📚 Reading Quest
🔋

The Second-Best Invention

Hana Sato and Dev Raman have been rivals since second grade, and this year only one of them can win the city's Young Inventors Fair. Hana is building a pill box for her grandmother. Dev is building beeping tags for his great-uncle, who loses everything. Told by both of them, this is the story of a dead battery, a hard choice, and two old people who know much more than they are saying.

4th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonFriends · Inventors2243 wordsAbout 30 minutes

Read it in the app 🚀

In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.

Words to know

prototype
the first working model of an invention, built to test the idea
circuit
a path that electricity flows around, connecting the parts of a machine
rival
someone you compete against again and again
partnership
two or more people working together as a team
engineer
a person who designs and builds machines, tools or structures

Chapter 1: Hana

The first time I lost to Dev Raman was in second grade, in the paper airplane contest. My plane flew farther, but his did a loop. The judges liked the loop.

Since then, we have competed at everything. Spelling bees. Times tables. The fourth-grade bridge-building challenge, where his popsicle-stick bridge held eleven pounds and mine held eleven and a half, and he said my glue wasn't dry yet so it didn't count. It counted.

So when Ms. Okonkwo announced that our school could send two students to the city's Young Inventors Fair, and only the top prize would go on to the state competition, I knew who I'd be up against before she even finished talking.

"An invention that solves a real problem for a real person," Ms. Okonkwo said. "Not a robot that pours cereal. A real problem."

Everyone in the class turned around to look at Dev, and then at me. Ms. Okonkwo sighed. Even the teachers knew. Dev was not just a classmate. He was my rival, the way the sea is the rival of a sandcastle.

I knew my real person right away.

My grandmother, Kiyo Sato, lives in the Linden Tower apartments, across the park from us. She was an electrical engineer for forty years, and she still fixes every toaster in the building. But lately she forgets things. Not big things. Little things, like whether she has taken her heart pills. Sometimes she takes them twice. Sometimes she doesn't take them at all, and my mother calls her every evening and asks, "Did you take them, Okaasan?" and Grandma says, "Of course," and my mother doesn't know whether to believe her.

It was actually Grandma who gave me the idea. "Build me a box that tattles on me," she said, while she was teaching me to solder on her kitchen table. "That would solve your mother's problem and mine."

So I designed PillPal. It's a small box with seven little doors, one for each day. A tiny circuit inside tells whether each door has been opened. At eight o'clock every morning, the right door lights up and plays a soft chime. If the door doesn't open by nine, PillPal sends a text message to my mother's phone. If a door opens twice in one day, it beeps a warning.

The hardest part was the battery. My first prototype ran down in a day and a half, because the chip inside was awake all the time, checking and checking. Grandma showed me how to put the chip to sleep, so it only wakes up for a split second every minute to check the doors and then goes back to sleep. After that, the battery lasted four months. I tested it for three weeks at Grandma's apartment. Every morning, the chime was a gentle reminder, and every morning my mother's phone stayed quiet, which meant that Grandma had opened the right door. Twice she tried to trick it by opening the door without taking the pills. PillPal couldn't catch that, but I could, because I counted.

"Lazy machines last longest," Grandma said. "Remember that."

On Thursdays, Grandma plays cards in the Linden Tower lounge with her friend Mr. Raman from apartment 4B. She says he is the worst card player in the building and the second-best engineer.

"Who's the best?" I asked.

She just raised one eyebrow at me, which meant: obviously me.

I didn't think about the name Raman at the time. There are lots of Ramans. I was too busy thinking about winning.

Check your understanding

  1. Key details What problem does Hana's invention try to solve?

    1. Her grandmother keeps losing her keys
    2. Her grandmother forgets whether she has taken her heart pills
    3. Her mother forgets to call her grandmother
    4. Her grandmother can't open pill bottles
  2. Vocabulary Hana's "first prototype ran down in a day and a half." What is a prototype?

