The No-Take Zone
On a small island in the Philippines, the fish are getting fewer and smaller every year. When the village votes on whether to close part of the reef to all fishing, Ligaya's father is furious, because it's his best fishing ground. Ligaya's grandfather has a secret from long ago that might change his mind, and Ligaya has to decide what to do when she catches someone breaking the new rule.
5th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeyOcean · Village · Family2695 wordsAbout 30 minutes
In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.
Words to know
- sanctuary
- a protected place where animals or plants are kept safe
- outrigger
- a float attached to the side of a canoe to keep it from tipping over
- spillover
- in ocean science, when fish grow and multiply in a protected area and then swim out into nearby waters
- enforce
- to make sure people follow a rule or law
- livelihood
- the way a person earns the money and food they need to live
Chapter 1: Smaller Every Year
Ligaya Santos could hold her breath for one minute and forty seconds. She had timed it.
That was long enough to dive down to the coral reef off the island of Pulo Bituin, swim along the edge of it looking at fish, and come back up again before her lungs began to burn. She had been doing it since she was six, with a mask her father had found washed up on the beach and a snorkel tube patched with tape.
The reef was the most beautiful place she knew. Coral grew in a hundred shapes: branching like antlers, rounded like brains, spreading like fans. Fish of every color darted among them. Sometimes, if she was very lucky, she saw a sea turtle gliding past like a slow green bird.
But Ligaya had noticed something that worried her. The fish were getting smaller.
When she was six, the big groupers that lived in the caves under the reef had been as long as her arm. Now the biggest ones she saw were the length of her hand. The schools of silver fish that used to swirl around her like a tornado had grown thin.
Her father had noticed it too. Every morning before sunrise, he sailed out in his bangka, a narrow wooden boat with a bamboo outrigger on each side like the arms of a water strider. He set his nets and lines and came home at noon. When Ligaya was small, the bottom of the boat had been full of fish. Now, many days, there were only a few, and they were small.
"Too many boats," her father said, sorting the thin catch on the beach. "Too many people. Not enough fish." He said it the way someone talks about the weather: a fact he could not change.
There were more boats than ever. Pulo Bituin had grown. And there were bigger boats, too, from other islands, with motors and huge nets that scooped up everything in their path.
Ligaya's mother sold dried fish at the market, and Ligaya knew from the way her parents talked in the evenings that money was getting very tight. Her older brother, Nonoy, had already left to work on a cargo ship. He sent money home every month, but he was gone for nine months of the year, and Ligaya missed him terribly.
One evening, the barangay captain, the leader of the village, called a meeting at the basketball court. A woman from a university in Manila stood in front of the crowd with a projector and a white sheet hung between two poles.
"My name is Dr. Reyes," she said. "I study coral reefs. And I want to tell you about an idea that has worked on many other islands."
She showed photographs. In one, a reef was gray and broken, with only a few small fish. In another, the same reef five years later was bursting with color and life, crowded with fish of every size.
"This reef was made into a marine sanctuary," Dr. Reyes said. "A no-take zone. Nobody was allowed to fish there. Not a single fish. Not for five years."
"And how did the people eat?" someone shouted.
"At first, it was very hard," Dr. Reyes admitted. "But the fish inside the sanctuary grew big, and big fish lay many more eggs than small fish. After a few years, there were so many fish that they spilled out of the sanctuary into the waters around it. We call it spillover. The fishermen fishing just outside the sanctuary caught more fish than ever before."
She paused. "I would like to propose a sanctuary here. Around the main reef. Off the south point."
Ligaya felt her father go stiff beside her.
The south point was his fishing ground. It was where he had fished every day for twenty-five years, and where his father had fished before him.
Check your understanding
Key details What changes has Ligaya noticed on the reef since she was six?
- The water has become warmer
- The fish have become smaller and fewer
- The coral has grown taller
- The turtles have become more common
Cause and effect According to Ligaya's father, why are there fewer fish?
