The Great Gnome Debate
When a twelve-foot garden gnome is left to the town of Pickering Falls in a rich woman's will, the whole town goes to war over whether it belongs in the town square. Desmond, who writes the kids' column for the local paper, is asked to choose a side in print. There is just one problem. Every time he listens to one side, he agrees with it, and every time he listens to the other, he agrees with that too.
5th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeyHumor · Village · Newspapers2621 wordsAbout 30 minutes
In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.
Words to know
- editorial
- a newspaper article that gives the opinion of the writer or editor
- controversy
- a disagreement that many people argue about strongly
- petition
- a written request signed by many people asking for a change
- column
- a regular article in a newspaper written by the same person
- satire
- writing that uses humor to point out foolishness
Chapter 1: Mrs. Thornbury's Last Wish
When Mrs. Agatha Thornbury died at the age of ninety-seven, she left her mansion to her nephew, her jewelry to her niece, her fortune to the animal shelter, and her gnome to the town of Pickering Falls.
The gnome was twelve feet tall.
It was made of fiberglass and painted in colors that could only be described as enthusiastic. It had a pointed red hat, a white beard that reached its belly, a bright blue coat, and a pair of yellow boots the size of bathtubs. In one hand, it held a fishing rod. In the other, it held a fish. The fish was smiling. So was the gnome. It had been smiling in Mrs. Thornbury's front garden for forty-one years, and nobody in Pickering Falls could remember a time without it.
Her will was very clear. "I leave my beloved gnome, Sir Reginald Puddlefoot, to the people of Pickering Falls," it said, "on the condition that he be displayed in the town square, where everyone can enjoy him."
The town square of Pickering Falls was small and very tidy. It had a white bandstand, four benches, a bronze statue of the town's founder, Colonel Josiah Pickering, on a horse, and a flower bed shaped like a clock. It was, according to the sign at the edge of town, "The Prettiest Square in Wisconsin." This was not officially true, but nobody had ever argued.
Until now.
Desmond Pike heard the news at breakfast. His mother was reading the Pickering Falls Gazette, the town's weekly newspaper, and laughing so hard that coffee came out of her nose.
"They're putting Sir Reginald in the square!" she wheezed. "Next to the Colonel! Oh, this is going to be wonderful."
Desmond was eleven and wrote a column for the Gazette called "The Junior Desk." It came out every Thursday on page nine, next to the crossword and the lost-pet notices. Mostly he wrote about school lunches, the library's summer reading program, and the time the high school mascot costume was found inside the town water tower. He had about forty readers. Thirty of them were relatives.
The editor of the Gazette was a woman named Mrs. Bunting, who wore reading glasses on a beaded chain and had the energy of a hummingbird that had just discovered espresso. She called Desmond that afternoon.
"Desmond! The gnome! It's the biggest story in Pickering Falls since the Great Cheese Fire of 2009! I want you on it."
"Me? But I just do the kids' column."
"Exactly! Fresh eyes! A young perspective!" Desmond could hear her pacing. "I want an editorial. Your opinion. Should Sir Reginald go in the square, yes or no? Front page, Thursday. Can you do it?"
Desmond had never been on the front page. He had never been anywhere near the front page.
"Yes," he said. "Absolutely. I can do it."
He hung up and sat back in his chair. Then he realized something. He had absolutely no idea what his opinion was.
Check your understanding
Key details What condition did Mrs. Thornbury's will set for the gnome?
- It must be painted a new color
- It must be displayed in the town square where everyone can enjoy it
- It must be sold to raise money for the animal shelter
- It must stay in her front garden forever
Vocabulary Mrs. Bunting asks Desmond for an "editorial." What is an editorial?
- A list of facts about a topic
- A story about a made-up character
- A newspaper article that gives the writer's opinion
- A crossword puzzle
Inference The author says Mrs. Bunting has "the energy of a hummingbird that had just discovered espresso." What is the author suggesting?
- She is very small
- She drinks too much coffee
- She is extremely excited and full of fast, buzzing energy
- She likes birds
Character Why does Desmond agree to write the editorial so quickly?
