The Windmill That Ran Dry
Mari's grandfather planted the family's almond orchard forty years ago, when water flowed easily from the ground. Now, in the fourth year of a drought, the trees are thirsty and the family well is sputtering. Drilling a deeper well could save the orchard, but Mari discovers it might also take water from the neighbors, and her family must decide what they owe to the people around them.
5th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeyFarm · Family · Climate2578 wordsAbout 30 minutes
In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.
Words to know
- drought
- a long period with much less rain than usual
- aquifer
- a layer of rock, sand, or gravel underground that holds water
- groundwater
- water stored underground in soil and rock
- irrigation
- bringing water to crops through pipes, ditches, or sprinklers
- sacrifice
- giving up something you value for the sake of something more important
Chapter 1: Forty Years of Almonds
The windmill at the edge of the Ortega orchard had not turned in twenty years.
It was tall and skinny, made of crisscrossing metal beams, with a wheel of rusted blades at the top that creaked when the wind blew but no longer spun. Marisela Ortega, whom everyone called Mari, had climbed it once when she was eight and gotten into enormous trouble.
"That windmill used to pump all our water," Grandpa Ortega told her, the summer she turned eleven. They were standing in its thin shadow, looking out over the orchard. "When I bought this land in 1984, you only had to dig twenty feet to hit water. The windmill brought it up, slow and steady. Twenty feet! Imagine."
Mari tried to imagine. Now the family's electric well pump pulled water from more than three hundred feet underground.
The orchard stretched out in front of them: forty acres of almond trees in perfectly straight rows, their gray branches dusty in the heat. Every February, the trees burst into clouds of white and pink blossoms, so thick and sweet-smelling that bees came from miles around. Every August, the shakers came, big machines that grabbed each trunk and shook it until the almonds rained down onto the ground like hail.
Grandpa had planted every one of those trees with his own hands, back when he was a young man who had come to California's Central Valley from Mexico with almost nothing. He had worked on other people's farms for ten years, saving every dollar, until he could buy forty acres of his own. The orchard was his life's work. Mari's father ran the farm now, but Grandpa still walked the rows every morning, touching the trunks like old friends.
This was the fourth year of the drought.
The valley usually got its rain in winter, and snow piled up in the mountains to the east. In spring, the snow melted and filled the rivers and canals that watered the farms. But for four winters, almost no rain had fallen, and the mountains had been nearly bare. The canals were low. Farmers had to pump more and more water from underground to keep their crops alive.
Mari had learned about groundwater in science class. Under the valley, her teacher explained, was an aquifer: a huge layer of sand and gravel soaked with water, like a giant sponge. For thousands of years, rain and rivers had slowly filled it up. But when farmers and towns pumped water out faster than rain could put it back, the water level dropped lower and lower.
"That's why the windmill stopped," Mari said. "The water went down too far for it to reach."
Grandpa nodded slowly. "And now our pump is starting to struggle too."
It was true. For the last two weeks, the well had been sputtering, coughing up air and sand along with water. Some days, it gave only half as much as it used to. The thirsty almond trees were beginning to show it, even with the irrigation drips running all night. Their leaves curled at the edges and turned yellow. A few of the youngest trees near the road had dropped their nuts early, small and shriveled.
That night, Mari's father sat at the kitchen table with papers spread everywhere. Her mother sat across from him. Mari sat on the stairs where they couldn't see her, listening.
"A deeper well," her father was saying. "Six hundred feet. It's the only way. Otherwise we lose the orchard."
"Do you know how much that costs?" her mother said.
"I know exactly how much it costs. I also know how much forty years of trees are worth."
Mari crept back up to bed. Through her window, she could see the windmill against the stars, its blades dark and still.
Check your understanding
Key details How deep did Grandpa have to dig to find water in 1984?
- Twenty feet
- Three hundred feet
- Six hundred feet
- Two hundred feet
Vocabulary Mari's teacher compares the aquifer to "a giant sponge." What does this comparison help explain?
