📚 Reading Quest
🧬

Eighty-Seven Percent Beagle

Rupert Achterberg, age twelve and self-appointed Official Historian of the Achterberg-Mensah family, is determined to settle the family's great arguments once and for all with a home DNA test. His grandmother refuses to take part. His uncle insists they're descended from a pirate. And when the results arrive, they reveal something nobody expected, mostly about Rupert.

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonHumor · Family2674 wordsAbout 30 minutes

Read it in the app 🚀

In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.

Words to know

ancestry
the people a person is descended from, going back many generations
genetic
related to genes, the instructions inside cells that are passed from parents to children
privacy
the right to keep personal information to yourself and control who sees it
heritage
the traditions, culture, and history passed down from earlier generations
confidential
meant to be kept private or secret

Chapter 1: The Historian Begins His Work

My name is Rupert Achterberg, I am twelve years old, and I am the Official Historian of the Achterberg-Mensah family. Nobody appointed me. I appointed myself, which I believe is how most important historians have started.

I should explain our family, because it is complicated, and because most of my relatives explain it incorrectly.

My father's side, the Achterbergs, came to America from the Netherlands. Or possibly Belgium. Or possibly, according to my Uncle Pieter, from a long line of Dutch pirates who terrorized the North Sea in the 1600s under the command of a man called One-Eyed Hendrik. Uncle Pieter tells this story at every family gathering, usually while holding a chicken leg like a sword. There is no evidence for One-Eyed Hendrik. I have looked.

My mother's side, the Mensahs, came to America from Ghana. My grandmother, Grandma Efua, moved to Chicago from Accra when she was twenty-three to study nursing, and became the head nurse of an entire hospital, which she mentions roughly once per hour. She knows exactly who her family is, going back seven generations, because her grandmother taught her the names, and she has taught them to my mother, and she is now trying, with limited success, to teach them to me.

Then there is everybody else. My cousins. My aunts. My great-uncle Bertrand, who claims to be one-sixteenth Cherokee, one-eighth French royalty, and a quarter Viking, which adds up to more than a whole person, a fact I have pointed out to him several times.

As Historian, I find this level of disagreement unacceptable.

So, for my birthday, I asked for a home DNA ancestry kit. You spit into a tube, about a teaspoon of saliva, which is harder to produce than you might think, mail it to a laboratory, and a few weeks later the company emails you a report. It tells you what percentage of your genetic material comes from different parts of the world, and can even find relatives you've never met who've also taken the test. Science. Hard evidence. No more One-Eyed Hendrik.

My parents bought me the family pack: six kits.

My plan was simple. I would test myself, my parents, Uncle Pieter, Great-Uncle Bertrand, and Grandma Efua. I would then publish the results in a full report at our family's annual Fourth of July barbecue, settling every argument permanently. I even made a title page: THE TRUTH: A Genetic History of the Achterberg-Mensah Family, by Rupert Achterberg, Historian.

Five of my relatives agreed. Uncle Pieter agreed so enthusiastically that he spat in the tube before I'd finished explaining the instructions, and then had to start again. Great-Uncle Bertrand agreed on the condition that I "don't believe anything the computer says about the Vikings."

Grandma Efua said no.

"Absolutely not," she said, without even looking up from her crossword. "I am not sending my spit to a company."

"It's not a company, Grandma," I explained patiently. "It's a laboratory. For science."

"It's a company," said Grandma Efua. "That owns a laboratory. And keeps your information in a computer. Forever." She filled in a word with a pen, which is how she does crosswords, because she says pencils are for people who expect to be wrong. "Who reads that computer, Rupert?"

"Nobody. It's confidential. It says so on the box."

Grandma Efua finally looked up at me over her glasses. It was the look she probably used to give junior doctors.

"Many things say so on the box," she said. "I was a nurse for forty-one years. I have read a great many boxes."

I want to be fair to my grandmother. She is an intelligent woman. But in this case, I felt she was simply being old-fashioned. I made a note in my Historian's notebook: G. Efua declined to participate. Reasons: suspicion of technology (generational).

Then I gathered the five tubes, plus my own, sealed them in the special envelope, and walked them to the mailbox myself, so nothing could go wrong.

Something went wrong.

Check your understanding

  1. Inference Rupert says he "appointed myself, which I believe is how most important historians have started." What does this reveal about him?

    1. He has a real job as a historian
    2. He is very confident, a bit pompous, and not entirely reliable as a narrator, which creates humor
    3. He was chosen by his family to be historian
    4. He doesn't care about history
  2. Key details Why does Great-Uncle Bertrand's ancestry claim not make sense?

