📚 Reading Quest
🌳

The Lungs of Canal Street

Zainab has asthma, and some mornings the walk to school along the busy road leaves her gasping. When the city announces that it will cut down the old trees on Canal Street to widen the road, her neighbor is furious, but her uncle, a bus driver stuck in traffic every day, thinks it's a great idea. Zainab decides to measure the air itself, and the invisible numbers she finds surprise everyone, including her.

5th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxNature · Health · City · School2698 wordsAbout 30 minutes

Read it in the app 🚀

In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.

Words to know

asthma
a condition that makes the airways in the lungs narrow and swell, so breathing becomes hard
inhaler
a small device that sprays medicine into the lungs to make breathing easier
particles
extremely tiny pieces of something, like dust or soot, that can float in the air
exhaust
the smoky gases that come out of a car or bus engine
data
facts and numbers collected so they can be studied

Chapter 1: The Walk to School

The worst part of the walk to school was the corner of Canal Street and Ring Road, where the traffic lights took forever and the cars stood in a long, grumbling line, coughing gray smoke into the cold morning air.

That was where Zainab Hussain's chest started to tighten.

It always began the same way. First, a tickle at the bottom of her throat. Then a small dry cough. Then the feeling that someone had wrapped a belt around her ribs and was pulling it, notch by notch, tighter and tighter. Her breath started to whistle, a thin, high sound she hated.

On a Tuesday in November, standing at the red light, it got so bad that she had to sit down on the curb.

Her older brother, Bilal, crouched beside her. "Inhaler," he said. "Zainab. Where's your inhaler?"

She fumbled in her coat pocket and pulled out the small blue inhaler. She shook it, breathed out, put it to her lips, pressed, and breathed in slowly and deeply, the way the nurse had taught her. Then she held her breath and counted to ten.

The belt around her ribs loosened, one notch at a time.

Zainab was eleven, and she had had asthma since she was four. Most days, it was not a big deal. She took a brown inhaler every morning and night to keep her airways calm, and she carried the blue one for emergencies. She played football at lunch and ran in the school cross-country race. But some days, her lungs simply refused to cooperate, and lately there had been more of those days.

"It's the cars," said Bilal, glaring at the line of traffic. "It's always worse on this corner."

Zainab thought he was probably right. But she didn't know for sure. Nobody could see the air.

That afternoon, she sat in Dr. Abiola's office at the health center with her mother, blowing as hard as she could into a plastic tube called a peak flow meter. It measured how fast air could rush out of her lungs. The little marker shot up the scale and stopped at a lower number than it had last time.

"Your asthma is less well controlled than it was in the summer," said Dr. Abiola. "Cold air can trigger it. So can colds and flu. And so can air pollution, especially from traffic. Have you noticed if it's worse in certain places?"

"The corner of Canal Street," said Zainab.

Dr. Abiola nodded slowly, as if she'd heard that answer before. She gave Zainab her own peak flow meter to take home and a chart to fill in every morning and evening. "Write down where you were and how you felt," she said. "Patterns help us understand what's going on."

When they got home, there was a sheet of yellow paper taped to every lamppost on their street. Zainab's mother read one aloud.

"'Notice of proposed works. The city council plans to widen Canal Street from two lanes to four to reduce traffic congestion. Twenty-two trees will be removed.'"

Zainab looked down the street. The trees were enormous old plane trees, with spotted bark that peeled off in patches like a jigsaw puzzle and branches that met overhead to make a green tunnel in summer. Now, in November, their big leaves lay in golden heaps along the sidewalk.

Their neighbor, Mr. Okonkwo-Price, was already standing beside one of the trees with his walking stick, shaking his head. He was eighty-three and had lived on Canal Street for fifty years.

"Twenty-two trees," he said. "Planted in 1910. They've seen two world wars, and the council wants to cut them down for a few more cars." He thumped the trunk gently with his stick. "These trees are the lungs of this street. Cut them down and the street can't breathe."

That evening, Zainab's Uncle Tariq came for dinner. He drove the number 14 bus, which went down Canal Street twenty times a day.

"Widen the road? About time," he said, helping himself to rice. "Do you know how long it takes me to get down Canal Street at rush hour? Twenty-five minutes. For one kilometer. People are late for work, late for the hospital, late for school. And all that time, the engines are running, the buses are idling, burning fuel." He shrugged. "More lanes, less traffic, less smoke. Simple."

"But the trees," said Zainab.

"Trees are nice," said Uncle Tariq kindly. "But people need to get where they're going."

