📚 Reading Quest
🍎

The Grafting Knife

The oldest apple trees on the Nowak family farm are going to be pulled out to make room for new ones, including the gnarled tree that grows a golden apple found nowhere else on Earth. Kasia's grandfather taught her a secret way to save it before he died. But using that secret means going behind her father's back.

4th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerFarm · Family · Nature2478 wordsAbout 30 minutes

Read it in the app 🚀

In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.

Words to know

graft
to attach a cut branch from one plant onto another plant so they grow together
scion
a small cut branch used for grafting
rootstock
the root and lower trunk of a tree that a graft is attached to
variety
a particular kind of fruit or plant, such as one type of apple
mortgage
a loan from a bank to buy land or a house, which must be paid back over many years

Chapter 1: The Orange Ribbons

The ribbons appeared on a Tuesday in March, when the snow was still lying in the shadows of the orchard.

Kasia Nowak saw them from the school bus window: bright orange plastic ribbons, tied around the trunks of the old trees in the north block. There were forty-one of them. She counted twice, her nose pressed to the cold glass, and her stomach dropped further with every number.

The orange ribbon around the very last tree, the big crooked one by the stone wall, was the one that made her run the whole way up the driveway.

"Dad!" She found him in the barn, sharpening the blades of the mower. "Why are there ribbons on the north block?"

Her father put down the file. He had the look he always had before saying something hard, a kind of tightening around his mouth. "Sit down a minute, Kasiu."

She didn't sit down.

"Those trees are almost seventy years old," he said. "They're tired. They make half the apples a young tree makes, and the apples are small. They're too tall to pick without ladders, and ladders are slow and dangerous." He wiped his hands on a rag. "In April, a crew is coming to pull them out. We'll plant new trees, the short kind that grow along wires, like the Kowalskis did. In three years, that block will grow three times as many apples."

"But the Golden Lady," Kasia said. "You can't pull out the Golden Lady."

The crooked tree by the stone wall had no official name. It grew an apple that didn't exist anywhere else in the world: small, round and golden, with a pink blush on one cheek and a taste like honey and pears and something sharp underneath. Nobody had planted it on purpose. Kasia's great-grandmother had found it growing as a wild seedling by the wall in 1953, probably from an apple core some long-ago picker had tossed over his shoulder. She had loved the fruit so much that she let it grow. Grandpa Stefan had called it the Golden Lady.

Every apple from the Golden Lady was a little gift. You couldn't buy them in stores. The tree produced only a few bushels a year, and the family ate them, gave them to neighbors and baked them into Grandpa's famous autumn cake.

Dad looked down at the rag in his hands.

"Kasiu, the Golden Lady is the oldest and slowest tree we have. It's half hollow inside. It might fall down in the next big storm anyway." He took a breath. "The orchard has had three bad years. Hail, then the late frost, then the prices fell. We have a mortgage on this land, and if we can't make the payments, we lose more than one tree. We lose the farm."

She was frightened. She was also furious, which was easier to feel.

"Grandpa would never have let you," she said, and she watched the words hit him like a slap.

Her father didn't answer. He picked up the file and went back to sharpening the blade, scrape, scrape, scrape, and didn't look up again.

Kasia walked out to the stone wall and stood beside the Golden Lady. The bark was rough and gray, and the branches twisted up into the sky like the arms of a dancer. The orange ribbon fluttered in the wind.

Two winters ago, Grandpa Stefan had died in his sleep. And now, Kasia thought, she was going to lose the last thing in the orchard that felt like him.

Then she remembered the knife.

Check your understanding

  1. Key details What makes the Golden Lady apple special?

    1. It is the largest apple in the state
    2. It grew from a wild seedling and exists nowhere else in the world
    3. It was planted by a famous scientist
    4. It is sold in every grocery store
  2. Cause and effect Why does Kasia's father plan to pull out the old trees?

    1. He doesn't like apples
    2. The neighbors told him to
    3. The old trees produce fewer apples, and the farm needs more income to pay its mortgage
    4. A storm already knocked them down
  3. Vocabulary What is a "mortgage" in this chapter?

