Whale Fall
Four months after her grandfather's death, Isla joins her mother on a research ship off the California coast, insisting she is completely fine. Then the ship's robot camera, a kilometer below the surface, finds the body of a gray whale on the seafloor, surrounded by a whole world of strange creatures that are living because it died.
5th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerOcean · Family2643 wordsAbout 30 minutes
In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.
Words to know
- whale fall
- the body of a dead whale that has sunk to the deep ocean floor, where it feeds many living things
- submersible
- a vehicle that can travel deep underwater; some carry people, and some are robots controlled from a ship
- scavenger
- an animal that feeds on dead plants or animals
- decompose
- to slowly break down and rot after death
- bioluminescent
- able to make its own light, like a firefly or some deep-sea animals
Chapter 1: Fine
I want to make one thing clear before I start: I was fine.
Everybody kept asking. My mom asked every morning. My teacher asked. The school counselor asked so often that I started taking a different hallway to avoid her office. My aunts asked on the phone, in Spanish and in English, as if one language might get a different answer.
I was fine. My grandfather had died in March. It was July now. People die. Abuelo Tomás was eighty-three, and he had a weak heart, and it was nobody's fault, and he had a good long life, which is what everybody said at the funeral, over and over, like a password. I had cried at the funeral, and then I had stopped, and that was that.
So when my mom said I could come with her on the research ship for two weeks that summer, instead of staying with my aunt, I said yes because it sounded interesting. Not because I needed to get away from anything. I was fine.
My mom is a marine biologist. She studies the deep sea: the dark, cold, enormous part of the ocean below where sunlight reaches, which is most of the ocean, actually, and which people know less about than the surface of the Moon. Her ship was called the Ventana Azul. It was sixty meters long and painted white and orange, and it carried twenty-two scientists and crew, a laboratory, a kitchen that made surprisingly good pancakes, and, in a big hangar at the back, a robot submersible named Pico.
Pico was the size of a small car, bright yellow, with lights and cameras on the front and two mechanical arms that could pick up things as delicate as a jellyfish. A long cable connected it to the ship. Pilots sat in a dark control room full of screens and steered it with joysticks, like a video game, while Pico sank down into the abyss, two thousand, three thousand meters, to places no human had ever seen.
The first three days, I watched everything. I watched Pico dive. I watched the screens in the control room as it sank through blue water into black, and bioluminescent creatures began to glow and flash in its lights like sparks: jellyfish trailing glowing threads, a squid that lit up like a lantern, a fish with a tiny light hanging in front of its mouth. I wrote everything in my notebook. I asked a lot of questions. I was, the chief scientist told my mom, "a very good sailor."
What I did not mention to anyone was that I wasn't sleeping much. At night in our little cabin, I lay in my bunk listening to the engine and the waves against the hull, and I thought about Abuelo's hands.
He had been a fisherman, in a small town near the Chilean coast, before he came to California. His hands were enormous and brown and scarred from fishing lines and knives. He used them to tie knots faster than I could see, and to make empanadas on Sundays, and to point at the sea from the end of the pier and tell me things about it. The sea gives and the sea takes, mija, he used to say. And it never wastes anything.
I didn't know what that meant. I'd never asked. Now I couldn't.
But I was fine.
Check your understanding
Inference Why does the narrator keep insisting "I was fine"?
- She wants to sound cheerful for the reader
- She is trying to convince herself and others that she isn't grieving, which suggests that she actually is
- Her mother told her to say it
- She is describing her health after an illness
Key details What is Pico?
- The name of the research ship
- Isla's grandfather's fishing boat
- A robot submersible controlled from the ship by pilots using joysticks
- A deep-sea fish with a light
Character Which detail best shows Isla's true feelings in this chapter?
- She asks many questions about the deep sea
- She enjoys the ship's pancakes
- She lies awake at night thinking about her grandfather's hands
- She writes in her notebook
Vocabulary What does "abyss" mean in "Pico sank down into the abyss"?
- The extremely deep part of the ocean
- A kind of robot arm
- The bright surface of the sea
- A tropical island
Chapter 2: Something Big
On the fifth day, Pico found the whale.
I was in the control room. It was a normal dive, a survey of the seafloor about a kilometer down, in a deep canyon off the coast. On the main screen, Pico's lights showed nothing but gray mud stretching away into the dark, with a few sea cucumbers and a sea star here and there. One of the pilots, a young woman named Kendra who had grown up surfing in Hawaii, was humming to herself.
Then the sonar beeped.
"Something big," said Kendra. "Two o'clock. Fifteen meters long."
Everyone in the control room leaned forward. My mom, who had been typing at the back, stood up so fast her chair rolled across the floor.