    1. The final version of an invention that is sold in stores
    2. An early working model built to test an idea
    3. A kind of battery
    4. A drawing of an invention
  3. Cause and effect Why did Hana's first prototype use up its battery so fast?

    1. The battery was broken
    2. The light was too bright
    3. The chip inside was awake all the time, constantly checking the doors
    4. Her grandmother opened the doors too often
  4. Inference The author includes the detail about Mr. Raman from apartment 4B. Why might this detail be important later?

    1. It shows that Grandma doesn't like cards
    2. It hints that Grandma's friend may be related to Dev, Hana's rival
    3. It explains how PillPal works
    4. It shows that Hana wants to learn card games

Chapter 2: Dev

My great-uncle Vikram loses everything.

He loses his glasses, usually while they are on his head. He loses his keys, his wallet, his hearing aids and his TV remote. Once he lost a whole cooked chicken, which we found two days later in the bathroom cabinet. Nobody, including Vikram Chacha, knows how it got there.

He lives alone in apartment 4B of Linden Tower, and he refuses to move in with us. "I lived in five countries and designed radios for half the world," he says. "I can live in one apartment by myself." Then he spends forty minutes looking for his shoes.

When I told him about the Young Inventors Fair, he slapped his knee. "Make me something to find my things! Little tags that beep. Then I will never need your mother to come over and find my glasses again."

So I built Homing Pigeons. They are small plastic tags, about the size of a cookie, that you stick onto anything you don't want to lose. Each one has a tiny radio and a buzzer inside. There's a remote control with six colored buttons. Each button sends a radio signal to one tag. Press the blue button, and the blue tag on your glasses beeps until you find it. Press red, your keys beep. It's simple, and it works, and Vikram Chacha loved it so much that he made me put a tag on his teapot.

The only problem was that it worked for about six hours.

After that, every single tag went dead. I tried bigger batteries. They lasted eight hours. I tried different radio chips. Seven hours. I took the whole thing apart three times and put it back together. I watched videos until midnight. Every night, I lay in bed thinking about it and getting more frustrated. Somewhere in my circuit there was a mistake, and I couldn't see it.

"Ask a friend for help," Vikram Chacha said on the phone.

"I don't need help," I said. "And everyone I know who's good at circuits is someone I'm trying to beat."

He made a sound that might have been a laugh. "Ah," he said. "I knew someone like that once."

"What happened?"

"She beat me," he said, "at almost everything. Fifty years. Now she beats me at cards on Thursdays."

I wasn't really listening. I was staring at my tags, which had gone dark again.

The night before the fair, my tags still died after six hours. I decided to bring a whole bag of fresh batteries and change them every few hours. It wasn't a solution. It was a bandage. But the fair was only five hours long, and I told myself that maybe nobody would notice.

I am not proud of that.

Check your understanding

  1. Main idea What is the main problem Dev faces in this chapter?

    1. His great-uncle won't let him build the invention
    2. His Homing Pigeon tags work, but their batteries die after only about six hours
    3. He can't think of an invention idea
    4. He loses the remote control
  2. Vocabulary Dev says his plan to keep changing batteries "wasn't a solution. It was a bandage." What does he mean?

    1. He hurt his hand while building the tags
    2. His plan only covered up the problem for a short time instead of truly fixing it
    3. He used tape to hold the tags together
    4. He wanted to invent bandages instead
  3. Inference Readers who remember Chapter 1 might notice that Dev's problem sounds familiar. Why?

    1. Hana's first PillPal battery died quickly too, because its chip was always awake, and she fixed it with a sleep mode
    2. Hana also built beeping tags
    3. Hana's grandmother lost a chicken too
    4. Dev used the same box as Hana
  4. Inference When Vikram Chacha says "I knew someone like that once" and that she beats him at cards on Thursdays, who is he probably talking about?

    1. Dev's mother
    2. Ms. Okonkwo
    3. Hana's grandmother, Kiyo Sato
    4. A woman from another country

Chapter 3: Hana

The Young Inventors Fair was held in the big hall of the science museum, under a hanging skeleton of a whale. There were sixty booths, and of course mine was right next to Dev's.