- He is excited by the chance to be on the front page for the first time
- He already has a strong opinion about the gnome
- His mother forces him
- He wants to make Mrs. Bunting angry
Chapter 2: On One Hand
Desmond decided the best way to find his opinion was to ask people for theirs. He took his notebook and walked into town.
His first stop was Mr. Featherstone, the president of the Pickering Falls Beautification Society. Mr. Featherstone was a thin man with a perfectly trimmed mustache. He was kneeling in the clock-shaped flower bed, trimming a petunia with tiny scissors.
"The gnome? In the square?" Mr. Featherstone shuddered so hard his scissors rattled. "Young man, our square is a place of dignity. Of history. Colonel Pickering founded this town in 1851. He fought bravely. He built the first mill. And you want to put a twelve-foot cartoon next to him? With a smiling fish?" He pointed his scissors at Desmond. "It's ridiculous. It would make us a laughingstock. People would drive through and think we're a town of clowns."
Desmond wrote this down. It made sense. The square was very pretty. And the gnome was, objectively, a bit much.
"Thank you, Mr. Featherstone," he said. "I think you're right."
Then he walked across the street to Rosie's Diner, where Rosie herself was wiping the counter. Rosie had run the diner for thirty years and knew everything that happened in Pickering Falls before it happened.
"Sir Reginald?" Rosie's face lit up. "Oh, honey, I love that gnome. When I was a little girl, my daddy used to drive me past Mrs. Thornbury's house just so I could wave at him. Everybody did. People got engaged in front of that gnome. People took their wedding pictures with him." She leaned on the counter. "And let me tell you something else. You know how many people stop in this town every summer? Hardly any. They drive right through on the way to the lakes. But you put a twelve-foot gnome in the square? People will stop. They'll take pictures. And then they'll get hungry." She winked. "Business, honey. That gnome is good for business."
Desmond wrote this down too. It also made sense. The town did need visitors. Half the shops on Main Street had closed in the last five years.
"Thank you, Rosie," he said. "I think you're right."
He walked out of the diner and stopped on the sidewalk. He looked at his notebook. On one page, it said "Gnome = embarrassing, disrespectful." On the next, it said "Gnome = beloved, good for business."
He had agreed with both of them. Completely.
That was a problem.
He tried asking more people. Old Mr. Halvorsen said the gnome was an eyesore and should be melted down. His wife, Mrs. Halvorsen, standing right next to him, said it was the most charming thing in Wisconsin and she would chain herself to it if anyone tried. The librarian said the gnome represented the joyful spirit of folk art. The mayor said, carefully, that she would not be taking a position at this time. A group of teenagers said the gnome was "iconic" and should have its own social media account.
By the end of the day, Desmond had filled twenty pages, and he agreed with every single one of them.
He went home and stared at a blank screen for three hours. He wrote "Sir Reginald belongs in the square because" and then deleted it. He wrote "Sir Reginald does not belong in the square because" and deleted that, too. He wrote "Gnomes: A Complicated Issue" and then put his head down on the keyboard, which typed four hundred letter J's.
His grandmother, who lived with them, came in with a cup of hot chocolate.
"How's the editorial going?" she asked.
"Terrible," Desmond said into the keyboard. "Everyone I talk to is right. Even when they disagree with each other."
His grandmother sat down on the edge of his bed. "That," she said, "is the most grown-up thing I've heard you say."
Check your understanding
Main idea What is the main problem Desmond faces in Chapter 2?
- Nobody will talk to him about the gnome
- His computer breaks
- He finds that both sides of the argument make sense, so he can't choose an opinion
- Mrs. Bunting cancels his column
Key details What is Rosie's main reason for wanting the gnome in the square?
- It matches the flower bed
- It holds happy memories for the town and could bring visitors who spend money
- It looks like Colonel Pickering
- It would scare away birds
Inference Why is Desmond's grandmother impressed when he says "Everyone I talk to is right"?
