📚 Reading Quest
🚡

The Cable Car Question

The town of Valbrenna is voting on whether to build a cable car to the top of Monte Corvo, and Nico's class is holding a debate about it. Nico loves the old mountain trail and knows exactly which side he's on, until his teacher assigns him to argue for the other side. Now he has to find the best reasons for something he's against, and the answers he finds will surprise him.

5th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxSchool · Mountains · Friends2690 wordsAbout 30 minutes

Read it in the app 🚀

In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.

Words to know

debate
a formal discussion in which people give reasons for opposite sides of a question
rebuttal
an answer that tries to prove that the other side's argument is wrong
accessible
easy for everyone to reach, enter, or use, including people with disabilities
refuge
a shelter or safe place, such as a hut where mountain hikers can rest
persuade
to make someone agree with you by giving good reasons

Chapter 1: The Wrong Side

The summit of Monte Corvo was 2,904 meters high, and Nico Bernasconi had stood on top of it eleven times, once for every year of his life.

His grandmother had carried him up the first time, when he was three months old, wrapped in a sling against her chest. Every summer since, the two of them had climbed it together. They left Valbrenna at dawn, hiked five hours up the steep trail through pine forests, and stopped for lunch at the Rifugio Corvo, the stone refuge for hikers where his grandmother had worked as the keeper for forty years. Then they climbed the last hour to the top.

At the summit, there was an iron cross, a heap of stones, and a metal box. Inside the box was the summit book: a thick, weather-stained notebook where everyone who reached the top could write their name and the date. Nico's name was in it eleven times. His grandmother's was in it hundreds of times.

So when Nico heard that the town was going to vote on building a cable car to the top of Monte Corvo, he was horrified.

"A cable car?" he said at dinner. "With cables and towers and those little boxes swinging in the air? All the way to the summit?"

"All the way to the summit," said his father, passing the polenta. "A company from the city wants to build it. They say it will bring thousands of tourists to Valbrenna every summer. New jobs. New shops. A restaurant at the top with a glass floor."

"A glass floor?" Nico looked as if he might be sick. "That's... that's terrible. The whole point of the mountain is that you have to climb it."

At school the next day, Nico's teacher, Signora Ferrante, announced that the fifth-grade class would hold a formal debate on the question before the town vote. "Resolved: Valbrenna should build a cable car to the summit of Monte Corvo," she said, writing it on the board in her neat handwriting. "Two teams of four. Each team will give opening speeches, then rebuttals, then closing arguments. Parents and the town council are invited to watch."

Nico's hand shot up. "I want to be against it."

"Me too," said half the class.

Signora Ferrante smiled in a way that made Nico nervous. "I'm afraid it doesn't work like that," she said. "In a real debate, you don't always choose your side. Your job is to find the best arguments for whatever side you're given. That's how you learn to understand people who disagree with you." She pulled names from a jar. "Nico Bernasconi. You're on the team for the cable car."

Nico stared at her. "But I don't believe in the cable car."

"Then you'll have to work harder," said Signora Ferrante cheerfully. "You'll have to find the best reasons you can, even for a side you don't like. And you'll have to understand your opponent's arguments better than they do, so you can answer them."

The other three on Nico's team were his best friend Ines Rocca, a quiet boy named Tomasz whose family had moved to Valbrenna from Poland, and Giulia, who wanted to be a lawyer and argued with everyone about everything.

"This is going to be easy," Giulia said at their first meeting in the library. "Jobs. Money. Tourists. The town is shrinking. A cable car brings people. People bring money. Done."

Nico slumped in his chair. "The other side will say it ruins the mountain. Noise. Crowds. Garbage. Towers sticking out of the wilderness. Animals scared away. And the old trail and the rifugio become pointless. Who's going to hike for six hours when they can ride up in twelve minutes?"

Giulia frowned. "Whose side are you on?"

"Theirs," Nico admitted.

Ines had been quiet the whole time. She sat in her wheelchair at the end of the table, turning a pencil around and around in her fingers.

"I've never been to the summit," she said.

Nico looked at her. He had known Ines since kindergarten. He had known she used a wheelchair since kindergarten, too. But somehow he had never thought about that. Not once, in eleven summers.

"Never?" he said.

"How could I?" Ines said. "The trail is rocks and roots and steep steps. My dad says the view from the top is the most beautiful thing in the whole valley." She shrugged. "I've seen pictures."

