The Acre We Bought
Sam's fifth-grade class in Minnesota raises money to "buy" an acre of the Amazon rainforest and save it forever. They are proud of their certificate, until a letter arrives from their pen pal in a Kichwa village in Ecuador. Yaku's family has lived in that forest for centuries, and he has some questions about who gets to save it.
5th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeySchool · Rainforest · Culture2637 wordsAbout 30 minutes
In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.
Words to know
- Indigenous
- describing the first people to live in a place, whose families have been there for a very long time
- territory
- an area of land that belongs to or is cared for by a particular group
- assumption
- something you believe is true without checking
- perspective
- a particular way of seeing or thinking about something
- deforestation
- the cutting down of large areas of forest
Chapter 1: Twenty-Five Dollars an Acre
It started with a video about sloths.
Ms. Lindgren's fifth-grade class at Cedar Hills Elementary in Minneapolis was studying ecosystems, and on a gray Monday in February, with snow piled against the classroom windows, she showed them a film about the Amazon rainforest.
The class went silent. On the screen, the forest stretched green and endless under a hot blue sky. Macaws flashed red and gold through the treetops. A jaguar slipped through the shadows. A three-toed sloth hung from a branch, chewing a leaf with the slowest expression Sam Nguyen had ever seen. Half the class said "awww" at the same time.
Then the film changed. Now the screen showed the same forest from above, but with long brown scars cut through it. Bulldozers. Smoke. Stumps as far as the eye could see. A narrator said that an area of rainforest the size of a soccer field was being cut down every few seconds, for cattle ranches, farms, mines, and timber.
"That's not fair," said Sam, out loud, before he could stop himself.
Ms. Lindgren turned off the screen. "What do you think we could do about it?" she asked.
Sam had an idea before anyone else even raised their hand. He had seen a website the night before, when he was looking up sloths for fun. A charity let people "buy" an acre of rainforest for twenty-five dollars. They used the money to purchase land and protect it from being cut down. You even got a certificate with a map showing where your acre was.
"We could buy some," Sam said. "If we raised money. We could save part of the rainforest."
The class loved it. So did Ms. Lindgren. That afternoon, they made a plan. They would hold a fundraiser for the whole month of March, and try to buy twenty acres. That was five hundred dollars.
Sam was in charge. He made posters. He organized a bake sale and a car wash in the school parking lot, which turned out to be a mistake in Minnesota in March, because the water froze on the cars. He talked his grandmother into teaching the class how to make Vietnamese spring rolls to sell at the school talent show.
His grandmother, Bà Nội, had come to Minnesota from Vietnam forty years ago. She was small and quiet and had very strong opinions about spring rolls.
"Why do you want to buy a forest so far away?" she asked, as she showed him how to roll the rice paper tightly.
"To save it," Sam said. "So nobody can cut it down."
Bà Nội nodded slowly. "And the people who live in the forest? What do they think?"
Sam stopped rolling. "I don't know," he said. "I didn't know people lived there."
His grandmother smiled a little and didn't say anything else. But Sam thought about the question all evening.
At the same time, Ms. Lindgren had another project going. For two years, her class had been writing letters to a pen pal class at a small school in Ecuador. The school was in a Kichwa village called Sacha Llakta, deep in the Amazon rainforest, on the banks of a winding brown river. Their teacher, Señora Cuji, spoke English and helped translate the letters.
Sam's pen pal was a boy named Yaku, who was also eleven. In his last letter, Yaku had described catching a fish as long as his arm and seeing a giant otter. Sam had written back about ice fishing and snow forts.
"You should tell Yaku about the fundraiser!" said Sam's friend Ruby. "He'll be so happy. We're saving his forest!"
That seemed like a great idea. Sam wrote a long, excited letter explaining everything: the sloth video, the bake sale, the spring rolls, the plan to buy twenty acres of rainforest so it could never be cut down.
He mailed it the next morning, feeling proud.
Check your understanding
Key details How much did it cost to "buy" one acre of rainforest through the charity?
- Five dollars
- Twenty-five dollars
- Five hundred dollars
- One hundred dollars
Cause and effect What made Sam want to raise money for the rainforest?
- He saw a film showing the rainforest being cut down and felt it wasn't fair
- His grandmother asked him to
- Yaku asked him for help
- The principal assigned the project
Inference Why do you think Bà Nội asks, "And the people who live in the forest? What do they think?"
- She wants Sam to stop the fundraiser
- She doesn't believe people live in rainforests
- She wants Sam to think about whose home the forest is, and whether they've been asked
- She is only interested in spring rolls
Character How does Sam feel when he mails his letter to Yaku?
