The Day They Broke the Levee
In the spring of 1927, the Mississippi River rises higher than anyone has ever seen. To protect the great city of New Orleans, powerful men decide to blow a hole in the levee downstream, flooding the marshes where Rosalie's family has trapped and fished for generations. Rosalie's cousin in the city calls it a wise sacrifice. Rosalie calls it something else. Based on real events.
5th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeyHistory · Rivers · Culture2519 wordsAbout 30 minutes
In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.
Words to know
- levee
- a high bank of earth built along a river to keep it from flooding
- parish
- in Louisiana, a region like a county
- evacuate
- to leave a place because it is dangerous
- compensation
- money paid to someone to make up for a loss
- décima
- a ten-line song or poem, a tradition the Isleño people brought from the Canary Islands
Chapter 1: The River Rises
In the spring of 1927, the Mississippi River was the angriest anyone had ever seen it.
All winter, rain had poured down over the middle of America. It fell on the plains, the forests, the farms of Iowa and Illinois and Missouri. It filled the Ohio River and the Missouri River and a hundred smaller rivers, and every one of them emptied into the Mississippi. By April, the great river was swollen and brown and roaring, carrying whole trees and pieces of barns as it rushed south toward the sea.
Rosalie Esteves was eleven years old, and she lived at the very end of it.
Her family's house stood on stilts at the edge of the marsh in St. Bernard Parish, just downriver from New Orleans. Her people were Isleños. Their ancestors had sailed from the Canary Islands, off the coast of Africa, more than a hundred and fifty years before. They had settled in the wild wetlands south of the city and learned to live with the water. They fished for shrimp and oysters. In winter, they trapped muskrats in the marsh and sold the soft brown furs to buyers from New York and Paris.
Rosalie's father had a flat-bottomed wooden boat called a pirogue that he could pole through grass so thick it looked like solid ground. Her mother mended nets on the porch. Her grandmother, Abuela Pilar, sang décimas, long ten-line songs in Spanish that told stories about storms and saints and fishermen lost at sea. The songs had come with their ancestors all the way across the ocean, passed from mouth to mouth for generations.
That April, the songs stopped. Everyone was listening to the river instead.
Between the marsh and the river stood the levee, a long, high bank of earth that kept the Mississippi in its channel. Rosalie had climbed it a thousand times. From the top, you could see the great river on one side, and the low, green marsh on the other, lying well below the water. It always made Rosalie a little dizzy. The river was higher than her house.
Now the river was higher than ever. It lapped near the top of the levee. Men from the parish walked the bank day and night with lanterns, looking for leaks. Rosalie's father joined them, stacking sandbags until his hands bled.
News came by newspaper and telegram and word of mouth. Upriver, levees had already broken in Mississippi and Arkansas. Whole towns were underwater. Hundreds of thousands of people had lost their homes. Families were living on top of levees in tents, surrounded by miles of brown water.
And now, everyone said, the flood was coming to New Orleans.
New Orleans was the biggest city in the South, with more than four hundred thousand people. It sat in a low bowl, much of it below the level of the river. If the levees there broke, the whole city could drown.
Rosalie had a cousin in New Orleans, Henri, who was twelve. He sold newspapers on a street corner downtown, shouting the headlines to people walking past. Every week, he wrote Rosalie a letter. His latest one arrived on April twentieth.
"Everyone here is scared," Henri wrote. "The bankers and the big men are having meetings every day. My boss at the paper says they have a plan to save the city. He says it's a secret, but it's going to be big."
Rosalie read the letter twice. She did not know why, but it gave her a cold feeling in her stomach.
Check your understanding
Key details Where did Rosalie's Isleño ancestors come from?
- From France
- From Mexico
- From the Canary Islands, off the coast of Africa
- From New York
Cause and effect Why was the Mississippi so high in the spring of 1927?
- A hurricane pushed seawater into it
- Heavy rain across the middle of America filled many rivers that all drained into the Mississippi
- A dam upstream broke
- Snow melted in Louisiana
Vocabulary Rosalie's grandmother sings décimas. Based on the story, what are décimas?
- Spanish recipes
- Fishing nets
- Ten-line songs that tell stories, passed down from their ancestors
- Letters from relatives
Inference Why does Henri's letter give Rosalie "a cold feeling in her stomach"?
- She is jealous of Henri's job
- She thinks Henri is lying
- She senses that the city's secret plan might somehow affect her own family
- She doesn't like the bankers
Chapter 2: The Plan
The secret did not stay secret for long.
On April twenty-sixth, a man in a fine gray suit came down the river road in a shiny black automobile. He stopped at the parish courthouse, and by evening, the news had spread to every house in St. Bernard.
