📚 Reading Quest
🐪

The Long Walk to Pushkar

Moti the camel has carried Ravi's family's water, wood and dreams across the Thar Desert since before Ravi was born. Now his father has decided to sell Moti at the great camel fair and buy a motorbike. On the three-day walk across the sand, Ravi plans to change his father's mind. But at the fair, the choice Ravi faces turns out to be very different from the one he expected.

4th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerAnimals · Journeys · Culture2480 wordsAbout 30 minutes

Read it in the app 🚀

In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.

Words to know

fair
a large outdoor gathering where animals and goods are bought and sold, often with games and celebrations
haggle
to argue about a price before buying or selling something
livelihood
the way a person earns the money they need to live
nomad
a person who moves from place to place instead of living in one spot
decline
a gradual drop in number or importance

Chapter 1: The Decision

Moti the camel was older than Ravi by four years, taller than the roof of their house and, according to Ravi's grandmother, more stubborn than any man in the village of Kheda, which was saying something.

He was a tall, sandy-brown camel with a lopsided hump, enormous knobby knees and long eyelashes that would make a movie star jealous. When he was annoyed, which was often, he made a gurgling, grumbling noise like a pot of porridge boiling over. When he was happy, he leaned his huge, soft head down and rested it on top of Ravi's, very gently, like a hat.

Every morning before school, Ravi brushed the sand out of Moti's coat and led him to the well at the edge of the village. Every afternoon, Ravi's father hitched Moti to the wooden cart and drove him out across the Thar Desert, the great sea of sand and scrub that stretched across the west of India, to carry firewood, water cans and sacks of millet to villages that no truck could reach.

Moti could walk for days without water. He could carry more than a whole family could lift. His wide, padded feet didn't sink in the sand, and his long eyelashes and closable nostrils kept out the dust when the hot wind blew. For hundreds of years, camels like Moti had been the lifeblood of the desert. Ravi's family had owned camels for as long as anyone could remember.

That was why Ravi didn't understand, at first, what his father was saying at dinner.

"After Diwali," his father said, not looking up from his plate, "Moti and I will walk to Pushkar for the fair. I'm going to sell him."

Ravi's spoon stopped halfway to his mouth.

"Mr. Choudhary's son is selling his motorbike," his father went on. "With a small trailer. It can carry as much as Moti and goes three times as fast. And it doesn't need feeding when it isn't working." He finally looked up. "The new road reaches almost every village now, Ravi. The truck drivers take most of the work. We can't keep up with a camel anymore."

"But Moti is family!" Ravi burst out.

His father's jaw tightened. "Moti is our livelihood. Or he was. Now he's costing us more than he earns." He set down his bread. "You think I want to do this? My father bought Moti's mother. I grew up with camels the way you grew up with Moti. But I have to think about feeding you, and your sisters, and your grandmother. Not only about what I love."

Ravi ran out of the house before anyone could see him cry.

He found Moti lying in the sand behind the house with his legs folded neatly underneath him, chewing slowly, looking at the stars with an expression of great wisdom. Ravi sat down and leaned against the camel's warm, dusty side. Moti grumbled once, then swung his long neck around and rested his chin on top of Ravi's head.

Ravi's grandmother told the story at least once a month, so he knew it by heart, although he had been too young to remember it.

He had been a baby, less than a year old, during the worst drought anyone in Kheda could remember. The well had gone dry. The buses had stopped coming. Ravi had gotten a fever so high that his mother was afraid he wouldn't live through the night. The nearest clinic was in a town forty kilometers away across the sand.

Ravi's father had tied a cloth sling to Moti's saddle, put baby Ravi in it, wrapped in his mother's shawl, and ridden through the night. Moti had walked without stopping for nine hours, through a sandstorm, and reached the clinic at dawn. The doctor said if they had come even a few hours later, it might have been too late.

"That camel saved your life," Grandmother always finished. "Never forget it."

Ravi had not forgotten. He didn't understand how his father could.

