📚 Reading Quest
🫧

The Great Hiccup Outbreak

When half of Westbrook Elementary starts hiccuping at once, everyone has a cure and everyone is sure theirs is the best. Fifth-grader Priya Raman decides to find out the truth the way real doctors do: with a fair test. But her best friend Oskar is selling a "miracle" cure, her grandmother swears by sugar, and the principal just wants the noise to stop.

5th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxHumor · School · Medicine2539 wordsAbout 30 minutes

Read it in the app 🚀

In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.

Words to know

diaphragm
the dome-shaped muscle under your lungs that helps you breathe
remedy
something that is supposed to cure or ease a problem
contagious
able to spread from one person to another
control group
in an experiment, the people who get no treatment, so you can compare them with those who do
placebo
a fake treatment that has no real effect, used to test whether people feel better just because they expect to

Chapter 1: Patient Zero

The first hiccup of the Great Hiccup Outbreak happened at 11:52 on a Tuesday morning, in the Westbrook Elementary cafeteria, and it belonged to a third-grader named Teddy Abernathy.

Nobody noticed it. Teddy hiccuped all the time. He was the kind of boy who ate his lunch as if someone might steal it, and he usually swallowed half the air in the room along with his sandwich.

The second hiccup belonged to Teddy's table partner, Rosalind. The third, fourth, and fifth belonged to the twins at the next table. By 12:05, the entire third grade was hiccuping, and the sound rolled across the cafeteria like popcorn in a pan: hic, hic, hic-HIC, hic.

Priya Raman was sitting at the fifth-grade table with a forkful of rice halfway to her mouth when it reached her.

"Hic," she said, startled. She put down the fork. "Oh no. Hic."

Across from her, her best friend Oskar Lindqvist started laughing so hard that he hiccuped too, which made him laugh harder, which made him hiccup more. Within two minutes, the fifth-grade table sounded like a flock of very small, very confused geese.

By the end of lunch, sixty-three students and two lunch helpers had the hiccups. By the end of the day, the number was ninety-one.

The principal, Mrs. Okonjo-Bell, made an announcement over the loudspeaker. She was trying to sound calm. "Students, there is no need to (hic) panic." There was a long pause. Then the loudspeaker clicked off.

That night, the whole Raman household argued about cures.

"A spoonful of sugar," said Priya's grandmother, Paati, who had moved from Chennai to live with them two years ago. She held the spoon out like a medal. "Swallow it dry. It has worked in our family for a hundred years."

"Hold your breath and count to thirty," said Priya's father.

"Drink a glass of water upside down," said her older brother, Arjun, who was fifteen and liked to say things just to see if people would do them.

Priya tried all three. The sugar was gritty. Holding her breath made her dizzy. The upside-down water went mostly up her nose. Her hiccups stopped at 8:14 p.m., and she honestly had no idea which remedy had worked, or whether any of them had.

That was the thing that bothered her. Her mother was a nurse at Westbrook General Hospital, and she had a saying that she repeated so often that Priya could hear it in her sleep: "'It worked for me' is a story. It isn't evidence."

The next morning, the hiccups came back. Not just for Priya. For everyone. The school had become a place where you could not finish a sentence without it breaking in half.

Then Oskar arrived at school with a cardboard box under his arm.

"Behold," he said, flipping the lid open in front of her locker. Inside were dozens of tiny paper cups, each one filled with a yellow liquid. A sign taped to the box read: OSKAR'S MIRACLE HICCUP CURE. 100% GUARANTEED. 50 CENTS.

"What is it?" Priya asked suspiciously.

"Lemon juice with a pinch of salt," Oskar said proudly. "My uncle Lars swears by it. It cured him in 1998."

"Did anyone test it?"

"My uncle Lars tested it," Oskar said. "In 1998."

By lunchtime, Oskar had sold forty-two cups and had twenty-one dollars in his pocket. Some kids said it worked right away. Others said it did nothing but make their mouths pucker. Everyone who said it worked told everyone else, very loudly.

Priya watched all of this and felt an idea forming, slowly, like a bubble rising through honey.

Check your understanding

  1. Inference Why does the author describe the first hiccup with the exact time, "11:52 on a Tuesday morning"?

    1. Because the time explains what caused the hiccups
    2. To make the silly event sound as serious as a real disease report, which adds humor
    3. Because Teddy always hiccups at that time
    4. To show that Priya was wearing a watch
  2. Vocabulary Paati offers a "remedy" for hiccups. What does "remedy" mean?