- That the aquifer is soft and squishy
- That the aquifer is a layer underground that holds water in its spaces, like a sponge holds water
- That the aquifer can be squeezed by hand
- That the aquifer is used for cleaning
Cause and effect Why did the old windmill stop working?
- A storm broke its blades
- Grandpa replaced it with a newer one on purpose
- The groundwater level dropped too low for the windmill to reach it
- The family stopped needing water
Inference Why does Mari's father say he knows "how much forty years of trees are worth"?
- He plans to sell the trees for wood
- The orchard is Grandpa's life's work and the family's livelihood, worth more than money alone
- He has calculated the price of every almond
- He wants to buy a new orchard
Chapter 2: Mrs. Kessler's Faucet
The well drilling company came out the following Tuesday to look at the land. The driller was a sunburned man named Mr. Hargrove, who had been drilling wells in the valley for thirty years. He walked around the old pump, shaking his head.
"Everybody's going deeper," he said. "I've got a waiting list four months long. The big farms down the road just went to nine hundred feet."
"Nine hundred?" Mari's father said.
"They've got the money." Mr. Hargrove shrugged. "Thing is, when the big wells go deep, the water level drops for everybody. It's all one aquifer. Like a bunch of kids drinking from one milkshake with long straws. Whoever's got the longest straw gets the last of it."
Mari didn't like that idea at all.
On Saturday, she rode her bike down the dirt road to deliver a basket of tomatoes to Mrs. Kessler, an elderly widow who lived in a small white house at the end of the lane. Mrs. Kessler had taught third grade at Mari's school for thirty-five years. She knew the name of every child in the valley, and their parents', and usually their grandparents'.
When Mari knocked, Mrs. Kessler opened the door looking tired. Behind her, on the kitchen counter, stood a row of plastic jugs full of water.
"Come in, honey," she said. "Watch your step. I've got buckets everywhere."
"What happened?" Mari asked.
Mrs. Kessler sighed and turned on the kitchen faucet. Nothing came out except a gurgle and a puff of air.
"My well went dry last week," she said. "It's only a hundred and twenty feet deep. It was dug in 1962, and it never gave me a lick of trouble until now. But all the big new wells around here have pulled the water down past it." She smiled weakly. "The church brings me water in those jugs. I flush the toilet with a bucket. It's like camping, at my age."
Mari stared at the empty faucet. "Can't you drill a deeper well?"
"Sweetheart, that would cost more than my house is worth." Mrs. Kessler patted her hand. "Don't you worry. The county says they'll connect us all to the town water system someday. Maybe in three years. Maybe five."
Mari biked home slowly, thinking. She thought about Mr. Hargrove's milkshake straws. She thought about her father's plan for a six-hundred-foot well. If the Ortegas went deeper, would someone else's faucet run dry? Was it already happening because of the big farms? Was it fair to blame them, when her own family was about to do the same thing?
She found Grandpa in the orchard, walking the rows as usual.
"Grandpa," she said. "Mrs. Kessler's well went dry."
He stopped walking. He stood very still for a long moment under the almond trees.
"Mrs. Kessler," he said quietly. "She taught your father to read."
"If we dig a deeper well," Mari said, "won't the water go down even more? For everybody?"
Grandpa didn't answer right away. He reached up and touched a branch, rubbing a curled yellow leaf between his fingers.
"Mija," he said finally, "when I came here, I had nothing. Your grandmother and I lived in a trailer with no air conditioning. We worked so hard. Every one of these trees is a year of my life." His voice cracked a little. "And you are asking me to let them die."
"I'm not asking that," Mari said, her throat tight. "I don't know what I'm asking."
Grandpa looked at her for a long time. Then he did something unexpected. He put his hand on her head, gently, the way he used to when she was small.
"No," he said. "But you're asking the right question. That's harder."