Nico felt something shift inside him, like a stone rolling loose on a slope.

Check your understanding

  1. Key details What is inside the metal box at the top of Monte Corvo?

    1. Emergency food and water for hikers
    2. A map of the trail
    3. A summit book where climbers write their names and the date
    4. The keys to the Rifugio Corvo
  2. Cause and effect Why does Signora Ferrante assign sides instead of letting students choose?

    1. She wants the cable car to be built
    2. She is punishing Nico for interrupting
    3. She wants students to learn to find good arguments for any side and to understand people who disagree with them
    4. Most students wanted to be on the cable car team
  3. Inference Why does Nico feel "something shift inside him" when Ines speaks?

    1. He is about to fall off his chair
    2. He suddenly realizes that the mountain he loves has always been closed to his best friend, and he never noticed
    3. He is angry that Ines agrees with Giulia
    4. He remembers that he left his homework at home
  4. Vocabulary Signora Ferrante says Nico must understand his "opponent's" arguments. What is an "opponent"?

    1. A teammate who helps you
    2. A judge who decides the winner
    3. A person on the other side of a contest or argument
    4. A teacher who gives advice

Chapter 2: Gathering Evidence

Signora Ferrante had one rule about the debate that Nico found extremely annoying. "Every argument needs evidence," she said. "Not feelings. Not 'everybody knows.' Facts, numbers, examples, people who know what they're talking about."

So Nico's team went looking.

Giulia went to the town hall and came back with numbers. Fifteen years ago, Valbrenna had 2,100 residents. Now it had 1,450. Six shops on the main street had closed in five years. The cable car company promised forty permanent jobs and estimated eighty thousand visitors a year.

Tomasz found an example. His uncle lived in a village in the Tatra Mountains in Poland, where a cable car had been built twenty years earlier. His uncle said the village had become much richer. Families who used to leave for the cities had stayed. But he also said that on summer weekends the summit was so crowded you had to wait in line to take a photograph, and that some of the old hiking trails were now worn into deep, muddy ditches.

"So it's good and bad," said Tomasz, writing it all down.

"We only use the good part," said Giulia.

"That's not fair," said Tomasz.

"It's a debate," said Giulia. "We're not supposed to be fair. We're supposed to win."

Nico wasn't sure about that. But he didn't say anything, because he had his own job, and it was the hardest one. He had to interview the person who knew Monte Corvo better than anyone in the world.

His grandmother.

Nonna Teresa was seventy-six and had retired as keeper of the rifugio two years earlier.

Nico sat at her table with his notebook open. "Nonna," he said, "I have to argue for the cable car in the debate. But I know you hate the idea. So really, I want you to tell me all the reasons it's terrible, so I can understand the other side."

His grandmother poured him a cup of warm milk with a drop of coffee in it, the way she always had. Then she sat down across from him.

"Who told you I hate the idea?" she said.

Nico blinked. "You... don't?"

"Nico." She smiled, and her face crinkled into a hundred lines. "When was the last time I climbed the mountain with you?"

He thought. "Last summer."

"And how long did it take us?"

He remembered. It had taken them nine hours instead of six. They had stopped every few minutes. His grandmother had leaned on her walking stick, breathing hard, and once she had sat on a rock for a long time with her eyes closed. He had thought she was just enjoying the view.

"My knees are finished," she said simply. "The doctor says no more. Last summer was my last time on the summit." She looked out the window at the dark slope of Monte Corvo. "Do you know how that feels? To spend your whole life on a mountain and then be told you can never go to the top again?"

Nico didn't know what to say.

"So yes," she said. "Part of me hates the idea of a cable car. The noise, the crowds, the glass floor. It's ridiculous. A restaurant on the summit." She snorted. "But part of me thinks, why should the mountain belong only to people with strong knees? To young people? To people who can walk?" She tapped his notebook. "Write that down. That's an argument."

Nico wrote it down. His hand was shaking a little.

"But what about the rifugio?" he said. "If people can ride to the top, nobody will stop at the hut."

"The rifugio was built for climbers," said Nonna. "Climbers will still climb. The real climbers always do. They don't want an easy way. That's why they're climbers." She sipped her coffee. "But I'll tell you what does worry me. Not the cable car. The size of it. Eighty thousand people a year on one small summit? That's not a mountain anymore. That's a shopping center with a view."