- There are too many boats and people fishing, including big boats from other islands
- The water is too polluted
- The fish have moved to a different reef
- Sharks have eaten them
Vocabulary Dr. Reyes describes "spillover." What does spillover mean in this story?
- When a boat takes on too much water
- When fishermen catch too many fish at once
- When fish grow and multiply in a protected area and then swim into the waters nearby
- When the ocean floods the village
Inference Why does Ligaya's father "go stiff" when Dr. Reyes mentions the south point?
- He is cold from the evening wind
- He is excited about the idea
- The proposed sanctuary would close the fishing ground his family has used for generations
- He doesn't like Dr. Reyes
Chapter 2: Lolo's Secret
The argument at home that night was the loudest Ligaya had ever heard.
"Five years!" her father said, pacing the small room. "Five years without fishing at the south point! How will we eat? Do they think fish just jump into our pots?"
"She said the fishing would get better," Ligaya's mother said.
"After five years! Maybe! What do we eat while we wait for maybe?" He threw up his hands. "It's easy for a professor from Manila to talk about sanctuaries. She doesn't have a daughter to feed."
Ligaya sat quietly in the corner, mending a net. Part of her agreed with her father. She knew how little money there was.
But part of her thought about the reef. The fish getting smaller every year. If nothing changed, what would the reef look like in five more years? In ten? Would there be any fish at all?
Her grandfather, Lolo Ben, had been sitting silently in his chair by the window. He was very old, with skin like brown leather and white hair. Three fingers were missing from his left hand. Ligaya had asked him once how he lost them, and he had only said, "A long time ago, I made a mistake."
Now, Lolo Ben spoke for the first time.
"Arturo," he said quietly to Ligaya's father. "Sit down."
Her father sat down. Nobody ever argued with Lolo Ben.
"Have I ever told you how I lost my fingers?" Lolo asked.
Her father looked surprised. "You said it was an accident with a boat."
"I lied." Lolo Ben looked out the window, at the dark sea. "When I was young, in the 1970s, the fishing here was already getting harder. And some of the men, me among them, found a quicker way. We made bombs. Bottles filled with explosives, with a fuse. We would throw them into the water over the reef. The explosion killed every fish nearby, and they floated to the top, and we scooped them up. Hundreds of fish in one minute."
Ligaya stared at him, horrified.
"It worked," Lolo Ben said. "For a while. We caught more fish than ever. But each bomb also smashed the coral to pieces. Coral that had taken hundreds of years to grow, gone in a second. Where there is no coral, there is no home for the fish. So every year, there were fewer fish, and we needed bigger bombs." He held up his scarred left hand. "One day, a fuse was too short. I was lucky. I only lost three fingers. My friend Pedro lost his life."
The room was completely silent.
"The north reef, where we bombed, is still dead," Lolo Ben said. "Fifty years later. You've seen it, Arturo. Gray rubble. Nothing lives there." He turned to his son. "The south point is the last good reef we have. If we keep taking and taking, it will go the same way. Slower than bombs. But the same way."
Ligaya's father put his head in his hands.
"I know you're right, Tatay," he said finally, in a muffled voice. "I know. But how do I feed my family for five years?"
Lolo Ben was quiet for a long time.
"I don't know," he said. "That is the hard part. I don't think anyone knows. But I know what happens if we don't try."
Ligaya looked at her grandfather's hand, with its two remaining fingers. All her life, she had seen it without thinking about it. Now it looked different. It looked like a warning, written in skin.
Check your understanding
Key details How did Lolo Ben really lose his fingers?
- In a boat accident
- Fighting a shark
- A homemade fishing bomb exploded too soon
- Fixing a fishing net
Cause and effect Why did bomb fishing eventually lead to fewer fish?
- The explosions scared the fish away to other islands
- The explosions destroyed the coral, and without coral, the fish had no homes
- The bombs poisoned the water
- The government banned fishing on the north reef
Character Why does Ligaya's father say "I know you're right" but still feel stuck?