- Nervous that Yaku won't write back
- Proud and excited, believing he is helping save Yaku's forest
- Bored with the project
- Guilty about the car wash
Chapter 2: Yaku's Letter
The fundraiser was a huge success. By the end of March, the class had raised five hundred and seventy-five dollars, enough for twenty-three acres. Ms. Lindgren sent the money to the charity, and two weeks later, a large envelope arrived.
Inside was a certificate printed on thick, creamy paper with a gold seal. It said "CERTIFICATE OF RAINFOREST PROTECTION" and "Cedar Hills Elementary, Grade 5" and "23 acres." There was a map with a small green square outlined in the middle of a much larger green area.
The class cheered. Ms. Lindgren hung the certificate on the wall beside the whiteboard. Sam felt like he might float right off the ground.
Two days later, Yaku's reply arrived.
Ms. Lindgren handed Sam the envelope with a strange expression on her face. Señora Cuji had attached a note to the outside: "Yaku asked me to translate his letter exactly as he wrote it. I hope you will read it with an open heart."
Sam opened it.
"Dear Sam," Yaku wrote. "Thank you for your letter. I can tell you care very much about the forest. That makes me happy. Many people do not care at all.
"But I have to tell you something, and I hope you will not be angry.
"My people, the Kichwa, have lived in this forest for thousands of years. My grandfather's grandfather's grandfather was born here. We know every river, every hill, every tree where the birds nest. We hunt and fish and grow our food in small gardens, and we let the forest grow back afterward. Our ancestors are buried here. This forest is not something we own like a car or a house. It is our family. We belong to it.
"When you say you want to buy the forest to save it, I feel confused. Who are you buying it from? In some places, people from the cities or from other countries buy land in the forest to protect it, and that can be good. But sometimes they put up fences and signs that say no one can enter. Sometimes the people who lived there for a thousand years are told they cannot hunt or fish there anymore. It is like someone saving your house by locking you out of it.
"Here in Sacha Llakta, our forest is already protected. It is protected by us. For many years, oil companies wanted to drill here. Our people fought them for a long time, in the courts and with our voices, and we won. Now my uncle and other adults patrol our territory to watch for illegal loggers and miners. Scientists have studied satellite maps. They say that forests where Indigenous people have the right to their land are cut down much less than other forests. We are not the people the forest needs to be saved from. We are the people saving it.
"I am not saying your money is bad. I am only saying that, next time, maybe you could ask us first.
"Your friend, Yaku."
Sam read the letter twice. Then he put it down on his desk and stared at it. His face felt hot. He had been so sure. So proud. And now he felt like someone had turned on a light in a room and shown him that he had been standing on someone else's foot the whole time.
"What's wrong?" Ruby whispered.
Sam slid the letter over to her without a word.
Check your understanding
Main idea What is the main point of Yaku's letter?
- He is angry that Sam's class raised money
- He wants Sam to send the money to him personally
- His people already protect their forest, and outsiders should ask Indigenous communities before deciding how to help
- He wants Sam to visit the rainforest
Vocabulary Yaku's uncle helps patrol their "territory." What does territory mean here?
- A type of tree
- An area of land that a group lives on and takes care of
- A country's capital city
- A school district
Inference What does Yaku mean by comparing some outside protection to "saving your house by locking you out of it"?
- Protecting land in a way that keeps out the people who have always lived there harms them, even if the forest is saved
- People should lock their doors
- Houses in the forest are dangerous
- He doesn't want visitors in his village
Character How does Sam feel after reading Yaku's letter?
- Angry at Yaku for being ungrateful
- Happy that Yaku liked his idea
- Embarrassed and surprised, realizing he made an assumption without asking
- Bored and uninterested
Chapter 3: Two Sides of the Map
Ms. Lindgren asked Sam if he would be willing to read Yaku's letter aloud to the class. Sam didn't want to. But he did it anyway.
When he finished, nobody spoke for a long moment.
Then the class split almost exactly in half.
"I don't get it," said Marcus. "We're trying to help. The forest is getting cut down. If we buy land, it can't be cut down. How is that bad?"
"Because nobody asked them," said Ruby. "It's their home. You wouldn't like it if some kid from Ecuador bought your backyard and told you you couldn't play in it."
"But the charity isn't buying Yaku's land," said Priya. "It's somewhere else. Maybe nobody lives there."
"Do we know that?" asked Ruby.
Nobody knew that.
"The money still helps the forest," said Marcus. "Even if it's not perfect. Isn't something better than nothing?"
"Maybe," said Ruby. "But what if something better than something is out there, and we didn't bother to look?"
Ms. Lindgren let them argue for a while. Then she held up her hand.
"I think," she said, "that you're both making good points. Marcus, you're right that land protection groups do important work, and many of them do work closely with Indigenous communities. Ruby, you're right that we made an assumption without asking the people who know the forest best." She looked at Sam. "Sam, what do you think?"