Check your understanding
Key details What did Mari see on Mrs. Kessler's kitchen counter?
- A basket of almonds
- A row of plastic jugs full of water
- A broken faucet
- Photographs of her students
Vocabulary Mr. Hargrove compares the wells to "kids drinking from one milkshake with long straws." What does he mean?
- All the wells share one aquifer, and the deepest wells can take water that shallow wells can no longer reach
- Farmers like to drink milkshakes
- Wells are shaped like straws
- Everyone should share drinks
Cause and effect Why did Mrs. Kessler's well go dry?
- She used too much water in her garden
- Her pump broke
- Nearby farms drilled deeper wells and pulled the water level below her shallow well
- The county shut off her water
Inference Why does Grandpa say "you're asking the right question. That's harder"?
- He is angry at Mari
- He sees that Mari is thinking about fairness to others, even though there is no easy answer
- He thinks the question is a trick
- He has already decided to drill the well
Chapter 3: The Science Fair Map
Mari couldn't stop thinking about the milkshake. For the school science fair that fall, she decided to make a project about the aquifer.
She called it "Who Gets the Water?" She went around the valley with her mother, visiting farmers and neighbors and asking how deep their wells were and when they had been drilled. She found old county records at the library. Then she built a model out of a clear plastic box filled with layers of sand and gravel. She poured in blue-colored water. Then she pushed a row of drinking straws down into the sand at different depths, some shallow and some deep.
When she sucked water out through the deep straws, the blue line in the box sank lower and lower. Soon, the shallow straws were sucking only air.
She also made a big map of the valley, with a colored pin for every well she had found. Red pins for wells that had gone dry. There were thirty-one red pins. Almost all of them belonged to small houses and small farms, like Mrs. Kessler's.
Mari's father came to the science fair. He stood in front of the map for a long time without saying anything. Then he put his finger on a red pin very close to their own farm.
"That's the Garcias' house," he said. "Their well's dry too?"
"Since August," Mari said. "They've borrowed water from their cousins in town ever since."
Her father was quiet. Mari could see him thinking, the same way she had been thinking for weeks.
"Do you think I'm wrong to want the deeper well?" he asked her. Mari was surprised. Her father didn't usually ask her opinion about the farm.
She thought carefully before she answered.
"I don't think you're wrong," she said. "I think you're trying to protect our family. That's your job. And if we don't drill, the big farms will keep drilling anyway. So maybe it doesn't matter what we do." She looked at the red pins. "But I think if everybody says that, then nobody stops, and everyone's well goes dry eventually. Even the deep ones. The aquifer doesn't care how much money you have. It just runs out."
Her father looked at her for a long moment.
"When did you get so smart?" he said.
"Science fair," Mari said, and he laughed, even though his eyes looked sad.
That night, Mari heard her parents and grandfather talking late into the night. The next morning, her father called Mr. Hargrove and told him to cancel the new well. Then he called a meeting.
He invited every farmer and neighbor whose name was on Mari's map: the big farms, the small farms, Mrs. Kessler, the Garcias, everybody. More than forty people crowded into the community hall. Mari's map and model were set up at the front.
Some people were angry. A man who managed one of the big farms said that he had paid for his well legally and could pump whatever he wanted. "It's my land," he said. "It's my water."
"The water under your land," said Mrs. Kessler, standing up slowly with her cane, "is also under mine. That's what an aquifer is. We're all standing on the same sponge."
People murmured. Some nodded. Some crossed their arms.
Then Grandpa stood up.
Everyone went quiet. Grandpa rarely spoke at meetings. He was not comfortable speaking English in front of crowds, and Mari could see his hands shaking a little.
"Forty years ago," he said, "I dug my first well twenty feet. My windmill pumped it. Now it is rusted. That windmill is a warning." He paused. "We can keep making the straws longer. But one day there will be no milkshake left. Not for my grandchildren. Not for yours."
He sat down. For a moment, nobody said anything at all.
