📚 Reading Quest
🦌

The Wind and the Reindeer

In the mountains of northern Norway, giant wind turbines are rising on the winter grazing land where Áilu's Sámi family has herded reindeer for generations. Ingrid's father helped build them, and she is proud of the clean energy they make. When the two of them are paired for a school project, they discover that a good cause and a fair decision are not always the same thing.

5th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerCulture · Nature2671 wordsAbout 30 minutes

Read it in the app 🚀

In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.

Words to know

Indigenous
describing the first peoples to live in a region, who have deep, long-standing ties to the land
lichen
a slow-growing living thing, part fungus and part alga, that grows on rocks and ground; reindeer eat it in winter
grazing land
land where animals feed on growing plants
compensation
something, usually money, given to make up for a loss or harm
injustice
a situation in which people are treated unfairly or their rights are ignored

Chapter 1: Áilu

The reindeer knew the way better than the herders did. That was what Áilu's grandfather always said.

Every year, in late autumn, when the first real snow fell, the family's herd began to move. Two thousand reindeer, gray and brown and white, flowing down from the high summer pastures toward the winter grazing grounds in the lower mountains, where the snow was softer and the lichen grew thick beneath it. Áilu's family were Sámi, the Indigenous people of the far north of Norway, Sweden, Finland, and Russia, and they had followed the reindeer on this migration for longer than anyone could count.

Áilu was twelve. He had been riding on the back of his father's snowmobile behind the herd since he was four, bundled in a reindeer-skin coat, watching his father and grandfather work. Now he had his own snowmobile, a small, battered one with a cracked seat, and his own job: keeping the stragglers at the back of the herd moving.

The winter grounds were a high plateau of rolling hills and frozen lakes, called Gaskavárri in the family's language. In winter, it was white and silent except for the wind. Under the snow grew the lichen that the reindeer depended on to survive until spring. They dug for it with their hooves, scraping away the snow to reach the pale, crunchy food beneath. Reindeer lichen grew very slowly, only a few millimeters a year. A pasture that was destroyed could take decades to come back.

That year, the herd stopped at the edge of Gaskavárri, and would not go on.

Áilu saw why at once. Across the plateau, where there had always been nothing but snow and sky, stood a line of white towers, enormous, each one taller than a twenty-story building. Huge three-bladed propellers turned slowly on top of them, whooshing through the cold air. There were dozens of them, stretching off over the hills. Between them, new gravel roads had been cut into the land, and there were concrete platforms and power lines and a small gray building with a fence around it.

Wind turbines.

Áilu had known they were coming. Everyone in the community had known for years. His grandfather and other herders had gone to meetings and written letters and signed petitions. They had explained, again and again, that this was their winter grazing land, that the reindeer would not graze near the noisy, moving turbines, that the roads would cut through their migration routes. A government office had listened politely, and then given the energy company permission to build anyway.

But knowing it was different from seeing it.

The lead reindeer, an old female with one broken antler, stood at the front of the herd, staring at the turning blades. Then she turned around and began to walk back the way she had come. The rest of the herd followed her.

"They won't go near," said Áilu's father quietly, as the herders gathered on their snowmobiles. His face was very still. "They can hear the blades. They can see the shadows moving on the snow. They're afraid."

"Where will they go?" Áilu asked.

His grandfather was silent for a long time, looking at the turbines. The old man had herded reindeer on Gaskavárri for sixty years. His father and grandfather had herded here before him.

"Somewhere else," he said finally. "Somewhere with less food. And other herders' reindeer already there." He looked at Áilu. "There isn't enough room for everyone, Áilu. There never was much. Now there's less."

On the way back, Áilu rode at the back of the herd, as always, keeping the stragglers moving. Behind him, the giant blades turned and turned against the gray sky, making electricity for people far away who would never see this place.

Check your understanding

  1. Key details Why is lichen so important to the reindeer?

    1. It keeps them warm at night
    2. It is the food they dig for beneath the snow to survive the winter
    3. It helps them find their migration route
    4. It protects them from wolves
  2. Cause and effect Why does the herd turn back at the edge of Gaskavárri?

    1. A storm blocks the way
    2. The reindeer are frightened by the noise, movement, and shadows of the new wind turbines
    3. The herders tell them to stop
    4. The lichen has already been eaten
  3. Inference Why does the author describe the herders going to meetings and writing letters before the turbines were built?