    1. He says he is from Ghana
    2. His fractions add up to more than one whole person
    3. He claims he is a pirate
    4. He refuses to give any answer
  3. Vocabulary Grandma Efua says, "Many things say so on the box." What is she suggesting?

    1. Companies may promise confidentiality, but those promises aren't always trustworthy, so she doesn't automatically believe them
    2. She wants to read the instructions
    3. She likes the box's design
    4. She thinks Rupert can't read
  4. Inference What does Rupert's note, "Reasons: suspicion of technology (generational)," show about his attitude?

    1. He agrees with his grandmother's worries
    2. He dismisses her concerns as old-fashioned instead of taking her reasons seriously
    3. He wants to study her generation
    4. He thinks she is right about privacy

Chapter 2: The Results

The results arrived on a Tuesday in late June, all at once, in six emails.

I opened mine first, alone in my room, with the door locked, the way a historian should when receiving important documents.

The report had a big colorful map of the world, and a pie chart, and a list of percentages. I read it three times.

Your ancestry results: Beagle: 87% Basset hound: 9% Cocker spaniel: 4%

I closed my laptop. I opened it again. It still said beagle.

Underneath, the report helpfully suggested that I might enjoy their premium service, which could tell me about my likely "temperament traits," including "strong sense of smell" and "tendency to howl."

I sat very still for a long time.

Then I went downstairs to the kitchen, where our family beagle, Professor, was asleep in his basket by the radiator, snoring. Professor is nine years old, has long droopy ears, and is the laziest animal I have ever met. He was snoring with his tongue sticking out slightly.

I looked at Professor. Then I looked at the kitchen counter, where two weeks before I had laid out six tubes, all identical, while I was writing names on labels. I remembered that Professor had woken up and come to see what I was doing, and had licked my hand, and then licked the counter, and possibly, I now realized, one of the open tubes, which I had then capped and labeled RUPERT.

I had mailed the beagle.

"Rupert," called my mother from upstairs, in a strange, high voice. "Can you come here, please?"

She was in her office, staring at her own email. Her shoulders were shaking. I thought for a horrible moment that she was crying.

She was laughing so hard she couldn't breathe.

"You're... a beagle," she gasped. "It says... it says you're my son... and you're a beagle..."

The company's matching system, it turned out, had compared everyone's results to find relatives. It had correctly matched my mother and father as unrelated adults. It had correctly matched Uncle Pieter as my father's brother. It had then, with great confidence, listed "Rupert Achterberg" as a "close relative" of nobody, because nobody else in the family was eighty-seven percent beagle.

Within an hour, the whole family knew. Uncle Pieter sent a message to the family group chat that just said WOOF. Great-Uncle Bertrand sent a photograph of a beagle wearing a graduation cap with the caption THE HISTORIAN. My cousin Delphine made a meme.

I want to be clear that this was a laboratory error. Mostly. Well, partly. Let us call it a misunderstanding between a historian and a beagle. Everyone else in the family preferred to call it the most ridiculous thing that had ever happened to an Achterberg, including the time Uncle Pieter got his head stuck in a banister.

There were, however, some genuine results.

My father's report showed that he was mostly Dutch, with some German and a small percentage from Scandinavia. There was no specific evidence of pirates, although Uncle Pieter, who had nearly identical results, argued that "pirates don't show up on DNA tests, that's the whole point of pirates." My mother's report showed mostly West African ancestry, with the largest share from the region including Ghana, exactly as Grandma Efua had always said. Great-Uncle Bertrand's report showed that he was almost entirely Dutch, with no Cherokee, French royalty, or Viking ancestry of any kind. He said the computer was "obviously biased against Vikings."

I printed everything, for the report.

And then, the following week, I received a seventh email, which was not from the company. It was from a man named Gerald, in Ohio, who said that the company's website had matched him to my father as a likely third cousin. He wanted to know if we would be interested in purchasing his book about the Achterberg family, which he said was available for $39.99, and had also sent my father an invitation to join his "exclusive ancestry investment opportunity."

I found it interesting that Gerald had found my father so quickly. I also found it interesting that he knew my father's email address, his city, and his birthday.

I made a note in my notebook. Then, after a moment, I underlined it.

Check your understanding

  1. Cause and effect Why did Rupert's results say he was 87% beagle?

    1. The family beagle had licked one of the open tubes, which Rupert then capped and labeled with his own name
    2. Rupert's family is secretly part dog
    3. The laboratory made up the results as a joke
    4. Rupert sent the wrong email address
  2. Inference Why is the beagle mix-up especially funny given how Rupert presented himself in Chapter 1?

