The Forest Under the Waves
Mia Tanaka's grandfather was once the best abalone diver on the California coast, and he still grumbles every time he sees a sea otter. But when Mia joins a project to save the dying kelp forest in their cove, she discovers that her grandfather's story about the otters has a missing piece, and that he has been carrying it for fifty years.
4th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonOcean · Family · Nature2211 wordsAbout 30 minutes
In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.
Words to know
- kelp
- a very large brown seaweed that grows in tall underwater forests
- abalone
- a sea snail with a flat shell that is shiny like a rainbow on the inside
- predator
- an animal that hunts and eats other animals
- ecosystem
- all the living things in one place and the ways they depend on each other
- barren
- empty, with almost nothing able to grow
Chapter 1: Mia
My grandfather says sea otters are thieves with fur coats.
He says it every time we walk along the cliffs above Pelican Cove and see them floating on their backs in the water, cracking shells on their bellies with rocks. He says it the way some people talk about the weather, without even really thinking.
"Look at that one," he'll grumble. "Eating like a king. In my day, that abalone would have been on somebody's dinner plate."
My grandfather, Hiro Tanaka, was an abalone diver for thirty years. When he was young, he dove off the rocky California coast with a heavy suit and a tank of air, prying abalone off the rocks with a flat iron bar. Abalone are big sea snails with flat, oval shells. On the outside the shells are rough and brown, but on the inside they shine like rainbows poured into a bowl, pink and green and silver and blue. Grandpa has one on his windowsill. When the sun hits it, the whole kitchen glows.
Back then, he says, there were so many abalone that you could fill a boat in a morning. Restaurants in San Francisco paid a lot for them. He bought his house with abalone money. He sent my dad to college with abalone money.
Then the abalone began to disappear. And Grandpa blamed the otters.
I am eleven, and I don't know very much about the 1970s, but I know about otters. I know that sea otters have the thickest fur of any animal on Earth, about a million hairs in a space the size of a postage stamp, because they don't have blubber like seals do. I know they hold hands while they sleep, so they don't drift apart. And I know that a hundred years ago, they were hunted for their fur until almost all of them were gone, and that they were protected by law just in time.
This summer, my science teacher, Ms. Delgado, signed our class up for a project at the marine lab in town. Our job was to help count the creatures in the kelp forest in Pelican Cove.
A kelp forest is exactly what it sounds like, except underwater. Kelp is a giant brown seaweed that grows from the rocky seafloor all the way up to the surface, sometimes thirty meters tall. It can grow half a meter in a single day. The long stalks sway together in the waves, and sunlight comes down through them in green-gold beams, just like sunlight in a real forest. Hundreds of kinds of fish and crabs and sea stars live among the stalks.
At least, that's how it's supposed to look.
On the first day, the scientist from the lab, Dr. Okafor, showed us a photograph of Pelican Cove from twenty years ago: a thick, golden-brown forest, so dense you couldn't see the bottom. Then she showed us a photograph from this spring.
The kelp was almost gone. The seafloor was bare gray rock, covered with hundreds and hundreds of spiny purple balls.
"Sea urchins," Dr. Okafor said. "They're eating the forest."
Check your understanding
Key details What did Grandpa Hiro do for a living?
- He was a fisherman who caught tuna
- He worked at the marine lab
- He was an abalone diver who pried abalone off rocks underwater
- He sold sea otter fur
Vocabulary "Kelp is a giant brown seaweed that grows from the rocky seafloor all the way up to the surface." Why is a group of kelp called a forest?
- Because trees grow under the water
- Because the tall kelp grows close together like trees, with light shining down between the stalks, and many creatures live in it
- Because it is green
- Because it grows on land near the ocean
Inference Why does Grandpa grumble that the otter is "eating like a king"?
- He thinks otters should eat less to be healthy
- He resents the otters because he believes they took the abalone that used to be his livelihood
- He is joking and actually loves otters
- He thinks otters should only eat fish
Main idea What problem do the two photographs show?
- The kelp forest in Pelican Cove has almost disappeared and been replaced by bare rock covered with sea urchins
- The cove has more kelp than ever
- The otters are eating all the fish
- The cove has been polluted with oil
Chapter 2: Hiro
Mia came home from the marine lab with a clipboard and a lot of questions. That's how it started.
"Grandpa," she said, sitting down at my kitchen table. "Did you know that sea urchins can eat a whole kelp forest? Dr. Okafor says that when there are too many urchins, they chew through the bottom of the kelp stalks, and the kelp floats away. Then nothing else can live there. It's called an urchin barren."