Check your understanding
Main idea What does Mari's science fair project show?
- How to make the best milkshake
- That deep wells pump the shared aquifer down, leaving shallow wells, often small homes and farms, dry
- That almond trees need more water than other trees
- That the drought is ending
Character How does Mari answer when her father asks if he is wrong?
- She tells him he is selfish
- She respects his reasons for protecting the family, but explains why everyone drilling deeper will hurt everyone in the end
- She refuses to answer
- She agrees he should drill the deepest well possible
Inference What does Grandpa mean when he says "That windmill is a warning"?
- The windmill might fall down and hurt someone
- The rusted windmill shows how far the water has dropped, and what could happen again if people keep overpumping
- The windmill should be repaired
- The windmill makes too much noise
Sequence What does Mari's father do right after the night of the science fair?
- He drills the new well
- He cancels the new well and calls a meeting of everyone on Mari's map
- He sells the farm
- He visits Mrs. Kessler
Chapter 4: The Hardest Harvest
The meeting did not solve everything. Meetings rarely do.
But it started something. Over the next months, the farmers and neighbors in the valley formed a group. They agreed to measure how much water each well pumped, and to share the information openly. The big farms agreed, grudgingly, to pump a little less during the driest months. Everyone agreed to chip in money for a water truck that would deliver to families whose wells had gone dry, until the county could connect them to the town system.
It wasn't perfect. Some farms refused to join. The man from the big farm who had said "It's my water" never came to another meeting. And the drought did not end.
For the Ortega family, the decision was the hardest one they had ever made.
Without a deeper well, there wasn't enough water for all forty acres of almonds. So in January, Mari's father and grandfather walked the orchard together and chose which trees would stay and which would go. They kept the healthiest twenty-five acres, closest to the house. The other fifteen acres, the oldest trees near the road, would be pulled out.
On the day the bulldozer came, Grandpa stood by the fence and watched. He did not say a word. Mari stood beside him and held his hand. When the first old tree fell, with a long cracking groan, she felt him flinch.
"I'm sorry, Grandpa," she whispered.
"Don't be sorry," he said, though his voice was rough. "A sacrifice is only sad if it's for nothing. This isn't for nothing."
Where the old trees had stood, Mari's father planted something new. Some of the land he left fallow, letting native grasses and wildflowers grow, which needed no watering at all. On the rest, he planted rows of a desert crop that could survive on very little water. It would never make as much money as almonds. But it wouldn't take water from Mrs. Kessler's faucet, either.
That spring, a surprising thing happened. In the fallow fields, the wildflowers bloomed so thickly that the land turned orange and purple. Bees came, and butterflies, and a pair of burrowing owls that made their home in an old ground squirrel hole. Grandpa started walking those rows too, every morning, alongside the almonds.
In April, the county finally began laying pipes to connect Mrs. Kessler's road to the town water system. The work had been sped up, the newspaper said, because a group of farmers and neighbors had written letters and shown up at meetings, again and again, with a map full of red pins.
On the day the water was connected, Mrs. Kessler invited Mari over. She turned on the kitchen faucet with a flourish, like a magician pulling a rabbit out of a hat. Water gushed out, clear and cold.
"Look at that," she said, her eyes bright. "I'd almost forgotten what it sounds like."
As Mari biked home along the dirt road, she passed the old windmill. She stopped and looked up at it. The rusted blades creaked in the warm wind.
For years, she had thought of the windmill as sad: a broken thing, a reminder of what was lost. Now she saw it differently. It was more like a lighthouse. It stood at the edge of the farm to remind them how far the water had fallen, and how far they still had to climb to bring it back.
That evening, she asked her father if they could keep the windmill forever, and never take it down.
"Even though it doesn't work?" he asked.
"It does work," Mari said. "It just does a different job now."
Her father looked at the windmill, then at her, and nodded. "All right," he said. "It stays."