    1. A type of spoon
    2. A family recipe for dessert
    3. Something that is supposed to cure or ease a problem
    4. A rule made by the principal
  3. Cause and effect Why can't Priya tell which cure stopped her hiccups?

    1. She tried all three, so there was no way to know which one, if any, worked
    2. She fell asleep before her hiccups stopped
    3. Her family would not tell her the answer
    4. She forgot what she had tried
  4. Character What does Oskar's box of "miracle" cures show about him?

    1. He is shy and avoids attention
    2. He is careful and always tests his ideas
    3. He is energetic and quick to act, but he trusts a story without checking it
    4. He wants to trick his friends on purpose

Chapter 2: A Fair Test

At the end of the day, Priya knocked on the door of Mrs. Okonjo-Bell's office. The principal was sitting at her desk with a paper bag over her mouth, breathing in and out of it slowly.

"I read online that this helps," she said through the bag. "It does (hic) not."

"I want to run an experiment," Priya said. "A real one. To find out which hiccup cures actually work."

Mrs. Okonjo-Bell lowered the bag. "Go on."

Priya had spent all of math class planning it in the margins of her worksheet. She explained it carefully. She would need volunteers who had the hiccups. Each volunteer would be given one cure, chosen at random by pulling a slip of paper from a jar, so that nobody could pick the cure they already believed in. There would be four groups: Paati's sugar, Dad's breath-holding, Oskar's lemon juice, and one more group.

"What's the fourth group?" asked the principal.

"Nothing," said Priya. "They just sit and wait. That's the control group. If people in the control group get better just as fast as everyone else, then none of the cures are really doing anything. The hiccups are just stopping on their own."

Mrs. Okonjo-Bell looked at her for a long time. "Your mother is a nurse, isn't she?"

"Yes."

"I thought so." The principal smiled for the first time in two days. "You may use the library after school tomorrow. I will write a note to the families."

Priya's mother helped her that evening. She showed Priya how to make a simple chart with columns for each volunteer's number, the cure they got, the time their hiccups started, and the time they stopped. "Write down everything, even the things that seem boring," she said. "The boring numbers are where the truth hides."

"Mom," Priya asked, "what actually causes hiccups?"

Her mother put down her pen. "Your diaphragm is a big, flat muscle under your lungs. When you breathe in, it pulls down. Sometimes it gets irritated, maybe from eating too fast, or gulping air, or fizzy drinks, or even from being excited, and it suddenly squeezes on its own. That jerk pulls air in, and a little flap in your throat snaps shut. The snap is the 'hic.' Most hiccups go away by themselves within a few minutes or a few hours."

"So any cure would seem to work," Priya said slowly, "if you tried it right before they were going to stop anyway."

Her mother raised her eyebrows. "Now you're thinking like a scientist."

The hardest part was Oskar.

"You're testing my cure?" he said the next morning. His face went red. "You think I'm a liar."

"I don't think you're a liar," Priya said. "I think you believe your uncle. I just want to know if it's true. Don't you?"

Oskar crossed his arms. "What if it doesn't work? Then everyone will think I cheated them out of fifty cents."

"What if it does work?" said Priya. "Then you'll have proof. Real proof, not just a story from 1998."

Oskar was quiet for a long moment. He looked at his box of paper cups, which was nearly empty now. Then he uncrossed his arms.

"Fine," he said. "But I'm bringing the lemon juice. Nobody else is allowed to make it wrong."

On Thursday afternoon, forty volunteers with hiccups showed up in the library. That was more than Priya had hoped for and fewer than the number of kids still hiccuping in the hallway. Arjun came to help keep time with a stopwatch. Paati came to supervise the sugar. Oskar stood behind a table of lemon cups like a scientist guarding a secret formula.

One by one, the volunteers reached into the jar and pulled out a slip. SUGAR. BREATH. LEMON. WAIT.

The kids who pulled WAIT groaned. "That's not fair," said a fourth-grader named Benedict. "I want a cure."

"You're the most important group," Priya told him, and she meant it. "Without you, we can't tell if anything works at all."

Benedict looked doubtful, but he sat down in a beanbag and hiccuped grumpily.

Arjun clicked the stopwatch. "Begin," he said, in a deep, dramatic voice he had clearly been practicing.

The library filled with the sounds of crunching sugar, puckering lips, held breath, and forty different rhythms of hiccups, all slowly, slowly getting quieter.

Check your understanding

  1. Main idea What is this chapter mostly about?

    1. Mrs. Okonjo-Bell trying to stop her own hiccups
    2. Priya planning and starting a fair experiment to test the hiccup cures
    3. Oskar making more money from his lemon juice
    4. Priya's mother explaining her job at the hospital
  2. Key details Why does Priya have volunteers pull slips from a jar?