Zainab looked from her uncle to the window, where she could see the dark shapes of the plane trees against the streetlights. She didn't know who was right. She only knew that her chest felt tight just thinking about it.

Check your understanding

  1. Vocabulary Dr. Abiola says air pollution can "trigger" Zainab's asthma. What does "trigger" mean here?

    1. To cure something completely
    2. To cause something to start
    3. To measure something carefully
    4. To hide something from view
  2. Key details Why does Dr. Abiola give Zainab a peak flow meter and a chart?

    1. To prove that Zainab doesn't really have asthma
    2. So Zainab can record how her lungs work in different places, which may reveal patterns
    3. So Zainab can stop taking her inhaler
    4. To measure the trees on Canal Street
  3. Inference What does Mr. Okonkwo-Price mean when he calls the trees "the lungs of this street"?

    1. The trees have actual lungs inside them
    2. He believes the trees help keep the street's air clean and healthy, the way lungs help a body breathe
    3. He thinks the trees make the street smell nice
    4. He wants to plant more trees on his own street
  4. Character How does Uncle Tariq's view differ from Mr. Okonkwo-Price's?

    1. Uncle Tariq hates trees, while Mr. Okonkwo-Price hates buses
    2. Uncle Tariq believes a wider road would reduce traffic and smoke, while Mr. Okonkwo-Price believes the trees are more important
    3. They both want to cut the trees down
    4. They both want to close Canal Street completely

Chapter 2: Measuring the Invisible

The next morning, Zainab brought her peak flow chart to science club. The club met every Thursday in Ms. Fenwick's classroom.

Zainab told Ms. Fenwick everything: the asthma attack on the corner, the yellow notices, Mr. Okonkwo-Price and Uncle Tariq.

"I want to know who's right," she said. "But you can't see air pollution. So how do you know where it's worst? How do you prove anything?"

Ms. Fenwick smiled the slow smile she always smiled when someone asked exactly the right question. She went to a cupboard and came back with a cardboard box. Inside were five small white plastic boxes about the size of a deck of cards, each with a tiny fan and a little screen.

"Air quality sensors," she said. "The university lent them to us last year for a project, and they never asked for them back. They measure two things. The first is called PM2.5."

"PM what?" said a boy named Kofi.

"Particulate matter. Tiny particles in the air. Soot from engines, dust from brakes and tires, smoke. The '2.5' means they're smaller than 2.5 micrometers across. That's about thirty times thinner than a human hair." She held up one of her own hairs to the light. "Too small to see. Small enough to travel deep into your lungs, all the way down to the tiniest air sacs, where your body can't easily get them out."

Zainab felt a shiver run down her back.

"The second thing these sensors measure is nitrogen dioxide," Ms. Fenwick went on. "A gas that comes mostly from vehicle exhaust, especially diesel engines. It irritates the airways, especially for people with asthma."

"So we could measure the air on Canal Street," said Zainab slowly. "And find out how bad it is."

"You could measure the air in lots of places," said Ms. Fenwick. "And compare them. That's how scientists work. One measurement tells you almost nothing. Many measurements, in many places, can tell you a story."

The science club made a plan. Five members, five sensors. For two weeks, every morning and every afternoon, each of them would carry a sensor along a different part of the walk to school. Zainab would take the corner of Canal Street and Ring Road. Kofi would take a quiet side street with no trees. A girl named Rosa would take the stretch of Canal Street under the plane trees. Another boy, Dmitri, would take the park. And a tall girl named Harriet would take the area right outside the school gates.

They would write down every reading and the time. Zainab would also keep her peak flow chart, so they could compare it with the pollution numbers.

That night, Zainab told Uncle Tariq about the experiment.

He laughed, but not unkindly. "You're going to prove me wrong with a little white box?"

"I'm not trying to prove anybody wrong," said Zainab. "I'm trying to find out what's true." She thought for a moment. "If the numbers show that the traffic jams are the worst part, then maybe you're right. Maybe a wider road would help."

Her uncle stopped laughing. He looked at her with new interest. "That's fair," he said. "Very fair. All right. I'll be interested to see your little box's opinion."

Mr. Okonkwo-Price was even more excited. He insisted on walking with Zainab to the corner every morning to watch, leaning on his stick, asking questions about every number on the screen.

"In my day," he said, "we could see the pollution. Coal smoke. Black fog so thick you couldn't see your own feet. Now the poison is invisible." He shook his head. "That's almost worse. People don't believe in what they can't see."

Check your understanding

  1. Main idea What is the main idea of this chapter?

    1. Ms. Fenwick's classroom is full of interesting things
    2. Zainab and the science club plan an experiment to measure invisible air pollution in different places
    3. Uncle Tariq changes his mind about the road
    4. Zainab's asthma is cured
  2. Key details Why are PM2.5 particles especially harmful?