Sam had been quiet the whole time. He was thinking about his grandmother.
"My Bà Nội asked me the same question Yaku did," he said slowly. "Before we even started. She asked what the people who live in the forest think. And I didn't know. I didn't even know there were people there." He swallowed. "The video we watched didn't show any people. Just animals and trees and bulldozers. So I guess I thought it was empty. Like it was waiting for somebody to come save it."
That evening, Sam asked his grandmother why she had asked that question.
Bà Nội was quiet for a long time, slicing vegetables at the kitchen counter. Then she put down her knife.
"When I was a girl in Vietnam," she said, "my family had a small farm by a river. Rice and fish. My grandmother's grandmother farmed it. One year, men came from the city. They said the land would be made into a park, to protect the birds. A good thing. But the park had fences. We were told to leave." She shrugged, but her eyes were far away. "The birds were protected. But no one asked where we would go."
Sam stared at her. "You never told me that."
"You never asked about forests before." Bà Nội picked up her knife again. "People who save things sometimes forget to look at who is standing there. That is all I wanted you to see."
Sam went to his room and wrote a letter to Yaku. It was the hardest letter he had ever written.
"Dear Yaku," he wrote. "I'm sorry. You were right. I didn't ask. I didn't even know to ask. I think I thought the forest was empty because the video didn't show any people. That was a big mistake.
"We already sent the money for the acres. I think it will still help some animals. But now I want to know: if a class far away wanted to help your forest, what would you want us to do? Not what we think. What you think."
He sent it the next day. Then he waited.
Check your understanding
Character What does Marcus believe about the fundraiser?
- It was a complete waste of money
- Even if imperfect, buying land still helps protect the forest, and something is better than nothing
- They should take the money back
- Yaku should pay them back
Cause and effect Why did Sam think the rainforest was empty?
- Yaku told him nobody lived there
- The video showed animals, trees, and bulldozers, but no people
- His teacher said so
- He saw it on the charity's map
Inference Why does Bà Nội's story about the farm in Vietnam matter so much to Sam?
- It teaches him how to grow rice
- It shows that his own family experienced being pushed out by a "protection" project, so he sees Yaku's concern is real
- It explains why she likes birds
- It makes him want to visit Vietnam
Theme Which sentence from Chapter 3 best states an important idea of the story?
- "People who save things sometimes forget to look at who is standing there."
- "Nobody knew that."
- "Then she put down her knife."
- "He sent it the next day."
Chapter 4: The Seed
Yaku's reply took three weeks. When it came, it was in a small padded envelope, and it was not only a letter.
Inside, wrapped in a soft piece of cloth, was a seed. It was large and smooth, dark brown, about the size of a walnut.
"Dear Sam," Yaku wrote. "Thank you for your letter. I read it to my grandfather. He laughed and said you have a good heart, and that a person who can say sorry is a person worth teaching.
"You asked what we would want. Here is what my community talked about.
"Our forest guardians, like my uncle, walk many kilometers every week to watch for illegal logging. It is dangerous and very slow. Some communities near us use small drones with cameras, which can fly over the forest and see trees being cut far away. Our community would like to buy one, and train young people to fly it. My cousin Sisa is sixteen and she wants to be the pilot. The drone costs about six hundred dollars.
"Also, we have a school project. Our teacher wants us to plant seedlings in the places where the oil company cut roads many years ago, before we made them leave. We are growing the seeds of the trees our grandparents knew. This is one of them, from the ceibo tree. It is a sacred tree for us. It can grow taller than any other tree in the forest, and its roots are like walls. My grandfather says the ceibo holds up the sky.
"I am sending you one seed. It will not grow in your snow, I think. But maybe you can keep it, to remember that the forest has people in it.
"Your friend, Yaku."
Sam read the letter to the class. When he finished, Marcus was the first to raise his hand.
"Six hundred dollars," Marcus said. "We raised five hundred and seventy-five in a month. We could do another fundraiser."
"But we'd send the money to Yaku's community," said Ruby. "To their guardians. So they decide how to use it."
Marcus nodded. "Yeah," he said. "Yeah, that makes sense. Then it's not us deciding."
Ms. Lindgren smiled. Sam realized that even Marcus, who had argued against Ruby so hard, had changed his mind. Not because someone won the argument, but because Yaku had told them something they hadn't known.
The second fundraiser was even bigger than the first. This time, the class didn't just sell spring rolls and cookies. They made a presentation for the whole school about the Kichwa people, and the forest guardians, and the difference between protecting a forest and protecting the people who protect it. Sam's grandmother came and told her story about the farm by the river. Señora Cuji joined by video call from Ecuador, with Yaku and Sisa sitting beside her, and Sisa showed everyone a picture of the drone she hoped to fly.