    1. To make the experiment more fun
    2. Because there were not enough cups of lemon juice
    3. So that nobody can choose the cure they already believe in
    4. So that the principal can choose the winner
  3. Inference Why does Priya tell Benedict that the WAIT group is the most important group?

    1. She feels sorry for him and wants to cheer him up with a white lie
    2. The control group shows how fast hiccups stop on their own, which is what every cure must be compared to
    3. The WAIT group gets a prize at the end
    4. The WAIT group has the most volunteers
  4. Character How does Oskar change during his talk with Priya?

    1. He goes from friendly to angry and refuses to help
    2. He goes from feeling insulted to agreeing to have his cure tested
    3. He admits that he made up his uncle's story
    4. He decides to stop selling cups for good

Chapter 3: The Numbers Speak

When the last hiccup in the library stopped, Arjun clicked the stopwatch for the final time. Priya sat down at a long table with her chart and a calculator, and everyone crowded around to see.

She added up the minutes for each group and divided by the number of people in it, the way her teacher had shown them for finding an average.

Sugar: an average of eleven minutes.

Holding breath: an average of ten minutes.

Lemon juice: an average of twelve minutes.

Waiting and doing nothing: an average of eleven minutes.

The library was very quiet.

"So," said Benedict slowly, from his beanbag, "the fake cure works just as well as the real cures?"

"There was no fake cure," Priya said. "You just waited. And your hiccups stopped about as fast as everyone else's." She tapped the numbers. "That means none of the cures made much difference. At least not for this group, on this day."

Oskar's face fell. Paati frowned at her sugar spoon as if it had personally betrayed her.

"But it worked for me," said a girl from the lemon group. "As soon as I drank it, I stopped."

"I know," said Priya. "And Benedict stopped right after he sat in the beanbag. Should we sell beanbags as a cure?"

Everyone laughed. Then, quite suddenly, three people hiccuped again.

Priya stared at them. A thought hit her so hard that she almost dropped her pencil.

"Wait," she said. "Did you see that? They laughed, and then they hiccuped."

She flipped back through her notes. On Tuesday, the hiccups had started in the cafeteria and spread table by table. Kids had laughed at each other's hiccups. She remembered Oskar laughing at hers, and then catching them himself. And today, in the hallway, the hiccups always seemed loudest where people were giggling.

"Mom said excitement and laughing can set off the diaphragm," she said. "And maybe when you hear someone hiccup, you start paying attention to your own breathing, and that makes it worse. Like yawning. When someone yawns, you yawn."

"So hiccups are contagious?" asked Oskar.

"Not like a germ," said Priya. "There's no virus. But maybe they spread by suggestion. And by laughter."

"Then why did it start in the first place?" asked Arjun. "Teddy can't have started a whole outbreak by himself."

That was the question Priya couldn't stop thinking about. All weekend, she turned it over in her mind. On Monday she went to the cafeteria early and found the head cook, Mr. Delgado, unloading boxes from a truck.

"Mr. Delgado," she said, "did anything change on the lunch menu last Tuesday?"

He scratched his chin. "Last Tuesday? That was the first day of the new drink. Volcano Punch. Extra fizzy, very popular." He held up a carton covered in cartoon lava. "The kids love it. They gulp it down in about four seconds."

Priya felt the pieces click together like the parts of a puzzle. Fizzy drinks. Gulping. Swallowing air. Everything her mother had said could irritate the diaphragm. On Tuesday, every child in the school had been given the same extra-fizzy drink at the same time, and then they had laughed at each other.

"Mr. Delgado," she said, "can I ask you for a favor? It's for science."

For the next two weeks, with Mrs. Okonjo-Bell's permission, Westbrook ran a second experiment. On Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays, the cafeteria served Volcano Punch. On Tuesdays and Thursdays, it served plain milk and water. Priya, Oskar, and five helpers walked around the cafeteria with clipboards, counting every hiccup they heard.

Oskar turned out to be an excellent counter. He was loud, he was fast, and he never missed a "hic."

At the end of two weeks, Priya laid out the numbers. On Volcano Punch days, the clipboards had recorded an average of two hundred and twelve hiccups at lunch. On milk-and-water days, they had recorded nineteen.

