The Silver Fish of Chimbote
Off the coast of Peru swims one of the most important fish on Earth: the tiny silver anchoveta. Luz Huamán's father catches it from a small wooden boat; her brother grinds it into fishmeal at a giant factory; the seabirds on the islands offshore depend on it to survive. When El Niño warms the sea and the fish grow scarce, Luz discovers that everyone is fighting over the same small silver fish.
5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonOcean · Justice2765 wordsAbout 30 minutes
In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.
Words to know
- upwelling
- the rising of cold, nutrient-rich water from the deep ocean to the surface
- artisanal
- done by hand or on a small scale, using traditional methods rather than large machines
- quota
- a fixed limit on how much of something, such as fish, can be taken
- fishmeal
- a powder made by cooking, drying, and grinding fish, used mainly to feed farm animals and farmed fish
- guano
- the droppings of seabirds or bats, used as a valuable fertilizer
Chapter 1: The Smell of Money
In Chimbote, people say you can tell how the fishing is going by the smell.
When the fish are running, the whole city smells of fishmeal: a thick, oily, burned stink that rolls in from the factories along the bay and settles over everything. It gets in your hair and your clothes and your school notebooks. Visitors from Lima hold their noses. But old people in Chimbote just breathe in deeply and say, "Ah. Olor a plata." The smell of money.
When the fish aren't running, the air is clean. And everyone is worried.
Luz Huamán was twelve, and that autumn the air was clean.
Chimbote sits on the coast of Peru, where the Pacific Ocean does something unusual. A cold current flows north along the coast from Antarctica, and along it, steady winds push the surface water away from the shore. To replace it, cold water rises up from the deep ocean, carrying nutrients that have been sinking and collecting down there for centuries. Scientists call this upwelling. The nutrients feed vast blooms of tiny plants and animals, and those feed the anchoveta.
The anchoveta is a small silver fish, no longer than a finger. But there are more of them off the coast of Peru than almost any other fish anywhere on Earth. In a good year, Peru catches millions of tonnes of them. More fish are taken from this one stretch of sea than from almost any other fishery in the world.
And almost none of them are eaten by people.
Most of them go to the factories. There they are cooked, pressed, dried, and ground into fishmeal, a brown powder that is shipped across the world in enormous sacks, to feed pigs and chickens and, most of all, farmed salmon and shrimp in faraway countries. Luz had learned in school that it could take several kilos of wild anchoveta to make the feed for one kilo of farmed salmon. She thought about that sometimes when she saw salmon in the expensive supermarket in the center of town. A pink fish that came from the other side of the world, fed on silver fish that came from here.
Luz's family lived on both sides of the anchoveta. Two livelihoods, one fish.
Her father, Don Ernesto, was an artisanal fisherman. He owned half of a small wooden boat called La Esperanza, painted blue and yellow, with a crew of four. He fished close to shore, with nets pulled by hand, for anchoveta that he sold to people who salted or canned it to eat, and for other fish when he could get them. He had fished since he was thirteen. So had his father.
Her older brother, Marco, was nineteen, and he worked at the Pacífico Azul fishmeal factory on the bay. It was a good job: steady pay, health insurance, the first person in the family with a contract and a pension. He worked the night shift, feeding fish into the giant cookers. He came home every morning smelling of fishmeal so strongly that their mother made him take off his clothes on the patio.
The factory's fish came from the industrial fleet: big steel boats with powerful engines and enormous nets that could haul in hundreds of tonnes in a single trip.
At dinner, Luz's father and brother did not talk about work. They talked about football, and about Luz's grades, and about the neighbor's terrible new dog. But Luz noticed that when the fishmeal smell was strong, her father's face got tight. And when it was weak, Marco's did.
That autumn, the smell was weak for weeks.
Then the news came on the radio, and everyone in Chimbote stopped what they were doing to listen. The scientists who watched the ocean had made an announcement.
El Niño was coming.
Check your understanding
Cause and effect What causes the huge numbers of anchoveta off the coast of Peru?
- Fishermen release baby fish each year
- Upwelling brings cold, nutrient-rich water from the deep ocean, which feeds the tiny living things the anchoveta eat
- The water is very warm and shallow
- Rivers carry fish down from the mountains
Inference Why do old people in Chimbote call the fishmeal stink "the smell of money"?
