📚 Reading Quest
💡

First Light in Kisima

Electricity is finally coming to the lakeside village of Kisima, from a new solar mini-grid that can power only sixty of the village's one hundred and forty homes in its first year. Who should get the light first? Achieng, who studies by a smoky kerosene lamp, is sure the answer will be "the rich and the powerful." But as the village argues, she discovers there are at least four different ideas of what "fair" means.

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonVillage · Justice2785 wordsAbout 30 minutes

Read it in the app 🚀

In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.

Words to know

mini-grid
a small, local electricity system that generates power, often from solar panels, and delivers it to nearby homes and buildings
priority
being treated as more important, so that something is done or given first
subsidy
money given, often by a government or organization, to lower the cost of something for people
criteria
the standards or rules used to judge or decide something
resentment
a bitter feeling of having been treated unfairly

Chapter 1: Achieng — The Lamp

Every night, I do my homework by a kerosene lamp, and every night the lamp tries to stop me.

It's a small tin lamp with a glass chimney and a cotton wick, and it gives off a yellow, wobbling light about as bright as a candle. When the wind comes in off the lake, the flame flickers and the shadows jump across my notebook. When it burns low, I have to lean so close to the page that my eyes water. And it smokes. A thin black smoke that smells like a truck and gets into my throat. My mother coughs every night, and so do my little brothers. The nurse at the dispensary says kerosene smoke is bad for our lungs, and that it's like breathing the exhaust of a car for hours. She says we should buy a solar lantern instead. A good one costs more than my mother earns in two weeks of selling fish at the market.

So we use the lamp. Everyone in Kisima does, except the families who can afford something better. Mr. Ochieng, who owns the biggest shop, has a diesel generator that roars behind his shop every evening for three hours, and the whole street can hear it.

Kisima is a village on the shore of Lake Victoria, in western Kenya. It has one hundred and forty households, a primary school, a small dispensary run by one nurse, a mosque, two churches, three shops, and a beach where the fishing boats come in at dawn. It has never had electricity. The national power lines run along the main road, twelve kilometers away, and the government has been promising to bring them to Kisima since before I was born. My grandmother says they've been promising since before she was born, which I think is an exaggeration, but only a small one.

Then, last March, a company came.

It was called Jua Power. Jua means "sun" in Swahili. They built a fenced area on the hill behind the school and filled it with rows and rows of solar panels, tilted toward the sky, shining like a field of mirrors. Next to them they built a small concrete building full of batteries, to store the power for the night. And they began putting up wooden poles along the paths of the village, with wires strung between them.

Everybody came out to watch. Children followed the workers. Old men sat in the shade and argued about whether it would really work. My grandmother said she'd believe it when she saw a light bulb.

Then the company's engineer, a woman named Ms. Njeri Kamau, called a meeting under the big fig tree in the middle of the village, and explained the problem.

The mini-grid, she said, was smaller than they'd hoped. The funding had come up short. In the first year, it could only power sixty households, plus the school, the dispensary, and the water pump. The other eighty households would have to wait until the company raised more money to add more panels and batteries. Maybe one year. Maybe two. Maybe more.

"So who gets it first?" someone called out.

"That," said Ms. Njeri, "is what the village needs to decide."

The meeting went on until dark. People shouted. People argued. Before it ended, though, I already knew how it would turn out. I'd seen it my whole life. The families with money would get the light. The chief's family would get it. The shopkeepers would get it. People like us, the fish-sellers and the day laborers and the widows, would go on sitting by our smoky lamps.

That's not cynicism. That's experience.

My best friend, Baraka, didn't agree.

"You always think the worst of everyone," he said, as we walked home along the dark path, with the lake slapping softly at the shore.

"Your father owns a shop," I said. "You'll get it. Of course you think it'll be fair."

Baraka was quiet for a while.

"Maybe," he said. "But my father wants it to be fair. He said so."

"Everyone says so," I said.

Check your understanding

  1. Cause and effect Why is the kerosene lamp a problem for Achieng's family?

    1. It gives weak, flickering light that makes studying hard, and its smoke harms their lungs
    2. It is too bright to sleep near
    3. It uses too much electricity
    4. It attracts mosquitoes from the lake
  2. Key details How many households can the mini-grid power in its first year?