    1. To show that the herders tried to be heard through fair means, but their concerns were overruled
    2. To show that the herders agreed with the wind farm
    3. To explain how electricity is made
    4. To show that Áilu enjoys meetings
  4. Inference What does the final image of blades making electricity "for people far away who would never see this place" suggest?

    1. That the electricity is wasted
    2. That the benefits go to distant people while the cost falls on the herders, raising a question of fairness
    3. That the turbines are beautiful
    4. That the herders will move to the city

Chapter 2: Ingrid

Ingrid Solberg thought wind turbines were the most beautiful machines in the world.

She had grown up with them. Her father was an engineer who had spent fifteen years building wind farms, first along the coast and now in the mountains. When she was little, he used to take her to see them being put up: the giant blades arriving on trucks so long they needed police escorts, the cranes lifting them into the sky. He had shown her how the wind turned the blades, and the blades turned a generator, and the generator made electricity, with no smoke and no burning, from nothing but moving air.

"Every turbine on that hill," he had told her, "means less coal burned somewhere. Less oil. Less carbon in the air, heating up the planet."

Ingrid cared about climate change more than almost anything. She had read about melting glaciers, rising seas, stronger storms, and animals losing their habitats. She had marched in the school climate strike with a sign she'd painted herself. She thought clean energy was the most important thing a person could build. She was proud of her father.

That January, her family moved north, to a small town at the foot of the mountains, because her father was now in charge of the new Gaskavárri wind farm.

On her first day at the new school, the teacher, Mr. Haugen, gave the class a project. They would work in pairs, he explained, and present a report on a question facing their local community. He had already chosen the pairs, and the questions.

"Ingrid Solberg," he read from his list, "and Áilu Gaup. Your question: Is the Gaskavárri wind farm good for our community?"

A few kids in the class went very quiet. One or two glanced at Áilu, who was sitting by the window. Ingrid looked too. He was a thin boy with dark hair and a very serious face, and he was looking at her with an expression she didn't understand.

After class, he walked up to her desk.

"Your father built the turbines," he said. It wasn't a question.

"He's in charge of them," Ingrid said. "Why?"

Áilu was silent for a moment. "Because my family's reindeer can't go to their winter pasture anymore," he said. "Because of the turbines. So I thought you should know before we start."

Then he walked away.

Ingrid went home and asked her father. He sat down at the kitchen table with a heavy sigh, as if he'd been expecting the question.

"Yes," he said. "Some of the Sámi herders objected. The reindeer avoid the turbines; that's known. The company studied it. It paid some money. And the government approved the project. It was all done legally." He rubbed his eyes. "Ingrid, Norway has promised to cut its carbon emissions. We can't do that without wind power. We need these places. They're windy and nobody lives there."

"Áilu's family lives there," Ingrid said slowly. "In the winter."

"Not lives, exactly. They use it for grazing."

"Isn't that a kind of living?"

Her father looked at her. Then he looked down at his hands. He didn't answer.

That night, Ingrid lay in bed and tried to think it through. Climate change was real. It was dangerous. It was hurting people and animals all over the world, including, she'd read, reindeer: warmer winters were causing rain to fall on snow and freeze into hard ice, locking away the lichen so the reindeer couldn't dig through it. Wind power was part of the answer. She believed that with her whole heart.

But Áilu had looked at her as if she were part of something that had happened to him. And she couldn't stop thinking about her father's words: Nobody lives there.

How many times, she wondered, had someone said that about a place where somebody did?

Check your understanding

  1. Character Why does Ingrid admire wind turbines?

    1. She thinks they are noisy and exciting
    2. She cares deeply about climate change and sees turbines as clean energy that reduces pollution
    3. Her teacher told her to
    4. She wants to become a herder
  2. Inference Why does the author switch to Ingrid's point of view in this chapter?

    1. To show that Ingrid is the villain
    2. To show that the wind farm also comes from good intentions, so the conflict is not simple
    3. To describe the reindeer migration
    4. Because Áilu has moved away
  3. Vocabulary When Ingrid asks, "Isn't that a kind of living?" what is she questioning?

    1. Whether reindeer are alive
    2. Her father's idea that the land was empty just because no one had a house there
    3. Whether her father works hard enough
    4. Whether herders sleep in tents
  4. Inference What does Ingrid realize when she wonders how many times people said "nobody lives there" about places where somebody did?

