📚 Reading Quest
📷

The Attention Score

When Westbrook Middle installs smart cameras that give every student a live "attention score," Nadia Rahman is delighted, because her score is the highest in the class. But as her best friend Theo's number keeps dropping, Nadia begins to wonder what the machine is really measuring, and whether she has been fooling it all along.

5th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerSci-fi · School2685 wordsAbout 30 minutes

Read it in the app 🚀

In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.

Words to know

algorithm
a set of step-by-step rules a computer follows to solve a problem or make a decision
pilot
a small first trial of a new program, to see whether it works before using it everywhere
dashboard
a screen that shows important numbers and information at a glance
privacy
the right to keep information about yourself from being watched or shared
interpreter
a person who translates between languages, including sign language, as people speak

Chapter 1: Ninety-Four

I want to be honest from the start, since this whole story is about honesty: when the cameras first arrived, I loved them.

They came over the winter break, small black domes the size of tennis balls, one in each upper corner of every classroom at Westbrook Middle. Our principal, Mr. Osei, explained them at a special assembly on the first day back. He was clearly excited. He kept bouncing on his toes.

"Westbrook has been chosen," he said, "for a pilot program. A trial. These cameras are connected to an algorithm called Focus. Focus watches where your eyes are pointed, how your head is tilted, and how much you move. From that, it calculates an attention score from zero to one hundred, every minute of every lesson. Your teachers will see the scores on a dashboard. And at the end of every week, your families will get a report."

There was a groan from the back of the gym. Mr. Osei smiled patiently.

"I know. It sounds strange. But think about it. If a teacher can see that half the class has drifted off, she knows to try a different way of explaining. If a student's attention drops week after week, we can find out why and help. This isn't about catching anyone. It's about understanding."

I was sitting next to my best friend, Theo Brandt, who had been my best friend since we were five and had shared a cubby. Theo leaned over and whispered, "It's about catching people."

I rolled my eyes at him. Theo was suspicious of everything. He thought the school lunch fish was secretly chicken.

"Think about it," he went on, still whispering. "Who decides what paying attention looks like? A camera can't see inside your head. It can only see the outside."

"It's technology," I whispered back. "It's not guessing. It's math."

"Math somebody wrote," Theo said. "Somebody who's never met me."

At the time, I thought that was just Theo being Theo. Later, I would remember it word for word.

That afternoon, we had our first lesson under the cameras. It was math with Mr. Delgado, who taught fractions as if they had personally insulted him. Everyone sat up very straight. Nobody whispered. Nobody passed notes. Even Jaylen Moss, who usually spent math folding paper footballs, kept his hands flat on his desk like a statue in a museum. It was the quietest math lesson in the history of Westbrook Middle, and I am fairly sure nobody learned anything, because everybody was busy thinking about the little black dome in the corner.

By the next morning, the strangeness had already started to wear off. That is the odd thing about being watched. After a while, you forget that you are, and you start to believe the watching is normal.

The first weekly report came home that Friday. My average attention score was ninety-four, the highest in my grade. My mother stuck it on the refrigerator next to my little sister's crayon drawing of a horse. My father took a photo of it and sent it to my grandparents in Dhaka, who sent back eleven heart emojis.

I am not going to pretend I did not enjoy that. I enjoyed it very much.

What I did not mention to anyone was what I had figured out on the second day: Focus liked stillness. It liked faces turned toward the front of the room. It liked eyes that did not drift down, or sideways, or out of the window. You did not actually have to be listening. You only had to look like you were listening.

So I sat up straight. I pointed my face at the teacher. I kept my eyes wide and my hands folded. And inside my head, a good amount of the time, I was planning what I would draw that evening, or replaying an argument with my sister, or thinking about absolutely nothing.

Ninety-four.

Theo's average was fifty-one.

"What were you even doing?" I asked him at lunch.

"Learning," Theo said, and stabbed his fish. "Same as you."

"Your score says you weren't."

He looked at me then, a long, flat look I did not like. "Yeah," he said. "It does say that, doesn't it?"

Check your understanding

  1. Inference Why does the narrator say "I want to be honest from the start"?

    1. She wants to sound like a news reporter
    2. She is admitting she was not completely honest at the time, which hints that her early view of the cameras was flawed
    3. She is copying something Mr. Osei said
    4. She is about to tell a joke
  2. Key details What does the Focus algorithm look at to calculate an attention score?