Check your understanding

  1. Key details Why does Ravi's father want to sell Moti?

    1. Moti is sick and can't walk
    2. Moti bit a neighbor
    3. The new road and trucks have taken most of the work, and a motorbike is faster and cheaper to keep
    4. Ravi's grandmother asked him to
  2. Vocabulary Ravi's father says, "Moti is our livelihood." What does "livelihood" mean?

    1. The way a family earns the money it needs to live
    2. A kind of camel saddle
    3. A family pet
    4. A long journey
  3. Inference Why does the author include the flashback about the drought and the fever?

    1. To explain how to cure a fever
    2. To show why Ravi feels Moti is part of the family and why selling him feels like a betrayal
    3. To prove that Ravi's father doesn't care about Ravi
    4. To describe what the clinic looked like
  4. Character What do Ravi's father's words "Not only about what I love" reveal?

    1. He never loved Moti at all
    2. He loves Moti too, but feels responsible for feeding his whole family
    3. He is happy to sell Moti
    4. He wants Ravi to take care of Moti

Chapter 2: Three Days of Sand

They left for Pushkar a week after Diwali, before the sun was up. It was a three-day walk across the desert. Ravi had begged to come.

Ravi had a plan. Over three days, he would convince his father to change his mind.

On the first day, he tried facts. "Camels don't need petrol," he said, walking beside Moti in the soft morning light. "Petrol costs money. And a motorbike breaks down. And it can't go across the dunes where there's no road."

"True," said his father. "But it doesn't need fodder, either. And it doesn't need a doctor. And it doesn't get sulky and sit down in the middle of the road for an hour, like a certain camel did last week."

On the second day, Ravi tried feelings. He reminded his father about the drought. He reminded him about the sandstorm, and the nine hours, and the clinic at dawn.

His father walked in silence for a long time. Then he said, "Do you think I don't remember that night, Ravi? I was the one riding him. I was the one holding you in the sling, feeling how hot you were, praying with every step." His voice was rough. "I remember every minute of it. That's why this is so hard."

Ravi didn't know what to say. He hadn't thought about his father being afraid. He had only thought about Moti being brave.

That night they camped beside a dry riverbed. Moti folded himself onto the sand, and Ravi and his father sat against his warm side and ate flatbread and pickles while the stars came out, more stars than Ravi had ever seen, as thick as spilled sugar across the black sky.

"There used to be many more camels," his father said into the dark. "When I was your age, every family in Kheda had at least two. Now there are four camels in the whole village. All over Rajasthan, it's the same. People are selling them, because the trucks and roads have come. There are less than half as many camels in India as there were when I was born." He was quiet. "I'm not the only one making this choice, Ravi. I'm just the one you have to watch."

On the third day, Ravi didn't try anything. He just walked beside Moti with one hand on his warm, rough neck, and counted the steps, and tried to remember everything. The way Moti swung his feet. The creak of the saddle. The smell of dust and camel.

Late in the afternoon, they climbed a long ridge of sand, and Ravi stopped in his tracks.

Below them lay a valley filled with more camels than he had ever imagined, thousands and thousands of them, stretching as far as he could see, all the way to the horizon. There were tents and smoke from cooking fires and a huge, slowly turning Ferris wheel. In the middle of it all was a small white town around a lake, with temples on the shore. The sound came floating up the hillside: the bells, the music, the grumbling of a thousand camels, the shouting of a hundred thousand people.

"The Pushkar fair," said his father quietly. "Welcome."

Check your understanding

  1. Sequence In what order did Ravi try to change his father's mind?

    1. Feelings first, then facts, then nothing
    2. Facts on the first day, feelings on the second day, and on the third day he stopped trying
    3. Begging on all three days
    4. He didn't try at all
  2. Inference What does Ravi's father mean when he says, "I'm just the one you have to watch"?

    1. He wants Ravi to watch him work
    2. Many families are making the same hard choice, but Ravi only sees his own father doing it
    3. He thinks Ravi is spying on him
    4. He wants Ravi to watch the camels
  3. Character How does Ravi's understanding of his father change on the second day?

    1. He realizes his father never liked Moti
    2. He realizes his father was frightened that night and remembers it as deeply as anyone
    3. He decides his father is a bad person
    4. He learns his father was never in the sandstorm
  4. Inference Why does Ravi stop trying to change his father's mind on the third day?