The leaders of New Orleans, along with the governor, had decided to blow up the levee.
They had chosen a spot called Caernarvon, about thirteen miles below the city. They would set off dynamite in the levee there and open a gap. The river would rush through the gap and spill out across the marshes of St. Bernard and Plaquemines Parishes, toward the sea. The water level near New Orleans would drop, and the city would be saved.
The people living in the flooded area, about ten thousand of them, would have to evacuate. Their homes, their boats, their traps, their land would be underwater. But the city promised, in writing, to pay them back for everything they lost.
Rosalie's father came home from the courthouse that night with his face gray.
"They are going to drown us," he said quietly, "to keep their feet dry."
Abuela Pilar crossed herself. Rosalie's mother sat down heavily at the kitchen table.
"They promised to pay," her mother said. "The man said there would be compensation."
"Promises." Her father laughed, but it wasn't a real laugh. "Promises from bankers in the city. To trappers and fishermen. Do you think they will remember us when the water goes down?"
That night, Rosalie wrote a letter to Henri by candlelight. Her hand shook as she wrote.
"They are going to flood our parish to save your city," she wrote. "How can they do this? This is our home. My father's traps are here, and our boat, and our house, and the church where I was baptized. Abuela was born in this house. Do the people in New Orleans even know we are here?"
Henri's answer came back quickly, three days later. It was not what she expected.
"I'm sorry, Rosalie, I really am," he wrote. "But you have to understand. There are four hundred thousand people in the city. If the levee breaks here, thousands could die. Hospitals. Schools. Little babies. My boss at the paper calls it a necessary sacrifice. He says the leaders had no choice. They have to protect the most people. Isn't it better that ten thousand people lose their homes than that four hundred thousand lose everything? And they promised to pay you back. Uncle Tomás will get a new boat. Maybe a better one."
Rosalie read the letter on the porch, with the marsh stretching green and gold in front of her. Red-winged blackbirds sang in the reeds. Somewhere out there, a muskrat was building its little dome-shaped house of grass and mud, the way muskrats had done for thousands of years.
She was angry at Henri. But she was angrier that some part of her thought he had a point.
Four hundred thousand people. It was more people than she could even imagine. Hospitals and schools and babies. If it were her choice, would she let all those people drown to save one marsh?
No, she thought. Of course not.
But then she thought of her father's face, gray in the lamplight. She thought of Abuela Pilar, born in this house eighty years before. She thought of the way the man in the gray suit had driven away in his shiny black car, back to the city, without even getting out to look at the marsh.
Nobody had asked them, she realized. That was what hurt the most. Not just that the decision was made, but that it was made somewhere far away, by people who would never see what they were giving up.
Check your understanding
Sequence Which happens first in Chapter 2?
- Rosalie writes a letter to Henri
- Henri writes back that the leaders had no choice
- A man in a gray suit brings news of the plan to the courthouse
- Rosalie reads Henri's letter on the porch
Character What is Henri's opinion about the plan to break the levee?
- He thinks it is cruel and should be stopped
- He feels sorry, but thinks protecting the city's many people is more important
- He doesn't care either way
- He thinks the plan will not work
Inference Why does Rosalie's father say "They are going to drown us to keep their feet dry"?
- He feels that the powerful city leaders are protecting themselves by pushing the cost onto poorer people downriver
- He thinks the city leaders want to go swimming
- He is confused about where the water will go
- He thinks New Orleans is already flooded
Main idea According to Rosalie, what hurts most about the decision?
- That the city leaders were rude
- That Henri disagrees with her
- That the decision was made far away by people who never asked her community or saw what was being lost
- That her family has to move to New Orleans
Chapter 3: The Water Comes
The family packed in two days.
They loaded what they could carry onto a wagon: bedding, pots and pans, a crate of chickens, Abuela's wooden chest, a picture of the Virgin Mary from the wall. Rosalie's father made three trips in the pirogue, poling it up the bayou to a cousin's house on higher ground. Everything else had to be left behind: the table her grandfather had built, the net-mending bench, the stilts and walls and roof of the only home Rosalie had ever known.
On the morning they left, Rosalie walked through every room one last time. She touched the doorframe where her height had been marked every birthday since she was three. She tried to memorize the sound the floorboards made under her feet.
Abuela Pilar sat on the porch steps and did not move. "Come, Mamá," Rosalie's mother said. "It's time."
Abuela stood slowly. Then she did something Rosalie had never seen her do. She began to sing.
It was a décima, an old one. Rosalie knew the tune. It was about a fisherman whose boat was lost at sea, and how his village waited on the shore for him every night for a year. Abuela's voice was thin and cracked, but it carried out over the marsh, and for a moment, even the blackbirds were quiet.