For the first hour, we didn't speak. I set up PillPal with a tablet that showed the texts arriving on a pretend phone. He set up his Homing Pigeons on a table covered in everyday junk: a pair of glasses, a set of keys, a teapot.

Then, at about half past ten, I noticed him crouched under his table, changing batteries with shaking hands.

At first I didn't understand. Then I watched him do it again an hour later, and I saw the whole bag of batteries in his backpack, and I understood exactly. His tags were dying. They were dying the way my first PillPal had died, a day and a half after I built it, when my chip never went to sleep.

I stood very still. Around me, the hall was full of noise: a robot arm clanking two booths down, a little kid crying because a volcano model had erupted on his shoes, a loudspeaker announcing that the snack bar was open. I didn't hear any of it.

The judges were moving down the row toward us. There were three of them: a woman from the university, a man who made medical devices, and a famous inventor who had designed a kind of folding wheelchair. They were asking hard questions and writing in notebooks. In about twenty minutes, they would reach Dev's booth, and if his tags died while they were watching, he would lose. I would almost certainly win.

I thought about the paper airplane with the loop. I thought about the bridge and the glue that wasn't dry. I thought about seven years of coming in second to Dev Raman.

Then I thought about something else. I thought about Grandma at her kitchen table, saying, "Lazy machines last longest," and I realized she had not invented that trick. Somebody had taught it to her once, too. That's how it works. Somebody always teaches somebody.

I walked over to Dev's booth.

"Your radio chip is awake all the time," I said. "It's listening for the remote every single second. That's what kills the battery."

Dev looked up at me from under the table. His face did something complicated: surprise, then suspicion, then something like relief.

"How do you know?"

"Because mine did the same thing. Make it sleep. Have it wake up for a tiny moment every two seconds, listen, then go back to sleep. Your tags will beep two seconds late, but the batteries will last months. Your chip has a sleep setting. It's one line of code."

He stared at me for another second. Then he grabbed his laptop.

It took him fourteen minutes. I watched from my booth while I explained PillPal to visitors, and I could see him typing fast and muttering to himself. When the judges finally reached him, he had reprogrammed all six tags. He pressed the blue button, and the glasses beeped. He told them the battery would last three months. He did not say anything about me. I don't think there was time.

The judges were impressed with both of our inventions. They said so. They asked me careful questions about the text messages and about how I'd tested PillPal with my grandmother.

At four o'clock, they announced the winners. Second place: Hana Sato, for PillPal. First place, and the trip to the state competition: Dev Raman, for Homing Pigeons.

I clapped. I smiled. I meant it, mostly. And I went to the bathroom and cried for exactly two minutes, which I think is allowed.

Check your understanding

  1. Sequence What happened right before Hana walked over to Dev's booth?

    1. The judges announced the winners
    2. Dev asked her for help
    3. She remembered her grandmother saying "Lazy machines last longest" and realized someone had once taught that trick to her grandmother, too
    4. She cried in the bathroom
  2. Character What does Hana's decision to help Dev show about her?

    1. She doesn't care about winning at all
    2. She cares about winning, but she cares more about doing what's right and sharing what she knows
    3. She wants Dev to owe her a favor
    4. She thinks her own invention is not very good
  3. Inference Why does Hana cry for "exactly two minutes" even though she says she meant her clapping?

    1. She is truly happy she helped, but losing still hurts, and both feelings can be true at once
    2. She is angry at the judges
    3. She thinks Dev cheated
    4. She broke PillPal
  4. Key details How did Hana's advice change the way Dev's tags work?

    1. They became louder
    2. They now beep about two seconds late, but the batteries last months
    3. They became smaller
    4. They no longer need a remote control

Chapter 4: Dev

I won, and I felt terrible.

Hana's grandmother would have said a machine can run perfectly and still be built wrong. That was how I felt: like a machine that worked, but only because someone else had fixed it in secret.