- She thinks he's being silly
- Seeing that people with opposite views can each have good reasons is a sign of mature thinking
- She wants him to stop writing
- She agrees that the gnome is ugly
Vocabulary Mr. Featherstone says the gnome would make the town "a laughingstock." What does laughingstock mean?
- A place that sells jokes
- Someone or something that people make fun of
- A kind of soup
- A comedy show
Chapter 3: The Gnome Wars
While Desmond struggled with his editorial, the rest of Pickering Falls did not struggle at all. Everyone knew exactly what they thought, and they wanted everyone else to know it too.
Mr. Featherstone started a petition called "Keep Our Square Dignified." It got three hundred and twelve signatures.
Rosie started a petition called "Sir Reginald Belongs to Us." It got three hundred and fourteen signatures, two of which were from her cats.
The letters to the editor began to pour into the Gazette. On Monday, there were six. On Tuesday, there were thirty. By Wednesday, Mrs. Bunting had to put a laundry basket by the door to hold them all.
Some of them were thoughtful. Some of them were not. One letter said the gnome was "an insult to the memory of Colonel Pickering and all decent people." Another said Colonel Pickering "was no saint himself, considering he once lost the town's entire treasury in a card game in 1853." Someone wrote a forty-line poem titled "Ode to Sir Reginald." Someone else wrote a forty-line poem titled "Ode to Getting Rid of Sir Reginald."
Mrs. Bunting printed all of them. The Gazette doubled its pages. For the first time in years, every single copy sold out.
"Isn't it wonderful? Nothing sells newspapers like a good controversy!" Mrs. Bunting said, when Desmond came by the office on Wednesday. She was surrounded by stacks of paper and looked as though she hadn't slept. "People are reading! People are talking! We've sold more papers this week than in the whole last year!"
Desmond looked at the latest letters on her desk. One of them, from a man on Elm Street, called the people who liked the gnome "fools with no taste." Another, from a woman on Maple Street, called the people who disliked the gnome "joyless snobs who probably hate puppies."
"Mrs. Bunting," Desmond said slowly, "are people actually talking? Or are they just yelling?"
Mrs. Bunting paused with her pencil in the air.
"I went to the grocery store yesterday," Desmond went on. "Mr. Halvorsen and Mrs. Halvorsen were in different aisles. They've been married for fifty-two years. Mrs. Halvorsen told me he's sleeping on the couch until he apologizes to Sir Reginald." He looked at the laundry basket of letters. "It's kind of funny. But it's also kind of not."
Mrs. Bunting took off her reading glasses and let them dangle on their beaded chain. For a moment, she didn't look like a hummingbird at all.
"Hmm," she said.
Then things got worse. On Wednesday night, someone sneaked into the town hall parking lot, where Sir Reginald was waiting under a tarp for the town council to decide his fate, and painted a mustache on him. A large, black, curly mustache. It looked a lot like Mr. Featherstone's mustache, only twelve times bigger.
On Thursday morning, Mr. Featherstone stood in front of the gnome, purple with rage. "This is mischief!" he sputtered. "This is vandalism! This is an attack on the dignity of my mustache!"
Half the town came to look. Some people laughed so hard they had to sit down. Others shouted. A man from Elm Street and a woman from Maple Street got into an argument so loud that a police officer had to stand between them. Somebody's dog got loose and ran in circles barking at the fish.
Desmond stood at the edge of the crowd, watching. He thought about his editorial, still unwritten. He thought about Mrs. Bunting's front page, waiting to be filled with one side or the other.
And suddenly, he knew exactly what to write.
Check your understanding
Cause and effect Why are the Gazette's sales suddenly so high?
- The gnome controversy has people eagerly reading the flood of letters and opinions
- The paper started giving away free gnomes
- Desmond's column became famous
- Mrs. Bunting lowered the price
Inference What point is Desmond making when he asks, "Are people actually talking? Or are they just yelling?"
- People's voices are too loud
- The newspaper should stop printing letters
- The debate has become insulting and divisive instead of a real conversation
- People should talk on the phone instead
Character How does Mrs. Bunting react when Desmond points out the problem?
