📚 Reading Quest
🏃

The Unfair Advantage

Mateus Oliveira lost his lower left leg to cancer when he was seven, and now, at thirteen, he runs the 400 meters on a carbon-fiber blade, fast enough to reach the regional final. Then a rival's father files a protest claiming the blade gives him an unfair advantage. Told by Mateus and by the rival, Caleb, this is a story about what fairness in sport actually means.

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonSports · Justice2903 wordsAbout 30 minutes

Read it in the app 🚀

In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.

Words to know

prosthetic
an artificial body part, such as a leg or hand, that replaces one that is missing
biomechanics
the science of how bodies move, including the forces on muscles, bones, and joints
eligibility
being allowed to take part in something because you meet the rules
acceleration
the rate at which something speeds up
inclusion
making sure everyone can take part and is treated as belonging

Chapter 1: Mateus — The Blade

People always want to know what it feels like. Running on a blade, I mean. So I'll tell you first, and then we can get on with the story.

It feels like running on a spring. My blade is a long, curved strip of carbon fiber, shaped like the letter J lying on its side, attached to a socket that fits over what's left of my left leg below the knee. When I land on it, it bends. When I push off, it straightens and pushes me forward. It doesn't feel like a leg. It feels like a very good tool that I have learned to use with my whole body, the way a violinist learns a violin.

I lost my leg when I was seven. Bone cancer, and then an amputation. I'm fine now, and I don't really want to talk about that part, except to say that for about a year afterward I thought my life was over. I thought I'd never run again. Then a physical therapist named Rosana took me to a track and strapped a borrowed running blade onto my leg, and I fell over eleven times, and on the twelfth time I ran about twenty meters, wobbling, and something inside me that had been closed for a year opened up. Rosana told me afterward that the falling didn't matter. "Everyone falls," she said. "Runners are just people who persevere."

By thirteen, I was running the 400 meters for Ridgeview Middle School. One lap of the track, all-out. It's the hardest race in sprinting, my coach says, because it's too long to sprint the whole way and too short to pace. The last hundred meters, your legs fill with something that feels like wet cement, and the race becomes about who can keep their form while their body screams at them to stop.

That last hundred meters is where I'm strongest. On the start, I'm slow. Acceleration is my weakness. Getting out of the blocks is hard on a blade, because it's designed to bounce, not to push from a crouch. On the bend, I'm slow too, because the blade doesn't grip the curve the way a foot does, and I have to lean carefully or I'll skid. But on the final straight, when everyone else is tying up, my blade doesn't get tired. My right leg does. My lungs do. But the blade keeps springing the same way it did at the start.

I'm not the fastest kid in our league. But at the district meet in May, I ran 58.4 seconds and came second, which qualified me for the regional final. Only the top eight in the region make the final. I was seventh.

Two days after the district meet, my coach, Mr. Abernathy, called my parents.

A parent from another school had filed a formal protest with the league. The protest said that my prosthetic blade gave me an unfair advantage over other runners, that it was lighter and springier than a human leg, that it didn't get tired, and that I should be ruled ineligible to compete against non-disabled athletes. It questioned my eligibility for the whole season. It asked the league to remove me from the regional final.

The parent's name was Richard Novak. His son, Caleb, had come ninth at the district meet. One place out of the final.

If I was removed, Caleb would take my place.

I remember sitting at the kitchen table while my mother read the letter out loud, in a very calm voice that meant she was furious. I remember my father leaving the room and coming back and leaving again. And I remember a strange, cold feeling in my stomach that wasn't quite anger. It was more like being told that the thing I'd worked hardest for in my whole life was something I'd been given. Something unfair. Something I hadn't earned.

"An unfair advantage," I said. "He thinks losing a leg is an advantage."

My mother put the letter down.

"He doesn't think that," she said. "He thinks the blade is. That's different. And we're going to have to answer him properly. Not with anger. With facts."

Check your understanding

  1. Vocabulary Mateus says running on a blade feels like using "a very good tool that I have learned to use with my whole body, the way a violinist learns a violin." What is he emphasizing?

    1. That blades are musical instruments
    2. That running on a blade requires years of skill and practice, not just the equipment itself
    3. That he prefers music to running
    4. That the blade does the work for him
  2. Key details Where in the race does Mateus say he is weakest?

    1. At the start out of the blocks and on the curve of the bend
    2. On the final straight
    3. In the middle of the race only
    4. He is equally strong everywhere
  3. Inference Why does Mr. Novak's protest feel so painful to Mateus?