That's not how winning is supposed to feel. I had wanted to beat Hana Sato since I was seven years old, and now I had, and the whole time the judges were shaking my hand, I could only think about one thing: that without her, my tags would have died in front of them.

After the fair, my mom drove me to Linden Tower so I could show Vikram Chacha my medal. We took the elevator to the lounge on the ground floor. It was Saturday, not Thursday, but there he was anyway, at the card table, laughing. And across from him, laughing too, was a small woman with short white hair and one raised eyebrow.

And next to her, holding a box with seven little doors, was Hana.

We stared at each other.

"Ah," said Vikram Chacha. "The inventors."

"Grandma," Hana said slowly. "Is Mr. Raman Dev's...?"

"Great-uncle," said Mrs. Sato. "Yes. We have known each other for fifty years. We worked at the same radio company when we were young. We competed at everything. I always won."

"Not always," said Vikram Chacha.

"Almost always," said Mrs. Sato. "Then one year our company wanted a new radio, small enough to fit in a shirt pocket, and neither of us could solve it alone. My circuit was too big. His battery died in a day." She looked at me. "Sound familiar?"

I felt my face get hot.

"So we worked together," Vikram Chacha said. "And it was the best radio either of us ever made. We sold two million of them."

Hana narrowed her eyes. "Grandma. Did you give me the idea for PillPal on purpose? So that I'd have the battery problem and figure it out?"

"I gave you a real problem," said Mrs. Sato. "That's all."

"And did you," I said to my great-uncle, "ask for beeping tags because you knew I'd make the same mistake you did?"

Vikram Chacha examined his cards very carefully. "I lose things," he said. "This is a real problem. Ask anyone. Ask the chicken."

Hana and I looked at each other, and then, for the first time in seven years, we both started laughing at the same thing.

Later that week, I went to see Ms. Okonkwo. I told her the truth about the fair: that Hana had fixed my battery problem, and that my invention wouldn't have worked without her. I asked if the state competition allowed teams.

It did.

So now we are building something new together, for the state fair in the spring. It's a PillPal with a Homing Pigeon inside it, so if Mrs. Sato's pill box ever wanders off, which, she admits, it has, she can press a button and it beeps. Hana handles the sleep code. I handle the radio. We argue about almost everything. It's going very well.

Last Thursday, I asked Vikram Chacha what the best thing he ever invented was. I thought he would say the pocket radio.

"The radio?" he said. "No. That was the second best." He nodded across the card table at Mrs. Sato, who was busy beating him again. "The best thing was the partnership. It's lasted much longer than any battery."

Check your understanding

  1. Character Why does Dev feel terrible after winning?

    1. His medal is too small
    2. He knows he couldn't have won without Hana's help, and she didn't get credit for it
    3. His great-uncle didn't come to the fair
    4. He doesn't like the judges
  2. Inference Vikram Chacha "examined his cards very carefully" when Dev asks him a question. What does this suggest?

    1. He is trying hard to win the card game
    2. He is avoiding Dev's eyes because Dev has guessed his secret plan
    3. He can't hear the question
    4. He is confused about the rules
  3. Cause and effect What did Dev do because he felt he hadn't earned the prize alone?

    1. He gave his medal back
    2. He told Ms. Okonkwo the truth and asked if he and Hana could compete as a team
    3. He stopped speaking to Hana
    4. He asked the judges to change the scores
  4. Theme Why is the story called "The Second-Best Invention"?

    1. Because Hana came in second place
    2. Because Homing Pigeons is not as good as PillPal
    3. Because Vikram Chacha says the radio was only his second-best invention; the best was the partnership with his friend, and the same is now happening for Dev and Hana
    4. Because the two kids only invent things that come in second

Spelling words

These 12 words all appear in the story.

  • inventor
  • rival
  • prototype
  • circuit
  • battery
  • signal
  • competition
  • frustrated
  • engineer
  • partnership
  • reminder
  • judges

Writing prompt

Hana had a chance to let her rival fail, and she chose to help him instead. Do you think she made the right choice, even though it may have cost her first place? Give at least two reasons from the story, and explain what you would have done in her place.

