The Rain Latch
While helping her great-grandmother move out of her old house, Mara Villanueva finds a dusty box of drawings, a strange wooden latch, and a bundle of letters from 1961. The drawings are of a famous invention, one that made a lot of money, but the name on the patent belongs to someone else. Told by Mara and through Lola Pilar's old letters, this is the story of a stolen idea that may not have been stolen at all.
4th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonFamily · Inventors · History2325 wordsAbout 30 minutes
In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.
Words to know
- patent
- an official document that says a person invented something and has the right to make and sell it
- typhoon
- a powerful storm with strong winds and heavy rain, like a hurricane
- mechanism
- the working parts of a machine that make it move or do its job
- credit
- praise or recognition for something you did
- sacrifice
- giving up something you value for the sake of something or someone else
Chapter 1: Mara
My great-grandmother, Lola Pilar, is ninety-four years old, and she still beats me at checkers. But this spring, she fell in her kitchen and broke her wrist, and the family decided she couldn't live alone anymore. She was moving into a senior home near us, in San Diego. My job, for a whole Saturday, was to help my mom pack up the garage.
Lola's garage was not a normal garage. There was no car in it. There was a long workbench covered in tools, jars of screws sorted by size, coils of wire, and a big old drill press that my mom said was older than she was. Lola had worked as a seamstress her whole life, but whenever anything in the family broke, it went to Lola's garage, and it came back fixed.
At the bottom of a cabinet, under a pile of rags, I found a cardboard box tied with string.
Inside were three things.
The first was a stack of drawings on thin, yellow paper, so old that the edges crumbled when I touched them. They were careful pencil drawings of a window, with a wooden shutter on hinges, and a small box attached to the windowsill. Arrows showed how the parts moved. The labels were in a mix of English and Tagalog.
The second was the box itself, the real one, made of dark wood and brass, about the size of a deck of cards. On top was a little round metal cup with holes in it. Inside the cup was a gray, dried-up disk that looked like an old sponge.
The third was a bundle of letters, tied with a faded blue ribbon. The envelopes had stamps from the Philippines. They were dated 1961, 1962, 1963.
I brought the box into the kitchen, where my grandmother, Lola Pilar's daughter, was wrapping plates in newspaper. I called her Lola Nena.
"What's this?" I asked.
Lola Nena picked up the brass box, and her face went strange. "Oh," she said. "Oh, my goodness. I haven't seen this since I was a little girl. That's the rain latch."
"The what?"
She turned it over in her hands. "Where your Lola Pilar grew up, in the Philippines, in the province of Samar, typhoons come every year. Huge storms. The rain comes sideways, out of nowhere. If you're not home to close your shutters, the whole house floods. So my mother invented this. The sponge sits in the little cup on the windowsill. When the rain starts, the sponge gets wet and swells up, and it pushes a little lever, and the lever trips a spring, and the shutters slam shut by themselves. No electricity. Nothing to break."
I pressed the little lever with my finger. Inside the box, something clicked, and a tiny brass arm snapped forward. Even after sixty years, the mechanism still worked.
"Lola invented that?" I said. "That's amazing!"
My grandmother nodded slowly. Then she said something that made my stomach drop.
"You've heard of Cruz Shutters?"
Of course I had. Everyone had. Cruz Shutters was a huge company. They made storm shutters that closed automatically when it rained, for houses all over the world, all along the coasts of Asia and Florida and the Caribbean. Their logo was a little brass box with a raindrop on it.
"Benjamin Cruz," said Lola Nena. "My uncle. Your Lola Pilar's younger brother. He got the patent in 1962. That's how the company started. He became a very rich man."
I stared at the drawings. At the careful handwriting. At the brass box with the raindrop-shaped hole in the cup.
"But Lola invented it," I said. "Didn't she?"
My grandmother didn't answer. She just looked at the bundle of letters with the blue ribbon, and for a long moment, she didn't say anything at all.
Check your understanding
Key details How does the rain latch work?