    1. He is afraid of Mr. Novak
    2. It suggests that his hard-earned achievement was given to him by his equipment rather than earned through his own effort
    3. He didn't want to run in the final anyway
    4. He thinks Caleb is faster
  4. Character What does Mateus's mother's response show about her?

    1. She is ready to fight Mr. Novak in anger
    2. She is upset but determined to respond thoughtfully, separating the real claim from an insult and answering with evidence
    3. She agrees with Mr. Novak
    4. She wants Mateus to quit running

Chapter 2: Caleb — My Father's Letter

I didn't know my dad was going to send the letter. I want that on the record. I found out the same way everyone else did, when Coach Morales called me into his office and asked me if I knew anything about it.

I came ninth at districts. 58.9 seconds. Half a second behind Mateus Oliveira. My dad was standing at the fence the whole race, shouting, and when the results went up and I was one place out of the regional final, he didn't say anything to me at all on the drive home. He just gripped the steering wheel. I knew what that meant. He'd run the 400 in high school. He'd been really good. He'd had a scholarship to college, and then he hurt his knee in his first year and never ran again. He talks about it a lot, and also never.

That night, I heard him on the computer for hours, reading things. Articles about blade runners. Science studies. A famous case, years ago, of a runner with two prosthetic legs who wanted to run in the Olympics, and how some scientists said his blades gave him an advantage and others said they didn't. A study that said blades used less energy than human legs. Another study that said that wasn't the whole story.

The next morning, he'd sent the protest.

"It's not personal," he told me, when I asked him about it. "I've got nothing against the kid. It's about the rules. A race is supposed to be the same for everyone. Same distance, same track, same rules. If one runner has a piece of equipment that gives him a mechanical advantage, then it's not the same race. You'd never let someone run with springs in their shoes."

"His leg isn't a shoe, Dad."

"No," said my dad. "But his blade is equipment. And there are rules about equipment for a reason."

I didn't know what to say to that. Part of me thought he was right. That was the worst thing about it. I'd watched Mateus's last hundred meters at districts. He came past three of us on the straight, including me, and his stride didn't change at all while the rest of us were falling apart. I'd thought, How is he doing that? I'd thought it more than once. And I'd hated myself a little bit for thinking it, because I knew what he'd been through.

But another part of me kept thinking about the start. I'd been in the lane next to his. I'd seen him come out of the blocks. He was slow. Way slower than me. He'd had to fight to catch up on the bend, leaning so carefully I thought he'd fall. Whatever advantage the blade gave him on the straight, it was taking something away at the start.

So was it an advantage or not? I honestly didn't know. And I didn't think my dad really knew either. I think he just knew I'd come ninth, and that he'd never got to run again after his knee, and that he couldn't stand to see me lose a place I might have had.

At school the next day, everybody knew. Somebody had posted about it online. Half the comments said my dad was a monster. The other half said Mateus was a cheater. Nobody said anything that sounded like they'd actually thought about it.

I went to find Mateus at lunch. I didn't know what I was going to say. I just felt like I had to say something.

He was sitting by himself on the bleachers, eating a sandwich and staring at the track. He saw me coming and his face went completely still.

"Did you know?" he asked.

"No," I said. "I swear. I didn't know until yesterday."

He looked at me for a long moment. Then he moved his bag off the bench, which I figured was an invitation, so I sat down.

"Do you think I have an advantage?" he asked.

I thought about lying. I didn't.

"I don't know," I said. "Honestly. On the straight, maybe. At the start, definitely not. I don't think anyone knows. Not even my dad."

Mateus was quiet. Then, to my surprise, he nodded.

"That's the first honest thing anyone's said to me about it," he said.

Check your understanding

  1. Inference Why does the author switch to Caleb's point of view in this chapter?

    1. To show that the protest is not simply cruel, and to reveal the real motives and doubts on the other side
    2. To prove that Caleb is the villain
    3. To explain how to run the 400 meters
    4. Because Mateus has quit the team
  2. Cause and effect According to Caleb, what may be the deeper reason his father sent the protest?

    1. He dislikes Mateus personally
    2. His own running career ended with an injury, and he couldn't bear to see Caleb miss a place he might have had
    3. He was paid by another school
    4. He wanted to change the rules for everyone
  3. Key details What evidence does Caleb notice that complicates the claim of an advantage?

    1. Mateus's blade is broken
    2. Mateus is much slower out of the blocks and on the bend, even if he is strong on the final straight
    3. Mateus has a faster pair of shoes
    4. Mateus trains less than everyone else
  4. Inference Why does Mateus call Caleb's answer "the first honest thing anyone's said to me about it"?