    1. That maps are often wrong
    2. That powerful people have often ignored those already using a land, calling it empty so they could take it
    3. That the town is too small
    4. That her father is lying on purpose

Chapter 3: Both Sides

They started the project the way Mr. Haugen told them to: by collecting evidence. Not opinions. Evidence.

It was awkward at first. They met in the school library after class, sitting at opposite ends of a table, saying as little as possible. But on the third day, Áilu said, "You should see it. Not the turbines. The herd. You should see what we're talking about."

So on Saturday, Ingrid's mother drove her up the valley to the Gaup family's winter camp, and Áilu's grandfather took her out on the back of his snowmobile to see the reindeer.

She had never been so close to so many animals. They were everywhere, two thousand of them, spread across the snowy hills, their breath steaming in the cold air, their hooves scraping at the snow. Áilu's grandfather, whose name was Ánte, showed her how they dug for lichen, and how thin some of them were getting.

"This is not our winter land," he said in slow Norwegian. "This is other herders' land. Too many animals now, for too little food. We are buying feed. Hay, pellets. It costs very much money. If it continues, maybe we can't continue."

"You'd stop herding?" said Ingrid.

The old man looked at the herd for a long time.

"Many families have stopped," he said. "Over the last hundred years. Roads. Dams. Mines. Cabins for tourists. Power lines. Each one takes a piece. Each one, people say, is only a small piece." He shrugged. "Many small pieces make a big hole."

Later, in the warm tent, Áilu's grandmother served them coffee and dried reindeer meat, and sang a short song in a high, wavering voice that seemed to rise and fall like the hills. It was called a joik, Áilu explained. A joik wasn't really a song about something. It was a way of calling something to mind, a person or a place or an animal, so that it was present with you. His grandmother had a joik for Gaskavárri. She hadn't sung it since the turbines went up.

"Why not?" Ingrid asked quietly.

Áilu translated the question. His grandmother answered without looking up from her cup.

"She says it hurts too much," Áilu said. "She says when a tradition loses its place, it's like a song that loses its words. You can still hum it. But you forget what it meant."

Ingrid thought about that all the way home.

The next week, Áilu came to her house and talked to her father. Ingrid had been nervous about it, but her father was kind and serious and answered all of Áilu's questions. He showed them maps of the wind farm. He showed them the studies the company had done about the reindeer. And Áilu asked him something Ingrid hadn't thought to ask.

"Did anyone ask the herders where to put the turbines? Before you decided?"

Her father hesitated. "There were consultations," he said. "Meetings."

"But did anyone change the plan because of what they said?"

Her father looked at the map for a long moment. "No," he said quietly. "Not very much."

Afterward, when Áilu had gone, Ingrid found her father sitting on the porch in the cold, looking up at the mountains, where on a clear night you could just see the red lights blinking on top of the turbines.

"I've spent fifteen years believing I was doing something good," he said, without looking at her. "I still believe it. The world needs clean energy. Desperately." He was quiet. "But I never once went up to see the reindeer. Not once. It was always just a line in a report."

Ingrid sat down next to him.

"You can be doing something good," she said slowly, working it out as she spoke, "and still be doing it unfairly. Can't you? Both things."

Her father didn't answer. But he put his arm around her, and they sat there together, watching the red lights blink on Gaskavárri.

Check your understanding

  1. Main idea What is the main thing Ingrid learns on her visit to the herd?

    1. That reindeer are dangerous
    2. That losing the winter pasture is forcing the family to crowd onto other land and buy expensive feed, threatening their way of life
    3. That the turbines are too small
    4. That Áilu's grandfather wants to build turbines
  2. Vocabulary Ánte says, "Many small pieces make a big hole." What does he mean?

    1. The reindeer have dug too many holes
    2. Each project takes only a little land, but together they destroy much of the herders' land and way of life
    3. The snowmobile needs repair
    4. The turbines leave holes in the ground
  3. Sequence Which of these happened first?

    1. Ingrid visited the herd with Áilu's grandfather
    2. Áilu asked Ingrid's father whether the plan had changed
    3. Ingrid and Áilu presented their report
    4. The herders took their case to court
  4. Theme Ingrid says, "You can be doing something good and still be doing it unfairly." How does this idea connect to the whole story?