- It uses an electric sensor to detect rain
- A sponge swells when it gets wet, pushing a lever that trips a spring and closes the shutters
- A person must pull a rope to close it
- It is powered by the wind
Vocabulary What is a typhoon?
- A powerful storm with strong winds and heavy rain
- A kind of wooden shutter
- A small island in the Philippines
- A kind of sponge
Inference Why does Mara's "stomach drop" when her grandmother mentions Cruz Shutters?
- She is hungry
- She doesn't like the company's logo
- She realizes that someone else may have gotten rich and famous from her great-grandmother's invention
- She is scared of storms
Inference Why do you think Lola Nena looks at the letters instead of answering Mara's question?
- She can't remember the answer
- The answer is complicated, and the letters may explain something that is hard to say out loud
- She wants Mara to stop asking questions
- She thinks the letters are from a stranger
Chapter 2: The Letters
These are some of the letters from the bundle. They were written by my great-grandmother, Pilar, to her best friend from school, Rosario, who had moved to Manila. Rosario's family sent them back to Lola Pilar after Rosario died, many years later. My grandmother helped me translate the Tagalog parts.
June 3, 1961
Dear Rosario,
It works! The rain latch works! Last week the big storm came in the night, and I was at the market, and when I ran home through the rain, every shutter on our house was closed tight and the floor was dry as bread. Mama cried. The neighbors all came to look. Mang Tonyo next door wants one. So does the priest! I have made eleven now, in Papa's old workshop, with sponges from the market and springs from broken clocks. Benjamin says I should sell them. He says I could make a fortune.
I laughed. Who would buy anything from me? I am a woman with no diploma, a sewing machine and two babies.
Your friend, Pilar
October 19, 1961
Dear Rosario,
I went to Manila to see about a patent. You were in the provinces visiting your mother, so I couldn't see you. It was a waste of a trip. The man at the office would not even look at my drawings. He asked where my husband was. I said my husband died last year, as you know, in the boat accident. He said, "Then send your brother."
Then I went to a factory to ask if they would make my latch. The manager laughed and patted my hand and said, "Ma'am, go home to your children."
I cried on the bus all the way home. I am not ashamed to tell you.
Pilar
February 2, 1962
Dear Rosario,
Benjamin has an idea, and I have been thinking about it for a week, and I need you to tell me if I am a fool.
He says: give me the drawings. I will go to the patent office, and they will talk to me, because I am a man in a nice shirt. I will go to the factories. I will start a company. And the money, he says, will come to you, half of everything, forever. And your girls will go to school. Real schools. The best ones. Maybe even in America.
My girls, Rosario. Nena is seven. She reads everything. She wants to be a doctor. In our village, girls do not become doctors. They become seamstresses, like me.
If I keep my name on the rain latch, it stays in Papa's workshop and saves the houses on our street. If I give it to Benjamin, it goes out into the world, and saves houses everywhere, and my girls go to school.
But it will have his name on it. Forever. Nobody will ever know it was me.
Pilar
March 30, 1962
Dear Rosario,
I did it. I gave him the drawings. He signed a paper promising half, and our lawyer cousin witnessed it.
Mama says it is a sacrifice. Maybe. But every typhoon season, I think of all the houses on all the coasts where a woman is at the market when the rain begins, and I think it is also a gift.
I kept one latch, the first one I ever made. I will keep it always. So that I know.
Pilar
Check your understanding
Main idea What do these letters mainly reveal?
- That Benjamin stole the drawings without asking
- That Pilar was turned away because she was a woman, and she chose to let her brother patent her invention so it could succeed and pay for her daughters' education
- That the rain latch did not really work
- That Rosario helped invent the latch
Cause and effect Why did Pilar's trip to Manila fail?
- Her drawings were lost on the bus
- The patent office was closed
- The officials and factory manager would not take her seriously because she was a woman without a husband or diploma
- Her invention was too expensive
Inference Why does Pilar keep "the first one I ever made" and say "So that I know"?
- Even though the world will not know she invented it, she wants proof, for herself, that it was hers
- She wants to sell it later for money
- She doesn't trust that the others will work
- Her brother asked her to keep it
Inference Why might the author have chosen to tell this part of the story through Pilar's own letters?