- Because fishmeal smells like coins
- Because a strong smell means the factories are busy and the fishing economy is doing well, even though the smell is unpleasant
- Because they sell perfume
- Because they don't mind pollution at all
Key details Where does most of the anchoveta catch end up?
- Ground into fishmeal to feed farm animals and farmed fish in other countries
- On dinner plates in Chimbote
- In aquariums
- Released back into the ocean
Inference What does the detail about her father's and brother's faces reveal about the family?
- They don't like each other
- Their livelihoods depend on the same fish in competing ways, creating unspoken tension between them
- They both dislike the smell
- They want to change jobs
Chapter 2: The Warm Water
El Niño, Luz's science teacher, Señora Quispe, explained, was a change in the Pacific Ocean that happened every few years. The winds that pushed the warm surface water away from Peru's coast grew weak. Warm water from the western Pacific sloshed back east, toward South America, like water in a bathtub. It spread over the top of the cold current like a lid. The upwelling slowed. The nutrients stopped rising.
And the anchoveta, which needed cold, rich water, swam deeper or farther south, or simply died off.
"Fishermen have known about it for hundreds of years," said Señora Quispe. "They named it El Niño, the Christ Child, because it often arrived around Christmas. But the scientists think it may be getting stronger and less predictable as the planet warms."
That autumn, the sea off Chimbote grew warm. Luz could feel it when she swam at the beach: water that should have made her gasp felt almost like a bath. Strange fish appeared in the nets: tropical ones, yellow and striped, that her father had never seen. And the anchoveta disappeared.
La Esperanza went out every day and came back with almost nothing. Her father's crew, who were paid in shares of the catch, went home with empty pockets. One of them, Tío Rubén, who had been fishing with her father for twenty years, stopped coming. He'd gone to Lima to look for construction work.
At the factory, the government's fishing ministry set the season's quota, the total amount of anchoveta the industrial fleet was allowed to catch, far lower than usual. Then, a few weeks later, they closed the fishery entirely for a while, to protect the young fish. The factories shut down. Marco was sent home without pay.
For the first time in her life, the whole house was quiet in the evenings. Her father and brother sat at the table with nothing to say to each other and nothing to keep them apart, either.
One Saturday, Luz went with her father on La Esperanza, not to fish, but to take a scientist from the government's marine institute out to the Guañape Islands, a group of bare, rocky islands about thirty kilometers offshore. The scientist, a young woman named Dra. Paola Ramírez, was studying the seabirds.
Luz had seen the islands from a distance her whole life: white rocks rising out of the sea. She had never been close. When they got near, she understood why they were white. They were covered, centimeters thick, in guano: the droppings of millions of seabirds.
"Peru's guano used to be one of the most valuable things on Earth," Dra. Ramírez said, as they bobbed in the swell beside the cliffs. "A hundred and fifty years ago, ships came from all over the world to dig it up and sell it as fertilizer. They called it white gold." She pointed. "All of it comes from the anchoveta. The birds eat the fish. The fish become guano. The guano feeds farms. Everything is connected to that little silver fish."
But that year, the islands were nearly silent.
Where there should have been huge, crowded colonies of guanay cormorants, Peruvian boobies, and pelicans, there were scattered birds, standing hunched on the rocks. Many of the nests were empty. Along the waterline, Luz saw the bodies of dead birds, thin and light, floating in the swell. On a rocky ledge below them, a Humboldt penguin stood alone, looking out to sea.
"They're starving," said Dra. Ramírez quietly. "The anchoveta have gone deep, out of reach. The birds can't dive that far. During strong El Niños, the seabird population can crash by millions. Some of them come back. Some years, they don't."
Luz's father didn't say anything. He was looking at the dead birds in the water with an expression Luz had never seen on his face before.
On the way home, he said, half to himself, "When I was a boy, during the season, the birds were so thick over the water you couldn't see the sky. We used to follow them to find the fish." He shook his head. "Now we have sonar. Now the big boats have sonar, and spotter planes, and satellites. They don't need the birds anymore." He was quiet. "But the birds still need the fish."
Check your understanding
Main idea What is the main effect of El Niño described in this chapter?