    1. It states the central problem: the wind farm helps fight climate change, yet the herders' rights and voices were ignored
    2. It proves that wind power is bad
    3. It shows that Ingrid wants to stop the project
    4. It suggests that fairness doesn't matter

Chapter 4: The Report

On the day of their presentation, Ingrid and Áilu stood together at the front of the classroom with a poster and a set of slides, and Ingrid's hands were so sweaty that she kept wiping them on her jeans.

They had argued about how to do it. Áilu had wanted to say the wind farm was simply wrong. Ingrid had wanted to say it was simply necessary. In the end, after a lot of arguing in the library, they had agreed to tell the truth, which was that it was both.

Áilu went first. He showed photographs of the herd turning away at the edge of Gaskavárri, and a map of the old migration routes, with the turbine roads cutting across them like scratches. He explained about the lichen, and the crowding, and the cost of feed. He explained how many Sámi families had stopped herding over the last century, as their land was taken in one small piece after another. He called it what it was: an injustice. Not because the turbines existed, he said, but because the people who would lose the most had been given the least say. His voice stayed steady the whole time, though Ingrid could see his hands shaking.

Then Ingrid went. She showed graphs of rising temperatures, and pictures of melting ice, and explained how much carbon the Gaskavárri wind farm saved each year. She explained that the warming climate was harming reindeer too, with rain freezing over the snow and locking away their food. "So the herders need climate change to be stopped," she said. "Just like everybody else does. Maybe even more."

Then they stood together for the last slide. It said:

CONCLUSION: The world needs clean energy. But clean energy built without listening to the people who live on the land is not just. A good cause does not make an unfair process fair.

Underneath, in smaller letters, they had added: Recommendations: Ask first. Listen. Change the plan when you're wrong. Pay fairly for what is taken. Look for places where the harm is smallest. And when you make a mistake, fix it.

The classroom was very quiet. Then Mr. Haugen started clapping, and everybody joined in.

That spring, something unexpected happened. A group of Sámi herders, including Áilu's grandfather, took their case to a court, arguing that the wind farm had violated their right to practice their culture, which is protected by international law. Their lawyers used some of the same evidence that Áilu and Ingrid had gathered. And after months of hearings, the court agreed with them. The permit, the judges said, should never have been given the way it was.

But the turbines were already built. They didn't come down. Instead, there were more meetings, long and difficult ones, between the herders, the energy company, and the government. This time, people listened. Ingrid's father was at many of them. Some of the herders' requests were met: the company agreed to pay much more in compensation, to give the herders new winter grazing land elsewhere, to shut down some turbines during the migration, and to work with the herders on any future plans from the very beginning.

It was not a perfect ending. Áilu's grandfather said so himself. "The land at Gaskavárri is still gone," he said. "Money does not grow lichen." But he also said that, for the first time in his long life, he had seen the people with the power admit that they had been wrong. "That is something," he said. "That is a beginning."

In June, Áilu invited Ingrid to come and see the herd move up to the summer pastures. She rode on the back of his battered little snowmobile, over the last of the snow, with two thousand reindeer flowing up the mountainside around them like a river.

At the top of the pass, they stopped. Far across the valley, they could see the turbines of Gaskavárri, still turning.

"Do you hate them?" Ingrid asked.

Áilu thought about it seriously.

"No," he said. "I hate how they got there." He looked at her. "Do you still think they're beautiful?"

"Yes," said Ingrid. "But I think about the reindeer when I look at them now. I don't think I'll ever stop."

"Good," said Áilu. "That's what it should feel like."

Below them, the old female with the broken antler led the herd on, up toward the high, green summer valleys, the way her mothers and grandmothers had always gone.

Check your understanding

  1. Key details What did the court decide about the wind farm?

    1. That the turbines must be torn down immediately
    2. That the permit should never have been given the way it was, because it violated the herders' rights
    3. That the herders were wrong
    4. That the case should go to another country
  2. Cause and effect What changes came out of the meetings after the court case?

    1. The herders received nothing
    2. More compensation, new winter grazing land, some turbines shut down during migration, and herders included in future planning
    3. All turbines were removed
    4. The reindeer were moved to a zoo
  3. Inference What does Áilu mean when he says, "I hate how they got there"?

    1. He dislikes the color of the turbines
    2. His anger is not at clean energy itself but at the unfair way the project ignored his people
    3. He is jealous of Ingrid
    4. He wanted the turbines somewhere else in town
  4. Theme Which theme is developed across the whole story?