- She fires him immediately
- She laughs and ignores him
- She stops and thinks seriously, realizing he may have a point
- She writes an angry letter
Key details What happened to Sir Reginald on Wednesday night?
- He was stolen
- He fell over in the wind
- Someone painted a big mustache on him that looked like Mr. Featherstone's
- He was moved into the square without permission
Chapter 4: On the Other Hand
Desmond's editorial appeared on the front page of the Gazette the next Thursday, under the headline "ON ONE HAND, ON THE OTHER HAND."
It began like this:
"Mrs. Bunting asked me to write my opinion about Sir Reginald Puddlefoot. I tried very hard. I talked to forty-three people. I filled two notebooks. And I have to tell you the truth: I can't decide. Not because I don't care, but because everyone I talked to had a good reason. So instead of telling you what I think, I'm going to tell you what YOU think. Both of you."
Then he laid it all out. On one hand, the square was historic and beautiful, and some people felt a giant cartoon gnome didn't fit there. On the other hand, the gnome was part of Pickering Falls' history too, full of happy memories, and it might bring visitors who could save the shops on Main Street. On one hand, Mrs. Thornbury's will said the gnome must go in the square. On the other hand, a will couldn't force a town to do something most people didn't want.
He wrote each side as fairly as he could, using the very best reasons he had heard, and none of the insults.
At the end, he wrote:
"Here's the only thing I'm sure about. Mr. and Mrs. Halvorsen have been married for fifty-two years, and right now Mr. Halvorsen is sleeping on the couch because of a fiberglass gnome. I don't think Mrs. Thornbury left us Sir Reginald so that we would fight. I think she left him to us because he made people smile. If we can't figure out a way to keep him without being mean to each other, then maybe we don't deserve him. And if we can't figure out a way to keep the square dignified without calling our neighbors snobs, then maybe we're not as dignified as we think."
Mrs. Bunting read it three times. Then she put it on the front page, with no letters to the editor at all that week. Instead, in the space where the letters usually went, she printed a small note: "The Gazette will be holding a town meeting about Sir Reginald on Saturday at the library. Bring an opinion. Leave the insults at home."
Two hundred people came to the meeting. It was crowded and noisy, and at first, it looked as though it would turn into another shouting match. But Desmond had brought copies of his editorial, and people kept pointing at it. "On the other hand," somebody would say, and the room would calm down a little.
In the end, it was Mr. Halvorsen, of all people, who came up with the solution.
"What about the park by the river?" he said gruffly. "Right where the highway comes into town. Every car driving to the lakes passes it. You could see Sir Reginald from a mile away. He'd be holding his fishing rod right next to the actual river, which makes more sense than standing next to the Colonel's horse, frankly. And the square stays the way it is."
There was a long silence.
"That's not the town square," Rosie said slowly. "The will says the town square."
The town lawyer, who had been sitting quietly in the back, stood up and cleared her throat. "Technically," she said, "the will says 'the town square, where everyone can enjoy him.' I'd argue the second part is what Mrs. Thornbury really cared about. I think a judge would agree."
Mr. Featherstone stroked his mustache. Then, slowly, he nodded. "A riverside location," he said, "would be... acceptable."
Rosie grinned. "And I could put up a sign: 'Hungry? Rosie's Diner, Two Blocks That Way.'"
The compromise passed by a vote of one hundred and eighty-seven to thirteen.
Sir Reginald Puddlefoot was installed in Riverside Park the following month, mustache removed, fishing rod pointed proudly at the water. Mrs. Halvorsen tied a ribbon around his boot. Mr. Halvorsen, who had moved back into the bedroom, stood beside her and pretended not to smile.
Tourists began to stop almost immediately. They took photographs with the gnome and posted them online, and within a summer, Sir Reginald had more followers than the mayor. Rosie hired two new waitresses. A gift shop opened on Main Street selling tiny Sir Reginald statues, which Mr. Featherstone declared "tasteless" and secretly bought three of.
And Desmond's column moved from page nine to page two. Mrs. Bunting renamed it "On One Hand, On the Other Hand." Every week, he took a question that people in Pickering Falls were arguing about, a new stoplight, the school dress code, whether pineapple belonged on the diner's pizza, and laid out both sides as fairly as he could.