    1. How many questions a student answers correctly
    2. Where a student's eyes point, how the head is tilted, and how much the student moves
    3. How loudly a student speaks in class
    4. The student's homework grades
  3. Character What is the narrator's secret about her score of ninety-four?

    1. She hacked the computer to change it
    2. She learned to look attentive while often thinking about other things
    3. She actually scored much lower
    4. Theo gave her his points
  4. Inference What does Theo's "long, flat look" suggest?

    1. He is jealous of the narrator's drawing
    2. He is hurt that the narrator trusts the score more than she trusts him
    3. He didn't hear what she said
    4. He has decided he doesn't like fish

Chapter 2: The Fidget Problem

Here is the thing about Theo that the Focus algorithm did not know: he could not think while sitting still.

I had known this for years. In second grade he used to spin his pencil so fast it blurred. In fourth grade, our teacher let him stand at a tall table in the back during math, and he went from failing to the top of the class in a single term. Theo had ADHD, which he explained to me once as "my brain has more tabs open than yours, and they all have sound." Moving helped him close some of the tabs. When he was allowed to fidget, he could concentrate. When his foot bounced and his fingers twisted a rubber band, he was concentrating harder, not less.

Focus saw the bouncing foot and the twisting fingers and the glances down at his notebook, and it wrote: distracted.

By the third week, Theo's score had dropped to forty-four. His parents got a phone call. They had a meeting with Mr. Osei and the school counselor. Theo was told, kindly but firmly, to try to "keep his body calm" during lessons.

He tried. I watched him try. He sat on his hands in science. He held his breath when he felt the urge to move. His score went up to sixty.

His test grades went down.

"It's like trying to read with someone poking you," he told me on the bus. He looked exhausted. "All I'm thinking about is not moving. I don't hear a word Ms. Kowalczyk says."

"Maybe it gets easier with practice," I said.

He turned and stared out of the window and didn't answer, and we rode the rest of the way in silence.

That night, I couldn't stop thinking about what he'd said. All I'm thinking about is not moving. That was exactly what I was doing too, wasn't it? Except that I was good at it, and it didn't cost me anything, so I had never noticed it was a trick.

The next day, I started paying attention to something else: other people's scores.

Teachers weren't supposed to show the dashboard to students, but Ms. Kowalczyk, our science teacher, often left her laptop open on the front desk while she helped people. Little green, yellow, and red circles glowed next to every name. I studied them sideways while I pretended to sharpen my pencil.

Most of the green circles belonged to the quiet, still students, the ones who were good at sitting. Some of them, I knew for a fact, were not quiet because they were listening. Ines Ferreira was reading a novel hidden inside her textbook, and she was green. Marcus Bell was nearly asleep with his eyes open, and he was green.

And Daniel Okafor was red.

Daniel was deaf. He had a sign language interpreter, Ms. Perez, who sat at the side of the room and signed everything the teacher said. Daniel watched Ms. Perez the whole lesson, because that was how he heard it. His head was turned to the side. His eyes were not on the front of the room.

Focus scored him thirty-eight. Distracted.

I stood there holding my pencil, and I felt cold all over, as if someone had opened a window behind me.

The cameras weren't measuring attention. They were measuring what attention looked like on a certain kind of person. And anyone who listened differently—with their hands moving, or with their eyes on an interpreter—was being marked as not listening at all.

Check your understanding

  1. Cause and effect What happened when Theo tried to "keep his body calm"?

    1. His score and his test grades both went up
    2. His attention score improved, but his test grades dropped because he was focused on not moving
    3. He was moved to a different class
    4. He stopped needing to move at all
  2. Vocabulary Theo describes ADHD as "my brain has more tabs open than yours, and they all have sound." What is he comparing his brain to?

    1. A crowded music class
    2. A computer browser with many windows open at once, all competing for attention
    3. A broken television
    4. A library with too many books
  3. Main idea What important discovery does the narrator make in Ms. Kowalczyk's classroom?

    1. That the dashboard is broken
    2. That Daniel is cheating
    3. That Focus rewards students who look still and forward-facing, even if they are not listening, and punishes students who listen in different ways
    4. That teachers can change the scores
  4. Inference Why does the narrator feel "cold all over" when she sees Daniel's score?

