📚 Reading Quest
🐈

The Lynx in Glen Arrin

Lynx have been extinct in Scotland for over a thousand years, until someone secretly releases two into the hills above Fi MacLeod's family sheep farm. When dead lambs are found, the whole glen blames the wild cats. Fi and her friend Tariq, whose mother wants lynx brought back properly, set a camera trap to find the truth, and discover that the truth satisfies nobody completely.

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonAnimals · Farm2760 wordsAbout 30 minutes

Read it in the app 🚀

In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.

Words to know

predator
an animal that hunts and eats other animals
reintroduction
returning an animal species to an area where it used to live but had died out
livestock
farm animals, such as sheep, cattle, and goats
overgrazing
when animals eat so much of the plants in an area that the land is damaged and cannot recover
coexistence
living together in the same place at the same time, without destroying each other

Chapter 1: Fi — Tracks in the Snow

The first person in Glen Arrin to see the lynx was my father, and he didn't believe it.

He'd been out at dawn in late January, checking the ewes on the hill above Corrie Beag, when something crossed the track in front of his quad bike about thirty meters ahead. A cat, he said. A big one. Bigger than a dog, gray-gold with dark spots, long legs, a short black-tipped tail, and ears with long black tufts on the tips like little paintbrushes. It stopped in the middle of the track and looked at him. Then it walked unhurriedly into the heather and disappeared.

"I thought I was seeing things," he said at breakfast, rubbing his face. "It looked exactly like a lynx. But there are no lynx in Scotland."

"There were," said my little brother Callum, who is eight and knows a lot of facts. "A long time ago."

He was right. Lynx used to live all over Britain. But they were hunted, and the forests where they lived were cut down, and by about thirteen hundred years ago they were gone. Extinct here, though they still lived in other parts of Europe. Now, people had started arguing about bringing them back. Some scientists and conservation groups wanted a reintroduction, a careful, official release of lynx into the wild, like the beavers that had been brought back to some Scottish rivers. Most sheep farmers I knew were against it. To them, a lynx was simply a predator, one more danger to their livestock on hills that were already hard to farm. Very against it. My father had signed a petition.

"Maybe it escaped from a wildlife park," my mother said.

But two days later, Callum and I found tracks in fresh snow at the edge of the forestry plantation above our top field. Round prints, as big as my palm, with four toe pads and no claw marks. Cat tracks. And beside them, a second set, slightly smaller.

Two of them.

By the end of the week, the whole glen knew. A man from the government wildlife office came out with a clipboard and photographed the tracks. He confirmed what everyone suspected. Two lynx were living in the hills above Glen Arrin. Nobody had reported any escapes from any wildlife park. Which meant only one thing: someone had released them. Illegally. In secret.

My father was furious in a way I'd never seen before.

"Somebody decided," he said, pacing the kitchen. "Some person from a city somewhere decided they knew best and dumped two predators on my hill. Didn't ask anyone. Didn't ask the people who actually live here. Who'll pay when they start killing my lambs?" He stopped by the window and looked up at the snowy hill. "It's not even about the lynx. It's about being treated like we don't matter."

That evening, my best friend Tariq Hussain came over to do homework. Tariq's family had moved to the glen three years ago from Glasgow. His mother, Dr. Hussain, was an ecologist who worked for a conservation trust. And she had been, for years, one of the loudest voices in Scotland arguing for lynx reintroduction.

Tariq knew what my father thought. I knew what his mother thought. We'd always managed not to talk about it.

That night we sat at my kitchen table with our maths books open, not doing maths, looking at each other.

"My mum didn't do it," Tariq said finally. "I know what everyone's saying. She didn't. She's really angry about it, actually."

"Why would she be angry?" I said. "She got what she wanted."

"No, she didn't," said Tariq. "That's the thing. She says a secret release is the worst thing that could happen. She says it'll make everyone hate lynx forever."

I didn't understand that then. I thought about it later.

Check your understanding

  1. Key details How did lynx disappear from Britain?

    1. They migrated to other countries
    2. They were hunted and their forests were cut down, and they went extinct about 1,300 years ago
    3. They were all moved to zoos
    4. A disease killed them recently
  2. Inference What does Fi's father mean when he says, "It's not even about the lynx. It's about being treated like we don't matter"?

    1. His deepest anger is that people who live in the glen were not consulted about a decision that affects their lives
    2. He secretly likes lynx
    3. He wants to be on television
    4. He thinks the government released them
  3. Inference Why might Dr. Hussain, who supports lynx reintroduction, be angry about a secret release?