    1. Progress should always win over tradition
    2. Indigenous people should never accept change
    3. Even a good cause must be pursued fairly, by listening to and respecting the people whose lives and land it affects
    4. Climate change is not important

Spelling words

These 12 words all appear in the story.

  • reindeer
  • turbines
  • herders
  • grazing
  • lichen
  • climate
  • permission
  • Indigenous
  • migration
  • compensation
  • tradition
  • injustice

Writing prompt

The wind farm made clean energy, which helps fight climate change, but it also harmed the herders. Can something be good for the world and unfair to some people at the same time? Explain your answer using evidence from both Áilu's and Ingrid's points of view.

Reading skills practiced

Key details, Cause and effect, Inference, Character, Vocabulary, Main idea, Sequence, Theme.

Answer key for grown-ups
  1. It is the food they dig for beneath the snow to survive the winter Reindeer "depended on" lichen to survive until spring.
  2. The reindeer are frightened by the noise, movement, and shadows of the new wind turbines Áilu's father explains, "They can hear the blades... They're afraid."
  3. To show that the herders tried to be heard through fair means, but their concerns were overruled They "explained, again and again," yet permission was given anyway.
  4. That the benefits go to distant people while the cost falls on the herders, raising a question of fairness The contrast highlights who gains and who loses.
  5. She cares deeply about climate change and sees turbines as clean energy that reduces pollution She marched in the climate strike and is proud of her father's work.
  6. To show that the wind farm also comes from good intentions, so the conflict is not simple Her love of clean energy makes the opposing side understandable.
  7. Her father's idea that the land was empty just because no one had a house there She sees that using the land for grazing is part of how the family lives.
  8. That powerful people have often ignored those already using a land, calling it empty so they could take it She connects her father's words to a larger pattern of unfairness.
  9. That losing the winter pasture is forcing the family to crowd onto other land and buy expensive feed, threatening their way of life Ánte explains the crowding and the cost of feed.
  10. Each project takes only a little land, but together they destroy much of the herders' land and way of life Roads, dams, mines, and power lines each took "a piece."
  11. Ingrid visited the herd with Áilu's grandfather The visit to the herd came first, then the talk with Ingrid's father, then the report, then the court case.
  12. It states the central problem: the wind farm helps fight climate change, yet the herders' rights and voices were ignored Both sides have real value, which is why the story's question is hard.
  13. That the permit should never have been given the way it was, because it violated the herders' rights The court agreed with the herders, though the turbines stayed.
  14. More compensation, new winter grazing land, some turbines shut down during migration, and herders included in future planning This time, "people listened."
  15. His anger is not at clean energy itself but at the unfair way the project ignored his people He separates the turbines from the unjust process.
  16. Even a good cause must be pursued fairly, by listening to and respecting the people whose lives and land it affects Both viewpoints, the report's conclusion, and the court case show that how something is done matters as much as why.

More 5th grade stories

🌿

The Hedgerow

Maisie Thornbury's father plans to tear out the ancient hedge that splits their two biggest fields, so the farm can use a larger harvester and pay its debts. Maisie…

5th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerFarm · Nature16 questions
📷

The Attention Score

When Westbrook Middle installs smart cameras that give every student a live "attention score," Nadia Rahman is delighted, because her score is the highest in the class.…

5th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerSci-fi · School16 questions
🛶

Wayfinder

Kaimana has always felt like the least useful person on her grandfather's voyaging canoe. On a training voyage across open ocean with no compass and no screens, a…

5th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerOcean · Culture16 questions
🧵

The Turn-Out

In 1836, eleven-year-old Abby Fletcher changes bobbins in a roaring cotton mill in Lowell, Massachusetts, where her older sister Hannah is a weaver. When the mill…

5th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerHistory · Justice16 questions
🦴

What I Saw at the Museum

On a class trip to the natural history museum, a 450-million-year-old trilobite fossil goes missing from the touch table, and Owen Pryce is absolutely certain he saw…

5th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerMystery · School16 questions
🚴

The Climb to Alto del Sol

In the mountains of Boyacá, Colombia, twelve-year-old Valentina trains every morning to climb like the great Colombian cyclists. Her cousin Andrés is suddenly flying up…

5th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerSports · Family16 questions