    1. All one hundred and forty
    2. Sixty, plus the school, the dispensary, and the water pump
    3. Only the chief's household
    4. Eighty
  3. Inference Achieng says, "That's not cynicism. That's experience." What does she mean?

    1. She doesn't know what cynicism means
    2. She believes her low expectations come from seeing unfairness her whole life, not just from being negative
    3. She thinks experience is useless
    4. She agrees with Baraka
  4. Character What is suggested about Achieng as a narrator in this chapter?

    1. She is completely neutral and objective
    2. She has strong expectations about how things will turn out, which may affect how she sees events
    3. She doesn't care about electricity
    4. She trusts the chief completely

Chapter 2: Baraka — Four Kinds of Fair

I'm Baraka, and Achieng asked me to tell this part, because she says I was there for the bits she wasn't, and because she says I'm "less biased," which I think is the closest she's ever come to a compliment.

The village held three more meetings about the electricity. I went to all of them with my father. By the end, I'd counted at least four completely different ideas of what was fair. Everyone was sure their idea was the right one, and everyone thought the others were selfish.

The first idea came from the company itself. Ms. Njeri explained that Jua Power had to pay back the money it had borrowed to build the mini-grid. To connect a house, there was a fee: a meter, the wiring, a few light bulbs, a socket. After that, people paid for power with their phones, a little at a time, like buying airtime. So one simple way to choose, she said, was first come, first served: the first sixty households to pay the connection fee would be connected first.

"That's fair," said Mr. Ochieng, who owned the biggest shop in the village and was the first to stand up. "Everyone has the same chance. Pay, and you get it."

But the fee was almost three thousand shillings. For my family, that was a lot, but possible. For Achieng's family, it was impossible. Achieng's mother earned maybe two hundred shillings on a good day at the fish market.

"It isn't the same chance," said Mama Akinyi, a widow who sold vegetables, standing up at the back. "If you have money, you have a chance. If you don't, you have nothing. That's not fairness. That's just the way things already are, written down on paper."

The second idea came from the old men, the elders. They said it should go by seniority: the oldest families, the ones who had lived in Kisima the longest, should go first. They had built the village. They deserved respect. Some of the younger families, especially the ones who'd moved here recently to fish, said this was just a way of keeping the power in the hands of a few old families, who happened to be the chief's relatives.

The third idea came from the schoolteacher, Mr. Odhiambo. He suggested a lottery. Put every household's name into a basket, and draw sixty. Everyone has an exactly equal chance. Nobody is favored for being rich or old or related to anyone. "It's the only way that's truly equal," he said.

Some people liked this. Others said it was foolish to leave something so important to luck. "What if the lottery picks the richest families anyway, who could buy solar lanterns themselves?" asked the nurse, Sister Mary. "And leaves out a family with a sick child who needs light at night?"

The fourth idea came from Sister Mary herself. She said the light should go first to those who needed it most. The families with babies, with sick or elderly members, with children in school. The poorest families, who were breathing kerosene smoke every night because they couldn't afford anything else. "Equality isn't the same as fairness," she said. "If you give everyone the same shoes, it doesn't help the person with no feet."

That started the loudest argument of all. Who decides who is "neediest"? Everybody had a reason to say they were. My father said that need was real but that it would be impossible to judge without people lying, or without the chief's friends being called "needy." Some people said that if only the poorest got light, the company would never get paid and the whole mini-grid would fail, and then nobody would get anything.

By the end of the third meeting, there was no agreement at all. Some people weren't speaking to each other. My father came home and sat on the step with his head in his hands.

"Every one of them is right about something," he said to me. "That's what makes it so hard. It's not right against wrong. It's right against right."

I told Achieng what he'd said. She was quiet for a while.

"Your father really said that?" she asked.

"Yes."

"Huh," she said. It was the first time I'd ever seen her look surprised.

Check your understanding

  1. Main idea What is this chapter mostly about?

    1. Baraka's father's shop
    2. The four different ideas of fairness the villagers propose for sharing the electricity, and why each has strengths and weaknesses
    3. How solar panels work
    4. The history of Kisima
  2. Vocabulary Sister Mary says, "If you give everyone the same shoes, it doesn't help the person with no feet." What is she arguing?

    1. Treating everyone identically does not always meet people's real, different needs, so equal is not always fair
    2. Everyone should get new shoes
    3. The lottery is the best method
    4. People without shoes should not get electricity
  3. Inference Why does Mama Akinyi say the payment method is "just the way things already are, written down on paper"?