    1. He has stopped caring about Moti
    2. He is too tired to talk
    3. He begins to accept that the sale is happening and wants to treasure his last moments with Moti
    4. His father tells him to be quiet

Chapter 3: Two Buyers

The Pushkar fair was the loudest, most crowded, most colorful place Ravi had ever been.

Camels everywhere, wearing necklaces of bells and anklets of silver, with their coats clipped into patterns of swirls and stars. Some had red and yellow pompoms on their bridles and tassels hanging from their saddles. There were camel races and beauty contests for decorated camels. There were acrobats balancing on poles, women selling glass bangles and men frying sticky sweets in giant pans of oil.

Ravi's father found a place for Moti in the camel grounds, and they waited. For a day and a half, nobody seemed interested in an old, lopsided, grumpy camel. Ravi was secretly glad. Maybe nobody would buy him.

Then, on the second afternoon, two buyers came on the same hour.

The first was a big man in a red turban and a shiny watch, with a stick that he slapped against his leg as he walked. He was a merchant from the city. He walked all the way around Moti twice, poked his ribs with the stick, pried open his mouth and looked at his yellow teeth.

"Old," he said. "But big. Strong legs." He named a price.

Ravi's father blinked. It was much more than he had hoped for. It was more than the motorbike cost.

"What will you use him for?" Ravi asked, before he could stop himself.

The merchant laughed. "Hauling stone, at the quarries near the border. Ten, twelve hours a day. I need strong animals. When they're worn out, I sell them on." He shrugged. "That's business."

Ravi's stomach turned cold. He looked at his father. His father's face showed nothing.

The second buyer came while the merchant was still standing there. She was a small, elderly woman in a faded green sari, with a stick of her own, though she used hers for walking. Her name was Mrs. Raika, and she ran a camel farm near Pushkar where she kept a herd of female camels and sold their milk. The milk was rich and healthy, she explained, and city people had recently started paying good money for it.

"I need a gentle male," she said. "Old enough to be calm. To lead my young camels to their grazing and back, and to teach them manners." She looked Moti straight in the eye. Moti looked straight back and grumbled. Mrs. Raika laughed, delighted. "Ah, he has opinions. Good."

"How much?" asked Ravi's father.

She named a price. It was a fair price. It was also much lower than the merchant's. Hardly enough for half a motorbike.

The merchant laughed again. "Take my offer, brother. That's twice the money."

Ravi's father rubbed his face. He looked at the merchant, and at Mrs. Raika, and at Moti. Then he did something Ravi didn't expect.

He turned to Ravi.

"You've walked with him for three days," he said. "You know him better than anyone. You choose."

Check your understanding

  1. Key details What does the merchant plan to do with Moti?

    1. Enter him in the beauty contest
    2. Make him haul stone at the quarries for long hours, then sell him when he's worn out
    3. Give him to a zoo
    4. Use him to give rides to tourists
  2. Cause and effect Why does Ravi feel "cold" when the merchant explains his plan?

    1. He realizes Moti would be worked hard and sold again with no care for him
    2. The desert night is very chilly
    3. He is afraid of the merchant's stick
    4. He thinks the price is too low
  3. Inference Why does Mrs. Raika laugh when Moti grumbles at her?

    1. She thinks Moti is sick
    2. She likes that he has a personality and isn't afraid of her
    3. She wants to scare him
    4. She is laughing at Ravi
  4. Inference Why do you think Ravi's father asks Ravi to make the choice?

    1. He is too tired to decide
    2. He trusts Ravi's love for Moti and wants him to have a fair say in Moti's future
    3. He doesn't care which buyer wins
    4. He wants to blame Ravi if something goes wrong

Chapter 4: The Price of a Good Life

Ravi's mouth went dry.

He had spent three days hoping and planning, and now that the choice was in his hands, he didn't want it at all.

He knew which one he wanted. Of course he did. He wanted Moti to go with the little old woman in the green sari, to lead young camels to pasture and grumble at them and teach them manners. He did not want Moti to haul stone for twelve hours a day until he was worn out and sold again to someone even worse.

