📚 Reading Quest
🎨

The Village Cloth

Tavita's mural design, full of the patterns her grandmother taught her in Samoa, loses the class vote to a giant space scene. That stings. But what stings more is when her teacher asks her to add "some of those cool patterns" to the border as decoration. Tavita has to decide whether to say yes, say nothing, or say something much harder.

4th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerSchool · Art · Culture2468 wordsAbout 30 minutes

Read it in the app 🚀

In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.

Words to know

mural
a large painting made directly on a wall
motif
a shape or design that is repeated in a pattern and often has a meaning
siapo
a traditional Samoan cloth made from tree bark and decorated with patterns
tribute
something done to show respect or thanks
respectful
showing that you value someone and their ideas

Chapter 1: Twelve Votes

The wall by the playground at Cedar Park Elementary was long, flat and the color of old oatmeal. For as long as anyone could remember, it had been a place to bounce balls against and nothing else. Then, in October, Principal Haraway announced that the fourth grade would paint a mural on it.

"Everyone may submit a design," said Ms. Okafor, the art teacher, holding up a sheet of rules. "Then the whole grade votes. The winning design goes on the wall, and everyone helps paint it."

Tavita Faleolo went home that afternoon and didn't come out of her room until dinner.

She knew exactly what she wanted to make. She took out the folder she kept in her desk drawer, the one with the photographs from last summer in Samoa, and spread them across her bed. In most of them, her grandmother, Losa, was sitting cross-legged on a woven mat, with a long piece of brown bark cloth across her knees.

The cloth was called siapo. Tavita's grandmother made it the old way, from the inner bark of the paper mulberry tree, soaked and beaten with a wooden mallet until it spread out thin and soft. Then she printed patterns on it with dark brown dye: rows of small triangles, star shapes, curling lines like waves and leaves.

Tavita's mural design was an ocean. A deep blue reef full of fish and turtles spread across the whole wall. Around its edges ran a wide border of the patterns from Grandma Losa's siapo, copied carefully from the photos, every line in its place. In the corner, very small, she drew a woman sitting on a mat, beating bark with a mallet.

She worked on it for two weeks. When she handed it in, Ms. Okafor held it up to the light for a long time.

"Tavita," she said. "This is beautiful."

There were six designs in the end. On voting day, they were pinned on the hallway wall, and every fourth grader dropped a paper ballot into a shoebox. Tavita voted for her own design and then felt guilty about it all day.

The results were announced at the end of the afternoon.

"With fifty-one votes," said Ms. Okafor, "the winner is Bennett Morales's design, Journey to the Stars!"

Bennett's design was a giant rocket blasting off into a purple sky full of planets, comets and a smiling alien waving from Saturn's rings. Half the class cheered. Bennett, who was not shy, jumped up on his chair and pumped his fist until Ms. Okafor told him to get down.

Tavita's ocean had come second. Twelve votes.

Twelve. She tried to keep her face calm, but she could feel heat spreading up her neck. Her best friend Jae-won squeezed her arm and whispered, "Yours was way better. Everybody just likes rockets."

Tavita knew that wasn't really fair to Bennett. His rocket was good. It was colorful and exciting, and you could see it from across the playground. But she was disappointed in a way that went deeper than losing. It felt as though nobody had looked closely enough to see what her design was really about.

That evening she called Grandma Losa on the computer. It was early morning in Samoa, and her grandmother was drinking tea on the porch, with roosters crowing somewhere behind her.

"I lost," Tavita said, and to her horror, her eyes filled with tears.

Grandma Losa listened to the whole story. Then she said, "Did the rocket boy work hard?"

Tavita sniffed. "Yes."

"Then it is his turn." Grandma Losa smiled. "And you will have another turn. The ocean is patient, Tavita. It is not going anywhere."

Check your understanding

  1. Key details What was special about the border of Tavita's design?

    1. It showed planets and comets
    2. It used the patterns from her grandmother's siapo cloth
    3. It had the names of every student
    4. It was painted gold
  2. Vocabulary What is "siapo" in this story?

    1. A kind of rocket
    2. A Samoan dance
    3. A traditional cloth made from tree bark and decorated with patterns
    4. A type of fish on the reef
  3. Inference Why is Tavita's disappointment "deeper than losing"?

