The Potato That Makes You Cry
High in the Andes mountains of Peru, Wayra's grandmother grows more than sixty kinds of potatoes on ancient stone terraces, while Wayra's father grows just one kind, the kind the city market wants. Told by Wayra and by her father, this is the story of one terrible frosty night, a two-thousand-year-old trick for saving food, and a family deciding what to keep.
4th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonFarm · Culture · Ancient Civilizations2251 wordsAbout 30 minutes
In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.
Words to know
- terraces
- flat steps of land built into the side of a hill so crops can be grown there
- variety
- one particular type of a plant, such as one type of potato
- storehouse
- a building where food or goods are kept for later
- scholarship
- money given to a student to help pay for school
- chuño
- potatoes that have been freeze-dried in the old Andean way so they can be stored for years
Chapter 1: Wayra
My grandmother has a potato that makes you cry.
That is its real name, in our language, Quechua: the potato that makes the daughter-in-law cry. It is purple and knobbly and twisted, with so many bumps and dents that it is almost impossible to peel. In the old days, when a young woman married into a family, her new mother-in-law would hand her one of these potatoes and say, "Peel it." If she could peel it without wasting any, she was a good cook. If not, well. She cried.
"Did you cry?" I asked my grandmother, Mama Inés, the first time she told me this.
"No," she said. "I made my mother-in-law cry. I peeled it perfectly. She was very disappointed."
My grandmother grows sixty-three kinds of potatoes. I know because I have counted them. Some are small and round and red like marbles. Some are long and yellow like fingers. Some are blue all the way through, and when you boil them the water turns violet. Each one has a name. There is the one shaped like a pinecone, and the one called "puma's paw," and the one that is so bitter you can only eat it after it has been frozen and dried.
She grows them on the terraces above our village, Chaska, which sits at almost four thousand meters, so high in the mountains that the clouds sometimes come down and walk through the streets. The terraces climb the steep hillside like a giant's staircase, each step held up by a wall of fitted stone. The Inca built them more than five hundred years ago, and some of the walls are even older than that. People in our valley have been growing potatoes on these same steps for longer than anyone can remember. For generations, each family has handed the seed potatoes down to the next like a treasure. Mama Inés says the terraces are ancient, but the potatoes are older.
My father, Tomás, grows only one kind of potato.
It is a single variety, a big white potato with smooth skin, the kind the buyers from the city want. Every potato in his field down in the valley bottom is exactly the same: the same size, the same color, the same taste. It grows fast and it grows big, and when the truck from the city comes at harvest time, the buyers pay good money for it.
"Your grandmother's potatoes are beautiful," my father says. "But nobody in Lima wants a potato they can't peel."
My father has a plan for that money, and the plan is me. Next year, I will be twelve, and I am supposed to go to a good school in the city of Cusco, three hours away by bus. There is a scholarship that pays for part of it. The white potatoes will pay for the rest.
I want to go. I think I want to go. When I imagine the city, with its big library and its laboratories and its streets full of people, my heart beats fast. But when I imagine leaving Chaska, and the terraces, and Mama Inés teaching me the names of the potatoes, my heart beats fast in a different way, like a bird that has flown into a window.
I have not told anyone this.
At the end of April, the radio in the village store said that a cold wind was coming from the south. "Possible frost," the announcer said. "Protect your crops."
My father looked at the sky and frowned. His potatoes would not be ready to harvest for another two weeks.
Check your understanding
Key details Why is the purple potato called "the potato that makes the daughter-in-law cry"?
- It tastes very spicy
- It is so bumpy and twisted that it is almost impossible to peel without wasting any
- It is the most expensive potato in the market
- It makes people's eyes water like an onion
Vocabulary Wayra says her grandmother grows many kinds of potatoes, but her father grows only one variety. What is a variety?
- One particular type of a plant
- A large field
- A kind of farming tool
- A market where food is sold
Inference Wayra says her heart beats fast "like a bird that has flown into a window" when she imagines leaving Chaska. What does this tell you?
- She is excited to leave
- She is anxious and sad about leaving home, even though she is also excited about the city
- She is afraid of birds
- She has never thought about leaving
Main idea What two different ways of farming does Chapter 1 introduce?
- Mama Inés grows many old varieties on ancient terraces; Tomás grows one market variety in the valley
- Mama Inés uses tractors; Tomás uses his hands
- Both grow only white potatoes
- Mama Inés grows corn; Tomás grows potatoes
Chapter 2: Tomás
My mother thinks I have forgotten where I come from. I have not forgotten. I remember it too well.