    1. She thinks the company is honest
    2. Because choosing by ability to pay would simply repeat the existing inequality between rich and poor families
    3. Because she wants a written contract
    4. Because she prefers the lottery
  4. Character Why is Achieng surprised by what Baraka's father said?

    1. She expected a shop owner to argue only for his own advantage, but he recognized that every side was "right about something"
    2. She didn't know Baraka had a father
    3. She thought he would refuse to talk
    4. She thought he supported the elders

Chapter 3: Achieng — The Plan I Didn't Expect

I'm taking the story back now, because the next part is mine, and because I was wrong about something, and if I'm going to admit it I want to do it myself.

After the third meeting, the chief asked the schoolchildren to help.

I thought this was a trick. Ask the children, I thought, so the adults could blame someone else when it went badly. But Chief Owino, who is an old man with a deep voice who walks with a carved stick, said something at the school assembly that I've thought about many times since.

"The adults are too angry," he said. "Each family is thinking about itself. That's natural. But you children will live with this decision longer than any of us. Mr. Odhiambo tells me you've been studying fairness in your civics lessons. So: think about it, together, and bring us a plan. We'll listen."

Our class, Standard Eight, worked on it for two weeks. Baraka and I were in the same group, with two others, Fatuma and Kevin.

At first, we argued exactly like the adults. Kevin said the lottery was fairest. Fatuma said need. Baraka said the company had to get paid or it would all fall apart. I said I didn't trust any of it, because whoever decided would cheat.

Mr. Odhiambo let us argue for two days. Then he asked us one question.

"You've been arguing about the criteria," he said. "Who deserves priority. But what if," he went on, "the first question isn't which families? What if the first question is what does the whole village need most?"

We looked at each other.

And slowly, we started to build something.

The school, the dispensary, and the water pump were already getting power. That was good. But what if those places could do more? What if the school stayed open in the evenings, with bright lights, so that any child from any family could come and study? What if there was a charging station there, where anyone could charge a phone or a small solar lantern for a tiny fee? What if the dispensary could keep vaccines cold and the nurse could deliver babies at night with real light instead of a torch?

Then the light would reach every family in some way, even before it reached every house.

Then for the sixty household connections: we thought about all four ideas, and tried to take the best part of each.

We proposed that twenty of the connections go to households chosen by need: families with a newborn baby, someone sick, or someone very old, chosen by a committee that included Sister Mary, a teacher, and two people chosen by the whole village, not by the chief. And that the company give these families a subsidy, so they paid only a small part of the connection fee, with the rest paid back slowly or covered by a charity.

Twenty connections would be chosen by lottery, open to every household, so that everyone had a real, equal chance.

And twenty would go to families who could pay the full fee immediately, which would help the company cover its costs, so that it could raise the money to connect the other eighty households sooner.

Every household that didn't get connected in the first year would go to the top of the list for the second year.

When we finished writing it, I looked at it for a long time. I realized I'd stopped thinking about whether my own family would get the light. I'd started thinking about whether it would work.

"Baraka," I said. "If this happens, your family probably gets connected in the first group. Because your father can pay."

"I know."

"And my family might not get connected at all. Not this year."

"I know," he said. "Is that okay?"

I thought about my mother coughing by the lamp. About my little brothers. Then I thought about the school with its lights on at night, and the charging station, and the dispensary.

"I think it's fair," I said slowly. "I don't like it. But I think it's fair. Those aren't the same thing."

Check your understanding

  1. Sequence What did the students' group do right after Mr. Odhiambo asked his question?

    1. They gave up and asked the chief to decide
    2. They began to plan how the school, dispensary, and water pump could serve every family before designing the household connections
    3. They chose the lottery
    4. They went home
  2. Cause and effect Why did the students propose that some connections go to families who could pay the full fee?

    1. Because rich families deserve more
    2. So the company could cover its costs and raise money to connect the remaining households sooner
    3. Because the chief told them to
    4. Because Baraka wanted to be connected
  3. Character How has Achieng changed in this chapter?

    1. She has become more suspicious than ever
    2. She has moved from expecting unfairness and thinking about her own family to working on a plan that is fair to everyone, even if it doesn't benefit her
    3. She has decided she doesn't need electricity
    4. She has stopped being friends with Baraka
  4. Theme Achieng says, "I think it's fair. I don't like it... Those aren't the same thing." What does this show?