- Because Mara can't read Tagalog
- So the reader hears Pilar's real thoughts and feelings at the time, which are different from what Mara assumed
- Because letters are shorter than chapters
- To show that Rosario was the main character
Chapter 3: Mara
I read the letters three times. The first time, I cried. The second time, I got angry. The third time, I got angrier.
"It isn't fair," I said to my mom, that night in our kitchen. I had the letters spread out on the table, and Lola's drawings, and the brass box. "She invented it! The patent office wouldn't even talk to her, just because she was a woman. And then her own brother put his name on it. And now there's a giant company with his name on every box, and nobody knows hers."
"He did send the money," my mom said quietly. "Half. Every year until he died. That's how your Lola Nena came to America for medical school. That's how she became a doctor. That's how your grandparents could buy their house, and how I went to college, and how..." She stopped and looked at me. "How we're all here."
I knew that. I still felt like I was going to explode.
"But it's not right," I said. "Everybody thinks Benjamin Cruz was a genius. There's a statue of him at the company's headquarters. I looked it up. A statue."
My mom didn't argue. She just said, "Then go and ask her."
So on Sunday, I went to the senior home with the brass box in my backpack.
Lola Pilar was sitting by the window of her new room, with her wrist in a cast and a checkerboard on the table in front of her. When she saw me take the rain latch out of my bag, she put down the checker she was holding very slowly.
"Ah," she said. "You found my garage box."
"I read the letters, Lola," I said. "All of them." And then everything came pouring out of me: how unfair it was, how she should have gotten the credit, how her brother had a statue and she didn't even have her name in a single book. "Let's tell everyone," I said. "We can write to the newspapers. We can write to the company. We can prove it. We have the drawings, and the letters, and the first latch. Everyone should know it was you."
Lola Pilar listened to all of it without interrupting. When I finished, she was quiet for a long time, looking out the window at the parking lot, where it was starting to rain a little.
"Mara," she said finally. "Do you think I was cheated?"
"Yes!"
"By who?"
I opened my mouth. Then I closed it. I had been about to say Benjamin. But Benjamin had kept his promise. Every year. Half.
"By... the patent man," I said slowly. "And the factory manager. And everyone who wouldn't listen to you."
She nodded. "Yes. They cheated me. Not my brother. My brother was the only one who said: Pilar, your idea is good, let's make it work. He just had a key that I didn't have."
"But he got all the credit."
"He did," Lola Pilar agreed. "And he hated it." She smiled, a small, strange smile. "Did you know that? Every year, when the newspapers wrote about him, he would call me on the telephone, all the way from Manila, and say, 'Ate, I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Let me tell them.' And every year, I said no."
I stared at her. "Why?"
Check your understanding
Character How do Mara's feelings change as she reads the letters?
- She becomes bored with them
- She is first sad, then angry, then even angrier about the unfairness
- She is happy that Benjamin was so smart
- She decides the letters are fake
Cause and effect According to Mara's mom, what happened because of the money Benjamin sent?
- The family bought a factory
- Lola Nena became a doctor in America, and the family's later education and home followed
- Lola Pilar went back to the patent office
- Benjamin built a statue of Pilar
Inference Why does Mara change her answer from "Benjamin" to "the patent man" and "the factory manager"?
- She realizes that Benjamin kept his promise, and that the real unfairness came from the people who refused to listen to Pilar
- She doesn't want to upset Lola Pilar
- She forgets Benjamin's name
- She thinks the factory manager stole the drawings
Vocabulary Lola Pilar says Benjamin "just had a key that I didn't have." What is the "key"?
- A real key to the patent office
- A key to Papa's workshop
- The respect and opportunities that men were given at that time, which opened doors that were closed to her
- A secret part of the rain latch
Chapter 4: Mara
"Because of Nena," said Lola Pilar.
She picked up the brass box and turned it over slowly in her good hand, the way my grandmother had in the kitchen.