    1. Because Caleb agrees that Mateus has no advantage
    2. Because Caleb apologizes for his father
    3. Because Caleb admits uncertainty instead of choosing a side without thinking, unlike the people commenting online
    4. Because Caleb offers to give up his place

Chapter 3: Mateus — The Hearing

The league held a hearing in the school library on a Thursday evening, a week before the regional final. There were three people on the panel: the league director, a retired track coach, and a sports doctor from the university who studied biomechanics, Dr. Lindqvist.

My parents came, and Mr. Abernathy, and Rosana, my old physical therapist, who drove two hours to be there. Mr. Novak came, in a suit, with a folder. Caleb came too, and sat at the very back, on his own.

Mr. Novak spoke first. He was calm and polite, and that made it worse, somehow. He said he had nothing but respect for me as a person. He read from scientific studies. He said blades were lighter than human lower legs, so they could be swung forward faster. He said they returned energy like a spring without getting tired. He said that the rules of track and field were meant to make sure the race tested the runner, not the equipment. "I'm not asking for Mateus to be banned from running," he said. "I'm asking for him to compete in a category for athletes with prosthetics, as happens at higher levels. Where it's fair for everyone."

That was the part I hadn't expected. It sounded reasonable. I could see the panel nodding.

Then it was my turn.

My mother had wanted to speak for me. I'd asked her not to. I'd spent a week reading everything I could find, with Rosana's help. I stood up with my notes shaking in my hand.

"There is no category for athletes with prosthetics in our league," I said. "There isn't one in the region either. Mr. Novak is right that there are separate events at the very highest levels, like the Paralympics. But this is middle school. If I'm put in a separate category, I'll be the only person in it. I'll be running alone." My voice wobbled. I made it stop. "That's not a fair race. That's no race at all."

I held up a page of my notes.

"Mr. Novak said the blade is lighter and springier, and that's true. But the scientists don't agree on whether that adds up to an advantage overall. Some studies say blades help on the straight. Others say they hurt at the start, on bends, and in wind. My 100-meter split times at districts were among the slowest in the race. My last 100 was the fastest. Coach Abernathy has the timing data." I took a breath. "If the blade made everything easier, why would I be slowest at the start?"

Then I said the thing I'd been practicing in front of the mirror all week.

"Every runner in that final has something different. Some are taller, with longer legs. Some have more expensive spikes. Some have coaches who used to run in college. Some have parents who can pay for summer training camps. Nobody says those are unfair, because they're normal differences. I'm asking you to treat my difference the same way. Not to ignore it. Just to measure it, before deciding it's an advantage."

I sat down. My legs, the real one and the other one, were both shaking.

Then Dr. Lindqvist asked if she could say something. She said that the honest scientific answer was that nobody fully knew, and that it depended very much on the specific blade, the specific runner, and the specific race. She said that the 400 meters with a below-knee blade was one of the least studied cases. And she said that at the level of youth sport, she thought the purpose of the competition mattered.

"At the Olympic level," she said, "we're trying to find out who is the very fastest human being on Earth. Every fraction of a second matters, and strict rules make sense. But this is a middle-school league. Its purpose, as I understand it, is to give young people a chance to compete, improve, and belong. If we have to choose between perfect precision and inclusion, I think at this level we should lean toward inclusion, and keep studying."

The panel went into a back room to talk. They were gone for forty minutes.

Check your understanding

  1. Main idea What is the main point of Mateus's argument at the hearing?

    1. Blades are never an advantage
    2. A separate category would leave him racing alone, the science is uncertain, and his difference should be measured like other differences before being called unfair
    3. Mr. Novak should be banned from the league
    4. The race should be shortened
  2. Vocabulary Dr. Lindqvist says that at the youth level, the league should "lean toward inclusion." What does she mean?

    1. When the evidence is uncertain, the league should prioritize letting young athletes take part and belong
    2. Every runner should get a medal
    3. Only disabled athletes should compete
    4. The rules should be ignored entirely
  3. Inference Why does Mateus find Mr. Novak's calm, polite speech "worse, somehow"?

    1. Because Mr. Novak is lying
    2. Because a reasonable-sounding argument is harder to dismiss and makes the panel more likely to agree with it
    3. Because he wanted Mr. Novak to shout
    4. Because he couldn't hear it
  4. Cause and effect What evidence does Mateus use to question whether the blade is an overall advantage?