"Of course I know about urchins," I said. "I've seen more urchins than you've seen breakfasts."
"But do you know what eats urchins?"
I didn't answer. I knew. I had known for a long time.
When I was young, in 1975, the abalone divers along this coast were angry. The sea otters were coming back. They had been hunted almost to extinction a hundred years before, but a small group had survived, and now, protected by law, they were slowly spreading south along the coast, cove by cove. And wherever they arrived, the abalone vanished. An otter eats a quarter of its own weight in food every single day. Abalone. Crabs. Clams.
And urchins.
We divers had a meeting at the harbor one night. Forty men, smoking and shouting. We said the otters were destroying our living. We said something should be done. Some men said things that were worse than that. We wrote letters to the government. We asked that the otters be stopped, moved, kept away from our coves.
I signed the letter. I was twenty-six. I had a new baby, Mia's father, and a house to pay for, and I was scared.
The otters stayed anyway, because the law protected them. But in Pelican Cove, the otters never really settled. Something kept them away. There were rumors about why. Some fishermen chased them off with boats. Some did worse. I never did anything like that, but I didn't stop anyone either. I didn't say a word. Within a few years, the otters in Pelican Cove were gone.
And for a while, it seemed like we'd won. There were fewer abalone than in the old days, but we could still dive.
Then, slowly, so slowly that I didn't notice for years, the urchins came.
Without otters to eat them, the purple urchins multiplied. They spread across the rocks like a carpet. They ate the kelp. The kelp forest grew thinner every year. Then the abalone, which also eat kelp, began to starve. By the 1990s, there were hardly any abalone left in Pelican Cove at all. Not because of the otters. Because of the urchins. Because the otters weren't there.
I understood this a long time ago. I have never told anyone. Not my wife, before she died. Not my son. It's easier to grumble about thieves with fur coats than to say: I was wrong, and I helped break something that I loved.
"Grandpa?" Mia said. "Do you know what eats urchins?"
I looked at the abalone shell on the windowsill, shining in the afternoon sun.
"Otters," I said quietly.
Check your understanding
Cause and effect According to Grandpa's flashback, what happened after the otters disappeared from Pelican Cove?
- The kelp forest grew thicker
- The urchins multiplied and ate the kelp, and then the abalone starved
- The abalone came back in huge numbers
- The fishermen moved away
Sequence Which happened FIRST in Grandpa's story?
- The divers met at the harbor and signed a letter against the otters
- The urchins covered the rocks
- The abalone began to starve
- Mia asked Grandpa what eats urchins
Character Why has Grandpa kept grumbling about otters for so many years, even though he knew the truth?
- He has forgotten what happened
- He truly still believes otters are the problem
- It is easier to blame the otters than to admit he was wrong and helped damage something he loved
- He wants Mia to dislike otters
Inference Why does Grandpa look at the abalone shell on the windowsill before answering Mia?
- He wants to clean it
- The shell reminds him of the life he loved and lost, and of his part in losing it
- He wants to show it to Mia
- He is checking the time by the sunlight
Chapter 3: Mia
Grandpa didn't say much after that. But the next Saturday, when Dr. Okafor's team took our class out on the boat to Pelican Cove, Grandpa came too.
I was surprised. He said he just wanted to see the boat. But he stood at the rail the whole way out, looking down at the water with a face I couldn't read.
Our job that day was urchin culling. The lab had permission to clear the purple urchins from one small patch of the cove, to see if the kelp would grow back. Divers would go down with hammers and crush the urchins, while those of us on the boat sorted the ones they brought up and counted them.
Dr. Okafor explained that urchins aren't bad. In a healthy kelp forest, they hide in cracks and eat bits of kelp that drift by, and they're an important part of the ecosystem. The problem is balance. When the otters are gone, there's no predator to keep the urchins in check. They come out of hiding, and they eat everything. Even when the kelp is gone, they don't die. They just get hungry and wait. An urchin barren can last for decades.
"So cutting down the urchins is like weeding a garden," I said.
"Exactly," she said. "Except the garden is underwater, the weeds have spikes, and there are about a million of them."
The divers went down. I watched their bubbles. Grandpa watched too, his hands gripping the rail so tightly that his knuckles were white.
"Grandpa," I said. "Do you miss it? Diving?"
He was quiet for a long moment. "Every day," he said.