- It makes the fishing season longer
- Warm water blocks the upwelling, so the anchoveta disappear, harming fishers, factory workers, and seabirds alike
- It brings more anchoveta to Chimbote
- It only affects tourists
Vocabulary Señora Quispe says the warm water spreads over the cold current "like a lid." What does this comparison help explain?
- How warm surface water blocks the cold, nutrient-rich water from rising up
- How fishermen cover their boats
- Why the ocean looks blue
- How guano forms on the islands
Inference Why does the author include Dra. Ramírez's explanation that guano was once called "white gold"?
- To show that the birds are worth more than people
- To show how the anchoveta connects to the whole ecosystem and economy, linking fish, birds, and farming
- To suggest people should dig up more guano
- To explain why the islands are white
Character What does Don Ernesto's comment, "But the birds still need the fish," reveal about him?
- He wants to buy sonar for his boat
- He recognizes that modern fishing has lost its connection to the ecosystem, and he feels responsible for the birds' suffering
- He doesn't care about the birds
- He blames the scientists
Chapter 3: Marco's Side
When Luz told Marco about the islands, she expected him to be upset. Instead, he got angry.
"So it's the factories' fault," he said. They were sitting on the roof of their house, where they always went when they wanted to talk without their parents hearing. Below them, the streets of their neighborhood ran down toward the bay, where the factory chimneys stood cold and smokeless. "The big boats. The fishmeal. That's what Papá thinks, isn't it? That's what everyone at your school thinks."
"I didn't say that."
"You didn't have to." Marco picked at a crack in the roof cement. "Do you know how many people in Chimbote work in fishmeal, Luz? Thousands. The factories, the boats, the trucks, the port. If they all closed tomorrow, this city would die. Papá's boat catches maybe three tonnes on a good day. A factory boat catches three hundred. Who do you think pays for the hospital? The schools? The roads?"
Luz didn't answer.
"And here's the other thing," Marco went on. "The ministry closed the fishery. When El Niño came, they shut us down to protect the fish. No fishing. No pay. Me and four hundred guys at Pacífico Azul, at home with nothing. The quota system, the closures, all the scientists counting fish: that's what keeps the anchoveta from being wiped out completely. It's not perfect. But it's one of the best-managed fisheries in the world. Papá's small boats? Nobody counts what they catch. Half of them don't even have licenses."
Luz had not known that. She thought about it.
"But the birds," she said finally. "And the pollution. And the smell. Señora Quispe says the factories used to dump waste straight into the bay. That's why the water by the port is dead. And kids in the neighborhoods next to the factories get asthma." She took a breath. "And it's not even food, Marco. It goes to feed salmon in other countries. Rich countries. Why should the fish go to them, instead of to the birds, or to people here?"
Marco was silent for a long time.
"I don't know," he said at last. "Maybe it shouldn't. But it's my job, Luz. It's the best job anyone in this family has ever had. When I got it, Mamá cried. Papá shook my hand like I was a man." He looked out at the cold chimneys. "You want me to quit? And do what? Go out on La Esperanza and catch nothing with him?"
Luz didn't have an answer. She realized, sitting there, that she had been thinking of the fish fight as a kind of story with heroes and villains. The small boats and the birds were the heroes. The big factories were the villains. But her brother wasn't a villain. He was nineteen, and he fed fish into a cooker all night so their family could have health insurance.
"The factory changed a lot, actually," Marco added after a while, more quietly. "Since I started. They put in new filters. The smell's half what it used to be, Papá says, and he hates them. They don't dump in the bay anymore. Not where I work." He shrugged. "Some of the older plants still do. The government's supposed to stop them. Sometimes it does."
"Would they change more?" Luz asked. "If people pushed?"
Marco looked at her sideways. "Depends who's pushing," he said. "And whether they're pushing to fix it or to shut it down."
Check your understanding
Main idea What is Marco's main argument in defense of the industrial fishery?
- It provides thousands of jobs and taxes for the city, and its quotas and closures help prevent the anchoveta from being wiped out
- It produces food for everyone in Chimbote
- It never causes pollution
- It is run by his own family
Key details What surprising fact does Marco tell Luz about small boats?