    1. His doctor's notes from when he was seven
    2. A video of Caleb's race
    3. Timing data showing his starts were among the slowest and only his final 100 meters was the fastest
    4. A letter from the Olympic committee

Chapter 4: Caleb — Lane Five

The panel ruled that Mateus could run.

They said the evidence of an overall advantage was not strong enough to remove him, and that the purpose of the league was to include young athletes. They also said the league would work with Dr. Lindqvist's university to study the question properly over the next year, and write clear regulations about prosthetics, so that no family would have to go through a hearing like this again. Nobody got everything they wanted. My dad didn't. Mateus didn't, either. He'd wanted them to say there was no advantage at all.

I thought that was the end of it for me. I'd come ninth. I wasn't in the final.

Then, on the Monday before the race, the runner who'd come third at districts, a boy from Lakeside named Devon, sprained his ankle playing basketball and had to withdraw.

The ninth-place runner moved up.

So I was in the final after all. In lane five. And Mateus was in lane six, right next to me.

My dad didn't know what to do with his face when he heard. I think he was relieved, and embarrassed, and something else I couldn't name. That night, he knocked on my door.

"I owe that kid an apology," he said. "And maybe you, too."

"For the protest?"

He sat on the end of my bed. "Not exactly. I still think the question is real. I'm glad they're going to study it." He rubbed his knee, the one he'd hurt in college. "But I didn't do it because of the question. I did it because I wanted you in that final so badly I couldn't see straight. And I told myself it was about fairness. That's the part I'm ashamed of."

At the regional final, it was hot and windy, and the stands were full.

I won't describe the whole race. I'll just tell you about the last hundred meters, because that's where everything happens in the 400.

Mateus was slow out of the blocks, the way he always was. I was out fast. On the bend, I was ahead of him by two meters, maybe three. Then we came off the curve into the final straight with a hard wind blowing in our faces, and my legs filled up with the wet cement, and I heard him coming.

I didn't look. You never look. But I could hear him, the rhythm of his feet, one soft and one with a sharp click of carbon on the track, getting closer. With fifty meters to go he was level with my shoulder. With twenty to go he was ahead of me.

And then, three meters from the line, I dipped my chest the way my dad had taught me when I was eight, and I don't know how, but I got there first. By two hundredths of a second.

Neither of us won. A boy from Westbrook won, by a mile. Five runners finished ahead of both of us. I came sixth. Mateus came seventh.

But it was the best race I've ever run.

We both collapsed on the infield afterward, lying on our backs on the grass, unable to speak, gasping at the sky. After a while, Mateus held out his fist without looking at me, and I bumped it.

"I thought I had you," he said, when he could breathe.

"You almost did."

"Your dad's in the stands."

"Yeah."

"Is he going to file another protest?" he said. "Because you beat me, and you have two legs, and that's clearly an unfair advantage."

I started laughing so hard that it hurt, lying there on the grass. After a second, so did he.

My dad came down to the infield after the medals were given out. He went straight past me to Mateus and his parents. I watched him hold out his hand. I couldn't hear what he said. But I saw Mateus's mother's face soften, very slightly. And I saw Mateus shake my dad's hand, and nod.

Later, on the drive home, my dad was quiet for a long time.

"He beat everyone on the straight," he said finally. "In a headwind. Who's ever going to know how much of that was the blade and how much of it was him?"

"Maybe that's the point," I said. "You can't really pull them apart. The same way you can't pull my legs apart from all the training. It's all just him."

My dad thought about that for a long time. He didn't say I was right. But at the next league meeting, he volunteered to help write the new rules. He said he wanted them to be fair to every kid who might someday need them. Including ones who hadn't been born yet.

Check your understanding

  1. Sequence What chain of events put Caleb in the regional final after all?

    1. The panel removed Mateus
    2. The third-place runner sprained his ankle and withdrew, so the ninth-place runner moved up
    3. His father paid for an extra lane
    4. Mateus gave him his place
  2. Character What does Caleb's father admit he is ashamed of?

    1. Asking a scientific question about blades
    2. Pretending his protest was about fairness when it was really driven by wanting Caleb in the final
    3. Running in high school
    4. Coming to the race
  3. Inference Why is Mateus's joke about filing a protest because Caleb "has two legs" meaningful?

    1. It turns the idea of "unfair advantage" upside down, showing that every runner has differences and that the boys have moved past the conflict
    2. It shows Mateus is still angry
    3. It proves Caleb cheated
    4. It means Mateus wants to quit
  4. Theme Which theme is developed across the whole story?