When she finished, she closed the door behind her, and did not look back.
On April 29, 1927, the engineers set off the first charge of dynamite at Caernarvon.
Rosalie heard it from her cousin's house five miles away: a deep thud that she felt in her chest more than she heard with her ears. Then another. Then another. The levee was thick and strong, and it took many blasts over many days to tear the gap wide open. Crowds of people came down from New Orleans in automobiles and on boats to watch, as though it were a show. Some of them had brought picnic lunches.
When the gap finally opened, the Mississippi poured through it with a roar like a freight train. A wall of brown water rushed across the marsh. It swallowed the reeds, the muskrat houses, the trapping trails, the fishing camps. It rose up the stilts of Rosalie's house, and then over the porch, and then through the door, until only the roof could be seen above the water.
Rosalie watched from the top of the levee with her father. Neither of them said a word.
Far out in the brown water, she could see things floating past: a wooden crate, a broken chair, a muskrat paddling desperately toward the levee. Her father climbed down to the water's edge and held out his pole, and the muskrat scrambled up it onto dry ground, shook itself, and vanished into the grass. Her father watched it go. "At least one of us found a way out," he said.
A few days later, a letter arrived from Henri. It was short.
"The river is going down here," he wrote. "Everyone is celebrating. My boss printed a headline that says CITY SAVED. I sold more papers than ever. But I keep thinking about you. I'm sorry, Rosalie. I don't know what else to say."
Rosalie folded the letter and put it in her pocket. She didn't know what to say either.
Check your understanding
Key details What did Abuela Pilar do before leaving the house?
- She cried and refused to go
- She wrote a letter to the governor
- She sang an old décima about a lost fisherman
- She locked the door and hid the key
Inference Why might the author include the detail that some people from the city brought picnic lunches to watch the dynamite?
- To show that the city had good food
- To show the painful difference between people treating it as entertainment and people losing their homes
- To explain how the dynamite worked
- To show that everyone in the city was cruel
Vocabulary The river poured through "with a roar like a freight train." What does this simile help the reader understand?
- That a train was nearby
- How loud and powerful the rushing water was
- That the water moved slowly
- That the levee was made of metal
Character How does Henri seem to feel in his last short letter?
- Proud that the city was saved
- Torn, because he is glad the city is safe but feels sorry for his cousin's loss
- Angry at Rosalie
- Excited about selling papers
Chapter 4: A Décima for the Marsh
The water stayed on the marsh for months.
When it finally drained away in the summer, Rosalie's family returned to find their house still standing, but ruined. The walls were coated in thick mud. The floorboards had buckled. A family of snakes had moved into the kitchen. The table her grandfather built had floated away and never been found.
Worse, the muskrats were gone. The flood had drowned them or driven them away. It would be years before the trapping was good again. Rosalie's father, like hundreds of other trappers, had no way to earn a living.
The city had promised to pay. And some people did get money. But the process was slow and confusing. You had to fill out long forms and prove what you had lost, with receipts and papers that most trappers had never had. Lawyers in the city argued about every claim. Many families received only a small fraction of what they had lost. Some received nothing at all.
And then came the bitterest news of all. Scientists studying the flood later said that the city might not have needed the levee broken. Upriver, other levees had collapsed on their own, letting so much water spread out that the river near New Orleans had already begun to fall. The dynamite, they said, might not have been necessary.
When Rosalie heard that, she ran out of the house and climbed up onto the levee, and sat there alone for a long time, looking at the river. It was calm now, brown and slow and peaceful, as though it had never done anything wrong.
That evening, Abuela Pilar found her there. She climbed up slowly, leaning on Rosalie's father's arm, and sat down beside her.
"It's not fair," Rosalie said, and her voice cracked. "They didn't even need to do it. They didn't ask us. And now they won't even pay."
"No," Abuela agreed. "It is not fair."
"Henri said they had to protect the most people. Maybe he was right. Maybe I would have done the same thing, if I were in charge. But they could have asked us. They could have kept their promise. They could have come and looked."
Abuela was quiet for a while. "Do you know why we sing the décimas, nieta?" she asked.
Rosalie shook her head.
"When our people came from the Canary Islands, they had nothing. No money, no power, no one in the government who listened. All they had was memory. So they put everything into the songs: the storms, the shipwrecks, the hard times and the good. They sang them to their children, and their children sang them to theirs, so that no one could ever say those things did not happen." She looked out at the marsh, gold in the setting sun. "The bankers write the newspapers. The governor writes the history books. But we write the songs."
Rosalie thought about that for a long time.