Then he did something I'll never forget. He went over to Dr. Okafor and said, in his gruff voice, "Do you have a spare suit? I've got a diving license. Forty years old, but I've got it."
Dr. Okafor raised her eyebrows. "You know you'd need a medical check first, Mr. Tanaka. And a refresher course."
"Then I'll do the medical check," said Grandpa. "And the refresher course. However long it takes."
I stared at him. He was seventy-five years old. His knees cracked when he stood up.
That night, at his kitchen table, he told me everything. The meeting at the harbor. The letter. The men who chased the otters with their boats, and how he had said nothing. He told it all in a flat, quiet voice, staring at the abalone shell.
When he finished, I didn't know what to say. I had always thought of my grandfather as someone who was always right. It felt strange, seeing him like this. Strange and sad, but also, somehow, it made me love him more.
"You were scared," I said finally. "You had a baby. You didn't know."
"I knew enough," he said. "Later, I knew everything, and I still didn't say anything." He turned the shell over in his hands. "That's the part I'm most ashamed of. Not the mistake. The silence."
Check your understanding
Vocabulary Dr. Okafor says, "The problem is balance." What does "balance" mean in this ecosystem?
- Standing on one foot on the boat
- A healthy situation where predators and prey keep each other's numbers in check, so nothing takes over
- Having the same number of every animal
- Keeping the boat level in the waves
Inference Why do Grandpa's knuckles turn white as he grips the rail?
- He is seasick
- He is cold
- He is feeling strong emotions: longing to dive again and guilt about the damaged cove
- He is trying to keep from falling overboard in a storm
Character How does Mia's feeling about her grandfather change after hearing his story?
- She becomes angry and stops visiting him
- She sees that he isn't always right, which is sad, but she loves him even more for being honest
- She decides he is a bad person
- She doesn't believe his story
Theme Grandpa says the part he is most ashamed of is "not the mistake. The silence." What does he mean?
- He wishes he had talked more at the meeting
- Everyone makes mistakes, but knowing the truth and never speaking up or trying to fix it was worse
- He thinks being quiet is always wrong
- He was ashamed of being shy
Chapter 4: Hiro
It took me four months. A doctor listened to my heart and frowned and listened again and finally said yes. A young instructor half my height taught me how modern scuba gear worked, and laughed at me when I tried to clear my mask the old way. My knees hurt. My lungs burned. Some nights I wondered if I was a foolish old man.
But in November, I went down into Pelican Cove again for the first time in thirty years.
The water was cold and green, and the moment it closed over my head, I felt it: the old silence, the old weightlessness, the old feeling of the ocean holding you like a hand. I had missed it more than I'd known.
Then I looked at the bottom, and my heart sank. Where the great forest had been, there was only gray rock and purple spines, mile after mile. It looked like the surface of the moon. I remembered swimming here as a young man through kelp so thick I had to push it aside like curtains. I remembered the abalone, the orange fish, the sea stars as big as dinner plates.
For a moment, floating there above the barren, I felt more guilty than I had ever felt on land. Up there, it had been easy to forget. Down here, the empty rock was like a page with my own name written on it.
I picked up my hammer and went to work.
I worked with the lab's divers every Saturday that winter. The younger divers called me "Grandpa Urchin" and teased me about my old-fashioned hand signals, but they always made sure I had the warmest spot on the boat, and one of them, a quiet young woman named Rosa, began asking me where the best abalone rocks used to be. I drew her maps from memory on paper napkins. Someday, if the forest came back, the abalone might come back too, and someone should know where they belonged. I crushed urchins until my arms shook. Mia worked on the boat, counting and sorting and writing everything down on her clipboard.
And slowly, in the small cleared patch, something began to happen.
In February, Mia spotted it first, in an underwater photograph. A small brown shoot, no taller than her hand, growing out of a crack in the rock. Then another. By April there were dozens. By June, the young kelp had reached the surface, and the sunlight came down through it in green-gold beams, just like before.
Fish came back. Crabs came back. Sea stars came back. Dr. Okafor said it was the fastest recovery she had ever seen.
But the best thing happened in August.
Mia and I were walking along the cliffs above the cove, the way we always do. And down below, floating on her back in the new kelp, wrapped in a long brown strand of it so she wouldn't drift away, was a sea otter. She was cracking a purple urchin on her belly with a rock. On her chest, a tiny fuzzy pup was sleeping.
Mia grabbed my arm. Neither of us said anything for a long time.
"She'll eat a lot of urchins," Mia said finally.