    1. They are large enough to block your nose
    2. They are so small they can travel deep into the lungs, where the body can't easily remove them
    3. They smell very bad
    4. They only appear in summer
  3. Inference Why does Uncle Tariq stop laughing and look at Zainab "with new interest"?

    1. He realizes the sensors are expensive
    2. He is impressed that she is open to finding out he might be right, instead of just trying to win
    3. He is angry that she wants to prove him wrong
    4. He wants to borrow a sensor for his bus
  4. Theme What does Mr. Okonkwo-Price mean by "People don't believe in what they can't see"?

    1. Invisible dangers are easy to ignore, which is why measuring them matters
    2. People should only believe in things they can touch
    3. Coal smoke was not dangerous
    4. Trees are invisible at night

Chapter 3: What the Numbers Said

For two weeks, the science club measured the air. They wrote down hundreds of numbers. Then, on a Thursday afternoon, they spread all their charts across the tables in Ms. Fenwick's room and tried to make sense of them.

Some things were exactly what Zainab expected.

The corner of Canal Street and Ring Road was the worst. Every morning at rush hour, when the cars and buses were stuck at the lights, the PM2.5 and nitrogen dioxide numbers on Zainab's sensor shot up into the red. On those same mornings, her peak flow readings were the lowest.

"So the traffic jam is the problem," said Kofi. "Your uncle was right. Get rid of the jam and you get rid of the pollution."

But other things were not what anyone expected.

Rosa had walked the stretch of Canal Street under the plane trees, only three hundred meters from the corner. The same cars drove down it. The same buses. But her pollution numbers were noticeably lower than on Kofi's quiet street with no trees at all, even though Kofi's street had far less traffic.

"How can that be?" said Rosa, frowning at her chart.

Ms. Fenwick pulled up a scientific article on her computer. "Large trees can help clean the air near them," she said. "Their leaves trap some of the tiny particles on their surfaces. The rain washes them away later. Trees with big, rough, or hairy leaves are especially good at it." She smiled. "Plane trees have big, slightly fuzzy leaves. They're one of the best."

"But the leaves are falling off now," said Dmitri. "It's November."

"True. So in summer, the effect is probably even stronger. These numbers may be the worst the trees can do."

Then came the biggest surprise. Harriet had measured outside the school gates. At 8:40 every morning, the numbers there were almost as bad as on Zainab's corner. Sometimes worse.

"But there's no main road outside school," said Zainab, confused.

Harriet looked embarrassed. "There's the school run," she said. "Parents dropping kids off. They all pull up at the gate at the same time and leave their engines running while they wait. Sometimes for ten minutes. I counted twenty-six cars one morning."

The room went quiet. Zainab thought about all the times her own mother had driven her to school on rainy days and waited at the gate with the engine running and the heater on. She had never thought about it once.

They looked at the numbers for a long time. Finally Ms. Fenwick asked, "So. What does it all mean?"

Zainab had been trying to put it into words. "It means everybody's a little bit right," she said slowly. "Uncle Tariq is right that traffic jams make the worst pollution. Mr. Okonkwo-Price is right that the trees help. But if they cut down the trees to make the road wider, they'd be removing one of the things that's cleaning the air." She paused. "And if the road gets wider, will there really be less traffic? Or just more cars?"

Ms. Fenwick raised an eyebrow. "That," she said, "is a very good question. Traffic engineers have a name for it. When you add more lanes to a busy road, often more people decide to drive, because driving seems easier, and after a few years the road is just as jammed as before. It's called induced demand. It doesn't always happen. But it happens a lot."

"So widening the road might not even fix the jam," said Rosa.

"It might. It might not. That's what the council needs to think about."

Zainab looked down at all the charts. The invisible air had finally become visible, in lines and numbers and colors. And it was telling a more complicated story than anyone had expected.

Check your understanding

  1. Cause and effect Why were pollution levels on Rosa's tree-lined section lower than on Kofi's quiet street?

    1. Rosa's sensor was broken
    2. Fewer cars drove on Rosa's section
    3. The large plane trees' leaves trapped some of the tiny particles from the air
    4. Kofi walked at a different time of day
  2. Inference Why does Zainab think about her own mother after Harriet explains the school-gate readings?

    1. She wants her mother to drive her more often
    2. She realizes that her own family has added to the pollution without knowing it
    3. She is worried her mother will be late
    4. She thinks Harriet's numbers are wrong
  3. Vocabulary Ms. Fenwick explains "induced demand." What does it mean?