- He doesn't believe Lolo Ben's story
- He agrees the reef needs protecting but doesn't know how to feed his family during the closure
- He wants to start bomb fishing again
- He is angry at Dr. Reyes
Inference Why does Ligaya think Lolo's hand looks like "a warning, written in skin"?
- His injury is a lasting reminder of what happens when people take too much from the reef
- His hand has words tattooed on it
- He uses his hand to signal danger
- She is afraid of her grandfather
Chapter 3: The Vote and the Night Boat
The village voted a week later. It was close. Many fishermen, like Ligaya's father had been, were afraid of losing their fishing grounds. But Lolo Ben stood up at the meeting and told his story again, the true one this time, in front of everyone. When he finished, many of the older people were nodding. Some of them had their own memories of the north reef, before it died.
The sanctuary passed by eleven votes.
There were conditions, which Ligaya's father had insisted on. The no-take zone would cover only half of the south point, not all of it, so fishermen could still fish nearby. The university would help families start seaweed farms in the shallow lagoon, so they would have another way to earn money while they waited. And the sanctuary would be checked every year. If it wasn't working after five years, the village could vote to open it again.
Volunteers formed a patrol to protect the sanctuary. They would take turns watching the reef from a small bamboo hut on the point, especially at night, when poachers might sneak in. To Ligaya's surprise, her father was one of the first to volunteer.
"If we're going to give up the reef," he said, "then we're going to make sure it works."
Dr. Reyes also organized the island's children to do a reef survey. Once a month, Ligaya and her classmates snorkeled over the sanctuary with waterproof slates, counting fish and writing down their sizes. Ligaya was the best counter in the group because she could hold her breath the longest.
For the first year, nothing much seemed to change. The fish were still small. Ligaya began to worry that it would never work.
The seaweed farming was hard, too. Her mother spent hours every day in the lagoon, tying seaweed to long lines strung between wooden stakes. Her hands grew rough and cracked from the salt. The money was much less than fish had been. There were weeks when dinner was only rice and a little salted fish.
Then, in the second year, Ligaya noticed something on her survey. The groupers were getting bigger. Just a little at first. Then more. A school of silver fish appeared, swirling around her like the tornado she remembered from when she was small. And one day, gliding slowly over the coral, she saw a sea turtle.
She came up whooping so loudly that Dr. Reyes almost fell out of the boat.
But that same month, something else happened.
Ligaya was walking home along the beach late one night after visiting her friend Rosa. The moon was full and bright. As she passed the south point, she saw a small boat sliding quietly across the water inside the sanctuary, with no lights on.
She ducked behind a rock and watched. A figure in the boat was pulling up a fishing line. At the end of it, flashing silver in the moonlight, was a large fish.
The boat drifted closer. And Ligaya's heart sank. She knew that boat. It belonged to Dodong, a boy of fifteen who lived three houses down from her. His father had been sick for a year and couldn't work. Dodong's family was the poorest on the island. Ligaya had seen his little sisters at school with no shoes.
She knew what she was supposed to do. She was supposed to tell the patrol. Dodong would be fined, and his boat might be taken away. Those were the rules.
But she also knew that without his boat, Dodong's family would have nothing at all.
Ligaya crouched behind the rock for a long time after the boat had gone, her heart pounding, not knowing what to do.
Check your understanding
Key details Which condition did Ligaya's father insist on for the sanctuary?
- That only children could swim in it
- That it cover only half of the south point, so fishermen could still fish nearby
- That it be closed forever
- That only his family could fish there
Sequence Put these events in order: (1) Ligaya sees a sea turtle on her survey, (2) the sanctuary vote passes, (3) Ligaya sees Dodong fishing in the sanctuary, (4) Ligaya's father volunteers for the patrol.
- 2, 1, 4, 3
- 2, 4, 1, 3
- 4, 2, 1, 3
- 2, 4, 3, 1
Character What does Ligaya's father's decision to join the patrol show?