    1. A fair decision may still disappoint us personally, and recognizing fairness means looking beyond our own interests
    2. She thinks fairness is impossible
    3. She will try to change the plan secretly
    4. She doesn't understand the plan

Chapter 4: Both — The Night the Lights Came On

Baraka: The village voted on the children's plan at a meeting under the fig tree. It was not unanimous. Some of the elders grumbled that young people shouldn't be making decisions. Mr. Ochieng said the subsidy part sounded expensive. But in the end, most hands went up. Ms. Njeri said Jua Power would accept it, and that she would ask a charity she knew to help with the subsidies.

Then came the lottery. They did it in the school courtyard, in front of everyone, with every household's name written on a slip of paper and folded into a big woven basket. Chief Owino asked the youngest child in the village who could read, a six-year-old girl named Grace, to draw the names, so that nobody could say the adults had cheated.

My family had already been placed in the paying group. So I stood beside Achieng and listened to every name.

Achieng: They didn't call ours.

I want to be honest. Even after everything, even though I'd helped write the plan, I stood there with my fists clenched and listened to Grace read twenty names that weren't mine, and I felt a hot, sour feeling rising in my chest. Resentment, my teacher calls it. I wanted to shout that it wasn't fair. And then I remembered that I was the one who'd said a lottery was fair.

The needs committee met the next week. They chose twenty families: the ones with newborn babies, with old grandparents who were sick, with children who had asthma. Mama Akinyi, the widow who sold vegetables, was one of them, because her youngest son had been coughing for a year.

My family wasn't chosen. My mother isn't sick, and my brothers are healthy, and there were others who needed it more.

When I got home and told my mother, I expected her to be angry. She just nodded.

"Mama Akinyi's boy," she said. "Good. He needs it." Then she went back to scaling fish.

Baraka: The lights came on in July.

The whole village gathered at dusk at the school to watch the first switch thrown. When it happened, every bulb in every classroom blazed into light at once, and people gasped, and then cheered, and then some of the old women began to sing. Achieng's grandmother, who had said she'd believe it when she saw a light bulb, stood in the doorway of Standard Eight with her mouth open, staring at the ceiling.

"Well," she said finally. "There it is."

Achieng: The night study room opened the following week.

Every evening from six to nine, the Standard Eight classroom stays open with all its lights on, and any child in Kisima can come and study. Mr. Odhiambo and the other teachers take turns supervising. There's a charging station by the door, where my mother charges a solar lantern for ten shillings so that my brothers can do their homework at home.

I go every night. So does Baraka, though his house has lights now. He says it's because he likes the company. I think it's because he feels guilty. I've told him he doesn't need to. But I don't mind having him there.

Our house still doesn't have electricity. We're at the top of the list for next year. Ms. Njeri says the company has nearly raised the money.

Sometimes, walking home in the dark from the study room, I can see the lit windows of the houses that got connected, scattered along the shore like stars. I used to think that when the light came, I'd hate the people who got it first. I don't. Some of them are rich. Some of them are poor. Some of them are just lucky. Mama Akinyi's boy has stopped coughing.

I was sure, at the beginning, that I already knew how the story would end: the powerful would take everything, and the rest of us would get nothing. I was wrong. Not completely wrong. Fairness is hard, and some people did try to bend it toward themselves. But a whole village, arguing for months, managed to make something better than any one of us would have made alone.

That's the part I didn't expect. Not the light. The listening.

Check your understanding

  1. Cause and effect Why did Chief Owino ask a six-year-old to draw the lottery names?

    1. She was his granddaughter
    2. So no one could accuse the adults of cheating, which helped people trust the result
    3. Because she couldn't read
    4. Because she won the lottery
  2. Inference Why does Achieng admit she felt resentment even though she helped design the lottery?

    1. To show honestly that accepting a fair process doesn't stop personal disappointment, which makes her more believable as a narrator
    2. To show that the lottery was secretly rigged
    3. To blame Baraka
    4. To show she has changed her mind about fairness
  3. Key details How does the electricity help Achieng's family even though their home isn't connected?

    1. They secretly connect to Baraka's house
    2. Achieng studies at the lit night study room, and her mother charges a solar lantern at the school's charging station
    3. The company gives them a free generator
    4. They move to another village
  4. Theme Achieng ends, "Not the light. The listening." Which theme does this express?