It was the most popular column in the Gazette. People said it was the only part of the newspaper they could read without getting angry.
"You know," his grandmother said one evening, reading it over his shoulder, "you still never tell anyone your own opinion."
Desmond grinned. "On one hand, that's true," he said. "On the other hand, I've noticed that when I give people both sides, they usually figure out a pretty good answer on their own."
His grandmother laughed and ruffled his hair. "That," she said, "is an opinion."
Check your understanding
Main idea What was the main idea of Desmond's editorial?
- The gnome must be destroyed
- The gnome must go in the square no matter what
- Both sides had good reasons, and the town should stop insulting each other and find a way forward together
- The newspaper should stop covering the gnome
Key details Where does Sir Reginald finally end up?
- In the town square next to the Colonel
- Back in Mrs. Thornbury's garden
- In Riverside Park near the highway, where everyone driving to the lakes can see him
- In the library
Inference Why does Mr. Featherstone "secretly" buy three tiny Sir Reginald statues?
- He wants to destroy them
- He has grown fond of the gnome but doesn't want to admit it after calling it tasteless
- He is buying them for Rosie
- He wants to paint mustaches on them
Theme What does Desmond's grandmother mean when she says, "That is an opinion"?
- Desmond is wrong about everything
- Desmond's belief that sharing both sides helps people find good answers is itself an opinion he holds
- Desmond should write about pizza
- Desmond needs to choose a side on the gnome
Spelling words
These 12 words all appear in the story.
- editorial
- column
- headline
- petition
- ridiculous
- controversy
- opinion
- statue
- tourists
- compromise
- mischief
- newspaper
Writing prompt
Desmond's "On One Hand, On the Other Hand" column became popular because it explained both sides fairly. Choose a question that people in your school or town disagree about. Write a short column in Desmond's style, giving the strongest reasons on each side, and then explain which side you lean toward and why.
Reading skills practiced
Key details, Vocabulary, Inference, Character, Main idea, Cause and effect, Theme.
Answer key for grown-ups
- It must be displayed in the town square where everyone can enjoy it The will says the gnome must be "displayed in the town square."
- A newspaper article that gives the writer's opinion She says she wants "Your opinion. Should Sir Reginald go in the square, yes or no?"
- She is extremely excited and full of fast, buzzing energy Hummingbirds are already quick; with espresso, they'd be even more energetic.
- He is excited by the chance to be on the front page for the first time He had never been anywhere near the front page and says yes right away.
- He finds that both sides of the argument make sense, so he can't choose an opinion He agrees with everyone, even when they disagree with each other.
- It holds happy memories for the town and could bring visitors who spend money She shares her childhood memories and says, "That gnome is good for business."
- Seeing that people with opposite views can each have good reasons is a sign of mature thinking She calls it "the most grown-up thing I've heard you say."
- Someone or something that people make fun of He worries people would "think we're a town of clowns."
- The gnome controversy has people eagerly reading the flood of letters and opinions "For the first time in years, every single copy sold out" because of the gnome debate.
- The debate has become insulting and divisive instead of a real conversation Letters call opponents "fools" and "snobs," and even a married couple is split.
- She stops and thinks seriously, realizing he may have a point She takes off her glasses, and "for a moment, she didn't look like a hummingbird at all."
- Someone painted a big mustache on him that looked like Mr. Featherstone's Someone painted on "a large, black, curly mustache."
- Both sides had good reasons, and the town should stop insulting each other and find a way forward together He presents both sides fairly and says the fighting goes against why the gnome was left to them.
- In Riverside Park near the highway, where everyone driving to the lakes can see him Mr. Halvorsen suggests the park by the river, and the town votes for it.
- He has grown fond of the gnome but doesn't want to admit it after calling it tasteless He publicly calls them "tasteless" but buys them in secret, showing a change of heart he hides.
- Desmond's belief that sharing both sides helps people find good answers is itself an opinion he holds Even "never giving an opinion" is based on something Desmond believes.