"She'll eat everything," I said. "Abalone too. Clams. Crabs. Everything." I paused. "Good."
Mia looked up at me, and I knew she was waiting to see if I would say it. Thieves with fur coats. Fifty years of saying it is a long habit.
"She's not a thief," I said. "She's the forest's gardener. We just didn't understand that. I didn't want to." I watched the pup wriggle on its mother's chest. "I was wrong, Mia. I'm saying it out loud now, because you should always say it out loud."
That fall, I gave my abalone shell to the marine lab. They put it in a glass case by the front door, with a small card that tells the whole story of Pelican Cove, the otters and the urchins and the kelp, and one old diver who was wrong for a long time.
Mia wrote the card. I asked her not to leave anything out.
Check your understanding
Main idea What is the main event of Chapter 4?
- Grandpa decides to sell his house
- Grandpa returns to diving, helps clear the urchins, and the kelp forest begins to grow back, bringing the otters home
- Mia becomes a scientist
- The lab closes the urchin project
Cause and effect Why did the kelp start growing back in the small patch?
- The water got warmer
- Scientists planted new kelp seeds
- The divers removed the urchins that were eating the young kelp
- The otters cleared the urchins first
Inference Why does Grandpa say "Good" after listing everything the otter will eat?
- He now understands that the otter's eating, especially the urchins, keeps the whole forest healthy, even if it means fewer abalone for people
- He is being sarcastic and still dislikes otters
- He wants the abalone to disappear
- He is glad the otter won't be hungry
Theme Grandpa gives his shell to the lab and asks Mia "not to leave anything out" of the card. What theme does this show?
- People should collect shells
- Old divers should stop diving
- Admitting the whole truth about our mistakes, openly, helps us and others learn and repair the damage
- Museums are the best place for family treasures
Spelling words
These 12 words all appear in the story.
- kelp
- urchins
- otters
- abalone
- underwater
- balance
- predator
- scuba
- harbor
- forest
- guilty
- ecosystem
Writing prompt
Grandpa Hiro believed for many years that sea otters were the enemy, but he learned he was wrong. Explain how the otters, the urchins and the kelp are connected, using details from the story. Then write about why it can be hard for people to change their minds, and what helped Grandpa change his.
Reading skills practiced
Key details, Vocabulary, Inference, Main idea, Cause and effect, Sequence, Character, Theme.
Answer key for grown-ups
- He was an abalone diver who pried abalone off rocks underwater He dove for thirty years and bought his house with abalone money.
- Because the tall kelp grows close together like trees, with light shining down between the stalks, and many creatures live in it Mia compares it to a real forest with sunlight in "green-gold beams."
- He resents the otters because he believes they took the abalone that used to be his livelihood He says the abalone "would have been on somebody's dinner plate."
- The kelp forest in Pelican Cove has almost disappeared and been replaced by bare rock covered with sea urchins Twenty years ago the forest was thick; now it is bare and full of urchins.
- The urchins multiplied and ate the kelp, and then the abalone starved Without a predator, the urchins took over and destroyed the forest.
- The divers met at the harbor and signed a letter against the otters The letter was in 1975; the urchins came slowly over the following years.
- It is easier to blame the otters than to admit he was wrong and helped damage something he loved He says so directly: "It's easier to grumble about thieves with fur coats than to say: I was wrong."
- The shell reminds him of the life he loved and lost, and of his part in losing it The shell is a symbol of both his pride and his guilt.
- A healthy situation where predators and prey keep each other's numbers in check, so nothing takes over With otters gone, the urchins have no check and the balance is broken.
- He is feeling strong emotions: longing to dive again and guilt about the damaged cove He admits he misses diving "every day."
- She sees that he isn't always right, which is sad, but she loves him even more for being honest "It made me love him more."
- Everyone makes mistakes, but knowing the truth and never speaking up or trying to fix it was worse He knew for years what had really happened and said nothing.
- Grandpa returns to diving, helps clear the urchins, and the kelp forest begins to grow back, bringing the otters home The cleared patch recovers and an otter with a pup returns.
- The divers removed the urchins that were eating the young kelp Once the urchins were removed, kelp shoots could grow out of the rock.
- He now understands that the otter's eating, especially the urchins, keeps the whole forest healthy, even if it means fewer abalone for people His word shows his change of heart.
- Admitting the whole truth about our mistakes, openly, helps us and others learn and repair the damage After fifty years of silence, he chooses to share the full story publicly.