    1. When people stop driving because roads are too busy
    2. When adding more lanes encourages more people to drive, so traffic eventually becomes just as bad
    3. When the council demands that people take the bus
    4. When buses run more often
  4. Sequence Which discovery did the science club make last?

    1. The corner of Canal Street was the most polluted place
    2. The tree-lined stretch had lower pollution than the quiet street
    3. The school gates were almost as polluted as the corner
    4. Widening the road might not reduce the traffic because of induced demand

Chapter 4: The Council Chamber

The council meeting about Canal Street was held in the city hall, in a wood-paneled room. It was packed. Zainab sat in the front row with her mother, Ms. Fenwick, the science club, Mr. Okonkwo-Price, and, to her surprise, Uncle Tariq in his bus driver's uniform.

A traffic engineer from the council spoke first. He showed maps and charts about congestion. He said that widening Canal Street would reduce travel times by up to forty percent.

Then the chair of the council asked if any members of the public wished to speak. Zainab stood up. Her legs were shaking. She could hear her breath, slightly whistly, the way it got when she was nervous.

She explained the experiment. She held up the charts: the red mornings at the corner, the lower numbers under the trees, the surprising numbers at the school gate. She showed her own peak flow chart and how it dropped on the worst pollution days. She explained what Ms. Fenwick had said about leaves trapping particles, and about induced demand.

"I'm not saying nothing should change," she said at the end. "The traffic really is terrible. My uncle drives the number 14 bus, and he's stuck in it every day, and that's bad for him and for everyone on his bus. But if we cut down the trees, we take away something that's helping us breathe. And we might end up with just as much traffic in a few years anyway."

She sat down. Her mother squeezed her hand.

A council member, a woman with silver hair, leaned forward. "So what would you suggest, young lady?"

Zainab hadn't expected that question. She looked at the science club. They had talked about it, but they hadn't agreed on anything.

Then Uncle Tariq stood up.

"May I?" he said. The chair nodded. "I've been driving buses in this city for nineteen years," he said. "I'll tell you what would make my bus faster. Not four lanes of cars. One lane just for buses." He gestured toward Zainab. "My niece showed me her numbers. One bus carries seventy people. That's maybe fifty cars off the road. If the buses moved quickly, more people would take them. Fewer cars, less smoke, and you can keep your trees."

Mr. Okonkwo-Price thumped his walking stick on the floor in approval. A few people clapped.

Then Harriet's mother stood up, looking a little embarrassed. "And maybe," she said, "the school could close the road outside the gates for half an hour in the morning and afternoon. So we parents stop sitting there with our engines running. I'll admit I'm one of them."

The meeting went on for another hour. Some people still wanted the road widened, and shop owners worried about deliveries.

But in January, the council made its decision. Canal Street would not be widened. The trees would stay. Instead, one lane in each direction would become a bus lane at rush hour. The traffic lights at the Ring Road corner would be changed so that buses got priority. And the street outside Zainab's school would be closed to cars at drop-off and pick-up times, starting in the spring.

The first morning the new bus lane opened, Uncle Tariq drove the number 14 down Canal Street in seven minutes instead of twenty-five. He honked the horn twice as he passed Zainab and Mr. Okonkwo-Price on the sidewalk.

That spring, when the plane trees put out their new leaves, big and pale green and slightly fuzzy, Zainab carried a sensor down Canal Street once more, just to see. The numbers under the trees were the lowest she had ever recorded.

Her peak flow chart was looking better, too. Not perfect. Asthma never went away completely. But better.

She stopped under the biggest tree and looked up at the green tunnel of branches overhead, the sunlight coming through in pieces. She took a slow, deep breath, all the way down to the bottom of her lungs.

It didn't whistle at all.

Check your understanding

  1. Character What does Uncle Tariq's suggestion at the meeting show about how he has changed?

    1. He still only cares about making his bus faster
    2. He has been persuaded by Zainab's data and found a solution that helps both buses and the trees
    3. He wants to stop driving buses
    4. He is angry that the trees won't be cut down
  2. Inference Why does Harriet's mother look embarrassed when she speaks?

    1. She forgot what she wanted to say
    2. She is admitting that she is one of the parents who caused pollution at the school gate
    3. She thinks Zainab's idea is silly
    4. She is late for work
  3. Main idea What did the council finally decide?

    1. To widen Canal Street to four lanes
    2. To ban all cars from the city
    3. To keep the trees, create rush-hour bus lanes, give buses priority at the lights, and close the school street at drop-off times
    4. To plant twenty-two new trees in a park
  4. Theme How does the title "The Lungs of Canal Street" connect to the story's message?