Reading skills practiced

Key details, Vocabulary, Cause and effect, Inference, Main idea, Sequence, Character, Theme.

Answer key for grown-ups
  1. Her grandmother forgets whether she has taken her heart pills PillPal lights up, chimes and texts Hana's mother if a pill is missed.
  2. An early working model built to test an idea She built a first version, found a problem, and improved it.
  3. The chip inside was awake all the time, constantly checking the doors Putting the chip to "sleep" between checks made the battery last four months.
  4. It hints that Grandma's friend may be related to Dev, Hana's rival Hana says, "There are lots of Ramans," which makes the reader suspect a connection she doesn't notice yet.
  5. His Homing Pigeon tags work, but their batteries die after only about six hours He tries bigger batteries and different chips, but nothing fixes it.
  6. His plan only covered up the problem for a short time instead of truly fixing it A bandage covers a wound but doesn't fix what caused it.
  7. Hana's first PillPal battery died quickly too, because its chip was always awake, and she fixed it with a sleep mode Two viewpoints let the reader see a solution that Dev can't see.
  8. Hana's grandmother, Kiyo Sato In Chapter 1, Grandma Kiyo plays cards on Thursdays with Mr. Raman from 4B.
  9. She remembered her grandmother saying "Lazy machines last longest" and realized someone had once taught that trick to her grandmother, too Her decision comes right after this thought about how knowledge is passed on.
  10. She cares about winning, but she cares more about doing what's right and sharing what she knows She thinks hard about their rivalry, but she helps anyway.
  11. She is truly happy she helped, but losing still hurts, and both feelings can be true at once The word "mostly" in "I meant it, mostly" shows she has mixed feelings.
  12. They now beep about two seconds late, but the batteries last months The chip sleeps and wakes up every two seconds to listen.
  13. He knows he couldn't have won without Hana's help, and she didn't get credit for it He thinks about how his tags would have died without her advice.
  14. He is avoiding Dev's eyes because Dev has guessed his secret plan Looking away and making a joke instead of answering suggests Dev guessed correctly.
  15. He told Ms. Okonkwo the truth and asked if he and Hana could compete as a team Telling the truth led to a new partnership.
  16. Because Vikram Chacha says the radio was only his second-best invention; the best was the partnership with his friend, and the same is now happening for Dev and Hana The title connects the old friendship to the new one and shows the theme: working together can create more than competing.

More 4th grade stories

🐻‍❄️

The Bear in the Shed

In a small town on the shore of a frozen bay, Eli Spence's mother works on the polar bear patrol. When a hungry young bear wanders into town, Eli knows exactly why she…

4th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonAnimals · Polar16 questions
🐶

The Dog Who Ran for Mayor

Every summer, the tiny village of Tuckett's Landing elects an honorary mayor, and every vote costs a dollar for the volunteer fire department. Rosa Delgado enters her…

4th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonHumor · Village16 questions
🛷

The Dog at the Front

Josie Peter has trained all winter for the Junior Taiga Sled Dog Race, a sixty-mile run along a frozen river in Alaska. She is sure that her lead dog, Moss, can carry…

4th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonSports · Polar16 questions
🥔

The Potato That Makes You Cry

High in the Andes mountains of Peru, Wayra's grandmother grows more than sixty kinds of potatoes on ancient stone terraces, while Wayra's father grows just one kind,…

4th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonFarm · Culture · Ancient Civilizations16 questions
🧭

The Snowdrifts Point Home

In a small Inuit town in the Canadian Arctic, Leah Akavak's grandfather keeps asking her to describe the ice, the sky, the snow. She thinks it is a teaching game, and…

4th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonCulture · Polar · Family16 questions
🦎

The Dragon in the Dark

After a great flood, Ana finds a strange pale creature in the spring below Dragon Cave: blind, pink, and as long as her hand. Three hundred years ago, people in her…

4th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonNature · Caves16 questions