When I was a boy, we grew the old potatoes, all of them, like my mother does now. We ate them, and we traded them, and we were poor. Not hungry, most years. But poor. My shoes had holes. My school had one room and one teacher who came three days a week, if the road was open. When I was fourteen, my father died, and I left school to work the fields. I never went back.
So when the buyers from the city came to our valley twelve years ago, offering seeds for a new white potato and a good price for every sack, I said yes. My mother said no. We have been arguing about it, quietly, ever since.
"One potato is a bet," she says. "Sixty potatoes is a plan."
"Sixty potatoes is a museum," I tell her.
But I am not a fool. I know the risks. The white potato is like a racehorse: fast and strong, but delicate. It needs fertilizer. It doesn't like cold. And because every plant in my field is the same, if something goes wrong for one of them, it goes wrong for all of them. My mother's potatoes are like a crowd of different people. Some are strong against frost, some against drought, some against the little worms. Whatever happens, some of them always survive.
I know all of this. I chose the racehorse anyway. Because of Wayra.
My daughter is the smartest person I know. She can do sums in her head faster than the man at the bank. She reads everything, even the labels on the fertilizer bags. When the teacher's car broke down last year, Wayra taught the younger children for a whole week. She deserves a real school, with a real library. She deserves more than one room and three days a week.
That school costs money. My mother's sixty-three potatoes do not make money. My one potato does.
That evening, after the radio warned of frost, I walked down to my field and stood among the plants. They were tall and green, with small white flowers. Two more weeks, I thought. Just two more weeks.
I could feel the air changing as the sun went down. The sky was perfectly clear, without a single cloud, which is the worst kind of sky on a cold night. Clouds are like a blanket. Without them, all the warmth of the day rises straight up into space.
Back home, my mother was sitting by the fire, sorting her seed potatoes into piles. Wayra was helping her.
"It will freeze tonight," my mother said, without looking up. "In the valley bottom. The cold air slides down the mountain like water and pools at the bottom."
"Maybe," I said.
"Not maybe." She held up a small red potato. "Your grandfather knew it. The Inca knew it. That is why they built the terraces on the hillside, not down in the valley. The cold runs past them."
I didn't answer. There was nothing to say. My field was in the valley bottom because the valley bottom was flat and easy to plow, and the trucks could reach it.
That night, I didn't sleep.
Check your understanding
Character What can you infer about why Tomás chose to grow only the white potato?
- He doesn't like his mother's potatoes
- He doesn't know anything about farming
- He grew up poor and had to leave school, and he wants to earn enough money so Wayra can have the education he never had
- The government forced him to
Vocabulary Mama Inés says, "One potato is a bet. Sixty potatoes is a plan." What does she mean?
- Growing only one kind is risky because one problem could ruin it all, but growing many kinds means some will always survive
- Betting on potatoes is against the law
- She wants to grow exactly sixty potatoes
- Plans are always better than bets in card games
Cause and effect Why is a clear night sky dangerous for crops?
- Clear skies bring wind
- The moon is too bright for plants
- Without clouds to act like a blanket, the day's warmth escapes, and the ground gets very cold
- Clear skies bring rain
Inference The chapter is told by Tomás instead of Wayra. What does his viewpoint add to the story?
- It proves that his way of farming is completely right
- It shows that he is not careless or greedy; he understands the risks and makes his choice out of love for his daughter
- It shows that he dislikes his mother
- It explains how to drive a truck
Chapter 3: Wayra
In the morning, the whole valley was white.
It wasn't snow. It was frost, thick and sparkling, coating every blade of grass and every stone. When I breathed, the air hurt my teeth. Mama Inés was already outside, wrapped in her red shawl, looking down at the valley bottom.
I ran down the path behind my father. Our feet crunched. When we reached his field, he stopped at the edge and didn't go any farther.
The potato plants had turned black.
Every single one. The tall green leaves that had been so healthy the evening before were drooping and dark and soft, as if they had been cooked. The white flowers were brown. My father knelt and dug his fingers into the soil, pulling up a plant. The potatoes underneath were small and pale, still two weeks from ready. When he squeezed one, it was mushy, and water ran out of it.
"Frozen," he said quietly. "All of it."
