Rosa, 1931
My papa, Enzo Albanese, set tiles with his hands, and his hands were the most beautiful thing I knew.
They were rough and cracked, with gray grout always stuck under the fingernails, and they could do magic. Give my papa a bucket of tiny tiles, a trowel and a bare brick wall, and in a week the wall would bloom into flowers and vines and swirling waves, cream and green and gold. He learned the trade in Italy, from his father, who learned it from his father, back to the old Romans for all anyone knew. Then he crossed the ocean and came to this city, an immigrant with one suitcase and one trowel.
In 1931, when I was nine, my papa was working on the most beautiful thing he ever made: the new subway station under Ash Street.
It was supposed to be the grandest station on the whole Harbor Line. The city wanted to show that even in hard times, it could still build beautiful things. The ceilings were curved like the inside of a shell. The chandeliers came from a glass factory up the river. And the tiles, the thousands and thousands of tiles, were set by hand by my papa and nine other men.
Sometimes, on Saturdays, Papa took me down the construction stairs to watch. I sat on an upside-down bucket on the unfinished platform, and the men sang while they worked, in Italian and Irish and Polish and Yiddish, all mixed together, their voices echoing off the curved ceiling. The air smelled of wet cement. It was the best place in the world.
But the city above was getting harder. Banks closed. Factories closed. Every week, the line of hungry men outside the church soup kitchen on our street got longer. This was the time people later called the Great Depression. Nobody had money, so nobody paid for anything, so nobody had jobs, so nobody had money.
One night, I heard my parents talking in the kitchen, when they thought I was asleep.
"The city's out of money," Papa said. "They're stopping the Harbor Line. Not finishing it. They might never finish it."
"And the station?" said Mama.
"Done. All done. We finish the last wall Friday. And then they lock it up." He was quiet for a long time. "Twenty years I've been setting tiles in this country. Kitchens. Bathrooms. Hotel lobbies. Rich people's floors. This was the first thing I ever made that everybody would see. Every worker, every kid, every grandmother going to the market. Thousands of people every day." His voice cracked. "And now nobody will see it. Nobody."
I lay in the dark with my eyes open. I had never heard my papa cry before.
On Friday, I went with him to the station for the last time. The men were finishing the bottom row of tiles along the far wall, under the big ASH STREET sign. While Papa was talking to the foreman, I saw a little pile of leftover blue tiles on a board, and a bucket of fresh grout, and his small trowel.
I had watched him for a whole year. I knew how to do it.
So I knelt down at the very bottom of the wall, in the corner, where nobody would look. And with my small hands and his small trowel, very quickly, while nobody was watching, I pressed four letters into the wet grout, one tiny blue tile at a time.
Check your understanding
Main idea What is the main reason the station never opened?
- It was flooded with water
- The tiles were not finished
- During the Great Depression, the city ran out of money and stopped building the subway line
- Nobody liked the design
Key details What languages did the tile workers sing in?
- Only English
- Italian, Irish, Polish and Yiddish, all mixed together
- Spanish and French
- Italian only
Inference Why is Papa so heartbroken that the station will be locked up?
- He will not be paid for his work
- It was the first thing he made that ordinary people would see and enjoy every day, and now nobody will ever see it
- He wanted to ride the train himself
- He doesn't like the color of the tiles
Inference What four letters does Rosa most likely press into the wall?
- PAPA
- ROSA
- ENZO
- STOP
Chapter 3: Kwame
Ms. Pryor told Kwame the whole history: the Depression, the money running out, the station that was finished and then sealed, its staircases bricked over and paved under the sidewalk. Ash Street Station had been sitting in the dark for ninety-five years, abandoned before a single passenger had ever stood on its platform.
"But nobody knows anything about a word that says PAPA," she said, frowning. "I've read every book about the subway. That's not in any of them."
"You know," she said slowly, "a real historian would want to find out. And I have always wanted to be a real historian."
Then she got very excited, the way only librarians get excited, and she brought out a heavy box of old newspapers on film and a stack of city records with yellow pages. For two weeks, Kwame came to the library every day after school. He and Ms. Pryor searched for the names of the workers who built the station.
It was harder than he expected. The records listed the engineers, the architects, the city officials who cut the ribbons on other stations. Their names were in big, bold print. But the workers, the men who actually built it, were hardly mentioned at all.
"That's how history usually goes," Ms. Pryor said. "We remember who paid for things. We forget who made them."