But Ravi also knew how much the merchant's money meant. With it, his father could buy the motorbike and still have money left over. Money for his sisters' school fees. Money to fix the roof before the rains. With Mrs. Raika's money, they would have hardly enough for half a motorbike, and his father would have to borrow the rest.

It wasn't a choice between good and bad. It was a choice between two different kinds of good, and two different kinds of hurt. That was what made it so hard.

He looked at Moti. Moti swung his long neck down and rested his chin on top of Ravi's head, the way he always did. Gently. Like a hat.

And Ravi remembered his grandmother's words. That camel saved your life. Never forget it.

He turned to his father. His voice shook.

"Mrs. Raika," he said. "I'm sorry, Papa. I know it's less money. I know what we need it for. But Moti carried me for nine hours when I was going to die. He doesn't deserve to be worn out and thrown away. If we sell him to someone who'll hurt him, I think we would be worn out a little bit too. Inside. Every time we remembered."

He waited for his father to argue. He waited for him to say Ravi was a child who didn't understand money.

His father looked at him for a long time. Then he turned to the merchant.

"Thank you," he said politely. "But my son has decided."

The merchant shrugged and walked away into the crowd. Ravi's father turned to Mrs. Raika and began to haggle, the way everyone at the fair haggled, with lots of shouting and arm-waving and pretending to walk away. By the time they shook hands, Mrs. Raika had added a little more money, and promised something else too.

"Bring the boy to visit," she said, "whenever you come to Pushkar. A camel should see his family."

That evening, Ravi led Moti through the crowded fair to Mrs. Raika's farm on the edge of town himself. A dozen female camels lay in the shade of a big neem tree in the yard. When Moti saw them, he stopped, lifted his head high and made a sound Ravi had never heard him make, a long, rumbling, bubbling call. Several of the young camels looked up and called back.

"He'll be all right," said Mrs. Raika, watching. "Look at him. He's already giving orders."

Ravi said goodbye in the yard. He brushed the sand out of Moti's coat one last time. He told him to be good, and not to sit down in the road, and to grumble only at people who deserved it. Moti rested his chin on Ravi's head for a long time. Then Mrs. Raika's grandson led him gently away toward the neem tree, and Ravi did not watch him go, because he couldn't.

On the long walk home, Ravi and his father didn't talk much. The desert felt very big and very empty without Moti's footsteps beside them.

On the second night, sitting by their small fire under the sea of stars, Ravi finally asked. "Are you angry? About the money?"

His father poked the fire with a stick.

"The motorbike will have to wait a few months," he said. "I'll borrow some from your uncle. We'll manage." He was quiet. "Before we left, your grandmother said to me, 'Let the boy choose. He'll choose what you would choose, if you weren't so tired.'" He smiled a little in the firelight. "She was right. She usually is."

Ravi leaned against his father's shoulder. It wasn't warm and dusty like Moti's side. But it was strong, and it was there.

The next autumn, when Ravi and his father went back to Pushkar on the new motorbike, the first place they went was Mrs. Raika's farm. Moti was lying in the shade of the neem tree, surrounded by three young camels. He looked fatter, and grumpier, and very satisfied with himself.

When he saw Ravi, he heaved himself up onto his knobby legs, walked across the whole yard, and gently rested his chin on top of Ravi's head.

Check your understanding

  1. Main idea What makes Ravi's choice so hard?

    1. He doesn't like either buyer
    2. Both choices have something good and something painful: more money for the family, or a kinder life for Moti
    3. He doesn't know how to count money
    4. His father is angry with him
  2. Inference What does Ravi mean when he says, "I think we would be worn out a little bit too. Inside"?

    1. Selling Moti to someone cruel would leave the family with guilt and sadness for a long time
    2. The family would get tired from walking home
    3. Ravi wants to work at the quarry too
    4. The money would be used up quickly
  3. Inference What does Grandmother mean when she says Ravi will "choose what you would choose, if you weren't so tired"?

    1. Ravi's father is lazy
    2. Deep down, Ravi's father also wanted the kinder choice, but worry about money had worn him down
    3. Ravi should always do what his father says
    4. The family should never sell any animals
  4. Theme Which theme BEST fits the story?