    1. She wanted to release them herself
    2. She is afraid of lynx
    3. She believes an illegal release will turn people against lynx and damage any chance of a fair, official reintroduction
    4. She thinks there should be more than two
  4. Character How have Fi and Tariq handled their families' disagreement before this chapter?

    1. They argue about it every day
    2. They have avoided talking about it to protect their friendship
    3. They both agree with Fi's father
    4. They have written a report together

Chapter 2: Tariq — The Case for the Cat

I'm going to explain my mum's side, because Fi asked me to, and because I think most people in Glen Arrin only heard half of it.

My mum doesn't want lynx back because they're cute. (They are cute, a bit. But that's not the point.) She wants them back because of deer.

Scotland has a huge number of red deer and roe deer, far more than the land can support. Hundreds of thousands. The reason there are so many is that there's nothing left to eat them. Wolves, bears, and lynx all used to hunt deer here, and they're all gone. So the deer population just keeps growing, and people have to shoot thousands every year to stop it getting even bigger.

Too many deer causes overgrazing. Deer eat young trees: saplings, seedlings, new shoots. They eat them before they can grow. That's one reason why so much of the Scottish Highlands is bare hillside instead of forest. Not because it's natural, my mum says, but because nothing young survives long enough to become a tree. She showed me photos of a hillside where they'd put up a fence to keep deer out. Inside the fence, after ten years, there was a young forest. Outside the fence, bare heather. Same hill. Same soil. The only difference was deer.

Lynx are ambush hunters. They mostly eat roe deer, the smaller kind, which are the ones that do a lot of damage to young woodland. They don't just reduce the number of deer. They change how deer behave. Deer get nervous. They don't stand in one place munching saplings for hours. They keep moving. Scientists call this a "landscape of fear," which sounds scary but actually means forests can grow back.

"An ecosystem is like a machine with missing parts," my mum told me once. "We took out the predators a long time ago and we've been trying to fix it with rifles and fences ever since. A lynx is a part that fits."

But here's the other half, the part people didn't hear.

My mum always said that lynx could only come back if the people who live alongside them agreed to it. She'd spent five years going to farmers' meetings, listening, answering questions, getting shouted at. She'd been working on a plan: years of consultation with every community, a proper study of where lynx could live, a fund to pay farmers compensation for any sheep killed, a team to track every animal with radio collars. In other countries in Europe where lynx were brought back, she said, the places where it worked were the places where farmers had been part of the decision from the start. The places where it failed were the places where people felt it had been forced on them.

"Trust is the whole thing," she said. "Without it, the lynx don't stand a chance. Someone will shoot them, or poison them. Who could blame them?"

That's why she was so angry about the secret release. The person who did it thought they were helping. They were impatient. They thought the official way was taking too long. And in one night, they'd done what five years of shouting farmers couldn't: they'd made my mum's whole plan look like a trick.

Then, in the second week of February, Fi's dad found two dead lambs on the hill above Corrie Beag. Early lambs, born to a ewe that had been brought down to the in-bye field to lamb under shelter. Their bodies had been dragged and torn.

By that evening, everyone in the glen was saying the same word.

Lynx.

Fi's dad drove to our house. My mum went out to meet him in the yard. I watched from the window. I couldn't hear what they were saying. I could only see Mr. MacLeod pointing up at the hill, his whole body shaking, and my mum standing very still with her hands at her sides, not arguing. Just listening.

Check your understanding

  1. Main idea What is the main argument in this chapter for bringing back lynx?

    1. Lynx are rare and beautiful animals
    2. Lynx would help control the deer population and change deer behavior, allowing Scotland's forests to regrow
    3. Lynx would attract tourists
    4. Lynx would eat all the sheep
  2. Vocabulary Dr. Hussain says an ecosystem is "like a machine with missing parts." What does she mean?

    1. Ecosystems are made of metal
    2. Removing predators left the natural system unbalanced, and people have been trying to make up for it artificially
    3. Machines are better than ecosystems
    4. Deer are broken animals
  3. Inference According to Tariq, why did reintroductions succeed in some places and fail in others?

    1. They succeeded where farmers were part of the decision from the start and failed where people felt it was forced on them
    2. They succeeded only in warm countries
    3. They failed because lynx don't like Europe
    4. They succeeded only where there were no sheep
  4. Cause and effect What event turns the whole glen against the lynx?