    1. She thinks Bennett cheated
    2. She feels that nobody looked closely enough to understand what her design meant to her
    3. She wanted to win a prize
    4. She doesn't like art class
  4. Character What does Tavita's thought that "that wasn't really fair to Bennett" show about her?

    1. She dislikes Bennett
    2. Even while upset, she tries to be fair and admits his design is good
    3. She wants Bennett to lose next time
    4. She doesn't care about the mural anymore

Chapter 2: Just a Border

Two weeks later, the scaffolding went up along the wall, and the painting began.

Ms. Okafor had drawn Bennett's design onto the wall in pencil, divided into numbered sections, and every class had a turn. Tavita painted part of a purple planet and, she had to admit, enjoyed it. Bennett turned out to be bossy about his rocket but terrible at painting straight lines. He dripped orange on his shoes, on the sidewalk and once on Ms. Okafor.

On the third Friday, Ms. Okafor called Tavita over to the bottom of the scaffolding.

"I've been thinking," she said, smiling. "The space design is wonderful, but the bottom edge looks a little empty. What if we added a border along the bottom? And I thought, who better than Tavita! Could you add some of those cool patterns from your design? The triangles and the stars? They'd look great as decoration."

Tavita opened her mouth. Nothing came out.

She knew Ms. Okafor meant it kindly. Ms. Okafor was her favorite teacher. Ms. Okafor was trying to give her a turn.

But a picture flashed into her mind, so clear it was almost like being there.

Last summer, in Samoa, she had been sitting beside Grandma Losa on the mat. Her grandmother was printing a long piece of siapo for a cousin's wedding. Tavita, bored, had picked up a scrap of bark and started drawing patterns on it with a stick dipped in dye: a row of triangles, then a star, then some wavy lines, then some more triangles, anywhere they looked nice.

Grandma Losa had stopped working. She had taken the scrap gently out of Tavita's hands.

"These are not just shapes," she had said. "My mother taught me these, and her mother taught her. Each one has a name and a meaning. This one is for the stars that guided our people across the ocean. This one is for the reef that feeds us. We choose them for a reason, and we put them where they belong. They are not just to make things pretty." Then she had handed Tavita a fresh piece of bark. "So. Which story do you want to tell? Choose first. Then print."

Tavita had felt embarrassed then. She felt something closer to that now.

"Tavita?" said Ms. Okafor. "What do you think?"

"Can I think about it?" Tavita mumbled.

"Of course! Let me know Monday."

All weekend, Tavita argued with herself.

Part of her wanted to say yes. It was a chance to have her grandmother's patterns on the wall, where the whole school would see them. Wasn't that what she'd wanted? Wasn't something better than nothing?

Another part of her wanted to say a flat no, and maybe add, "My culture isn't a decoration." But that sounded rude to Ms. Okafor, who was only trying to help. And it would mean the patterns weren't on the wall at all.

A third part of her wanted to say yes and secretly paint the patterns wrong, just slightly, so that they wouldn't really count. Then she was ashamed of herself for even thinking it.

"Why is this so hard?" she asked her mom on Sunday night.

Her mom, who was folding laundry, sat down on the edge of the bed. "Because you're trying to be respectful to two people at once," she said. "Your teacher, and your grandmother. That's always hard." She smoothed Tavita's hair. "Maybe there's a way to respect both."

Tavita lay awake for a long time, thinking about the scrap of bark. Choose first. Then print.

On Monday morning, she knew what she was going to say.

Check your understanding

  1. Inference Why does Ms. Okafor's request upset Tavita, even though Ms. Okafor means it kindly?

    1. Tavita doesn't like painting borders
    2. Ms. Okafor wants to use the meaningful patterns just to make the wall look nice, without knowing what they mean
    3. Tavita wants to paint the rocket instead
    4. Ms. Okafor asked her in front of the whole class
  2. Inference What is the author's purpose in including the flashback to the mat in Samoa?

    1. To describe what the weather is like in Samoa
    2. To explain why Tavita believes the patterns have meanings and must be chosen with care
    3. To show that Tavita is a bad artist
    4. To show that Grandma Losa is strict and unkind
  3. Sequence Which happened FIRST?