    1. A kind of apple tree
    2. A loan for land that must be paid back over many years
    3. A farm machine
    4. A ribbon tied around a tree
  4. Inference Kasia says, "Grandpa would never have let you," and watches the words "hit him like a slap." What does this show?

    1. Kasia's words make her father laugh
    2. Kasia uses her grandfather's memory to hurt her father, because she is scared and angry
    3. Kasia's father agrees with her
    4. Kasia didn't mean anything by it

Chapter 2: What Grandpa Taught

The grafting knife lived in a leather case in the top drawer of Grandpa's old workbench. It was small, with a wooden handle worn smooth by his thumb and a blade so sharp that Kasia had never been allowed to touch it alone.

She took it out and held it in her palm, and the memory came back so clearly she could almost smell the sawdust.

She had been eight years old. It was a cold April morning, and Grandpa had brought her into the greenhouse, where a row of little bare trees stood in pots, each one no taller than her knee.

"Do you know," Grandpa had said in his gravelly voice, "that if you plant a seed from a Golden Lady apple, you will not get a Golden Lady tree?"

Kasia hadn't known.

"Apple seeds are like children," he explained. "Each one is a mix of its two parents, and every child is different. Plant a hundred seeds, get a hundred different apples, and most of them will be sour and small. That's why the Golden Lady was such a lucky accident. One seed in thousands." He held up a short, thin branch he had snipped from the old tree that morning. "So if you want another Golden Lady, you can't grow it from a seed. You have to make a copy."

He showed her. "This is the rootstock. Strong roots, but its own fruit is nothing special." He cut the top off the rootstock at an angle with the grafting knife. Then he cut the bottom of the Golden Lady branch, the scion, at a matching angle, and fit the two pieces together like puzzle pieces, so that the thin green layer just under the bark of each one touched.

"That green layer is where the tree grows," he said. "If the green touches green, they will heal together and become one tree. Roots from this one, branches from that one. In a few years, it will grow Golden Lady apples, exactly the same as the old tree. Every Golden Lady could be a grandchild of the first one."

He wrapped the joint tightly with a rubber band and a strip of tape, like a bandage on a scraped knee, and dabbed wax over the top so it wouldn't dry out.

"Every apple tree in every orchard in the world is made like this," he said. "Did you know that? Every one is a copy of a copy of a copy, going back sometimes hundreds of years. Somebody kept them alive by doing exactly this."

Kasia had asked, "Why don't you make lots of Golden Ladies, Grandpa?"

He had laughed and ruffled her hair. "I keep meaning to. But there's always next year." Then his face had gone serious for a moment. "Someday you might need to do it, Kasiu. Remember how."

That little grafted tree had died the next winter, chewed by rabbits. Grandpa had kept meaning to try again. And then there hadn't been a next year.

Kasia stood in the cold barn, holding the knife. It was the second week of March. Grandpa always said the best time to cut scions was late winter, while the tree was still asleep, and the best time to graft was early spring. She had about four weeks before the crew arrived.

She knew she should ask her father. She knew it. But she kept hearing him say, "It's half hollow inside. It might fall down anyway," and she was afraid that if she asked, he would say no, and then it would be too late.

That night, she went out to the stone wall with Grandpa's pruning scissors and a flashlight. She climbed up into the lowest branches of the Golden Lady and cut twelve thin, straight twigs from last year's growth, each one about as long as a pencil. She wrapped them in a damp paper towel and a plastic bag and hid them in the back of the old refrigerator in the barn, behind the bottles of tractor oil.

Then she lay awake until nearly two in the morning, feeling like a thief.

Check your understanding

  1. Sequence What did Grandpa do right AFTER he fit the scion and rootstock together?

    1. He planted the seeds in pots
    2. He wrapped the joint tightly with a rubber band and tape and sealed it with wax
    3. He cut the top off the rootstock
    4. He gave the tree to the rabbits
  2. Key details Why can't you grow a Golden Lady tree from a Golden Lady seed?