Pico turned. Its lights swept across the mud. And there, rising out of the darkness, was a shape: long and pale and enormous, curved like a boat lying on its side. At first I didn't understand what I was seeing. Then I saw the jaw. A huge, curved jawbone, as long as a car. And ribs, rows and rows of them, like the frame of a building.
"Whale fall," my mother breathed. "Oh, look at that. Look at that."
It was a gray whale, she said, or what was left of one. It had probably died a year or two before, maybe of old age or illness, maybe hit by a ship. Its body had sunk all the way to the bottom. And now, a kilometer below the surface, in the cold and the dark, it had become something else.
It was crawling with life.
I had expected a skeleton lying alone on the mud, like a dinosaur in a museum. Instead, the bones were covered with living things. Red bacteria spread across them in mats like fuzzy carpets. White crabs picked their way along the ribs. Small snails clung in clusters. A pale, eel-like fish with no eyes slid between the bones, then another and another.
"Hagfish," said my mom. "Scavengers. When a whale first lands, the big scavengers come from all around: sleeper sharks, hagfish, crabs. They eat the soft tissue. It can take months, even a couple of years. A whale is a feast down here." She pointed at the screen. "But look closer. Zoom in on the bones, Kendra."
Kendra zoomed in. The camera moved slowly along one of the great ribs. It was covered in what looked like tiny red flowers, thousands of them, each one waving gently in the current.
"Osedax," said my mother. "Bone-eating worms. Some people call them zombie worms. They have no mouths and no stomachs. They grow roots, like a plant, down into the whale bones, and bacteria inside them help them digest the fat stored in the bone. They live on whale skeletons and almost nowhere else. They were only discovered about twenty years ago."
I stared at the screen. Little red flowers, eating bones in the dark.
"And it goes on," my mom said. Her voice was soft. "After the worms, when the bones start to decompose, they release chemicals. Special bacteria feed on those chemicals, and other animals feed on the bacteria. Clams, mussels, tubeworms. Some whale falls support life for fifty years or more. Scientists have found hundreds of different species living on a single skeleton. Some of them live nowhere else on Earth."
"Fifty years," I said. "From one whale."
"From one whale," said my mother. "A big whale's body holds an enormous amount of nutrients: fat, protein, minerals. Down here, there's almost no food. Most of the deep seafloor is like a desert. Everything that lives here depends on what falls from above. And a whale is the biggest thing that can fall. When it dies, it doesn't just disappear. It becomes a whole ecosystem. A whole world."
I didn't say anything else. I watched the red worms waving on the bones. And for no reason at all that I could explain, my eyes got hot and blurry, and I had to look down at my notebook and pretend to write something until it stopped.
Nobody noticed. Or if they did, they didn't say.
Check your understanding
Sequence What did the scientists see first when Pico reached the whale fall?
- Clams and tubeworms
- The huge curved jawbone and rows of ribs
- The bone-eating worms up close
- A sleeper shark
Key details What is unusual about Osedax worms?
- They glow in the dark
- They swim faster than fish
- They have no mouths or stomachs and grow roots into whale bones, using bacteria to digest the fat
- They live on the ocean surface
Cause and effect Why is a whale fall so important to life on the deep seafloor?
- It blocks strong currents
- It provides light in the darkness
- The deep seafloor has very little food, so a fallen whale provides nutrients that can support many species for decades
- It warms the cold water
Inference Why do Isla's eyes get "hot and blurry" while she watches the worms?
- The screen is too bright
- She is tired from not sleeping
- The whale fall stirs up her hidden grief about her grandfather, even though she can't explain why yet
- She is scared of the worms
Chapter 3: Night Watch
That night, I couldn't sleep at all. Around midnight, I gave up, put on my sweatshirt, and went up to the deck.
The ocean was black and enormous and calm, and the sky was full of more stars than I had ever seen. The ship hummed. Somewhere below us, a kilometer down, the gray whale lay in the dark with its red flowers.
My mom was already there, leaning against the railing with a mug of tea. She didn't seem surprised to see me. She held out her arm, and I went and stood next to her, and she put it around my shoulders.
We didn't say anything for a while.
"Do you know what I keep thinking about?" she said finally.
"What?"
"Your abuelo. He would have loved today." She smiled a little. "He'd have had a hundred questions for Kendra. He'd have wanted to know how many empanadas you could make from a gray whale."
I laughed, and it came out wrong, kind of cracked.
"He used to say the sea never wastes anything," I said.
My mom looked at me. "He said that to you too?"
"All the time. On the pier." I swallowed. "I never asked what it meant."
"He said it to me when I was your age," she said. "When my grandmother died. I was so angry. I didn't understand why everybody kept saying she'd had a long life, as if that made it okay." She was quiet a moment. "He took me fishing, and he told me that when a fish dies in the sea, other fish eat it, and the little bits that are left feed the tiny creatures, and the tiny creatures feed the bigger ones. Nothing is lost, he said. Everything gets passed on."