Kwame thought about his own father. In Accra, his father had been a civil engineer who designed bridges. Here, his engineering degree didn't count, so he worked nights fixing elevators in tall office buildings downtown. He was very good at it. Thousands of people rode his elevators every day, and not one of them knew his name.
Finally, in a box of old payroll records, they found it: a list of ten tile setters, paid for work on "Ash Street Station, Harbor Line," in 1931. One of the names was Vincenzo "Enzo" Albanese.
And in a 1931 newspaper, they found a short article, only one paragraph long, about tile workers losing their jobs when the Harbor Line was stopped. There was a blurry photograph of the workers on a half-finished platform. In the corner of the photograph, sitting on an upside-down bucket, was a little girl with dark braids.
"Who is she?" Kwame asked.
Ms. Pryor looked at the caption with a magnifying glass. "It just says 'workers and family.'"
Kwame went home that night and couldn't sleep. He kept thinking about the little girl on the bucket. He kept thinking about PAPA.
Then something unexpected happened. The city's transit museum announced a rare event: for one weekend only, in honor of the station's ninety-fifth anniversary, small groups would be allowed to tour Ash Street Station, with flashlights and hard hats. Ms. Pryor had helped them find old pictures for the tour. She got two tickets.
"One for you," she said to Kwame. "And one for someone who called the library last week, after the tour was announced in the newspaper. She says she has something to tell you."
"Who?" asked Kwame.
"Her name," said Ms. Pryor, "is Rosa Albanese Kaplan. She's one hundred and four years old."
Check your understanding
Vocabulary Ms. Pryor says, "We remember who paid for things. We forget who made them." What is she saying about history?
- History books are always correct
- The names of powerful or wealthy people are recorded, while the ordinary workers who built things are often forgotten
- Workers do not care about being remembered
- Paying for things is more important than making them
Inference Why does the author include the detail about Kwame's father fixing elevators?
- To show that Kwame wants to fix elevators too
- To connect Kwame's own family to the story's idea: his father also does important, skilled work that people use every day without knowing who he is
- To explain how the subway works
- To show that Kwame doesn't like his father's job
Sequence Which did Kwame and Ms. Pryor find FIRST?
- The payroll record listing Enzo Albanese
- The newspaper photograph with the girl on the bucket
- The tickets for the station tour
- The phone call from Rosa
Inference Who is most likely the little girl with dark braids in the photograph?
- Ms. Pryor's grandmother
- Rosa, Enzo Albanese's daughter
- A girl who sold newspapers
- Kwame's great-grandmother
Chapter 4: Rosa, Now
They brought me down in a special chair, the young people from the transit museum, two of them carrying me very carefully down the old staircase they had opened up for the weekend. I told them I was one hundred and four, not made of glass, but they were careful anyway. I let them be.
At the bottom, the boy was waiting. Kwame. He was small and serious, with a flashlight in one hand and a hard hat that was too big for him. He looked at me like I was a ghost.
"Mrs. Kaplan?" he said. "Are you...the girl on the bucket?"
"I was," I said. "A long time ago."
Then they turned on the big work lights, and I saw it again.
Ninety-five years. The chandeliers were gray with dust. Some tiles had fallen and lay in little piles on the platform. Water had stained one corner of the ceiling. But the swirls of cream and green were still there, the vines and waves and flowers my papa had set with his own hands, curving up over our heads like the inside of a shell. It was the most beautiful thing I had ever seen. It still was.
I had to sit very still for a while. Nobody rushed me. The boy stood beside my chair and didn't say a word, and I liked him for that. Most people your age can't stand a silence. He seemed to understand that some places need one.
"I saw something," the boy said finally, gently. "From the train. Near the floor, under the sign."
"Show me," I said.
He took my hand and walked beside my chair to the far wall, under ASH STREET, and he shone his flashlight down into the corner.
There it was. PAPA. Four letters in little blue tiles, a bit crooked, set by a nine-year-old girl in two minutes while nobody was watching.
"You did it," Kwame whispered. "Didn't you?"
"My papa thought nobody would ever see his work," I said. "He said it would be forgotten in the dark. I wanted to put his name on it. His signature. Every artist signs his work. But I couldn't spell Albanese very well yet, and I didn't have time, so I wrote what I called him." I touched the tiles with my old fingers. "He never knew. I never told him. I was afraid he'd be angry that I'd spoiled his wall."
"Would he have been?" Kwame asked.
I thought about it. "No," I said. "I think he'd have cried."