    1. Because beagles are funny animals
    2. Because the self-appointed historian who wanted "hard evidence" and "the truth" made the most ridiculous mistake of all
    3. Because his mother laughs
    4. Because the dog is named Professor
  3. Key details What did Great-Uncle Bertrand's real results show?

    1. That he was one-quarter Viking
    2. That he was part Cherokee
    3. That he was almost entirely Dutch, with none of the ancestries he had claimed
    4. That he was related to French royalty
  4. Inference Why does Rupert underline his note about Gerald?

    1. He wants to buy Gerald's book
    2. He is starting to realize that sharing DNA information exposed his family's personal details to strangers, just as his grandmother warned
    3. Gerald is his favorite relative
    4. He wants to remember Gerald's birthday

Chapter 3: Grandma Efua Was Right, Which She Will Mention Forever

Over the next two weeks, as I worked on my report, I began to notice things.

First, there was Gerald. He emailed my father three more times. Then he started emailing Uncle Pieter. Uncle Pieter accidentally gave him our home address while trying to explain the pirate story. Gerald sent a brochure.

Second, my father started getting advertisements. Online, everywhere he went, for things like "Dutch heritage tours," "Discover Your Viking Roots," and, on one occasion, a wooden clog.

Third, and worst, one evening my mother read a news story aloud at dinner, in a very calm voice. One of the big DNA testing companies (not ours, but one very like it) had been hacked. The personal genetic information of millions of customers had been stolen and offered for sale online, along with their names, their family connections, and their locations.

Nobody at the table said anything for a while. Professor snored.

"Could that happen to ours?" I asked.

"It could happen to any of them," said my mother. "That's the problem with privacy. You only notice it once it's gone. Anything stored in a computer can be stolen. And a password can be changed if it's stolen. Your DNA can't."

"What would someone even do with it?" asked my father, though he looked uneasy.

My mother counted on her fingers. "Find your relatives without asking them. Try to work out if you have a risk for certain diseases. Maybe, one day, an insurance company would want to know that. Or an employer. Or the police could search the database for a match to someone's relatives." She looked at me. "Some of that might even be good, in some cases. Some of it frightens me. The point is, once you've given it away, you don't get to decide anymore."

I thought about the tube. About how quickly everyone had spat into it. About how I'd sealed six envelopes on the kitchen counter without reading the terms and conditions, which were forty-three pages long. (I've read them since. They say, among many other things, that the company may share "de-identified" data with "research partners," and that it may change its policies "at any time.")

I thought about something else, too. My DNA hadn't only been about me. Well, technically, my DNA had been about a beagle. But my parents' DNA was also partly mine, and Uncle Pieter's was partly my father's, and when my mother sent hers in, she had also, in a way, sent part of Grandma Efua's. Grandma Efua had said no. But her genes had gone anyway, inside her daughter's.

That evening, I went to see Grandma Efua. She was in her armchair with her crossword.

"Grandma," I said, "I need to tell you something. I think you were right."

She did not look up. She filled in a word with her pen.

"I know," she said.

"You know what I was going to say?"

"Your mother called me about the news story." She looked up at last, over her glasses. "And Pieter called me to ask if I thought a man named Gerald was trustworthy. I said I'd need to see Gerald's spit first."

I laughed. I couldn't help it.

"I didn't say no because I'm old-fashioned, Rupert," said Grandma Efua, putting down her pen. "I said no because I worked in hospitals for forty-one years, and I have seen what happens when information gets into the wrong hands. And because some things about a person should be theirs to keep." She paused. "Also, I already know who I am. I didn't need a company to sell it back to me."

Check your understanding

  1. Main idea What is this chapter mostly about?

    1. Rupert finishing his report for the barbecue
    2. The family discovering the real privacy risks of sharing DNA, and Rupert realizing his grandmother's concerns were reasonable
    3. Uncle Pieter proving the pirate story
    4. Professor the beagle getting sick
  2. Inference Why does Rupert's mother say, "A password can be changed if it's stolen. Your DNA can't"?

    1. To explain that genetic information is permanent, so if it is stolen, the damage cannot be undone
    2. To remind Rupert to change his password
    3. To suggest DNA can be replaced
    4. To explain how DNA tests work
  3. Cause and effect How did Grandma Efua's genetic information become partly exposed even though she refused the test?

    1. She secretly took the test
    2. Gerald stole it from her
    3. Her daughter's DNA, which is partly inherited from her, was sent to the company
    4. Professor licked her crossword
  4. Character What does Grandma Efua mean when she says, "I didn't need a company to sell it back to me"?