Mari thought about how she had felt when she first heard her parents talking at the kitchen table, frightened and confused, sure there was no right answer. There still wasn't, not a perfect one. But she had learned that being responsible didn't mean finding a choice that cost nothing. It meant choosing what you were willing to give up, and why.
Check your understanding
Key details What did the Ortega family plant where the old almond trees had been?
- More almond trees
- Wildflowers and native grasses on some land, and a desert crop that needs little water on the rest
- Grapes and oranges
- Nothing at all, leaving bare dirt
Inference What does Grandpa mean when he says "A sacrifice is only sad if it's for nothing"?
- He doesn't care about the old trees
- Losing the trees still hurts, but it has meaning because it helps protect the water for others
- He wants to cut down all the trees
- He thinks the bulldozer is wasteful
Theme How does the meaning of the windmill change for Mari by the end of the story?
- She thinks it should be torn down
- At first it seems like a sad, broken thing, but she comes to see it as a lighthouse-like reminder to protect the water
- She thinks it should be repaired to pump water again
- She forgets about it completely
Theme Which statement best expresses the story's main message?
- Families should always protect their own property first
- Being responsible means being willing to give something up when your choices affect other people
- Farming is too difficult in dry places
- Science fairs can solve every problem
Spelling words
These 12 words all appear in the story.
- drought
- orchard
- groundwater
- irrigation
- neighbor
- aquifer
- shallow
- thirsty
- rusted
- borrowed
- responsible
- sacrifice
Writing prompt
The Ortega family chose not to drill a deeper well, even though it meant losing part of their orchard. Was this the right decision? Explain both sides of the argument, then give your opinion with at least three reasons from the story.
Reading skills practiced
Key details, Vocabulary, Cause and effect, Inference, Main idea, Character, Sequence, Theme.
Answer key for grown-ups
- Twenty feet Grandpa says, "you only had to dig twenty feet to hit water."
- That the aquifer is a layer underground that holds water in its spaces, like a sponge holds water Like a sponge, the sand and gravel of an aquifer soak up and hold water.
- The groundwater level dropped too low for the windmill to reach it Mari realizes "the water went down too far for it to reach."
- The orchard is Grandpa's life's work and the family's livelihood, worth more than money alone The trees mean decades of family work as well as income.
- A row of plastic jugs full of water Mrs. Kessler's well has gone dry, so she uses water from jugs.
- All the wells share one aquifer, and the deepest wells can take water that shallow wells can no longer reach The longest straw "gets the last of it," just as the deepest wells get the last water.
- Nearby farms drilled deeper wells and pulled the water level below her shallow well She explains that the big new wells "pulled the water down past it."
- He sees that Mari is thinking about fairness to others, even though there is no easy answer Asking how their choices affect neighbors is the right question, even if it makes the decision harder.
- That deep wells pump the shared aquifer down, leaving shallow wells, often small homes and farms, dry Her model and map show deep straws draining the water from shallow ones.
- She respects his reasons for protecting the family, but explains why everyone drilling deeper will hurt everyone in the end She sees both sides before giving her opinion.
- The rusted windmill shows how far the water has dropped, and what could happen again if people keep overpumping It stopped because the water sank, a sign of what is happening to all the wells.
- He cancels the new well and calls a meeting of everyone on Mari's map The next morning he calls Mr. Hargrove to cancel and then calls a meeting.
- Wildflowers and native grasses on some land, and a desert crop that needs little water on the rest Part of the land was left fallow and part was planted with a low-water crop.
- Losing the trees still hurts, but it has meaning because it helps protect the water for others He grieves the trees but believes the reason makes the loss worthwhile.
- At first it seems like a sad, broken thing, but she comes to see it as a lighthouse-like reminder to protect the water She says it "does a different job now" by reminding everyone how far the water has fallen.
- Being responsible means being willing to give something up when your choices affect other people Mari learns that being responsible means choosing what to give up, and why.