The boy was quiet for a moment. Then he said something that I will remember for whatever years I have left.
"I've seen it every morning for two years," he said. "Every school day, from the train. I didn't know what it meant. But I saw it. He wasn't forgotten. Not really. Somebody was looking."
The transit museum put up a small brass plaque on the wall above the blue tiles. It lists the names of all ten tile setters who built Ash Street Station, the Italians and the Irish and the Polish and the Jewish men who sang while they worked. At the bottom, it says: "And one helper, age 9."
Now, when the train slows for the curve, the motorman flashes the headlights twice, so the passengers at the front can see the station. It has become a small tradition. People put away their phones and look.
Kwame told me he still stands at the front window every morning. He says that somewhere, in some building in this enormous city, his own father is fixing an elevator, and someday, he is going to find a way to put his name on something, too.
Check your understanding
Character How does Rosa feel when she sees the station again after ninety-five years?
- Disappointed by the dust and fallen tiles
- Bored, because she has seen it before
- Deeply moved, so overwhelmed that she has to sit very still for a while
- Angry that it was never opened
Cause and effect Why did Rosa write PAPA instead of her father's full name?
- She didn't like the name Albanese
- Her father told her to
- She couldn't spell Albanese well yet and had very little time, so she wrote what she called him
- There were only four tiles left
Inference Why do Kwame's words, "Somebody was looking," matter so much to Rosa?
- They prove that her father's work, and her secret gift to him, were not lost in the dark after all
- They show Kwame was spying on her
- They mean the station will open again
- They make her worry about who else saw it
Theme Which sentence best states the theme of the story?
- Old subway stations should be torn down
- Only famous people deserve to be remembered
- The ordinary people who build our cities deserve to be seen and remembered, even when history forgets their names
- Children should not touch construction sites
Spelling words
These 12 words all appear in the story.
- subway
- station
- platform
- mosaic
- abandoned
- tunnel
- construction
- immigrant
- historian
- signature
- ceiling
- forgotten
Writing prompt
Rosa's father and the other workers built something beautiful that almost nobody ever saw. Why do you think Rosa hid the tile with her father's name? What does the story suggest about the people who build cities? Use details from both Rosa's and Kwame's chapters to support your answer.
Reading skills practiced
Key details, Vocabulary, Inference, Cause and effect, Main idea, Sequence, Character, Theme.
Answer key for grown-ups
- Through the front window of the train, for a few seconds, when the train slows for a curve If you stand at the front of the first car, you can see it for about four seconds.
- Left behind and no longer used Nobody ever used the station after it was built.
- The city felt huge and strange, and the ghost station was a secret that made him feel the city had something that belonged to him "The ghost station was the first thing in the city that he'd felt was his."
- The train stopped right beside the platform, and its headlights lit up the wall Usually the train passes too quickly to see such a tiny detail.
- During the Great Depression, the city ran out of money and stopped building the subway line Papa says the city is "stopping the Harbor Line."
- Italian, Irish, Polish and Yiddish, all mixed together The workers were immigrants from many places.
- It was the first thing he made that ordinary people would see and enjoy every day, and now nobody will ever see it Most of his work had been in rich people's homes; this was for everyone.
- PAPA In Chapter 1, Kwame sees the word PAPA in small blue tiles near the floor. The two viewpoints connect.
- The names of powerful or wealthy people are recorded, while the ordinary workers who built things are often forgotten The records list engineers and officials in bold, but barely mention the workers.
- To connect Kwame's own family to the story's idea: his father also does important, skilled work that people use every day without knowing who he is Like Enzo, Kwame's father is an immigrant whose work goes unnoticed.
- The payroll record listing Enzo Albanese They found the payroll records, then the newspaper photo.
- Rosa, Enzo Albanese's daughter In Chapter 2, Rosa says she sat on an upside-down bucket on the platform to watch her papa.
- Deeply moved, so overwhelmed that she has to sit very still for a while She says, "It was the most beautiful thing I had ever seen. It still was."
- She couldn't spell Albanese well yet and had very little time, so she wrote what she called him She says she "didn't have time" and "couldn't spell Albanese very well yet."
- They prove that her father's work, and her secret gift to him, were not lost in the dark after all Papa feared no one would ever see his work; Kwame saw it every day.
- The ordinary people who build our cities deserve to be seen and remembered, even when history forgets their names The plaque with all ten names, plus "one helper, age 9," shows this theme.