    1. Tavita painted part of a purple planet
    2. Ms. Okafor asked Tavita to add a border
    3. Grandma Losa took a scrap of bark gently out of Tavita's hands
    4. Tavita talked to her mom on Sunday night
  4. Character How many different choices does Tavita consider over the weekend?

    1. Only one: saying yes
    2. Two: yes or no
    3. Three: saying yes, saying a flat no, or painting the patterns wrong on purpose
    4. None, because she already knows what to do

Chapter 3: Choose First

Tavita found Ms. Okafor in the art room before school, washing brushes in the big metal sink.

"I thought about it," Tavita said. Her heart was thumping so loudly she was sure Ms. Okafor could hear it. "And I can't just add the patterns as a border."

Ms. Okafor turned off the tap. She looked surprised, and a little hurt. "Oh. I'm sorry, Tavita. I thought you'd love that."

"I know. Thank you. It's not that I don't want them on the wall." Tavita took a deep breath. She had practiced this in the bathroom mirror, but it was still hard. "It's that they're not just shapes. My grandmother says each one has a name and a meaning. If I put them on the wall just to fill an empty space, it would be like..." She searched for the right words. "Like using somebody's family photos as wrapping paper."

Ms. Okafor was quiet for a long moment. Then she dried her hands slowly on a towel.

"I didn't think about it that way," she said. "You're right. I'm sorry. I called them cool patterns, like they were stickers." She shook her head. "That was careless of me."

Tavita felt a rush of relief. She hadn't known a teacher could say sorry so simply.

"But I have another idea," Tavita said, "if you want to hear it."

That afternoon, Tavita stood in front of her class with her folder of photographs. Her knees were shaking, so she held on to the edge of Ms. Okafor's desk. She showed them pictures of Grandma Losa beating the bark with her mallet, and of the long brown sheets of siapo drying in the sun. She explained that in many parts of the Pacific, people have made bark cloth for hundreds of years, and that the patterns were passed down from parents to children, each family with its own way of telling stories.

Then she said, "So I was thinking. Instead of putting my family's patterns at the bottom of the wall, what if everyone made their own?"

The room went quiet.

"Not copies of mine," Tavita explained. "Your own. One shape that means something about your family. Your grandparents, or where you come from, or something you love. You'd have to choose what it means first. Then you'd draw it. And then we'd put them all together in a border around the whole mural, like one long siapo that belongs to all of us."

Bennett raised his hand. Tavita braced herself for a joke. But Bennett just asked, "Does it have to be a fancy shape? Can it be, like, a fish? Because my grandpa was a fisherman in Veracruz."

"It can be a fish," Tavita said. "If it means your grandpa, it should be a fish."

Jae-won wanted a shape for the persimmon tree in her grandmother's yard in Korea. A boy named Oliver chose a horseshoe, for his aunt's horse farm. A girl named Fatima chose a crescent moon and a small lamp. One kid wanted a pizza, which caused an argument, until he explained that his parents had met while working at a pizza restaurant, and then everybody agreed it counted.

By the end of the week, the art room wall was covered in small paper squares, each with a shape and a sentence underneath: This is my grandma's tree. This is the river by my dad's old village. This is for my mom, who is a nurse.

Ms. Okafor stood in front of them with her arms folded, shaking her head slowly.

"Seventy-four shapes," she said. "Seventy-four stories." She looked at Tavita. "This is better than my idea. Much better."

Check your understanding

  1. Main idea What is this chapter mostly about?

    1. Bennett's grandfather fishing in Veracruz
    2. Tavita explaining her feelings to Ms. Okafor and inviting everyone to create their own meaningful patterns
    3. Ms. Okafor washing brushes
    4. The class arguing about pizza
  2. Vocabulary Tavita compares using the patterns as decoration to "using somebody's family photos as wrapping paper." What is she saying?

    1. It would treat something precious and personal as if it were ordinary and unimportant
    2. Family photos should be wrapped up as gifts
    3. The patterns are printed on paper
    4. Wrapping paper is more beautiful than photos
  3. Cause and effect Why did the pizza shape end up counting?

    1. The teacher liked pizza best
    2. The boy explained that his parents met while working at a pizza restaurant, so it had real meaning
    3. Everyone voted for it
    4. It was the easiest shape to draw
  4. Inference Why does Bennett's question surprise Tavita?