Check your understanding

  1. Main idea What is the main idea of this chapter?

    1. Giulia wants to win the debate no matter what
    2. Nico's team gathers evidence and discovers that the cable car question has good and bad sides
    3. Tomasz's uncle lives in Poland
    4. Nonna Teresa used to cook soup at the rifugio
  2. Character How do Giulia and Tomasz disagree about using evidence?

    1. Giulia wants more numbers, but Tomasz wants fewer
    2. Giulia wants to use only the evidence that helps them win, while Tomasz thinks that's unfair
    3. Tomasz wants to change sides, but Giulia does not
    4. They both want to quit the debate
  3. Inference Why do you think Nico's hand shakes as he writes down his grandmother's argument?

    1. He is cold in her kitchen
    2. He is angry with her for changing her mind
    3. He is moved by her sadness and surprised that the argument he must make is one he now partly believes
    4. He is afraid his teacher will be upset
  4. Key details What is Nonna's biggest worry about the cable car plan?

    1. That climbers will stop climbing
    2. That the rifugio will be torn down
    3. That it is too big, and eighty thousand visitors a year would turn the summit into "a shopping center with a view"
    4. That the cables will break

Chapter 3: Both Sides of the Mountain

That night, Nico couldn't stop thinking about it. He lay in bed staring at the ceiling, turning the arguments over and over like stones in his hands.

The cable car would bring jobs. His town was shrinking, and people he knew had moved away. That was true.

The cable car would bring crowds and noise and trash to a wild place. That was also true.

The cable car would let his grandmother see the summit again. It would let Ines see it for the first time. It would let old people and small children and people with heart problems and people in wheelchairs stand at the top of Monte Corvo and look out over the whole valley. That was true too.

But if eighty thousand people went up every year, what would happen to the marmots that whistled in the high meadows? To the quiet that you could only hear at the top, a quiet so deep you could hear your own heart?

Nico realized something that made him sit up in bed. He wasn't really for or against the cable car anymore. He was for some parts and against others. And he suspected that most people were exactly the same, even if they shouted as though they weren't.

The next morning, he went to his team. "I think we should change our argument," he said.

Giulia looked alarmed. "Change it how? We can't switch sides."

"We don't switch sides," Nico said. "We argue for the cable car. But we argue for a different cable car. A better one." He pulled out his notebook. "What if the cable car only goes to the rifugio, not all the way to the top? Then people still have to walk the last part. And what if the path from the rifugio to the summit is rebuilt to be accessible, so wheelchairs can use it? And what if there's a limit on how many people can go up each day, like some national parks have?"

Tomasz nodded slowly. "My uncle said the worst problems in his village came from too many people at once."

Ines was looking at Nico with an expression he couldn't read. "You'd make a wheelchair path?" she said. "To the summit?"

"Is it possible?" Nico asked. "You'd know better than me."

Ines thought about it. "If it's wide enough and not too steep, with switchbacks and a hard surface," she said. "There are places that have done it. I've read about them." She paused. "Nobody's ever asked me before."

Giulia crossed her arms. "But that's not what the company wants. The company wants to go to the summit with a restaurant and a glass floor."

"So?" said Nico. "The debate question is whether Valbrenna should build a cable car. It doesn't say which cable car. We get to argue for the best version."

Giulia opened her mouth to argue, then closed it. Then a slow smile spread across her face. "That's sneaky," she said. "I love it."

For the next week, they worked every lunch period. Ines researched accessible trails, Tomasz worked out how many visitors the summit could handle, and Nico prepared for the hardest part: the rebuttal, where he would have to answer the other team's best arguments on the spot.

The other team was led by Marco Pellegrini, whose father was the most outspoken person in the village against the cable car. Marco had been hiking since he was four. He was smart, fast, and very confident.

The day before the debate, Nico passed Marco in the hallway.

"Good luck tomorrow," Marco said, grinning. "You'll need it. You don't even believe your own side."

"Maybe," said Nico. "But I understand yours."

Marco's grin faltered for a second.

Check your understanding

  1. Sequence What did Nico do right after he realized he was "for some parts and against others"?

    1. He told his grandmother he had changed his mind
    2. He suggested to his team that they argue for a different, better version of the cable car
    3. He argued with Marco in the hallway
    4. He gave his speech at the debate
  2. Cause and effect Why does Tomasz support the idea of a daily limit on visitors?