- He secretly wants to fish in the sanctuary
- Once the decision is made, he is committed to making it succeed, even though he argued against it
- He wants to be paid by the university
- He doesn't trust the other villagers
Inference Why is Ligaya so torn about reporting Dodong?
- She is afraid of Dodong
- She doesn't know the rules
- She knows breaking the rule could harm the sanctuary, but reporting him could ruin his already struggling family
- She wants to keep the fish for herself
Chapter 4: The Spillover
Ligaya didn't tell anyone for three days. She could barely eat or sleep. Every time she looked at her father coming home from his night patrol, tired and red-eyed, she felt guilty. And every time she saw Dodong's little sisters at school, she felt guilty in a different way.
Finally, she went to Lolo Ben. He was the only person she could think of who might understand.
She told him everything. He listened without interrupting, his scarred hand resting on his knee.
"What should I do?" she asked. "If I tell, Dodong's family loses everything. If I don't tell, and other people find out he's fishing there, they'll start doing it too. And then the sanctuary will fail, and everyone loses."
Lolo Ben nodded slowly. "Both of those things are true," he said. "That is what makes it hard."
"So what's the answer?"
"I don't know if there is one answer." He was quiet for a moment. "When I was throwing bombs, I wasn't a bad man. I was a hungry one. My children were hungry. Desperate people make choices that hurt the future, because the future feels very far away when your stomach is empty." He looked at her. "Dodong isn't a bad boy. He's a desperate one. If you only punish him, you stop the fishing, but you don't stop the hunger. And the hunger will find another way."
Ligaya thought about that for a long time.
"So I need to stop the hunger," she said slowly.
Lolo Ben smiled for the first time. "Now you're thinking like a fisherman who wants there to be fish next year."
The next day, Ligaya went to find Dodong. He was sitting outside his house, mending a torn net. When he saw her, he looked up nervously.
"I saw you," she said quietly. "At the south point. Three nights ago."
Dodong's face went pale. He dropped the net. "Are you going to tell?"
"I don't want to," Ligaya said. "But you can't keep doing it, Dodong. If people find out, they'll all start, and then there won't be any fish anywhere. Not for you, not for anyone."
"You think I don't know that?" Dodong's voice cracked. "My sisters haven't eaten fish in a month. My father can't get out of bed. What am I supposed to do?"
Ligaya took a breath. She had been thinking about this all night.
"Dr. Reyes needs someone to help with the seaweed farms," she said. "Someone strong, to carry the lines and drive the stakes. The university pays. Not a lot. But it's money. And the fishing just outside the sanctuary is getting better. Rosa's father caught a grouper there last week as long as my arm. You could fish there, legally, and nobody could say anything."
Dodong stared at her. "Why would you help me?"
Ligaya shrugged. "Because Lolo says hungry people make bad choices, and then they live with the regret for fifty years. So I'm trying to make you less hungry."
That afternoon, Ligaya walked Dodong to Dr. Reyes. She did not mention the south point. Dr. Reyes, who was generous with second chances, hired him on the spot.
It was not a perfect ending. The work was hard and the pay was small. But Dodong never went back to the sanctuary. Instead, he became one of the hardest workers on the seaweed farms, and later, one of the most passionate members of the patrol. Nobody guarded the reef more fiercely than Dodong, because nobody knew better how easy it was to slip inside.
By the fifth year, the change on the reef was astonishing. The groupers were as long as Ligaya's arm again. The schools of silver fish were so thick they blocked out the sun. Sea turtles came every week. And just as Dr. Reyes had promised, the fish spilled over the edges of the sanctuary into the waters around it. Ligaya's father, fishing just outside the line, came home with a boat fuller than it had been in fifteen years.
When the village voted on whether to keep the sanctuary, it passed by a huge majority. This time, Ligaya's father was the one who stood up to speak in favor of it.