    1. The air conditioning is too strong
    2. She suddenly understands that the system is unfair to people who learn differently, and that her own high score was part of the same flaw
    3. She is afraid Ms. Kowalczyk will catch her looking
    4. She is coming down with a fever

Chapter 3: The Experiment

I am a scientist's daughter—my mother studies soil, of all things—and in our house, if you think something is true, you test it.

So I designed an experiment.

For one full week, I would do everything I could to actually learn. I would take notes by hand, which meant looking down. I would draw diagrams in the margin, the way I always remembered things best. When I had a question, I would turn to my lab partner and whisper it. I would listen with my whole brain instead of my whole face.

And I would keep a record. Every evening, I would write down three things I had learned that day in each class, and test myself on them.

The following week, I would do the opposite. I would sit like a statue and stare at the front, and look attentive, and let my mind wander wherever it wanted.

I told Theo about it. He was quiet for a moment, then said, "If you get a bad score, your parents will freak out."

"Then they'll freak out," I said. "It's for science."

He looked at me in a new way, as if he was seeing something he had been waiting for. "I'll be your control group," he said. "I'll go back to moving. Like before."

Week one was hard. Really hard, actually, in a way I didn't expect. Real listening is tiring. My hand cramped from writing. But on Friday, I could explain photosynthesis, the causes of the War of 1812, and how to divide fractions, and I could draw a diagram of a plant cell from memory.

My Focus score for the week: sixty-one.

Week two was easy. I sat still. I stared. I went somewhere else in my head. On Friday, I tried to write down what I had learned, and I had almost nothing. A few words. A date I wasn't sure about.

My Focus score for the week: ninety-six. A new record.

Theo, moving and fidgeting and learning, had scored forty-nine and gotten a ninety-two on his science test.

When my report came home with a sixty-one on it, my mother looked at it for a long time. Then she looked at me.

"Explain," she said.

So I showed her my notebook. Both weeks. The pages full of diagrams and notes and self-tests from week one, and the nearly empty pages of week two. I explained about Theo, and the tall table in fourth grade, and Daniel and Ms. Perez. I explained that I had been tricking the cameras from the very first day, and that the ninety-four on the refrigerator was the least honest number in the house.

I thought she would be disappointed. I was ready for that.

Instead, she took the old report off the refrigerator, folded it in half, and set it on the table between us like a piece of evidence.

"So what you're telling me," she said slowly, "is that the instrument is measuring the wrong variable."

"Yes."

"And that the people relying on it don't know."

"Yes."

My mother, who studies soil, who once spent six months proving that a fertilizer company's measurements were wrong, leaned back in her chair and smiled the most dangerous smile I have ever seen.

"Well," she said. "We had better tell them."

Check your understanding

  1. Sequence Put the narrator's experiment in order.

    1. She tried to truly learn for a week, then sat still and let her mind wander for a week, then compared her scores to what she remembered
    2. She sat still for a week, then fidgeted for a week, then asked Theo for his scores
    3. She asked her mother for permission, then hacked the cameras, then compared results
    4. She took a test, then watched Daniel, then changed her seat
  2. Key details What were the narrator's scores in the two weeks of her experiment?

    1. Ninety-four and fifty-one
    2. Sixty-one when she was really learning and ninety-six when she was only pretending
    3. Ninety-six both weeks
    4. Forty-nine and ninety-two
  3. Character How has the narrator changed since Chapter 1?

    1. She has become more interested in her score than ever
    2. She has gone from proudly gaming the system to testing it honestly and being willing to give up her high score for the truth
    3. She has stopped being friends with Theo
    4. She has decided she hates school
  4. Inference What does the narrator's mother mean by "the instrument is measuring the wrong variable"?

    1. The cameras are broken and need repair
    2. The cameras are measuring how still someone looks, not whether they are actually learning
    3. The cameras should measure height instead
    4. Nadia's experiment was done incorrectly

Chapter 4: What Gets Measured

The school board met on the second Tuesday of every month in the library, under fluorescent lights that buzzed. Usually about six people came. That Tuesday, there were forty.

Word had gotten around. My mother had made some phone calls. Theo's parents had made more. Daniel's mother came, and Ms. Perez, the interpreter, came to interpret for her. Several teachers came, including Ms. Kowalczyk, who sat in the back with her arms folded and an expression I could not read.

When it was time for public comments, I walked up to the microphone. My knees felt like they were made of water.