    1. He wants fewer tourists in Valbrenna
    2. He is afraid of heights
    3. His uncle said the worst problems in his village came from too many people at once
    4. The teacher told him to support it
  3. Inference What does Ines mean when she says "Nobody's ever asked me before"?

    1. People make decisions about places like the mountain without asking people who use wheelchairs what they need
    2. Nobody has ever asked her to join a debate team
    3. She has never been asked to go hiking
    4. Nobody knows she reads about trails
  4. Character Why does Marco's grin falter when Nico says "But I understand yours"?

    1. He thinks Nico is being rude
    2. He realizes Nico has switched teams
    3. He senses that Nico has studied both sides carefully and will be a stronger opponent than he expected
    4. He forgot his speech at home

Chapter 4: The View from the Top

The debate was held in the school gym on a Friday evening. More than a hundred people came, including a man from the cable car company in a gray suit. Nonna Teresa sat in the front row with her walking stick across her knees.

Marco's team went first. They were good. Marco described the summit at dawn, the silence, the eagles, the way the light came over the eastern peaks like spilled gold. He said that a mountain you don't have to climb is just a picture, and that some things should be earned. People clapped loudly. Nico felt his own heart agreeing.

Then it was Giulia's turn. She stood up and gave the numbers: the shrinking population, the closed shops, the jobs, the families who had to leave. She did it clearly and sharply, like a lawyer trying to persuade a jury, and people nodded.

Then Ines rolled to the front of the gym.

"Marco said some things should be earned," she said. "I agree. But I can't earn the summit. Not because I'm lazy, and not because I don't want it. Because the trail was built by people who never imagined someone like me would want to go up it." She looked out at the audience. "I've lived in Valbrenna my whole life, and I've never seen the view from the top of my own mountain."

The gym was completely silent.

Ines explained the plan: a smaller cable car that would only go as far as the rifugio. An accessible path, wide and smooth, with gentle switchbacks, from the rifugio to the summit. A daily limit on visitors. No restaurant at the top. No glass floor. "A cable car," she said, "that brings people to the mountain without bringing the city with them."

Then came the rebuttals. Marco stood up and pointed out that any cable car would still mean towers, cables, and noise in the wilderness. That was true, and Nico said so. "You're right," he said. "It's not perfect. Nothing is. But right now, the mountain belongs only to people with strong legs. My grandmother kept the rifugio for forty years. She can't climb anymore. Should she never see the summit again?" He pointed to the front row. Every head turned toward Nonna Teresa, who lifted her chin. "The question isn't whether a cable car is perfect. The question is who the mountain is for."

Nobody officially won the debate. Signora Ferrante said both teams had argued brilliantly, which Giulia found deeply unsatisfying.

But afterward, the man from the cable car company came over and asked Ines for a copy of her research. And two weeks later, the town council voted on a revised plan: a smaller cable car to the rifugio, an accessible trail to the top, a daily visitor limit, and no summit restaurant. Marco's father voted for it. So did Nonna Teresa.

It took two years to build. On the first day it opened, Nico rode up in the very first cabin with Ines, Nonna Teresa, and Marco, who had insisted on coming. From the rifugio, they went up the new path together, Ines rolling steadily up the gentle switchbacks and Nonna leaning on Nico's arm. It took them almost two hours. Nobody was in a hurry.

At the summit, the wind was cold, and the whole valley spread out below them, green and gold, with Valbrenna tiny as a toy at the bottom. Ines didn't say anything for a long time. She just looked.

Then Nico opened the metal box and took out the summit book and handed it to her. She wrote her name carefully, and the date, and underneath it, in small letters: First time. Not the last.

Nonna Teresa signed beneath her. Then she handed the pen to Nico, and he wrote his name for the twelfth time. He thought that this time was the one he would remember the most.

Check your understanding

  1. Main idea What is Nico's main point in his rebuttal?

    1. A cable car is perfect and has no problems
    2. The old trail should be closed forever
    3. The real question is who the mountain is for, and right now it is only for people who can climb
    4. Marco's team doesn't know anything about the mountain
  2. Inference Why does Giulia find "both teams argued brilliantly" deeply unsatisfying?

    1. She thinks her team was terrible
    2. She wanted a clear winner, because to her a debate is mainly about winning
    3. She wanted the other team to lose badly
    4. She did not want to be on Nico's team
  3. Theme Which theme does the story express most strongly?

    1. Old traditions should never change
    2. New technology is always better than nature
    3. Truly understanding the other side can lead to a better solution that includes more people
    4. Winning a debate is the most important thing
  4. Character What does Ines's line in the summit book, "First time. Not the last.", show about her?