I stared out at the black water.
"That's what the whale is," I said. "Isn't it? It died, and it didn't just... stop. It's feeding all those things. The worms and the crabs and the clams. For fifty years."
"Yes," said my mom.
And then, without warning, I was crying. Really crying, the way I hadn't since the funeral, the kind of crying that makes your whole body shake. I didn't decide to. It just came up out of me like something that had been sinking for four months and had finally reached the bottom.
"I'm not fine," I said into her sweatshirt. "I keep saying I'm fine. I'm not."
"I know, mija," my mom said, and held on. "I know. Me neither."
We stood there for a long time. The ship rocked gently. Somewhere far off, a whale blew—a living one, on the surface—and we heard the long, hollow sigh of its breath across the water in the dark.
Later, when I could talk again, I asked her something I'd been wondering all day.
"What killed it? The gray whale?"
My mom hesitated. "We don't know for sure. We'll look at the skull more closely tomorrow. But there was a break in one of the jawbones that might be from a ship strike." She sighed. "Ships hit whales more than people realize, especially in busy shipping lanes like the ones near here. Big ships move fast, and whales don't always get out of the way in time. Some places now ask ships to slow down in areas where whales feed, and it helps a lot. But not everywhere does it yet."
"So it might not have been natural."
"It might not."
I thought about that. The whale's body was feeding a whole world. That was beautiful. But it would have been better, I thought, if it had lived longer first.
"Both things can be true," my mom said, as if she'd read my mind. "Something can be beautiful and also something we should try to prevent. Your abuelo's death was natural, mija. He was eighty-three. This whale might not have been ready."
Check your understanding
Main idea What is the turning point of this chapter?
- Isla discovers what killed the whale
- Isla finally admits she is not fine and lets herself grieve with her mother
- The ship changes course
- Isla decides to become a pilot
Inference The author writes that Isla's crying came up "like something that had been sinking for four months and had finally reached the bottom." What is this comparison connected to?
- The robot submersible's dive
- The whale's body sinking slowly to the seafloor, just as her grief has been sinking inside her
- A ship sinking in a storm
- A fishing line
Character What does Isla learn about her mother in this chapter?
- That her mother never knew Abuelo well
- That her mother is also grieving and once heard the same words from Abuelo when she was young
- That her mother wants to quit science
- That her mother is angry at Isla
Cause and effect According to Isla's mother, what helps protect whales from ship strikes?
- Painting ships bright colors
- Asking ships to slow down in areas where whales feed
- Keeping whales in aquariums
- Building fences in the ocean
Chapter 4: Passed On
We stayed at the whale fall site for three more days. The scientists collected samples with Pico's mechanical arms: a few of the bone-eating worms, some of the bacteria mats, a small piece of rib, a scoop of mud from beneath the skeleton. My mom let me help label the jars in the lab. Osedax sp., rib 7, 1,012 meters. Each jar went into a freezer to be studied back on land.
The research team took hundreds of photographs and measurements. They found the break in the jaw. They also found, in the mud around the skeleton, sixteen species of animals that nobody on the ship could identify, including a tiny pink snail and a worm that looked like a feather duster.
"Some of these might be new to science," the chief scientist said, grinning. "Somebody might name one after you, Isla."
"I'd rather they named one after my grandfather," I said.
Everyone went quiet. Then the chief scientist nodded slowly. "We can ask," he said. "Sometimes that's allowed."
On our last evening at the site, Kendra let me sit at the controls for a few minutes while Pico hovered above the whale. It was the strangest feeling, steering a robot through the dark a kilometer below my feet, seeing what it saw. I moved Pico slowly along the length of the skeleton, from the great curved jaw to the last small bones of the tail, and I looked at everything one more time: the red worms like flowers, the white crabs, the hagfish, the mats of bacteria, the tiny snails.
All those organisms. All that life. A whole world built out of one ending.
When Pico reached the tail, I stopped and held it there for a moment, just hovering, lights shining down.
"Goodbye," I said quietly. I wasn't sure whether I was saying it to the whale or to Abuelo. Maybe both.
Kendra didn't laugh. She just waited, and then she took the controls back gently, and Pico began its long climb back up toward the light.
On the drive home from the harbor, I asked my mom if we could stop at the pier in our town, the one where Abuelo used to fish. We sat on the bench at the end, where he always sat, and watched the sun go down over the water.
I'd been thinking about it for days.
"When I'm older," I said, "I want to do what you do. Study the deep sea."
My mom looked at me. "Because of the whale?"
"Because of the whale. And because of Abuelo." I looked out at the ocean. "He always said the sea never wastes anything. I want to find out all the ways that's true."