I didn't make a speech about privacy, though people later did, and good ones. I didn't say the cameras were evil, because I didn't think they were. I just told the truth. I held up my two notebooks. I read out my two scores. I explained what I had done in each week. I said that for two months I had been the "most attentive" student in my grade, and that much of the time I hadn't been listening at all.

"Focus taught me something," I said. "It taught me how to look like I'm learning. That's a skill. But it's not the skill school is supposed to teach."

Then Theo came up, and he talked about the tall table. And Daniel came up, with Ms. Perez beside him, and signed, and she spoke his words: "I pay attention with my eyes. Your camera wants my eyes in the wrong place."

After that, the room filled with voices. A father in a work jacket said he didn't want any company storing videos of his daughter's face, and asked who owned the recordings and how long they would be kept. Nobody on the board was completely sure, which made the room go quiet in an uncomfortable way. A grandmother said that in her day, teachers just threw chalk at sleepy children, and at least this was kinder. Some people laughed. A mother said her son's score had gone up, and he was proud, and she didn't want that taken away from him. I understood that. I had been proud too.

That was what surprised me most about the meeting. It wasn't heroes against villains. It was a room full of people who each could see one part of the problem clearly and the rest of it hardly at all. Even I had only noticed the problem because it happened to my best friend. If Theo had scored ninety, I might still have that report on the refrigerator.

Then Mr. Osei stood up.

I had been dreading this. I thought he would be angry. Instead, he looked tired and very serious.

"I want to say something," he said, "and I want to say it carefully. I brought Focus to this school because I believed it would help. I still believe some of the reasons were good. Teachers are responsible for thirty students at once. They can't see everything. A tool that helps them notice who is struggling could matter." He paused. "But a tool that tells a deaf student he isn't listening, and tells a student with ADHD to stop doing the very thing that helps him learn, is not helping. It's doing harm while looking helpful. And that's worse than doing nothing, because people trust it."

He turned to me. "Nadia, I want to thank you. And I want to apologize to Theo, and to Daniel, and to their families."

The board voted to pause the pilot program and review it. Not to cancel it forever—some board members thought it could be fixed—but to switch off the cameras until it had been studied by people who understood how different kids learn.

Afterward, in the parking lot, Ms. Kowalczyk came up to me.

"I want you to know," she said quietly, "I stopped looking at that dashboard after the first week."

I stared at her. "Why?"

"Because I've been teaching for twenty-two years," she said. "And I already knew how to tell who was listening. You ask them a question, and you listen to their answer." She smiled. "Your score went down that week you were really learning. Did you notice your science grade went up?"

I hadn't noticed. I had been too busy looking at the wrong number.

"So the cameras can't measure learning at all?" I asked.

"They can measure something," she said. "Everything measures something. The trick is remembering what it doesn't measure. Most people forget that part." She jingled her car keys. "Keep asking that question, Nadia. Not just about cameras. About grades, too. About everything with a number on it."

The cameras are still in the corners of the classrooms. They're switched off now, little black domes that watch nothing. Sometimes I look up at one in the middle of a lesson and wonder what it would say about me. Then I go back to drawing diagrams in the margin, with my head down, listening.

My mother framed the sixty-one. It's on the refrigerator, next to my sister's horse.

Check your understanding

  1. Main idea What is the main point of Nadia's speech to the school board?

    1. That the cameras invade students' privacy
    2. That Focus taught her to look like she was learning instead of actually learning, so it measured the wrong thing
    3. That Mr. Osei should lose his job
    4. That she deserves a reward for her high score
  2. Character How does Mr. Osei respond at the meeting?

    1. He angrily defends the cameras and blames Nadia
    2. He admits that the tool did harm while looking helpful, and apologizes, while explaining why he first thought it would help
    3. He refuses to speak
    4. He announces that the cameras will be used in every school
  3. Inference Why do you think Nadia's mother framed the sixty-one?

    1. She was embarrassed by the ninety-four
    2. It represents real learning and honesty, which matter more to the family than a high number
    3. Sixty-one is her lucky number
    4. She wanted to remind Nadia to work harder
  4. Theme Which theme does the story develop across all four chapters?

    1. Technology is always harmful and should be banned
    2. Teachers do not need any help in the classroom
    3. What can easily be measured is not always what matters most, and judging people by a number can hide the truth about them
    4. Good students always have high scores

Spelling words

These 12 words all appear in the story.