    1. Electricity is the most important invention
    2. Fairness grows from a community willing to listen to many perspectives and balance different needs, not from any single simple rule
    3. Lotteries are the best way to make decisions
    4. Children should run villages

Spelling words

These 12 words all appear in the story.

  • electricity
  • kerosene
  • solar
  • priority
  • equality
  • lottery
  • generator
  • subsidy
  • dispensary
  • households
  • criteria
  • resentment

Writing prompt

The village of Kisima considered several ways to share the electricity: by ability to pay, by lottery, by need, and by what benefits everyone. Which method do you think is fairest, and why? Use evidence from the story, and explain one weakness of the method you choose.

Reading skills practiced

Cause and effect, Key details, Inference, Character, Main idea, Vocabulary, Sequence, Theme.

Answer key for grown-ups
  1. It gives weak, flickering light that makes studying hard, and its smoke harms their lungs She describes the dim light, the smoke, and the coughing.
  2. Sixty, plus the school, the dispensary, and the water pump Ms. Njeri explains that funding came up short.
  3. She believes her low expectations come from seeing unfairness her whole life, not just from being negative She has "seen it my whole life" that the rich and powerful are served first.
  4. She has strong expectations about how things will turn out, which may affect how she sees events She says she "already knew how it would turn out," which hints she may be prejudging.
  5. The four different ideas of fairness the villagers propose for sharing the electricity, and why each has strengths and weaknesses Paying first, seniority, lottery, and need are all debated.
  6. Treating everyone identically does not always meet people's real, different needs, so equal is not always fair She distinguishes equality from fairness.
  7. Because choosing by ability to pay would simply repeat the existing inequality between rich and poor families Families with money would get light; families without would not.
  8. She expected a shop owner to argue only for his own advantage, but he recognized that every side was "right about something" Her surprise suggests her assumptions about wealthy families might be wrong.
  9. They began to plan how the school, dispensary, and water pump could serve every family before designing the household connections Changing the question led them to think about shared needs first.
  10. So the company could cover its costs and raise money to connect the remaining households sooner Payments would help the whole mini-grid survive and expand.
  11. She has moved from expecting unfairness and thinking about her own family to working on a plan that is fair to everyone, even if it doesn't benefit her She says she stopped thinking about "whether my own family would get the light."
  12. A fair decision may still disappoint us personally, and recognizing fairness means looking beyond our own interests She accepts a fair plan even though it may leave her family waiting.
  13. So no one could accuse the adults of cheating, which helped people trust the result Using a young child made the lottery more trustworthy.
  14. To show honestly that accepting a fair process doesn't stop personal disappointment, which makes her more believable as a narrator She remembers that she herself said a lottery was fair.
  15. Achieng studies at the lit night study room, and her mother charges a solar lantern at the school's charging station Shared public lighting reached every family in some way.
  16. Fairness grows from a community willing to listen to many perspectives and balance different needs, not from any single simple rule The story values the long, shared process that produced a fairer plan.

More 5th grade stories

🧠

The Letter in My Handwriting

Ines Albuquerque notices small, strange gaps in her life: an empty hook by the back door, a worn path in the grass, the careful way her family speaks to her. Then she…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonSci-fi · Family16 questions
🧂

A Handful of Salt

In 1930, in the coastal village of Dandi in India, it is against British law for Kamala's family to make salt from the sea at their own doorstep. When word comes that…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonHistory · Justice16 questions
🚛

Forty Centimeters

For six weeks each winter, a road made of frozen lakes and packed snow connects Rae Beaulieu's remote Dene community to the rest of Canada, and her father drives the…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonNature · Exploration16 questions
🤖

The Detective's Assistant

Two days before the regional robotics championship, someone sabotages the Westfield Middle School robot, and Imani Clarke, the sharpest mind in the seventh grade, takes…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonMystery · Friends16 questions
🌲

What the Forest Lends

For three hundred years, the village of Hollin has lived beside the Thornwood under an ancient bargain with the forest's ancient guardian. But the new sawmill is…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonFantasy · Nature16 questions
🐈

The Lynx in Glen Arrin

Lynx have been extinct in Scotland for over a thousand years, until someone secretly releases two into the hills above Fi MacLeod's family sheep farm. When dead lambs…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonAnimals · Farm16 questions