    1. A lynx attacks a person
    2. Two dead lambs are found on the hill above Corrie Beag
    3. The government announces a reintroduction
    4. Dr. Hussain releases more lynx

Chapter 3: Fi — The Camera

My father wanted to shoot the lynx. He didn't say it at breakfast, but I heard him on the phone with Mr. Grant from the next farm, and I heard the word rifle. Shooting them would be illegal. Lynx were protected, even released ones. But I knew there were men in the glen who wouldn't care.

I didn't want the lynx to be shot. I'm not sure exactly why. Partly because of the tracks in the snow, those two sets side by side. Partly because of what Tariq had told me about the forests. But mostly, I think, because I wasn't sure the lynx had done it, and I didn't want anything killed for something it hadn't done.

It was something about the lambs that bothered me. I'd seen them, though my father hadn't wanted me to. Lynx, Tariq's mum had told us, usually kill with a single bite to the throat and then drag their prey under cover to eat it slowly over several days, sometimes covering it with leaves or snow. These lambs had been bitten all over. Not eaten, really. Just torn up and left in the open.

Callum, who knows a lot of facts, said it looked like a dog had done it.

Tariq's mum had a trail camera, the kind that takes photographs automatically when something moves in front of it, with an infrared flash for night. Tariq and I asked to borrow it. We didn't tell anyone what it was for.

Lambing was starting properly now. My father had brought most of the ewes down to the in-bye field next to the farmhouse, but a few were still lambing in the lower fold, a walled pen at the edge of the hill. That was where the first lambs had been killed. On Friday night, Tariq and I strapped the camera to a fence post looking across the fold, and crept home in the dark.

On Saturday night, something killed another lamb.

My father found it at dawn. He came into the kitchen with a face like stone and went straight to the cupboard where the rifle was kept, and my mother said, "Donald," in a voice I'd never heard her use, and he stopped.

I ran out to the fold before anyone could stop me. I unstrapped the camera with shaking fingers and ran back to the house and plugged it into the computer in the kitchen, and the whole family crowded around the screen.

There were forty-two photographs. Most of them were of ewes shifting in their sleep. One was of a fox, at 1:14 a.m., trotting along the wall and then away.

At 3:47 a.m., there was a dog.

It was a big, rangy dog, gray, with a torn red collar, jumping over the wall of the fold. At 3:48, it was among the sheep. At 3:52, it was jumping back over the wall, alone. The next photograph, at 3:53, showed a lamb lying where the dog had been.

Nobody said anything for a long time.

"That's the Sinclairs' dog," my mother said finally. "From the holiday cottages. The walkers' dog. They've been letting it run loose. I saw it on the road last week."

My father sat down very slowly.

I could see the shape of what he was feeling, because I was feeling something like it too. Relief, that the lynx weren't killers. Anger, at the dog's owners. And underneath both, something more uncomfortable: the knowledge that everyone in the glen, including him, had been certain. Certain enough to reach for a rifle.

"I was so sure," he said quietly. "I'd have bet the farm."

"It doesn't mean they'll never take a lamb," I said. "Tariq's mum says it does happen sometimes. Just not much."

"I know." He was looking at the photograph of the dog. "But it means I was ready to shoot the wrong thing. On no evidence at all except being angry." He looked at me. "How long have you had that camera out?"

"Two nights."

My father almost smiled. "Your grandmother would've liked you," he said. "She never believed anything anybody said until she'd seen it twice."

Check your understanding

  1. Key details Why did Fi doubt that the lynx had killed the lambs?

    1. She had seen the lynx far away that night
    2. The lambs had been bitten all over and left in the open, unlike the way lynx usually kill and hide their prey
    3. The lambs were too large for a lynx
    4. Tariq told her the lynx had left the glen
  2. Sequence In what order did the animals appear in the camera photographs?

    1. Dog, fox, ewes
    2. Ewes, a fox at 1:14 a.m., then a dog at 3:47 a.m.
    3. A lynx, then a dog, then a fox
    4. Only a dog appeared
  3. Inference Why does Fi's mother say "Donald" in "a voice I'd never heard her use"?

    1. She is calling him to breakfast
    2. She is firmly stopping him from taking the rifle before they know the truth
    3. She is angry that he is late
    4. She wants him to help with the lambs
  4. Character What does Fi's father admit after seeing the photographs?