    1. She dislikes shopping
    2. She already knows her identity and heritage through her family's stories and memories, so she doesn't need a test to tell her
    3. She wants a refund
    4. She thinks the company is too expensive

Chapter 4: The Report

The Fourth of July barbecue was held in Uncle Pieter's backyard, as always, with too many hamburgers, an inflatable pool nobody used, and a sign on the gate that Uncle Pieter had painted himself that said WELCOME, DESCENDANTS OF ONE-EYED HENDRIK.

I had prepared my report. It was forty pages long, with charts. I had planned to read the whole thing aloud.

I read two paragraphs.

Then I put it down on the picnic table, under a bottle of ketchup, and said, "Actually, I've changed my mind."

Everyone looked at me. Professor, under the table, looked at me hopefully, in case I was holding a hamburger.

"I was going to read you all the percentages," I said. "And settle all the arguments. But I've realized something." I took a breath. "The percentages didn't settle anything. Uncle Pieter still believes in the pirate. Great-Uncle Bertrand still believes in the Vikings. Grandma already knew everything her test would have said, because she learned it from her grandmother. And the only result that surprised anybody was mine, and that was because I mailed the dog."

Everyone laughed. Uncle Pieter howled. Professor joined in.

"So instead," I said, when they'd stopped, "I want to do a different kind of history. I want to collect the stories. The pirate one, too, Uncle Pieter. Even if it isn't true, it's a true story about our family, because you've been telling it for thirty years and everybody knows it. Grandma's seven generations of names. How my parents met because my father fell off a ladder, broke his arm, and was treated by a terrifying head nurse whose daughter happened to visit her at work that day. That's history. Percentages are just numbers. Stories are what make us an Achterberg-Mensah. That's our real identity."

Great-Uncle Bertrand blew his nose loudly. Uncle Pieter said, "Hear, hear!" and raised a chicken leg.

Grandma Efua didn't say anything. But she nodded at me once, slowly, the way you might nod at a junior doctor who has finally, after much effort, got something right.

That autumn, my family did three things.

First, my parents, Uncle Pieter, and Great-Uncle Bertrand all logged into their accounts and asked the company to delete their genetic data and destroy their samples. It took my father two hours and four phone calls. The company said it would comply, though it noted that some data may already have been shared with research partners and could not be recalled.

Second, my father blocked Gerald.

Third, every Sunday for the rest of the year, I sat with a different relative and wrote down their stories. Grandma Efua went first. It took six Sundays to get through the seven generations, because each name came with a story, and each story came with three other stories, and also a lecture about the time a junior doctor tried to give a patient the wrong medication, which she prevented, single-handedly, in 1987.

I learned that her great-grandmother had been a cloth trader in the market at Kumasi, famous for her temper and her generosity in equal amounts. I learned that her grandfather had walked two hundred kilometers to go to school. I learned that she had come to Chicago with one suitcase and forty dollars and the phone number of a woman from her church whom she had never met, who picked her up at the airport and let her live in her spare room for a year.

"That woman's name was Mrs. Dorothy Hale," said Grandma Efua. "Write her down. She isn't in any DNA. But she's in this family."

I wrote her down.

I have kept the beagle report. It is framed above my desk. My mother had it framed for my birthday, which I felt was unnecessary, but which visitors seem to enjoy. Under it, she had a small brass label engraved:

RUPERT ACHTERBERG, HISTORIAN. 87% BEAGLE. 100% OURS.

Professor sleeps under it most afternoons. He has, as the report predicted, a strong sense of smell and a tendency to howl. He has no interest in history whatsoever. But he is, as far as I can tell, completely certain who his family is.

Check your understanding

  1. Sequence Which event happened first?

    1. Rupert's family asked the company to delete their data
    2. Grandma Efua told Rupert about Mrs. Dorothy Hale
    3. Rupert decided not to read his forty-page report at the barbecue
    4. Rupert's mother framed the beagle report
  2. Inference Why does Rupert say the pirate story is "a true story about our family" even if it isn't true?

    1. He has found new evidence of One-Eyed Hendrik
    2. The story is part of the family's real shared history and identity because it has been told and loved for decades, even if the events never happened
    3. He wants Uncle Pieter to stop telling it
    4. He thinks DNA tests are always wrong
  3. Inference Why does Grandma Efua insist on including Mrs. Dorothy Hale?