Check your understanding

  1. Key details What did Priya's averages show about the four groups?

    1. Sugar worked twice as fast as the other cures
    2. Lemon juice was the fastest cure
    3. All four groups, including the group that did nothing, stopped hiccuping in about the same time
    4. Nobody in the WAIT group stopped hiccuping
  2. Inference Why does Priya joke about selling beanbags as a cure?

    1. To show that stopping hiccups right after doing something doesn't prove that thing caused it
    2. Because she really thinks beanbags stop hiccups
    3. To make fun of Benedict for being lazy
    4. Because Oskar needs a new product to sell
  3. Cause and effect According to Priya's new idea, what helped the hiccups spread from person to person?

    1. A virus that was passed through the lunch trays
    2. Kids sharing cups of lemon juice
    3. Laughter, excitement, and paying attention to other people's hiccups
    4. Cold air coming through the cafeteria windows
  4. Sequence What did Priya do right after she began wondering what started the outbreak?

    1. She ran the library experiment with forty volunteers
    2. She went to the cafeteria and asked Mr. Delgado if anything had changed on the menu
    3. She counted hiccups with Oskar for two weeks
    4. She went to the principal to ask for the library

Chapter 4: The Debate in the Gym

Priya presented her results at a special assembly in the gym. She stood on the stage with a poster that showed two bars, one very tall and one very short. The whole school sat on the floor in front of her, and in the back row, she could see her mother, still in her blue nurse's scrubs, and Paati, who had brought her sugar spoon just in case.

"The Great Hiccup Outbreak," Priya announced, "was caused by Volcano Punch."

A loud groan rolled across the gym. Volcano Punch was the most popular thing that had happened to Westbrook lunch in years.

Priya explained everything: the gulping, the fizz, the diaphragm, the laughter that spread the hiccups from table to table. Then she said, "So I think the school should stop serving it."

A hand shot up in the third row. It belonged to Teddy Abernathy, the original hiccuper himself.

"But I like Volcano Punch," he said. "Hiccups don't hurt. They're just annoying. Why should everyone lose their favorite drink because of a symptom that goes away by itself?"

Some kids clapped. Priya opened her mouth, then closed it again. It was a good point. She had been so busy proving what caused the hiccups that she had not really thought about whether they mattered.

Then Ms. Fairweather, the music teacher, stood up. "Hiccups may not hurt," she said, "but we couldn't rehearse the spring concert for a week. And Mr. Huang's class missed a whole math test because nobody could concentrate." She sat down to scattered applause.

Then Oskar stood up. Priya held her breath. He had lost twenty-one dollars of business because of her experiment. She would not have blamed him for being angry.

"I have a compromise," Oskar said. "What if we keep the Volcano Punch, but only on Fridays, and only after the math tests? And everybody has to drink it slowly, through a straw, like civilized people." He looked at Priya. "Then we can count the hiccups again and see if slow drinking makes a difference. Because that's another experiment, right?"

Priya grinned at him. "That's exactly another experiment."

The school voted. The compromise won by a huge margin. Even Teddy raised his hand.

After the assembly, Priya found Oskar packing up his clipboard. "I'm sorry about your lemon juice business," she said.

Oskar shrugged. "I gave everybody their fifty cents back," he said. "All twenty-one dollars. It felt weird keeping money for something that didn't really do anything." He paused. "My uncle Lars was pretty upset when I told him, though."

"What did he say?"

"He said it still worked for him in 1998." Oskar grinned. "So I told him he should have had a control group."

Priya laughed so hard that she hiccuped. Oskar froze. Priya froze. Then they both started counting under their breath, and when the hiccup didn't come back, they laughed again, more carefully.

That evening, Priya's mother taped the poster to the refrigerator. Paati looked at it for a long time, holding her spoon.

"So my sugar does nothing," Paati said finally.

"It does nothing to the hiccups," Priya said gently. "But it makes me think of you. That's a different kind of cure."

Paati laughed and put the spoon back in the drawer. "That," she said, "is not very scientific."

"No," Priya agreed. "But it's still true."

Check your understanding

  1. Theme Which lesson does the whole story teach most clearly?

    1. Old family remedies should always be thrown away
    2. Fizzy drinks are dangerous and should be banned everywhere
    3. To find the truth, test ideas fairly instead of trusting stories, and stay open to other people's points of view
    4. Winning an argument is more important than being kind
  2. Character What does Oskar's decision to return the twenty-one dollars show?

    1. He is afraid of getting in trouble with the principal
    2. He wants to buy something more expensive
    3. He is honest and cares more about fairness than about keeping money
    4. He never believed in the lemon juice at all
  3. Inference Why does Priya open her mouth and then close it again after Teddy speaks?