I had never seen my father cry. He didn't cry then, either. He just knelt there with the frozen potato in his hand, looking at it, as if he were looking at a letter with very bad news. I knew what he was thinking. I was thinking it too. The school in Cusco. The scholarship that only paid for part. The truck that would come in two weeks and find nothing to buy.
I wanted to say something to help, but every sentence I thought of sounded wrong. So I just knelt down next to him and put my hand on his back.
Then we climbed up to the terraces.
They were frosty too. But on the terraces, it was different. Some plants were black and drooping, like my father's. But others were still green, standing straight up in the cold sunshine, as if nothing had happened. On each terrace, Mama Inés had planted a mix: a row of the purple ones, a row of the pinecone ones, a row of the bitter ones. The frost had taken some and left others.
"The bitter ones," Mama Inés said, touching a green leaf. "They are tough. They don't mind the cold. And the stone walls drink in the sun all day, and at night they let the warmth out again, like a hearth. The Inca knew this too."
I counted. Of her sixty-three varieties, forty-one had survived the frost.
My father stood at the edge of the terrace for a long time without saying anything. I watched his face. I think he was waiting for his mother to say it: I told you so. One potato is a bet.
She didn't say it. She just bent down and picked up one of his frozen white potatoes, which I had carried up in my pocket without knowing why.
"This is not finished," she said. "It is frozen. That is all. Frozen is only a beginning, if you know what to do next."
Check your understanding
Sequence What did Wayra and her father do right after finding his frozen field?
- They called the buyers from the city
- They climbed up to see the terraces
- They planted new potatoes
- They went back to bed
Cause and effect Why did more of Mama Inés's potatoes survive than Tomás's?
- She covered them with blankets
- She harvested them early
- She grew many different varieties, including tough ones that resist cold, and the stone terrace walls released stored heat at night
- Frost never reaches the terraces
Inference Why does Mama Inés NOT say "I told you so"?
- She forgot about their argument
- She cares about her son and knows he is already hurting; she wants to help him, not win the argument
- She didn't think the frost was important
- She is too cold to speak
Character How does Wayra show what kind of person she is when she finds her father in the frozen field?
- She blames him for the frost
- She runs back home
- She stays by him quietly and puts her hand on his back, showing kindness and understanding
- She tells him that everything will be fine
Chapter 4: Tomás
I had seen my mother make chuño my whole life. I had never paid attention. Now, for the first time, I watched.
We dug up every frozen white potato from my field and carried them in sacks up to the flat ground above the terraces, where the cold is strongest. We spread them out on beds of straw. For three nights, they froze hard under the clear sky. For three days, the strong mountain sun thawed them. Then came the strangest part: my mother, Wayra and I, and half the neighbors, walked on the potatoes with our bare feet, pressing out the water. They squished under our toes. The children laughed. I laughed, too, for the first time in days.
Then they dried in the sun for two more weeks, and every afternoon my mother turned them with her hands, one by one, the way she had done every year of my childhood while I was busy looking somewhere else. My daughter turned them beside her. They dried until they were small and light and hard as stones.
"Chuño," my mother said, holding one up. "Freeze-dried. Like the astronauts eat. Except we invented it first, two thousand years ago."
It is true. Long before the Inca, the people of the Andes were freezing and drying potatoes this way. Each storehouse was a small round stone building with tiny windows to let the cold wind blow through. The Inca built huge storehouses along the mountainsides, thousands of them, and filled them with chuño. It could last ten years, even twenty. When a bad year came, a frost or a drought, the storehouses were opened and nobody starved. Their whole empire was fed by a frozen potato.
I sold some of the chuño at the market in Cusco. It doesn't sell for as much as fresh white potatoes. But it sells. Between the chuño and my mother's surviving potatoes, which she let me sell for the first time in twelve years, we had enough. Not as much as I had hoped. Enough.
Wayra could still go to school.
On the night before she left, she sat by the fire with her grandmother, sorting seed potatoes for the next planting. I watched her hands move, quick and sure, through the piles. Red. Purple. Yellow. Pinecone. Puma's paw. She knew every name.
"Papa," she said, without looking up. "I've been thinking about what I want to study in Cusco."
"Mathematics," I guessed. "Or medicine."
"Agriculture," she said. "Plants. How to grow food when the weather changes." She held up a small, knobbly purple potato, the one that makes the daughter-in-law cry. "Mama Inés says there are scientists in the city who collect old potato varieties and keep them safe. Seeds from all over the mountains. I want to learn what they know. And then I want to come back."