They raised six hundred and forty dollars. Ms. Lindgren worked with Señora Cuji to send it directly to the community's guardian program.
Two months later, a video arrived. It showed Sisa standing in a clearing, surrounded by cheering children, holding a small black drone above her head. Then the camera switched to the drone's view as it rose up, up, up, over the treetops, until the forest spread out below like a vast green ocean, with the brown river curling through it like a ribbon. In the corner of the screen, a group of kids was waving. One of them was Yaku.
The class watched it three times.
The certificate from the charity still hung on the wall beside the whiteboard. Ms. Lindgren didn't take it down. "The acres are real," she said. "They're still being protected, and that's still good. We just learned that there's more than one way to help, and the best way usually starts with a question."
But Sam had a different favorite thing on the wall now. Beside the certificate, in a small glass frame, sat the ceibo seed. Under it, Sam had written a label in careful handwriting:
"Ceibo seed. From Yaku, Sacha Llakta, Ecuador. To remember that the forest has people in it."
On the last day of school, Sam's grandmother came to pick him up, and he showed her the frame.
Bà Nội looked at it for a long time. Then she put her hand on his shoulder.
"Good," she said. "Now you are not only saving a forest. You are making a friend. That is harder. And it lasts longer."
Sam looked at the seed, small and brown and full of a tree that could hold up the sky. He thought about his perspective at the start of the year, how sure he had been, and how much he hadn't known. He decided that was the most important thing he had learned in fifth grade: not that he had been wrong, but that being wrong was where the real learning started.
Check your understanding
Key details What did Yaku's community want to use the money for?
- To buy more land from the charity
- To build a new school
- To buy a drone to help forest guardians spot illegal logging
- To travel to Minnesota
Character Why does Marcus change his mind?
- Ruby wins the argument by shouting
- Ms. Lindgren tells him he is wrong
- Yaku's letter gives him new information about what the community actually wants
- He wants to fly the drone himself
Inference Why does Ms. Lindgren keep the certificate on the wall?
- The protected acres still do some good, and the certificate reminds the class there is more than one way to help
- She forgot to take it down
- She thinks Yaku was wrong
- The charity asked her to keep it up
Theme What does the ceibo seed symbolize for Sam?
- That trees can grow in snow
- That he will become a farmer
- That the forest is a living home for people, and that real help begins by listening to them
- That he should plant a tree in his backyard
Spelling words
These 12 words all appear in the story.
- rainforest
- certificate
- fundraiser
- Indigenous
- guardian
- logging
- community
- ancestors
- assumption
- perspective
- satellite
- territory
Writing prompt
Sam's class first wanted to buy rainforest land, but later decided to support Yaku's community instead. Explain both ideas and the good intentions behind each. Which do you think is the better way for people far away to help protect rainforests? Use at least three details from the story.
Reading skills practiced
Key details, Cause and effect, Inference, Character, Main idea, Vocabulary, Theme.
Answer key for grown-ups
- Twenty-five dollars The charity let people buy an acre for twenty-five dollars.
- He saw a film showing the rainforest being cut down and felt it wasn't fair Watching the scars cut through the forest made him say, "That's not fair."
- She wants Sam to think about whose home the forest is, and whether they've been asked Her question makes Sam realize he never thought about the people living there.
- Proud and excited, believing he is helping save Yaku's forest He mails it "feeling proud."
- His people already protect their forest, and outsiders should ask Indigenous communities before deciding how to help Yaku explains that his people are "the people saving it" and asks Sam to "ask us first."
- An area of land that a group lives on and takes care of The Kichwa patrol their land to watch for illegal loggers and miners.
- Protecting land in a way that keeps out the people who have always lived there harms them, even if the forest is saved Fences and rules can keep Indigenous people from their own homeland.
- Embarrassed and surprised, realizing he made an assumption without asking He feels "like he had been standing on someone else's foot the whole time."
- Even if imperfect, buying land still helps protect the forest, and something is better than nothing He says, "Isn't something better than nothing?"
- The video showed animals, trees, and bulldozers, but no people "The video we watched didn't show any people."
- It shows that his own family experienced being pushed out by a "protection" project, so he sees Yaku's concern is real Her family was removed so a bird park could be made, and no one asked where they'd go.
- "People who save things sometimes forget to look at who is standing there." Bà Nội's words sum up the danger of helping without seeing the people involved.
- To buy a drone to help forest guardians spot illegal logging Yaku explains the drone costs about six hundred dollars and Sisa wants to fly it.
- Yaku's letter gives him new information about what the community actually wants He changes his mind "because Yaku had told them something they hadn't known."
- The protected acres still do some good, and the certificate reminds the class there is more than one way to help She says "The acres are real... the best way usually starts with a question."
- That the forest is a living home for people, and that real help begins by listening to them Its label says "To remember that the forest has people in it."