- They catch more fish than the factories
- Their catches are not counted, and many of them do not even have licenses
- They are owned by the factories
- They are not allowed to fish for anchoveta
Character How does Luz's thinking change in this chapter?
- She decides the factories are completely good
- She realizes she had been seeing a simple story of heroes and villains, but her brother and the industry are more complicated than that
- She stops caring about the birds
- She decides to work at the factory
Inference What does Marco mean when he says change "depends who's pushing... And whether they're pushing to fix it or to shut it down"?
- He wants Luz to stop talking about it
- The factories and workers are more likely to accept improvements if critics aim to make the industry better rather than destroy people's jobs
- He thinks only the government can push
- He wants the factories to close
Chapter 4: Sharing the Silver
El Niño ended the following spring. The winds returned. The cold water rose again. And slowly, the anchoveta came back.
The smell came back too. When it rolled in over the city one morning in May, thick and oily, Luz's grandmother stood in the doorway in her slippers and breathed it in with her eyes closed. Marco went back to work the same week. La Esperanza came home that Friday with her hold full and her crew singing.
But the birds did not come back so quickly. When Dra. Ramírez returned to the Guañape Islands in the summer, she counted far fewer nesting pairs than before El Niño. "Birds recover more slowly than fish," she told Luz's class, when she came to speak at the school. "A cormorant takes years to grow up and breed. And if the fishing restarts at full strength straight away, they'll be competing with the fleets for the fish they need to rebuild."
That was when Luz had the idea for the project.
She called it Who Gets the Silver Fish? She spent four months on it, with two friends, Andrea and Joaquín, and a lot of help from Señora Quispe. They interviewed everyone they could: Luz's father and his crew, Marco and two of his coworkers, a manager from the factory (who agreed only after Marco asked him personally), Dra. Ramírez, a doctor at the health center about asthma, a woman who ran a small cannery that turned anchoveta into food, and an old man who had dug guano on the islands in the 1960s.
They didn't try to decide who was right. They tried to draw a map of everyone who needed the fish, and how much, and why.
The map turned out to be enormous. It went from the plankton to the anchoveta to the birds to the guano to the farms. It went from the boats to the factories to the trucks to the ships to the salmon farms on the other side of the world, and back again to the taxes that paid for the hospital in Chimbote. It went from the factory chimneys into children's lungs. It went everywhere.
At the end of the project, they wrote five recommendations, and presented them at a public meeting organized by the city's environmental office:
One. Leave enough anchoveta in the sea for the seabirds, especially after El Niño, by setting quotas that count the birds' needs, not only the fleet's.
Two. Count every fish taken, by every boat, big or small, so the rules are fair to everyone.
Three. Make sure all the factories use the newest filters and stop polluting the bay, not just some of them.
Four. Help small fishers sell more anchoveta as food for people in Peru, instead of almost all of it becoming feed for other countries.
Five. Plan ahead for El Niño, since scientists say it may get stronger, so that workers like our brothers and fathers are not left with nothing when the fish disappear.
The meeting was crowded and loud. Some fishermen shouted that the kids were working for the factories. Some factory workers shouted that the kids wanted to close the plants. A man from the fishing ministry took a lot of notes and didn't say much.
But at the end, two things happened that Luz did not expect.
First, the manager from Pacífico Azul stood up and said that his company would support recommendation three, and would pay for an independent study of air quality in the neighborhoods next to the factories. "My own kids live here too," he said.
Second, her father stood up. He said that the small fishers' association would support recommendation two, and register every boat and report every catch, even though many of them didn't want to. "My son works for the factories," he said. "My daughter studies the birds. I fish. If we want the others to play fair, we have to play fair too."
Then he sat down next to Marco. And Marco, after a moment, put his hand on his father's shoulder.
Not everything changed. The quota for the next season was set higher than Dra. Ramírez wanted. Some of the older factories still polluted. Most of the anchoveta still became fishmeal. Turning a fishery that was well managed on paper into one that was truly sustainable, for fish and birds and people at once, would take years. Real change, Señora Quispe told Luz, was usually slow, and partial, and full of compromises that left everyone a little unhappy.