She didn't answer right away. She just took my hand, and we sat there together on his bench.
The school counselor, the one whose office I'd been avoiding, had once given me a pamphlet about grief. I had thrown it away without reading it. But I remembered one line from the cover, because it had made me angry at the time: Grief is love with nowhere to go. I had thought that was the silliest thing I'd ever read. Now, sitting on Abuelo's bench, I wasn't so sure. Maybe the trick was finding somewhere for it to go.
Here is what I understand now, that I didn't understand in March.
When Abuelo died, I thought it was the end of something. And it was. But I've been noticing, since the whale, all the ways he's still here. My mom tells his stories now, the ones I'd never heard. My aunts make his empanadas on Sundays, and they argue about whether they're doing it right. I tie knots the way he showed me, still slower than he did. And I say his words to my little cousin Mateo on the pier: The sea gives and the sea takes, and it never wastes anything.
That's what a whale fall is, I think. Not just an ending. A passing on. Through generations of worms and crabs and clams, through generations of people, everything that a life was gets passed on to the lives that come after it.
I still miss him. I miss him every day. I'm not fine, not completely, and maybe I won't be for a long time.
But I'm okay with not being fine. And that, I think, is actually a lot closer to fine than I was before.
Check your understanding
Key details What does Isla ask the scientists to do if they discover a new species?
- Name it after the ship
- Name it after her grandfather
- Name it after Kendra
- Keep it a secret
Inference Why does Isla say "Goodbye" while hovering over the whale?
- She is talking to Kendra
- She is saying goodbye to both the whale and her grandfather, finally allowing herself to grieve
- She wants Pico to return to the ship
- She is practicing a speech
Vocabulary At the end, Isla says, "I'm okay with not being fine." What does this show about how she has changed?
- She has stopped pretending and has accepted her grief as natural, which helps her heal
- She has decided she will never feel better
- She is still hiding her feelings
- She has forgotten her grandfather
Theme Which theme is developed across the whole story?
- Deep-sea research is too dangerous for children
- Grief should be hidden so others don't worry
- Endings can nourish new beginnings, and the people we lose live on in what they pass to those who come after
- Whales are the most important animals in the ocean
Spelling words
These 12 words all appear in the story.
- submersible
- ecosystem
- scavengers
- skeleton
- decompose
- nutrients
- organisms
- grief
- abyss
- research
- generations
- bioluminescent
Writing prompt
Isla says she is "fine" many times in the story, but her actions show something different. Find three moments that show what Isla is really feeling and explain each one. Then explain how the whale fall helps her understand her grandfather's death.
Reading skills practiced
Inference, Key details, Character, Vocabulary, Sequence, Cause and effect, Main idea, Theme.
Answer key for grown-ups
- She is trying to convince herself and others that she isn't grieving, which suggests that she actually is Repeating "fine" so often is a clue that she is not fine.
- A robot submersible controlled from the ship by pilots using joysticks Pico is "the size of a small car" with cameras and arms.
- She lies awake at night thinking about her grandfather's hands Her sleeplessness and memories show grief she hasn't admitted.
- The extremely deep part of the ocean It refers to the very deep, dark ocean thousands of meters down.
- The huge curved jawbone and rows of ribs Isla first sees "the jaw" and "ribs" before the camera zooms in on the life.
- They have no mouths or stomachs and grow roots into whale bones, using bacteria to digest the fat Isla's mother explains how they feed on bones.
- The deep seafloor has very little food, so a fallen whale provides nutrients that can support many species for decades Her mother explains that "most of the deep seafloor is like a desert."
- The whale fall stirs up her hidden grief about her grandfather, even though she can't explain why yet Watching life grow from death touches feelings she has been denying.
- Isla finally admits she is not fine and lets herself grieve with her mother Her confession, "I'm not fine," is the emotional turning point of the story.
- The whale's body sinking slowly to the seafloor, just as her grief has been sinking inside her The image links her hidden grief to the whale's journey to the bottom.
- That her mother is also grieving and once heard the same words from Abuelo when she was young Her mother says "Me neither" and shares her own memory of Abuelo.
- Asking ships to slow down in areas where whales feed Slower ships give whales more time to move out of the way.
- Name it after her grandfather She says, "I'd rather they named one after my grandfather."
- She is saying goodbye to both the whale and her grandfather, finally allowing herself to grieve She says she wasn't sure whether she was saying it "to the whale or to Abuelo. Maybe both."
- She has stopped pretending and has accepted her grief as natural, which helps her heal Accepting her feelings is "closer to fine" than pretending.
- Endings can nourish new beginnings, and the people we lose live on in what they pass to those who come after The whale fall feeding life for decades mirrors how Abuelo's words, recipes, and love live on in his family.