    1. It means the street is shaped like a pair of lungs
    2. It connects the trees that help the street "breathe" with Zainab's own lungs, showing that caring for the environment is also caring for people's health
    3. It means Mr. Okonkwo-Price has a lung disease
    4. It is the name of the bus route

Spelling words

These 12 words all appear in the story.

  • asthma
  • inhaler
  • pollution
  • particles
  • sensor
  • traffic
  • exhaust
  • breathe
  • invisible
  • measure
  • council
  • lungs

Writing prompt

The city had to decide whether to widen Canal Street or keep its trees. Explain the best argument each side made. Then explain how Zainab's measurements changed the debate, and whether you think measuring something you can't see is a good way to settle an argument.

Reading skills practiced

Vocabulary, Key details, Inference, Character, Main idea, Theme, Cause and effect, Sequence.

Answer key for grown-ups
  1. To cause something to start Cold air, colds, and pollution can each set off, or start, an asthma attack.
  2. So Zainab can record how her lungs work in different places, which may reveal patterns She says, "Patterns help us understand what's going on."
  3. He believes the trees help keep the street's air clean and healthy, the way lungs help a body breathe Comparing trees to lungs suggests they help the street "breathe."
  4. Uncle Tariq believes a wider road would reduce traffic and smoke, while Mr. Okonkwo-Price believes the trees are more important Each has a real reason based on his own experience of the street.
  5. Zainab and the science club plan an experiment to measure invisible air pollution in different places They borrow sensors and plan careful measurements across the neighborhood.
  6. They are so small they can travel deep into the lungs, where the body can't easily remove them Ms. Fenwick explains that they reach "the tiniest air sacs."
  7. He is impressed that she is open to finding out he might be right, instead of just trying to win She says she is trying to find out what's true, even if it supports his side.
  8. Invisible dangers are easy to ignore, which is why measuring them matters He says today's invisible pollution may be "almost worse" than visible smoke.
  9. The large plane trees' leaves trapped some of the tiny particles from the air Ms. Fenwick explains that big, fuzzy leaves catch particles.
  10. She realizes that her own family has added to the pollution without knowing it Her mother had waited at the gate with the engine running, and Zainab "never thought about it once."
  11. When adding more lanes encourages more people to drive, so traffic eventually becomes just as bad More road space can lead to more cars over time.
  12. Widening the road might not reduce the traffic because of induced demand This idea comes at the end of the discussion, after all the data is shared.
  13. He has been persuaded by Zainab's data and found a solution that helps both buses and the trees He says, "My niece showed me her numbers," and proposes a bus lane.
  14. She is admitting that she is one of the parents who caused pollution at the school gate She says, "I'll admit I'm one of them."
  15. To keep the trees, create rush-hour bus lanes, give buses priority at the lights, and close the school street at drop-off times The decision combined ideas from several people at the meeting.
  16. It connects the trees that help the street "breathe" with Zainab's own lungs, showing that caring for the environment is also caring for people's health The trees clean the air, and Zainab breathes more easily when they are protected.

More 5th grade stories

🫧

The Great Hiccup Outbreak

When half of Westbrook Elementary starts hiccuping at once, everyone has a cure and everyone is sure theirs is the best. Fifth-grader Priya Raman decides to find out…

5th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxHumor · School · Medicine16 questions
🐑

The Summer Pasture

Every June, Aibek's family drives their sheep, horses, and yaks high into the mountains of Kyrgyzstan to the summer pasture, just as their ancestors did for a thousand…

5th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxFarm · Animals · Mountains · Migration16 questions
🏃🏾‍♀️

Thin Air

Hana has run the highland trails of Ethiopia since she could walk, and she wants nothing more than to win the regional junior race. Then a team of foreign runners…

5th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxSports · Mountains · Health16 questions
🐢

Lights Out on Playa Luna

Every year, sea turtles swim thousands of kilometers to lay their eggs on the beach where Mateo lives in Costa Rica. But this year, bright new lights along the shore…

5th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxOcean · Animals · Migration · Village16 questions
🫒

The Olive Tree on the Balcony

Three years after her family moved from Syria to Canada, eleven-year-old Leila is the one who speaks for everyone: at the bank, at the landlord's office, and now at her…

5th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxCulture · Family · Migration · Health16 questions
🚡

The Cable Car Question

The town of Valbrenna is voting on whether to build a cable car to the top of Monte Corvo, and Nico's class is holding a debate about it. Nico loves the old mountain…

5th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxSchool · Mountains · Friends16 questions