My mother looked at me across the fire. She didn't say anything. She didn't have to.
This year, I am planting differently. In the valley, I will still grow white potatoes for the market. I need the money. I won't pretend I don't. But on the terraces, next to my mother's rows, I am planting the old varieties again, the ones my father grew, the ones his grandfather grew. Twenty kinds, to start.
One potato is a bet. I have learned that the hard way. But I have also learned that a family is like a terrace wall: old stones and new stones, fitted together, holding each other up.
The potato that makes you cry is still impossible to peel. Wayra peeled one last week, perfectly. Her grandmother was very proud. I was the one who cried.
Check your understanding
Key details How is chuño made?
- Potatoes are boiled and then mashed
- Potatoes are frozen at night, thawed by day, stomped to remove water, and dried in the sun
- Potatoes are buried underground for a year
- Potatoes are cooked over a fire until black
Inference Why was chuño so important to the Inca empire?
- It tasted better than fresh potatoes
- It could be stored for many years, so in bad years the storehouses fed people and prevented hunger
- It was used as money
- It was only eaten by kings
Character How has Tomás changed by the end of the story?
- He decides to stop farming completely
- He refuses to plant white potatoes ever again
- He still grows market potatoes for money, but he now values the old varieties and plants them on the terraces too
- He moves to Cusco with Wayra
Theme Tomás says, "A family is like a terrace wall: old stones and new stones, fitted together, holding each other up." What theme does this express?
- The old ways and new ways are strongest when they are combined, and family members support each other
- Old things are always better than new things
- Stone walls are the most important part of a farm
- Children should do exactly what their parents did
Spelling words
These 12 words all appear in the story.
- terraces
- harvest
- variety
- ancient
- frost
- market
- storehouse
- generations
- scholarship
- survive
- valley
- freeze-dried
Writing prompt
Wayra's father and grandmother both had good reasons for the way they farmed. Explain each of their points of view, using evidence from the story. Then decide which ideas from each side the family should keep, and explain why.
Reading skills practiced
Key details, Vocabulary, Inference, Main idea, Character, Cause and effect, Sequence, Theme.
Answer key for grown-ups
- It is so bumpy and twisted that it is almost impossible to peel without wasting any Mothers-in-law used it as a test of a new bride's cooking skills.
- One particular type of a plant Each of Mama Inés's sixty-three kinds of potatoes is a different variety.
- She is anxious and sad about leaving home, even though she is also excited about the city The image of a trapped, hurt bird shows fear and sadness, not only excitement.
- Mama Inés grows many old varieties on ancient terraces; Tomás grows one market variety in the valley This difference sets up the conflict in the story.
- He grew up poor and had to leave school, and he wants to earn enough money so Wayra can have the education he never had He says, "I chose the racehorse anyway. Because of Wayra."
- Growing only one kind is risky because one problem could ruin it all, but growing many kinds means some will always survive Tomás explains the same idea with his racehorse-and-crowd comparison.
- Without clouds to act like a blanket, the day's warmth escapes, and the ground gets very cold Clouds trap heat; a cloudless sky lets it rise into space.
- It shows that he is not careless or greedy; he understands the risks and makes his choice out of love for his daughter Hearing his reasons makes the reader understand both sides of the argument.
- They climbed up to see the terraces After the field, they went up to see how Mama Inés's potatoes had done.
- She grew many different varieties, including tough ones that resist cold, and the stone terrace walls released stored heat at night Both the mix of varieties and the ancient terrace design helped.
- She cares about her son and knows he is already hurting; she wants to help him, not win the argument Instead of blaming him, she turns right away to solving the problem.
- She stays by him quietly and puts her hand on his back, showing kindness and understanding She can't find the right words, so she shows her support another way.
- Potatoes are frozen at night, thawed by day, stomped to remove water, and dried in the sun The process uses the mountain's cold nights and sunny days.
- It could be stored for many years, so in bad years the storehouses fed people and prevented hunger The storehouses turned a "frozen potato" into protection against disaster.
- He still grows market potatoes for money, but he now values the old varieties and plants them on the terraces too He combines both ways of farming instead of choosing only one.
- The old ways and new ways are strongest when they are combined, and family members support each other The ending blends the market, the ancient terraces, and Wayra's plans to study science.