    1. She is worried she will never come back
    2. She is joyful and determined, and she now feels the mountain belongs to her too
    3. She is disappointed by the view
    4. She wants the cable car to go all the way to the top

Spelling words

These 12 words all appear in the story.

  • debate
  • summit
  • accessible
  • opponent
  • argument
  • rebuttal
  • wilderness
  • tourists
  • refuge
  • persuade
  • wheelchair
  • evidence

Writing prompt

Nico had to argue for a side he didn't agree with. Choose a question that people disagree about in your school or town. Write the strongest argument you can for the side you disagree with, and then explain whether doing this changed your mind.

Reading skills practiced

Key details, Cause and effect, Inference, Vocabulary, Main idea, Character, Sequence, Theme.

Answer key for grown-ups
  1. A summit book where climbers write their names and the date Nico's name is in the summit book eleven times.
  2. She wants students to learn to find good arguments for any side and to understand people who disagree with them She says that's how you "learn to understand people who disagree with you."
  3. He suddenly realizes that the mountain he loves has always been closed to his best friend, and he never noticed He had known Ines for years but "had never thought about that. Not once."
  4. A person on the other side of a contest or argument In a debate, your opponent argues the opposite side.
  5. Nico's team gathers evidence and discovers that the cable car question has good and bad sides The team finds numbers, examples, and Nonna's surprising opinion.
  6. Giulia wants to use only the evidence that helps them win, while Tomasz thinks that's unfair Giulia says "we're supposed to win," but Tomasz says "that's not fair."
  7. He is moved by her sadness and surprised that the argument he must make is one he now partly believes Learning that his grandmother can never reach the summit again affects him deeply.
  8. That it is too big, and eighty thousand visitors a year would turn the summit into "a shopping center with a view" She worries "not the cable car" but "the size of it."
  9. He suggested to his team that they argue for a different, better version of the cable car The next morning he proposes changing the team's argument.
  10. His uncle said the worst problems in his village came from too many people at once Tomasz connects the limit to his uncle's experience in Poland.
  11. People make decisions about places like the mountain without asking people who use wheelchairs what they need She knows a lot about accessible trails, but her opinion had never been asked.
  12. He senses that Nico has studied both sides carefully and will be a stronger opponent than he expected Understanding the other side is what makes a debater dangerous.
  13. The real question is who the mountain is for, and right now it is only for people who can climb He admits the cable car isn't perfect but asks "who the mountain is for."
  14. She wanted a clear winner, because to her a debate is mainly about winning Earlier she said, "We're supposed to win."
  15. Truly understanding the other side can lead to a better solution that includes more people Arguing the side he disagreed with led Nico to a plan that served both nature and people like Ines and Nonna.
  16. She is joyful and determined, and she now feels the mountain belongs to her too She plans to return, showing that the summit is now hers as well.

More 5th grade stories

🫧

The Great Hiccup Outbreak

When half of Westbrook Elementary starts hiccuping at once, everyone has a cure and everyone is sure theirs is the best. Fifth-grader Priya Raman decides to find out…

5th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxHumor · School · Medicine16 questions
🐑

The Summer Pasture

Every June, Aibek's family drives their sheep, horses, and yaks high into the mountains of Kyrgyzstan to the summer pasture, just as their ancestors did for a thousand…

5th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxFarm · Animals · Mountains · Migration16 questions
🏃🏾‍♀️

Thin Air

Hana has run the highland trails of Ethiopia since she could walk, and she wants nothing more than to win the regional junior race. Then a team of foreign runners…

5th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxSports · Mountains · Health16 questions
🐢

Lights Out on Playa Luna

Every year, sea turtles swim thousands of kilometers to lay their eggs on the beach where Mateo lives in Costa Rica. But this year, bright new lights along the shore…

5th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxOcean · Animals · Migration · Village16 questions
🫒

The Olive Tree on the Balcony

Three years after her family moved from Syria to Canada, eleven-year-old Leila is the one who speaks for everyone: at the bank, at the landlord's office, and now at her…

5th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxCulture · Family · Migration · Health16 questions
🧊

The Cold Box

When measles appears in a village down the valley, Sunita's aunt, the only health worker in their Himalayan village, must bring vaccines up the mountain before it…

5th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxMedicine · Mountains · Village16 questions