    1. She expected him to make a joke, but he asks a sincere question about honoring his grandfather
    2. She didn't know Bennett could talk
    3. He asks to paint her grandmother's patterns
    4. He wants to cancel the border

Chapter 4: One Long Cloth

They painted the border in the first week of December, when the air was cold enough that the paint dried slowly and everyone wore gloves with the fingertips cut off.

Each student painted their own shape. Ms. Okafor had arranged them in one long band that ran along the bottom of the mural, up both sides and across the top, framing the rocket and the planets like the edges of a great brown cloth. She had chosen the colors on purpose: dark brown on a soft tan, the colors of siapo, so that all seventy-four shapes looked like they belonged to one fabric.

Tavita painted hers last. She had thought about it for days. In the end, she chose a single star, the same eight-pointed star her grandmother printed at the edges of her siapo, the star for the ones that guided their people across the ocean. Underneath it, very small, she painted three tiny triangles, one for herself, one for her mother and one for Grandma Losa.

It was the only one of her grandmother's patterns she put on the wall. But she had chosen it first, and she knew exactly what it meant.

On the day the scaffolding came down, the whole school gathered on the playground for a small ceremony. Principal Haraway made a speech. Bennett, who had been asked to say a few words because his design had won, climbed up onto a bench, looked at the crowd and then said something nobody expected.

"I just want to say," he said, "the rocket was my idea. But the border was Tavita's idea. And honestly the border's better." Everyone laughed. "No, seriously. My grandpa's fish is on there." He pointed. "Right there, next to the persimmon tree. My mom cried when she saw it."

Tavita's face went hot, but this time it was a good kind of hot.

That night, she called Grandma Losa again. It was early morning in Samoa, and she could hear the roosters. She held up the computer and showed her grandmother the photos of the wall, one by one. She explained about the fish and the persimmon tree and the horseshoe and the pizza, and about choosing first and then printing, and about the eight-pointed star with three triangles underneath.

Grandma Losa didn't say anything for a while. She was looking very closely at the screen. Tavita began to worry. Maybe she had done it wrong. Maybe her grandmother didn't like the idea of seventy-four other people's patterns all mixed up with a Samoan star.

"Grandma?"

"When I was a girl," Grandma Losa said slowly, "the women in our village made siapo together. Many hands. One woman beat the bark. One mixed the dye. Everyone printed a part. When it was finished, it belonged to the whole village. We used it for weddings, and for welcoming visitors, and for wrapping new babies." She smiled, and her eyes were wet. "You made a village cloth, Tavita. In a place with no village."

Tavita had not thought of it that way. But as soon as Grandma Losa said it, she knew it was true.

"I was upset that I lost the vote," she admitted. "I was upset for a long time."

"Of course," said her grandmother. "But look. If you had won, you would have painted your own ocean, by yourself, with my patterns. That would have been beautiful. But it would have been one family's story." She tapped the screen, right where the star was. "This way, your star is not alone. It is in a sky full of other people's stars."

Tavita looked at the photograph on the screen: the purple sky, the grinning alien, the rocket, and around it all, like a protective arm, the long brown border of seventy-four small, meaningful shapes.

Twelve votes, she thought. It didn't seem to matter very much anymore.

Check your understanding

  1. Key details Why did Ms. Okafor choose dark brown on soft tan for the border?

    1. Because those were the only paint colors left
    2. To match the colors of siapo so all the shapes looked like one cloth
    3. Because Bennett asked for them
    4. So the border would be hard to see
  2. Character How has Bennett changed by the end of the story?

    1. He is still bossy and only cares about his rocket
    2. He publicly gives Tavita credit and shows that the border means something to him and his family
    3. He decides to quit painting
    4. He is angry that the border was added
  3. Inference What does Grandma Losa mean when she says, "You made a village cloth, Tavita. In a place with no village"?

    1. Tavita should move back to Samoa
    2. Like the siapo her village made together, the mural border was made by many people and belongs to everyone
    3. The school should be turned into a village
    4. Tavita forgot to use bark cloth
  4. Theme Which theme BEST fits this story?