  • attention
  • algorithm
  • pilot
  • dashboard
  • average
  • privacy
  • measure
  • concentrate
  • interpreter
  • fidget
  • honest
  • technology

Writing prompt

Should schools use technology to measure how well students are paying attention? Write an argument for or against, using at least two examples from the story. Then explain one way the technology could be changed to be fairer.

Reading skills practiced

Inference, Key details, Character, Cause and effect, Vocabulary, Main idea, Sequence, Theme.

Answer key for grown-ups
  1. She is admitting she was not completely honest at the time, which hints that her early view of the cameras was flawed Her opening warns readers that this is a story about honesty and that her younger self had something to hide.
  2. Where a student's eyes point, how the head is tilted, and how much the student moves Mr. Osei explains that Focus watches eyes, head position, and movement.
  3. She learned to look attentive while often thinking about other things She discovers that Focus rewards stillness and a forward-facing face, not real listening.
  4. He is hurt that the narrator trusts the score more than she trusts him Nadia judges him by the score, and his look shows he feels misjudged by his own best friend.
  5. His attention score improved, but his test grades dropped because he was focused on not moving Sitting still made the camera happy but made real learning harder for him.
  6. A computer browser with many windows open at once, all competing for attention Like browser tabs that all play sounds, many thoughts compete in his mind at once.
  7. That Focus rewards students who look still and forward-facing, even if they are not listening, and punishes students who listen in different ways Ines and Marcus score green while not paying attention, and Daniel scores red while following the interpreter.
  8. She suddenly understands that the system is unfair to people who learn differently, and that her own high score was part of the same flaw The cold feeling shows the shock of realizing the system she trusted is unjust.
  9. She tried to truly learn for a week, then sat still and let her mind wander for a week, then compared her scores to what she remembered Week one was real learning (score 61); week two was looking attentive (score 96).
  10. Sixty-one when she was really learning and ninety-six when she was only pretending The scores went the opposite way from how much she actually learned.
  11. She has gone from proudly gaming the system to testing it honestly and being willing to give up her high score for the truth She accepts a lower score and admits her trick to her mother.
  12. The cameras are measuring how still someone looks, not whether they are actually learning In science terms, Focus measures appearance instead of real attention or learning.
  13. That Focus taught her to look like she was learning instead of actually learning, so it measured the wrong thing She uses her two notebooks and scores as evidence that looking attentive is not the same as learning.
  14. He admits that the tool did harm while looking helpful, and apologizes, while explaining why he first thought it would help His response shows that someone with good intentions can recognize a mistake.
  15. It represents real learning and honesty, which matter more to the family than a high number The lower score was the honest one, earned by actually learning.
  16. What can easily be measured is not always what matters most, and judging people by a number can hide the truth about them From Theo's low score to Nadia's experiment to Ms. Kowalczyk's comment, the story shows the danger of trusting the wrong number.

More 5th grade stories

🌿

The Hedgerow

Maisie Thornbury's father plans to tear out the ancient hedge that splits their two biggest fields, so the farm can use a larger harvester and pay its debts. Maisie…

5th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerFarm · Nature16 questions
🛶

Wayfinder

Kaimana has always felt like the least useful person on her grandfather's voyaging canoe. On a training voyage across open ocean with no compass and no screens, a…

5th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerOcean · Culture16 questions
🧵

The Turn-Out

In 1836, eleven-year-old Abby Fletcher changes bobbins in a roaring cotton mill in Lowell, Massachusetts, where her older sister Hannah is a weaver. When the mill…

5th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerHistory · Justice16 questions
🦴

What I Saw at the Museum

On a class trip to the natural history museum, a 450-million-year-old trilobite fossil goes missing from the touch table, and Owen Pryce is absolutely certain he saw…

5th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerMystery · School16 questions
🚴

The Climb to Alto del Sol

In the mountains of Boyacá, Colombia, twelve-year-old Valentina trains every morning to climb like the great Colombian cyclists. Her cousin Andrés is suddenly flying up…

5th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerSports · Family16 questions
🏔️

The Road to Sangu

For centuries, everything that reached the Himalayan village of Sangu came on the backs of mules, and Pemba's father leads the best mule train in the valley. Now…

5th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerVillage · Culture16 questions