    1. She has forgotten what she wanted to say
    2. She realizes Teddy has made a fair point that she hadn't considered
    3. She is about to hiccup and wants to hide it
    4. She is too angry to answer politely
  4. Vocabulary Teddy calls hiccups "a symptom that goes away by itself." What is a "symptom"?

    1. A kind of fizzy drink
    2. A sign that something is happening in the body, like a cough or a hiccup
    3. A cure that works every time
    4. A type of school vote

Spelling words

These 12 words all appear in the story.

  • experiment
  • evidence
  • remedy
  • contagious
  • diaphragm
  • cafeteria
  • symptom
  • volunteers
  • laughter
  • principal
  • suggestion
  • scientific

Writing prompt

Priya says that "it worked for me" is not the same as proof. Do you agree? Explain the difference between a story about one person and a fair test, and use at least two examples from the story to support your answer.

Reading skills practiced

Inference, Vocabulary, Cause and effect, Character, Main idea, Key details, Sequence, Theme.

Answer key for grown-ups
  1. To make the silly event sound as serious as a real disease report, which adds humor Exact times are used in real outbreak reports. Using them for hiccups is a joke.
  2. Something that is supposed to cure or ease a problem Paati, Dad, and Arjun each offer a remedy, or cure.
  3. She tried all three, so there was no way to know which one, if any, worked Trying everything at once means you can't separate one cure's effect from another's.
  4. He is energetic and quick to act, but he trusts a story without checking it He believes his uncle's single success from 1998 is proof enough.
  5. Priya planning and starting a fair experiment to test the hiccup cures The chapter shows how Priya designs her test and begins it.
  6. So that nobody can choose the cure they already believe in Choosing at random keeps people's beliefs from deciding which group they join.
  7. The control group shows how fast hiccups stop on their own, which is what every cure must be compared to Without a group that gets no cure, there is nothing to compare the cures against.
  8. He goes from feeling insulted to agreeing to have his cure tested At first he thinks she is calling him a liar, but then he agrees to the test.
  9. All four groups, including the group that did nothing, stopped hiccuping in about the same time Each group's average was between ten and twelve minutes.
  10. To show that stopping hiccups right after doing something doesn't prove that thing caused it Benedict's hiccups stopped after he sat down, but the beanbag obviously didn't cure him.
  11. Laughter, excitement, and paying attention to other people's hiccups She notices that people hiccup right after laughing, and compares it to catching a yawn.
  12. She went to the cafeteria and asked Mr. Delgado if anything had changed on the menu She investigates the start of the outbreak by talking to the head cook.
  13. To find the truth, test ideas fairly instead of trusting stories, and stay open to other people's points of view Priya uses fair tests to find the cause, then listens to Teddy and Oskar in the debate.
  14. He is honest and cares more about fairness than about keeping money He says it felt wrong to keep money for something that did nothing.
  15. She realizes Teddy has made a fair point that she hadn't considered She had proven the cause but had not thought about whether hiccups were a big enough problem to lose the drink.
  16. A sign that something is happening in the body, like a cough or a hiccup A symptom is something you notice in your body, like hiccups.

More 5th grade stories

🐑

The Summer Pasture

Every June, Aibek's family drives their sheep, horses, and yaks high into the mountains of Kyrgyzstan to the summer pasture, just as their ancestors did for a thousand…

5th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxFarm · Animals · Mountains · Migration16 questions
🏃🏾‍♀️

Thin Air

Hana has run the highland trails of Ethiopia since she could walk, and she wants nothing more than to win the regional junior race. Then a team of foreign runners…

5th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxSports · Mountains · Health16 questions
🐢

Lights Out on Playa Luna

Every year, sea turtles swim thousands of kilometers to lay their eggs on the beach where Mateo lives in Costa Rica. But this year, bright new lights along the shore…

5th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxOcean · Animals · Migration · Village16 questions
🫒

The Olive Tree on the Balcony

Three years after her family moved from Syria to Canada, eleven-year-old Leila is the one who speaks for everyone: at the bank, at the landlord's office, and now at her…

5th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxCulture · Family · Migration · Health16 questions
🚡

The Cable Car Question

The town of Valbrenna is voting on whether to build a cable car to the top of Monte Corvo, and Nico's class is holding a debate about it. Nico loves the old mountain…

5th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxSchool · Mountains · Friends16 questions
🧊

The Cold Box

When measles appears in a village down the valley, Sunita's aunt, the only health worker in their Himalayan village, must bring vaccines up the mountain before it…

5th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxMedicine · Mountains · Village16 questions