    1. Money is the most important thing in life
    2. Old traditions should never change
    3. Sometimes doing what's right costs something, but loyalty and kindness are worth the price
    4. Animals are better than motorbikes

Spelling words

These 12 words all appear in the story.

  • desert
  • camel
  • pasture
  • motorbike
  • fodder
  • decorated
  • satisfied
  • stubborn
  • tassels
  • merchant
  • horizon
  • gently

Writing prompt

Ravi chose the buyer who offered less money. Was that fair to his family? Explain both sides, using evidence from the story, and then say what you would have done and why.

Reading skills practiced

Key details, Vocabulary, Inference, Character, Sequence, Cause and effect, Main idea, Theme.

Answer key for grown-ups
  1. The new road and trucks have taken most of the work, and a motorbike is faster and cheaper to keep His father explains that Moti now costs more than he earns.
  2. The way a family earns the money it needs to live Moti's work hauling goods earned the family's money.
  3. To show why Ravi feels Moti is part of the family and why selling him feels like a betrayal Moti saved Ravi's life, which makes selling him so painful.
  4. He loves Moti too, but feels responsible for feeding his whole family He grew up with camels but must think about the family's needs.
  5. Facts on the first day, feelings on the second day, and on the third day he stopped trying Each day of the journey shows a different approach.
  6. Many families are making the same hard choice, but Ravi only sees his own father doing it Camels are declining all over Rajasthan as roads and trucks arrive.
  7. He realizes his father was frightened that night and remembers it as deeply as anyone Ravi "hadn't thought about his father being afraid."
  8. He begins to accept that the sale is happening and wants to treasure his last moments with Moti He keeps one hand on Moti and tries to "remember everything."
  9. Make him haul stone at the quarries for long hours, then sell him when he's worn out The merchant says, "Ten, twelve hours a day... When they're worn out, I sell them on."
  10. He realizes Moti would be worked hard and sold again with no care for him The merchant treats Moti only as "business."
  11. She likes that he has a personality and isn't afraid of her She says, "Ah, he has opinions. Good."
  12. He trusts Ravi's love for Moti and wants him to have a fair say in Moti's future He says, "You know him better than anyone."
  13. Both choices have something good and something painful: more money for the family, or a kinder life for Moti "It was a choice between two different kinds of good, and two different kinds of hurt."
  14. Selling Moti to someone cruel would leave the family with guilt and sadness for a long time He means they would feel bad every time they remembered.
  15. Deep down, Ravi's father also wanted the kinder choice, but worry about money had worn him down She suggests father and son share the same values.
  16. Sometimes doing what's right costs something, but loyalty and kindness are worth the price The family takes less money so Moti can have a good life.

More 4th grade stories

🖊️

Two Names on the Cover

Leo writes the stories and Kai draws the pictures. Together they have made eleven comics about Gearheart, a clockwork fox. But when their comic wins a place in the…

4th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerFriends · Art16 questions
🏠

The House That Said Yes

After Abuelo Tomás takes a tumble, Ruby's mom installs PIP, a talking smart-home helper, to keep an eye on him. PIP is very eager to please and takes every word…

4th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerHumor · Robots · Family16 questions
🐧

The Puffin Counter

Every summer of her life, Sigrun has helped her grandfather count the puffins on the cliffs of tiny Skarvøy island. This summer is her last, because her family is…

4th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerAnimals · Islands · Family16 questions
🍎

The Grafting Knife

The oldest apple trees on the Nowak family farm are going to be pulled out to make room for new ones, including the gnarled tree that grows a golden apple found nowhere…

4th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerFarm · Family · Nature16 questions
🎨

The Village Cloth

Tavita's mural design, full of the patterns her grandmother taught her in Samoa, loses the class vote to a giant space scene. That stings. But what stings more is when…

4th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerSchool · Art · Culture16 questions
🏃🏾‍♀️

The Hill at Mile Two

Ruth Wanjiru has trained all season to conquer the steep forest hill at the city cross-country championship. She crosses the finish line first, and her team wins the…

4th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerSports · Forest · Family16 questions