    1. Winning a vote is the most important thing
    2. It's best to keep your culture private
    3. Sharing a tradition respectfully, by teaching its meaning, can bring people together better than using it as decoration
    4. Art teachers always know best

Spelling words

These 12 words all appear in the story.

  • mural
  • patterns
  • border
  • design
  • decoration
  • ballot
  • disappointed
  • meaningful
  • grandmother
  • scaffolding
  • photographs
  • ceremony

Writing prompt

Tavita didn't want her grandmother's patterns used "just as decoration." Explain why this mattered so much to her, using evidence from the story. Then describe something from your own family or culture that has a meaning other people might not know.

Reading skills practiced

Key details, Vocabulary, Inference, Character, Sequence, Main idea, Cause and effect, Theme.

Answer key for grown-ups
  1. It used the patterns from her grandmother's siapo cloth She copied the patterns carefully from her photos of Grandma Losa's siapo.
  2. A traditional cloth made from tree bark and decorated with patterns Grandma Losa makes it from the inner bark of the paper mulberry tree.
  3. She feels that nobody looked closely enough to understand what her design meant to her The design was about her grandmother and her culture, not just a picture.
  4. Even while upset, she tries to be fair and admits his design is good She admits his rocket was colorful and exciting.
  5. Ms. Okafor wants to use the meaningful patterns just to make the wall look nice, without knowing what they mean She calls them "cool patterns" and "decoration."
  6. To explain why Tavita believes the patterns have meanings and must be chosen with care The memory shows Grandma Losa teaching that each pattern has a name and a story.
  7. Grandma Losa took a scrap of bark gently out of Tavita's hands That moment happened last summer, in the flashback.
  8. Three: saying yes, saying a flat no, or painting the patterns wrong on purpose She argues with herself about all three options.
  9. Tavita explaining her feelings to Ms. Okafor and inviting everyone to create their own meaningful patterns Tavita speaks up and suggests a new idea for the border.
  10. It would treat something precious and personal as if it were ordinary and unimportant Family photos have deep personal meaning that wrapping paper doesn't.
  11. The boy explained that his parents met while working at a pizza restaurant, so it had real meaning Once he explained the story behind it, the class agreed.
  12. She expected him to make a joke, but he asks a sincere question about honoring his grandfather She "braced herself for a joke," but he asks seriously.
  13. To match the colors of siapo so all the shapes looked like one cloth She wanted the shapes to look like they belonged to one fabric.
  14. He publicly gives Tavita credit and shows that the border means something to him and his family He tells the crowd the border is better and mentions his grandfather's fish.
  15. Like the siapo her village made together, the mural border was made by many people and belongs to everyone Many hands made the border, the way many hands once made village siapo.
  16. Sharing a tradition respectfully, by teaching its meaning, can bring people together better than using it as decoration Tavita shares the idea behind siapo, and everyone adds their own meaningful story.

More 4th grade stories

🖊️

Two Names on the Cover

Leo writes the stories and Kai draws the pictures. Together they have made eleven comics about Gearheart, a clockwork fox. But when their comic wins a place in the…

4th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerFriends · Art16 questions
🏠

The House That Said Yes

After Abuelo Tomás takes a tumble, Ruby's mom installs PIP, a talking smart-home helper, to keep an eye on him. PIP is very eager to please and takes every word…

4th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerHumor · Robots · Family16 questions
🐧

The Puffin Counter

Every summer of her life, Sigrun has helped her grandfather count the puffins on the cliffs of tiny Skarvøy island. This summer is her last, because her family is…

4th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerAnimals · Islands · Family16 questions
🍎

The Grafting Knife

The oldest apple trees on the Nowak family farm are going to be pulled out to make room for new ones, including the gnarled tree that grows a golden apple found nowhere…

4th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerFarm · Family · Nature16 questions
🏃🏾‍♀️

The Hill at Mile Two

Ruth Wanjiru has trained all season to conquer the steep forest hill at the city cross-country championship. She crosses the finish line first, and her team wins the…

4th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerSports · Forest · Family16 questions
🐚

The Sea Women's Whistle

Ji-woo has been afraid of deep water since she nearly drowned when she was six. Now she is spending the summer on Jeju Island with her grandmother, one of the famous…

4th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerOcean · Culture · Islands16 questions