    1. Rules in sport should never change
    2. Disabled athletes should always compete separately
    3. Fairness in sport is complicated and requires honest evidence, empathy, and attention to the purpose of competition, not just treating everyone identically
    4. Winning is the only thing that matters in sport

Spelling words

These 12 words all appear in the story.

  • prosthetic
  • amputation
  • carbon
  • protest
  • advantage
  • regulations
  • inclusion
  • acceleration
  • biomechanics
  • eligibility
  • compete
  • persevere

Writing prompt

Is it fair for a runner with a prosthetic blade to race against runners without one? Write an argument using evidence from the story. Consider the science, the purpose of school sports, and what "fair" should mean. Explain how you would decide cases like this one.

Reading skills practiced

Vocabulary, Key details, Inference, Character, Cause and effect, Main idea, Sequence, Theme.

Answer key for grown-ups
  1. That running on a blade requires years of skill and practice, not just the equipment itself The comparison shows that the blade is useless without the athlete's trained skill.
  2. At the start out of the blocks and on the curve of the bend The blade is designed to bounce, not push from a crouch, and doesn't grip the curve well.
  3. It suggests that his hard-earned achievement was given to him by his equipment rather than earned through his own effort He feels he is being told his success was "something I hadn't earned."
  4. She is upset but determined to respond thoughtfully, separating the real claim from an insult and answering with evidence She says, "Not with anger. With facts."
  5. To show that the protest is not simply cruel, and to reveal the real motives and doubts on the other side Caleb's chapter shows his father's history and his own honest uncertainty.
  6. His own running career ended with an injury, and he couldn't bear to see Caleb miss a place he might have had Caleb thinks his father "couldn't stand to see me lose a place I might have had."
  7. Mateus is much slower out of the blocks and on the bend, even if he is strong on the final straight He saw Mateus "fight to catch up on the bend."
  8. Because Caleb admits uncertainty instead of choosing a side without thinking, unlike the people commenting online Caleb says "I don't know," which is more truthful than the confident online comments.
  9. A separate category would leave him racing alone, the science is uncertain, and his difference should be measured like other differences before being called unfair He uses timing data and comparisons to other differences between runners.
  10. When the evidence is uncertain, the league should prioritize letting young athletes take part and belong She contrasts "perfect precision" at the Olympics with the purpose of youth sport.
  11. Because a reasonable-sounding argument is harder to dismiss and makes the panel more likely to agree with it He notices the panel nodding at points that sounded fair.
  12. Timing data showing his starts were among the slowest and only his final 100 meters was the fastest He asks, "If the blade made everything easier, why would I be slowest at the start?"
  13. The third-place runner sprained his ankle and withdrew, so the ninth-place runner moved up Devon's injury opened a spot for Caleb.
  14. Pretending his protest was about fairness when it was really driven by wanting Caleb in the final He says, "I told myself it was about fairness. That's the part I'm ashamed of."
  15. It turns the idea of "unfair advantage" upside down, showing that every runner has differences and that the boys have moved past the conflict The humor reveals both the absurdity of the label and their new respect.
  16. Fairness in sport is complicated and requires honest evidence, empathy, and attention to the purpose of competition, not just treating everyone identically From both narrators' doubts to the hearing and the race, the story shows that "fair" is not the same as "identical."

More 5th grade stories

🧠

The Letter in My Handwriting

Ines Albuquerque notices small, strange gaps in her life: an empty hook by the back door, a worn path in the grass, the careful way her family speaks to her. Then she…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonSci-fi · Family16 questions
🧂

A Handful of Salt

In 1930, in the coastal village of Dandi in India, it is against British law for Kamala's family to make salt from the sea at their own doorstep. When word comes that…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonHistory · Justice16 questions
🚛

Forty Centimeters

For six weeks each winter, a road made of frozen lakes and packed snow connects Rae Beaulieu's remote Dene community to the rest of Canada, and her father drives the…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonNature · Exploration16 questions
🤖

The Detective's Assistant

Two days before the regional robotics championship, someone sabotages the Westfield Middle School robot, and Imani Clarke, the sharpest mind in the seventh grade, takes…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonMystery · Friends16 questions
🌲

What the Forest Lends

For three hundred years, the village of Hollin has lived beside the Thornwood under an ancient bargain with the forest's ancient guardian. But the new sawmill is…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonFantasy · Nature16 questions
🐈

The Lynx in Glen Arrin

Lynx have been extinct in Scotland for over a thousand years, until someone secretly releases two into the hills above Fi MacLeod's family sheep farm. When dead lambs…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonAnimals · Farm16 questions