That fall, she began to write a décima of her own. It was hard. A décima had ten lines, and the lines had to rhyme in a certain pattern, and every line had to have exactly the right number of beats. She worked on it for weeks, crossing out and starting over, borrowing words from the old songs and finding new ones of her own.
When it was finished, she sang it for Abuela on the porch of their muddy, half-repaired house. It told the story of the river and the dynamite and the picnic crowds. It told of the promise made and broken. But it also told of Henri, who sold the papers that said CITY SAVED, and felt sorry anyway. It told of a city full of babies and schools that truly had been afraid. Rosalie did not want her song to be only angry. She wanted it to be true.
At the end, Abuela wiped her eyes.
"Good," she said. "Now it will be remembered."
Rosalie copied the song out carefully and mailed it to Henri, so that it would be remembered in the city too. Henri wrote back that he had read it aloud to his boss at the newspaper. His boss had been quiet for a long time. Then he had said, "Maybe we got the headline wrong."
Rosalie kept that letter for the rest of her life, folded inside the old wooden chest with Abuela's songs, like a small document of history that no textbook would ever print.
Check your understanding
Cause and effect Why did many trappers receive little or no compensation?
- They refused to accept money from the city
- The claims process required forms and receipts many trappers didn't have, and lawyers argued about each claim
- The city gave all the money to Henri's newspaper
- They moved away before the money arrived
Key details What did scientists later say about the decision to break the levee?
- It saved the city exactly as planned
- It may not have been necessary, because other levees upriver had already broken and lowered the river
- It caused the flooding upriver
- It should have been done sooner
Inference Why does Rosalie include Henri and the frightened city in her décima instead of making it only angry?
- She has forgiven the bankers completely
- Abuela told her she had to
- She wants the song to tell the whole truth, including the fears of the other side
- She ran out of things to say about St. Bernard
Theme What does Abuela mean when she says, "The bankers write the newspapers... But we write the songs"?
- Isleños should stop reading newspapers
- Songs are more fun than newspapers
- People without power can still preserve their own version of history through their stories and traditions
- Rosalie should become a banker
Spelling words
These 12 words all appear in the story.
- levee
- dynamite
- parish
- sacrifice
- muskrat
- telegram
- evacuate
- promise
- compensation
- marsh
- document
- swollen
Writing prompt
The leaders of New Orleans believed breaking the levee was necessary to save their city. The people of St. Bernard believed it was unfair. Using at least three details from the story, explain both points of view. Then explain what you think the leaders should have done differently.
Reading skills practiced
Key details, Cause and effect, Vocabulary, Inference, Sequence, Character, Main idea, Theme.
Answer key for grown-ups
- From the Canary Islands, off the coast of Africa Their ancestors sailed from the Canary Islands more than 150 years before.
- Heavy rain across the middle of America filled many rivers that all drained into the Mississippi Rain filled the Ohio, Missouri and other rivers, which all emptied into the Mississippi.
- Ten-line songs that tell stories, passed down from their ancestors The décimas came "across the ocean, passed from mouth to mouth for generations."
- She senses that the city's secret plan might somehow affect her own family Rosalie lives just downriver, and a "big" secret plan makes her uneasy.
- A man in a gray suit brings news of the plan to the courthouse The man in the gray suit arrives first, and the letters follow.
- He feels sorry, but thinks protecting the city's many people is more important He argues that saving 400,000 people outweighs the loss of 10,000 homes.
- He feels that the powerful city leaders are protecting themselves by pushing the cost onto poorer people downriver He sees the plan as rich people saving themselves at the expense of trappers and fishermen.
- That the decision was made far away by people who never asked her community or saw what was being lost She realizes "Nobody had asked them."
- She sang an old décima about a lost fisherman Abuela sings a décima that carries out over the marsh.
- To show the painful difference between people treating it as entertainment and people losing their homes The picnics contrast sharply with Rosalie's family watching their home disappear.
- How loud and powerful the rushing water was Comparing it to a freight train shows its noise and force.
- Torn, because he is glad the city is safe but feels sorry for his cousin's loss He celebrates with the city but keeps thinking of Rosalie and doesn't know what to say.
- The claims process required forms and receipts many trappers didn't have, and lawyers argued about each claim The process was slow, confusing, and required papers most trappers had never kept.
- It may not have been necessary, because other levees upriver had already broken and lowered the river Other levee breaks had already caused the river near the city to begin falling.
- She wants the song to tell the whole truth, including the fears of the other side She "did not want her song to be only angry. She wanted it to be true."
- People without power can still preserve their own version of history through their stories and traditions The décimas keep alive memories that official histories might leave out.