    1. That he never believed the lynx did it
    2. That he was ready to act violently based only on anger and certainty, without evidence
    3. That he released the lynx
    4. That he wants to keep the dog

Chapter 4: Both — What Comes Next

Tariq: The photographs changed some things and didn't change others. That's what surprised me most.

They changed things for the lynx, a bit. The story in the local newspaper was headlined DOG, NOT LYNX, KILLED GLEN ARRIN LAMBS, with Fi's photograph of the gray dog jumping the wall. The Sinclairs were fined and their dog was kept on a lead. A few people who'd been talking about rifles went quiet.

But the lynx still couldn't stay. My mum said so herself, at a meeting in the village hall, and some people were surprised that she was the one who said it. The government wildlife team caught both cats in large padded box traps in March. They were healthy, a male and a female, about three years old, and very well fed on roe deer. They were taken to a wildlife park in the north. Nobody ever found out who released them.

"Why couldn't they stay?" I asked my mum, after. "They didn't kill the lambs. They weren't doing any harm."

"Because the way they arrived was wrong," she said. She looked very tired. "If they stay, then the message is that you can skip everyone's consent if you're sure you're right. And the next person who's sure they're right might release something much worse. Or the next farmer who's sure he's right might shoot something he shouldn't." She sighed. "I want lynx back in Scotland more than almost anything. But I want them back in a way that will last. And that means doing it with people, not to them."

Fi: I thought about that a lot.

The thing is, my father's mind didn't change completely. He still thinks lynx would be a risk to farmers, especially smaller farms like ours that can't afford to lose many lambs. He still doesn't trust people from cities who've never pulled a lamb out of a ewe at three in the morning in the sleet. He still signed the petition.

But something did change. After the meeting in the village hall, he walked over to Dr. Hussain, and they talked for a long time by the tea urn. I couldn't hear most of it. I heard him say, "Fences around young trees cost money. Who pays?" And I heard her say, "Exactly. That's exactly the question." And I saw her take out a notebook and write something down.

A month later, he went to one of her consultation meetings. Then another one. He argued a lot. But he went.

Tariq: Fi and I did our school science project on it in the end. We called it Who Killed the Lambs? We presented the photographs, the evidence, and both sides of the lynx debate: the deer, the forests, the farmers, the costs, the trust. We tried to be fair. It was harder than it sounds.

At the end, our teacher asked the class to vote on whether lynx should be brought back to Scotland. It came out almost exactly even. Somebody complained that we hadn't told them the right answer.

"There isn't one yet," said Fi. "That's the point. It has to be worked out. By everyone."

Fi: Last week, my father and I walked up to the forestry plantation above the top field, where Callum and I first found the tracks. It was spring. The snow was gone. There were no lynx tracks anymore, only deer prints in the mud, dozens of them, everywhere, and young rowan trees nibbled down to stumps.

My father crouched and looked at one of the bitten saplings for a long time.

"Your friend's mother has a point about the deer," he said finally. It sounded like it cost him something to say it.

"And you have a point about being asked," I said.

He nodded. He stood up and looked out over the glen: the green fields with the ewes and their lambs, the bare brown hills above, the dark line of the forestry, the sky going pink over the mountains.

"Maybe someday," he said. "If it's done right. If we're part of it. If somebody pays for the losses. Maybe."

It wasn't a yes. But a year ago, it would have been a no.

Tariq: My mum says coexistence doesn't start with animals. It starts with people deciding they can live with each other's disagreements long enough to find something that works. She says it can take years.

I think the photograph of the dog was where it started in Glen Arrin. Not because it proved anyone right. Because it proved everyone could be wrong, and that finding out the truth was worth more than winning.

Check your understanding

  1. Inference Why does Dr. Hussain support removing the lynx even though they did no harm?

    1. Allowing an illegal release to succeed would reward skipping consent, damaging the trust needed for any lasting, legitimate reintroduction
    2. She has changed her mind about lynx completely
    3. The lynx were sick
    4. The wildlife park paid her
  2. Character How has Fi's father changed by the end of the story?

    1. He now fully supports releasing lynx immediately
    2. He hasn't changed at all
    3. He still has concerns, but he has become willing to listen, attend consultations, and consider reintroduction if it is done fairly
    4. He has sold his farm
  3. Vocabulary Tariq's mother says "coexistence doesn't start with animals. It starts with people." What does "coexistence" mean in this sentence?

    1. Agreeing about everything
    2. Living alongside others, including those you disagree with, without trying to destroy them
    3. Moving animals to a wildlife park
    4. Building fences between farms
  4. Theme Which theme is developed across the whole story?