    1. The seeds are poisonous
    2. Each seed is a mix of two parents, so the new tree's apples will be different
    3. The seeds are too small to plant
    4. Golden Lady apples have no seeds
  3. Inference Why does the author include this flashback in the middle of the story?

    1. To show that Kasia hated working in the greenhouse
    2. To teach readers how grafting works and to show that Grandpa trusted Kasia to save the tree someday
    3. To explain why rabbits are dangerous
    4. To show that Grandpa was a bad teacher
  4. Character Why does Kasia feel "like a thief" after cutting the branches?

    1. She took apples from a neighbor
    2. She did something important in secret, without her father's permission
    3. She broke Grandpa's knife
    4. She stole money for the trees

Chapter 3: Caught in the Greenhouse

Kasia needed rootstocks, and she had no money for them.

So she did the only thing she could think of. She rode her bike to the Kowalski farm, two miles down the road, and asked Mrs. Kowalski if she had any spare rootstocks left from their new plantings. Mrs. Kowalski gave her a strange look, then gave her a bucket with fifteen leftover little trees, their roots wrapped in wet burlap.

"Does your father know about this?" Mrs. Kowalski asked.

"It's a surprise," Kasia said, and her cheeks went hot.

For the next week, every day after school, she worked in the old greenhouse behind the barn. It had been empty since Grandpa died, and the glass was dusty, but it still kept out the wind. She potted the rootstocks. She practiced cuts on willow twigs until her angles were smooth and even. Then, one cold Saturday morning, she took the twelve Golden Lady scions out of the barn refrigerator and began.

Her first graft was crooked. The pieces didn't line up, and she had to cut them both again, which wasted a scion. Her second was better. By the fifth, her hands had remembered what Grandpa's hands had shown them, and the cuts fit together neatly, green against green. She wrapped each joint with a rubber band, then tape, then wax, and wrote the date on a wooden label.

She had finished nine when the greenhouse door creaked open behind her.

Her father stood in the doorway.

For a long moment neither of them said anything. Kasia looked at the row of little potted trees, each one wearing its bandage. Her father looked at them too. Then he looked at the grafting knife in her hand.

"Mrs. Kowalski called," he said finally. "She wanted to know how my surprise was coming along."

Kasia's face burned. "Dad, I..."

"You went behind my back." His voice was very quiet, which was worse than if he'd shouted. "You lied to a neighbor. You used Grandpa's knife alone. You climbed that tree in the dark, didn't you? A half-hollow tree. Do you know what could have happened if a branch broke?"

"You were going to cut it down!" The words burst out of her. "You didn't even ask anybody! You just tied ribbons on everything, and Grandpa's gone, and I was the only one who knew how to save it!"

She expected him to argue. Instead, her father's face did something strange. It crumpled.

He sat down heavily on an overturned bucket and put his hands over his eyes. Kasia had never seen her father cry, not even at Grandpa's funeral, where he had stood very straight and shaken everyone's hand.

"I asked your mother to marry me under that tree," he said through his fingers. "Did you know that? In September, when the apples were ripe. I had the ring in my pocket for three days because I was too nervous." He wiped his face with his sleeve. "Do you think I want to pull it out, Kasiu? I tied that ribbon on myself, and I stood there for half an hour before I could do it."

Kasia's anger drained out of her so fast it left her dizzy. She had been so sure she was the only one who loved the Golden Lady. She had never once wondered how her father felt.

"I'm sorry," she whispered. "I'm sorry about what I said in the barn. About Grandpa."

Her father looked up at the row of little grafted trees on the bench. He was quiet for a long time.

"Your cuts are good," he said finally. His voice was rough. "Better than mine. He never got around to teaching me."

Check your understanding

  1. Cause and effect How did Kasia's father find out about the grafting?

    1. He saw her climbing the tree
    2. He found the knife missing
    3. Mrs. Kowalski called and asked about his "surprise"
    4. Kasia told him at dinner
  2. Character Why is Kasia's father upset with her?

    1. Because her grafts are crooked
    2. Because she lied, used the sharp knife alone and climbed a dangerous tree in the dark without telling him
    3. Because she visited the Kowalskis
    4. Because she broke the greenhouse glass
  3. Inference Why does Kasia's anger "drain out of her so fast"?