    1. To show that family is also made of the people who help and love you, not only those related by blood
    2. Because Mrs. Hale was secretly a relative
    3. Because Mrs. Hale took a DNA test
    4. Because Rupert forgot to write her name
  4. Theme Which theme is developed across the whole story?

    1. DNA tests are always accurate
    2. Pets should be part of science projects
    3. A family's identity is made of shared stories, memories, and care, not percentages, and personal information deserves careful protection
    4. Historians should never change their minds

Spelling words

These 12 words all appear in the story.

  • ancestry
  • genetic
  • privacy
  • percentage
  • historian
  • saliva
  • laboratory
  • heritage
  • confidential
  • identity
  • ridiculous
  • misunderstanding

Writing prompt

Grandma Efua refused to send her DNA to a company, and Rupert thought she was being old-fashioned. Was she? Explain the privacy concerns raised in the story and whether you think the benefits of DNA testing outweigh the risks. Then explain what the story suggests makes up a family's identity.

Reading skills practiced

Inference, Key details, Vocabulary, Cause and effect, Main idea, Character, Sequence, Theme.

Answer key for grown-ups
  1. He is very confident, a bit pompous, and not entirely reliable as a narrator, which creates humor His grand claims about himself are part of the story's humor.
  2. His fractions add up to more than one whole person Rupert notes the fractions add up "to more than a whole person."
  3. Companies may promise confidentiality, but those promises aren't always trustworthy, so she doesn't automatically believe them Her experience has taught her not to trust claims just because they are printed.
  4. He dismisses her concerns as old-fashioned instead of taking her reasons seriously The note shows his assumption that her worry is just about her age.
  5. The family beagle had licked one of the open tubes, which Rupert then capped and labeled with his own name He remembers Professor licking the counter and possibly an open tube.
  6. Because the self-appointed historian who wanted "hard evidence" and "the truth" made the most ridiculous mistake of all The gap between his pompous confidence and his error creates the humor.
  7. That he was almost entirely Dutch, with none of the ancestries he had claimed He blamed the computer for being "biased against Vikings."
  8. He is starting to realize that sharing DNA information exposed his family's personal details to strangers, just as his grandmother warned Gerald knew his father's email, city, and birthday, suggesting a privacy problem.
  9. The family discovering the real privacy risks of sharing DNA, and Rupert realizing his grandmother's concerns were reasonable Gerald, advertisements, and the hacking story reveal privacy dangers.
  10. To explain that genetic information is permanent, so if it is stolen, the damage cannot be undone DNA cannot be reset, unlike a password.
  11. Her daughter's DNA, which is partly inherited from her, was sent to the company "Her genes had gone anyway, inside her daughter's."
  12. She already knows her identity and heritage through her family's stories and memories, so she doesn't need a test to tell her She knows seven generations of her family by name.
  13. Rupert decided not to read his forty-page report at the barbecue His change of plan at the barbecue led to the story collection and data deletion.
  14. The story is part of the family's real shared history and identity because it has been told and loved for decades, even if the events never happened The telling of the story is itself a real family tradition.
  15. To show that family is also made of the people who help and love you, not only those related by blood "She isn't in any DNA. But she's in this family."
  16. A family's identity is made of shared stories, memories, and care, not percentages, and personal information deserves careful protection From the beagle mix-up to the privacy scare and the collected stories, the story shows what really defines a family.

More 5th grade stories

🧠

The Letter in My Handwriting

Ines Albuquerque notices small, strange gaps in her life: an empty hook by the back door, a worn path in the grass, the careful way her family speaks to her. Then she…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonSci-fi · Family16 questions
🧂

A Handful of Salt

In 1930, in the coastal village of Dandi in India, it is against British law for Kamala's family to make salt from the sea at their own doorstep. When word comes that…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonHistory · Justice16 questions
🚛

Forty Centimeters

For six weeks each winter, a road made of frozen lakes and packed snow connects Rae Beaulieu's remote Dene community to the rest of Canada, and her father drives the…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonNature · Exploration16 questions
🤖

The Detective's Assistant

Two days before the regional robotics championship, someone sabotages the Westfield Middle School robot, and Imani Clarke, the sharpest mind in the seventh grade, takes…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonMystery · Friends16 questions
🌲

What the Forest Lends

For three hundred years, the village of Hollin has lived beside the Thornwood under an ancient bargain with the forest's ancient guardian. But the new sawmill is…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonFantasy · Nature16 questions
🐈

The Lynx in Glen Arrin

Lynx have been extinct in Scotland for over a thousand years, until someone secretly releases two into the hills above Fi MacLeod's family sheep farm. When dead lambs…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonAnimals · Farm16 questions