That night, Ligaya swam out over the reef alone in the moonlight. She dove down, holding her breath, and hung suspended above the coral. Fish swirled around her, silver and gold and blue, so many that she could not count them. The reef had begun to recover. Coral was even beginning to grow, slowly, on the edges where the old damage had been.
She came up, gasping, and floated on her back, looking at the stars.
Lolo Ben said the sanctuary had taught the village something important: that sometimes you have to give something up now to have more later. But Ligaya thought it had taught her something else, too. Rules could protect the reef. But only kindness could protect the people who were tempted to break them. A good sanctuary, she thought, needed both.
Check your understanding
Inference What does Lolo Ben mean when he says, "If you only punish him, you stop the fishing, but you don't stop the hunger"?
- Dodong should not be punished at all
- Punishment alone won't solve the real problem, which is that Dodong's family is desperate for food
- Dodong will always be hungry no matter what
- Ligaya should give Dodong her food
Cause and effect Why does Dodong become one of the most passionate patrol members?
- He is paid more than the others
- He knows from experience how easy it is to sneak into the sanctuary, and he understands why it matters
- Ligaya forces him to join
- He wants to catch fish in the sanctuary himself
Character How has Ligaya's father changed by the end of the story?
- He has moved away from the island
- He goes from angrily opposing the sanctuary to speaking in favor of keeping it
- He has stopped fishing completely
- He has become a scientist
Theme What is Ligaya's final lesson about the sanctuary?
- Rules are always more important than people
- Protecting nature needs both fair rules and kindness toward people who are struggling
- The ocean will always recover on its own
- Fishermen should never fish near reefs
Spelling words
These 12 words all appear in the story.
- sanctuary
- coral
- outrigger
- snorkel
- explosion
- patrol
- spillover
- generous
- desperate
- recover
- regret
- survey
Writing prompt
Ligaya chose not to report Dodong to the council and found a different way to solve the problem. Do you agree with her choice? Explain what might have happened if she had reported him, and give at least three reasons from the story for your opinion.
Reading skills practiced
Key details, Cause and effect, Vocabulary, Inference, Character, Sequence, Theme.
Answer key for grown-ups
- The fish have become smaller and fewer The groupers that were as long as her arm are now as long as her hand.
- There are too many boats and people fishing, including big boats from other islands He says, "Too many boats. Too many people. Not enough fish."
- When fish grow and multiply in a protected area and then swim into the waters nearby The fish "spilled out of the sanctuary into the waters around it."
- The proposed sanctuary would close the fishing ground his family has used for generations The south point is where he has fished for twenty-five years.
- A homemade fishing bomb exploded too soon He admits he lied and that a bomb's fuse was too short.
- The explosions destroyed the coral, and without coral, the fish had no homes Lolo explains that "where there is no coral, there is no home for the fish."
- He agrees the reef needs protecting but doesn't know how to feed his family during the closure He asks, "how do I feed my family for five years?"
- His injury is a lasting reminder of what happens when people take too much from the reef The missing fingers are evidence of the damage greed caused in the past.
- That it cover only half of the south point, so fishermen could still fish nearby The no-take zone covered half the south point, with seaweed farms and a five-year review.
- 2, 4, 1, 3 The vote passes, the patrol forms, she sees the turtle in the second year, and that same month sees Dodong.
- Once the decision is made, he is committed to making it succeed, even though he argued against it He says, "If we're going to give up the reef, then we're going to make sure it works."
- She knows breaking the rule could harm the sanctuary, but reporting him could ruin his already struggling family The rules say he should be reported, but his family is desperate.
- Punishment alone won't solve the real problem, which is that Dodong's family is desperate for food The hunger would "find another way" unless someone addresses it.
- He knows from experience how easy it is to sneak into the sanctuary, and he understands why it matters "Nobody knew better how easy it was to slip inside."
- He goes from angrily opposing the sanctuary to speaking in favor of keeping it In the final vote, he is the one who stands up to support it.
- Protecting nature needs both fair rules and kindness toward people who are struggling She decides a good sanctuary needs both rules and kindness.