    1. She is too tired to keep arguing
    2. She realizes her father loves the tree as much as she does and is also suffering
    3. Her father gives her money
    4. She decides the tree doesn't matter
  4. Main idea What is the most important discovery Kasia makes in this chapter?

    1. That grafting is easy
    2. That Mrs. Kowalski is a good neighbor
    3. That her father had mixed feelings about pulling out the tree all along
    4. That the greenhouse is too cold for trees

Chapter 4: Green Against Green

They finished the last three grafts together.

Her father held each little rootstock steady while Kasia made the cuts. He wrapped the tape, she dabbed the wax. They didn't talk much. But it was a different kind of quiet from the one in the barn, like the quiet of two people rowing a boat in the same direction.

When they were done, twelve small trees stood in a row on the greenhouse bench. Well, eleven. One scion had been wasted on Kasia's first crooked try.

"Not all of them will take," her father warned. "Grandpa said one in three failed, even for him."

Her father nodded slowly. "There's something else we should talk about," he said. "I still have to pull out the north block. That part hasn't changed. The farm needs it."

Kasia had known he would say that. It still hurt to hear. She looked out through the dusty glass at the crooked shape of the Golden Lady by the wall, and she realized that a part of her had already started to understand. Saving the orchard and saving the tree were two different jobs. Her father had been trying to do one. She had been trying to do the other.

"Okay," she said, and it was the hardest word she had ever said.

In April, the crew came with their machines. She and her father stood by the stone wall together and watched as the old trees came down one by one. When it was the Golden Lady's turn, her father put his arm around her shoulders. The trunk split open as it fell, and Kasia saw that the inside really was hollow, a dark tunnel of crumbling wood where a family of mice had been living.

"He was right," she said quietly. "It wouldn't have lasted much longer."

"No," said her father. "But it lasted long enough for you."

In May, the buds on the little grafted trees began to swell. Kasia checked them every morning before the bus came. On some of them, tiny green leaves unfolded from the Golden Lady scions, which meant the green layers had joined and the two trees had become one. On others, the scions turned brown and dry. By June, the count was final.

Seven out of eleven had taken.

Her father built a new row at the end of the north block, right along the stone wall where the old tree had stood. He and Kasia planted the seven young trees there together, in a straight line, each one with its own wooden label: GOLDEN LADY. GRAFTED BY KASIA NOWAK.

"Three years until the first apples," said her father, leaning on his shovel. "Maybe four."

"I can wait," said Kasia.

From the wood of the old tree, her father made two things. One was a new wooden handle for the grafting knife, because the old one had finally cracked. The other was a small, smooth bench that he set at the end of the row, facing the young trees.

Four years later, in September, the first seven Golden Lady apples ripened on the young trees. They were small and round and golden, with a pink blush on one cheek. Kasia baked them into Grandpa's autumn cake, using his handwritten recipe, and the whole kitchen smelled like honey and pears and something sharp underneath.

Her father took one bite and closed his eyes.

"Exactly the same," he said.

"Not exactly," said Kasia, smiling. "These ones are ours."

Check your understanding

  1. Sequence Put these events in order: (1) the grafted trees grow leaves, (2) the crew pulls out the old trees, (3) the first seven apples ripen, (4) Kasia and her father finish the last three grafts.

    1. 1, 2, 4, 3
    2. 4, 2, 1, 3
    3. 2, 4, 3, 1
    4. 4, 1, 3, 2
  2. Inference What does Kasia realize when she says, "Saving the orchard and saving the tree were two different jobs"?

    1. That she doesn't care about the orchard anymore
    2. That she and her father were each trying to protect something important, and both goals could be respected
    3. That her father was wrong all along
    4. That the tree could be moved to another farm
  3. Vocabulary When the scions grow leaves, it means "the green layers had joined." What does this tell you?

    1. The trees have caught a disease
    2. The graft worked, and the two plants have grown together into one tree
    3. The tape fell off
    4. The leaves were painted green
  4. Theme Which theme BEST fits the story?