But that summer, standing on the deck of La Esperanza off the Guañape Islands, Luz saw a dark cloud moving low over the water toward them. Her father pointed. It was birds. Thousands of guanay cormorants, flying in a long wavering line, diving into the sea in a frenzy of white splashes.
"There," said her father softly. "The fish are there."
They did not follow the birds. Her father turned La Esperanza away, toward another part of the sea, and let them have it.
Check your understanding
Sequence Which event happened first?
- Luz presented the five recommendations at a public meeting
- The factory manager agreed to fund an air quality study
- Dra. Ramírez reported that the seabirds were recovering more slowly than the fish
- Luz's father turned La Esperanza away from the feeding birds
Key details What did Luz's project try to do instead of deciding who was right?
- Map everyone who needed the fish, how much, and why
- Count every anchoveta in the sea
- Prove that the factories should close
- Raise money for a new boat
Inference Why is it significant that Luz's father agrees that small fishers should report every catch?
- He wants to compete with the factories
- He accepts that fairness requires his own side to make sacrifices too, not just the side he criticizes
- He has been ordered to by the factory
- He plans to stop fishing
Theme Which theme is developed across the whole story?
- Industrial fishing should be banned completely
- Small fishermen are always right
- When many people and creatures depend on the same limited resource, fairness requires understanding all their needs and accepting slow, shared compromises
- El Niño is the only cause of the problem
Spelling words
These 12 words all appear in the story.
- anchoveta
- fishmeal
- industrial
- artisanal
- quota
- seabirds
- guano
- upwelling
- pollution
- current
- sustainable
- livelihoods
Writing prompt
Luz's family is divided: her father fishes from a small boat, and her brother works for the fishmeal factory. Who do you think has the strongest claim to the anchoveta: the small fishers, the industrial fleet, the seabirds, or someone else? Use evidence from the story and explain how the fish could be shared more fairly.
Reading skills practiced
Cause and effect, Inference, Key details, Main idea, Vocabulary, Character, Sequence, Theme.
Answer key for grown-ups
- Upwelling brings cold, nutrient-rich water from the deep ocean, which feeds the tiny living things the anchoveta eat The cold current and steady winds create upwelling that supports the food chain.
- Because a strong smell means the factories are busy and the fishing economy is doing well, even though the smell is unpleasant The smell signals that fish are running and jobs are plentiful.
- Ground into fishmeal to feed farm animals and farmed fish in other countries "Almost none of them are eaten by people."
- Their livelihoods depend on the same fish in competing ways, creating unspoken tension between them Each man worries when the other's side of the fishery does well.
- Warm water blocks the upwelling, so the anchoveta disappear, harming fishers, factory workers, and seabirds alike The chapter shows the empty nets, the closed factory, and the starving birds.
- How warm surface water blocks the cold, nutrient-rich water from rising up A lid traps what is underneath, stopping the upwelling.
- To show how the anchoveta connects to the whole ecosystem and economy, linking fish, birds, and farming She says, "Everything is connected to that little silver fish."
- He recognizes that modern fishing has lost its connection to the ecosystem, and he feels responsible for the birds' suffering His memory of birds filling the sky contrasts with the silent islands.
- It provides thousands of jobs and taxes for the city, and its quotas and closures help prevent the anchoveta from being wiped out Marco points to jobs, public services, and the managed quota system.
- Their catches are not counted, and many of them do not even have licenses He says "Nobody counts what they catch."
- She realizes she had been seeing a simple story of heroes and villains, but her brother and the industry are more complicated than that "Her brother wasn't a villain."
- The factories and workers are more likely to accept improvements if critics aim to make the industry better rather than destroy people's jobs He hints that the purpose of the pressure affects whether people will cooperate.
- Dra. Ramírez reported that the seabirds were recovering more slowly than the fish Dra. Ramírez's report inspired the project, which led to the meeting.
- Map everyone who needed the fish, how much, and why "They tried to draw a map of everyone who needed the fish."
- He accepts that fairness requires his own side to make sacrifices too, not just the side he criticizes He says, "If we want the others to play fair, we have to play fair too."
- When many people and creatures depend on the same limited resource, fairness requires understanding all their needs and accepting slow, shared compromises From the family tensions to the map and the final act of leaving fish for the birds, the story explores sharing a common resource.