    1. Predators should never be brought back
    2. Farmers' needs never matter in conservation
    3. Solving conflicts between people and nature requires evidence, trust, and fair decision-making that includes everyone affected
    4. Science always gives a clear right answer

Spelling words

These 12 words all appear in the story.

  • predator
  • extinct
  • reintroduction
  • livestock
  • ecosystem
  • overgrazing
  • camera
  • evidence
  • illegal
  • consultation
  • compensation
  • coexistence

Writing prompt

Should lynx be brought back to Scotland? Write a balanced argument that gives the strongest points on both sides, using evidence from the story. Then explain your own view and how you think the decision should be made.

Reading skills practiced

Key details, Inference, Character, Main idea, Vocabulary, Cause and effect, Sequence, Theme.

Answer key for grown-ups
  1. They were hunted and their forests were cut down, and they went extinct about 1,300 years ago Fi explains that hunting and the loss of forests caused their extinction.
  2. His deepest anger is that people who live in the glen were not consulted about a decision that affects their lives He is upset that someone "didn't ask the people who actually live here."
  3. She believes an illegal release will turn people against lynx and damage any chance of a fair, official reintroduction Tariq says she believes it "will make everyone hate lynx forever."
  4. They have avoided talking about it to protect their friendship "We'd always managed not to talk about it."
  5. Lynx would help control the deer population and change deer behavior, allowing Scotland's forests to regrow Tariq explains overgrazing, the fenced hillside, and the "landscape of fear."
  6. Removing predators left the natural system unbalanced, and people have been trying to make up for it artificially She says lynx are "a part that fits."
  7. They succeeded where farmers were part of the decision from the start and failed where people felt it was forced on them Dr. Hussain says "Trust is the whole thing."
  8. Two dead lambs are found on the hill above Corrie Beag After the lambs are found, "everyone in the glen was saying the same word."
  9. The lambs had been bitten all over and left in the open, unlike the way lynx usually kill and hide their prey Lynx usually kill with one throat bite and drag prey under cover.
  10. Ewes, a fox at 1:14 a.m., then a dog at 3:47 a.m. The fox came first, then the dog that killed the lamb.
  11. She is firmly stopping him from taking the rifle before they know the truth The rifle and her unusual tone show a moment of serious tension.
  12. That he was ready to act violently based only on anger and certainty, without evidence He says, "I was ready to shoot the wrong thing. On no evidence at all except being angry."
  13. Allowing an illegal release to succeed would reward skipping consent, damaging the trust needed for any lasting, legitimate reintroduction She says she wants lynx back "in a way that will last... doing it with people, not to them."
  14. He still has concerns, but he has become willing to listen, attend consultations, and consider reintroduction if it is done fairly He says "Maybe someday... If it's done right. If we're part of it."
  15. Living alongside others, including those you disagree with, without trying to destroy them She means people must first learn to live with each other's disagreements before animals and people can share the land.
  16. Solving conflicts between people and nature requires evidence, trust, and fair decision-making that includes everyone affected From the camera trap to the consultations, the story shows that truth and trust matter more than winning.

More 5th grade stories

🧠

The Letter in My Handwriting

Ines Albuquerque notices small, strange gaps in her life: an empty hook by the back door, a worn path in the grass, the careful way her family speaks to her. Then she…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonSci-fi · Family16 questions
🧂

A Handful of Salt

In 1930, in the coastal village of Dandi in India, it is against British law for Kamala's family to make salt from the sea at their own doorstep. When word comes that…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonHistory · Justice16 questions
🚛

Forty Centimeters

For six weeks each winter, a road made of frozen lakes and packed snow connects Rae Beaulieu's remote Dene community to the rest of Canada, and her father drives the…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonNature · Exploration16 questions
🤖

The Detective's Assistant

Two days before the regional robotics championship, someone sabotages the Westfield Middle School robot, and Imani Clarke, the sharpest mind in the seventh grade, takes…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonMystery · Friends16 questions
🌲

What the Forest Lends

For three hundred years, the village of Hollin has lived beside the Thornwood under an ancient bargain with the forest's ancient guardian. But the new sawmill is…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonFantasy · Nature16 questions
🏃

The Unfair Advantage

Mateus Oliveira lost his lower left leg to cancer when he was seven, and now, at thirteen, he runs the 400 meters on a carbon-fiber blade, fast enough to reach the…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonSports · Justice16 questions