    1. Old things should never be replaced
    2. We can honor the past and still accept change, especially when we work together
    3. Children always know better than adults
    4. Secrets are the best way to solve problems

Spelling words

These 12 words all appear in the story.

  • orchard
  • grafting
  • branches
  • rootstock
  • neighbors
  • greenhouse
  • bandage
  • mortgage
  • furious
  • frightened
  • funeral
  • scissors

Writing prompt

Kasia decided to graft the trees without asking her father first. Was that the right choice? Explain both sides, using details from the story, and then say what you would have done and why.

Reading skills practiced

Key details, Cause and effect, Vocabulary, Inference, Sequence, Character, Main idea, Theme.

Answer key for grown-ups
  1. It grew from a wild seedling and exists nowhere else in the world Great-grandmother found it growing by the wall in 1953.
  2. The old trees produce fewer apples, and the farm needs more income to pay its mortgage He explains three bad years have put the farm in danger.
  3. A loan for land that must be paid back over many years If they can't make the payments, they could lose the farm.
  4. Kasia uses her grandfather's memory to hurt her father, because she is scared and angry Her fear turns into anger, and her words wound him.
  5. He wrapped the joint tightly with a rubber band and tape and sealed it with wax He wrapped it "like a bandage on a scraped knee" and then dabbed on wax.
  6. Each seed is a mix of two parents, so the new tree's apples will be different Grandpa says apple seeds are like children, each one different.
  7. To teach readers how grafting works and to show that Grandpa trusted Kasia to save the tree someday The memory explains grafting and ends with Grandpa saying "Remember how."
  8. She did something important in secret, without her father's permission She knows she should have asked her father first.
  9. Mrs. Kowalski called and asked about his "surprise" Mrs. Kowalski became suspicious and phoned him.
  10. Because she lied, used the sharp knife alone and climbed a dangerous tree in the dark without telling him He lists her lie, the knife and the climb.
  11. She realizes her father loves the tree as much as she does and is also suffering Learning he proposed under the tree changes how she sees him.
  12. That her father had mixed feelings about pulling out the tree all along Her father admits it took him half an hour to tie the ribbon.
  13. 4, 2, 1, 3 They finish the grafts, the crew comes in April, leaves appear in May, and apples ripen four years later.
  14. That she and her father were each trying to protect something important, and both goals could be respected She understands her father's choice while still saving the Golden Lady.
  15. The graft worked, and the two plants have grown together into one tree Grandpa said if green touches green, the pieces heal into one tree.
  16. We can honor the past and still accept change, especially when we work together The old tree comes down, but its "grandchildren" grow on, and Kasia and her father find a shared solution.

More 4th grade stories

🖊️

Two Names on the Cover

Leo writes the stories and Kai draws the pictures. Together they have made eleven comics about Gearheart, a clockwork fox. But when their comic wins a place in the…

4th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerFriends · Art16 questions
🏠

The House That Said Yes

After Abuelo Tomás takes a tumble, Ruby's mom installs PIP, a talking smart-home helper, to keep an eye on him. PIP is very eager to please and takes every word…

4th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerHumor · Robots · Family16 questions
🐧

The Puffin Counter

Every summer of her life, Sigrun has helped her grandfather count the puffins on the cliffs of tiny Skarvøy island. This summer is her last, because her family is…

4th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerAnimals · Islands · Family16 questions
🎨

The Village Cloth

Tavita's mural design, full of the patterns her grandmother taught her in Samoa, loses the class vote to a giant space scene. That stings. But what stings more is when…

4th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerSchool · Art · Culture16 questions
🏃🏾‍♀️

The Hill at Mile Two

Ruth Wanjiru has trained all season to conquer the steep forest hill at the city cross-country championship. She crosses the finish line first, and her team wins the…

4th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerSports · Forest · Family16 questions
🐚

The Sea Women's Whistle

Ji-woo has been afraid of deep water since she nearly drowned when she was six. Now she is spending the summer on Jeju Island with her grandmother, one of the famous…

4th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerOcean · Culture · Islands16 questions