"If the newspapers had learned that a seamstress from Samar invented the rain latch, a woman with no diploma, people would have said the company was a fraud. Your Lola Nena was in medical school by then. She was the only woman in her class. Every day, people were waiting for her to fail, so they could say: you see? Girls can't do this. I did not want my name in the newspaper. I wanted hers on a diploma." She smiled again. "And it was. That was my credit. I got it in 1979, in a big hall in Chicago. I was sitting in the front row."
I didn't know what to say. I looked down at the checkerboard.
"But," Lola Pilar said, and her voice changed. It got quieter. "You are right too, Mara. It isn't fair. It was never fair. I made my choice because the world gave me only bad choices. Benjamin is gone now. Nena is retired. The world is different." She looked out at the rain. "Maybe it is time."
"Time for what?"
"For the truth." She put the rain latch in my hands. "But not to punish anyone. Not to knock over my brother's statue. He was a good brother. Tell the whole story. Him, and me, and the patent man, and the bus, and the choice. All of it. So that some girl, somewhere, who has an idea and no key, will know that the door is open now. And that it wasn't always."
So that's what we did.
It took a whole summer. My mom helped me write a letter to the company, with copies of the drawings and the letters and photographs of the first latch. Lola Nena wrote one too, as a doctor, which made people take it more seriously, which Lola Pilar said was exactly the problem in the first place.
At first, nobody answered. Then, in August, a woman called. She was the company's president, and she was Benjamin Cruz's granddaughter. She said that she had found letters too, in her grandfather's desk, and that they said the same thing. She said he had written, in an envelope marked "to be opened after I'm gone": The rain latch belongs to my sister Pilar. I only carried it.
In October, the company held a ceremony. They didn't take down the statue of Benjamin. Instead, they put up a second one, right next to it: a woman in a simple dress, with a small brass box in her hand. Lola Pilar thought the statue was much too tall and the nose was wrong, and she said so to the sculptor, loudly.
The plaque underneath says: Pilar Cruz Villanueva, inventor of the rain latch. And under that: She gave her idea to the world, and her name to her daughters.
I still visit Lola Pilar every Sunday. We play checkers, and she still beats me. But lately, on the table next to the checkerboard, there's something new: a pile of springs, a coil of wire, a few sponges, and some drawings on clean white paper.
We're working on an invention together. I'm not going to tell you what it is yet.
But we've already decided whose names go on the patent. Both of them.
Check your understanding
Main idea What reason does Lola Pilar give for keeping her secret for so many years?
- She was afraid of her brother
- She didn't care about the invention
- She wanted to protect her daughter, the only woman in her medical school class, from people who would use the story against her
- The company paid her to keep quiet
Sequence Which event happened FIRST?
- Benjamin wrote a letter saying "The rain latch belongs to my sister Pilar"
- Mara wrote to the company
- The company's president called the family
- The second statue was put up
Inference Lola Nena's letter is taken more seriously because she is a doctor, "which Lola Pilar said was exactly the problem in the first place." What does Lola Pilar mean?
- She thinks doctors write better letters
- People still judge an idea by who says it instead of by the idea itself, which is the same unfairness that hurt her in 1961
- She doesn't like doctors
- She wanted to write the letter herself
Theme Which statement best expresses a theme of the story?
- Inventors should always work alone
- Family members cannot be trusted with secrets
- Sacrifice and unfairness can both be true in the same story, and telling the whole truth honors everyone in it
- Getting rich is the most important result of an invention
Spelling words
These 12 words all appear in the story.
- invention
- patent
- typhoon
- shutters
- sponge
- mechanism
- credit
- sacrifice
- letters
- factory
- unfair
- workshop
Writing prompt
Lola Pilar chose to let her brother put his name on her invention. Mara first thought this was a terrible unfairness, but later she saw it differently. Do you think Lola Pilar made the right choice? Explain what she gained and what she lost, using evidence from both the letters and Mara's chapters.
Reading skills practiced
Key details, Vocabulary, Inference, Main idea, Cause and effect, Character, Sequence, Theme.
Answer key for grown-ups
- A sponge swells when it gets wet, pushing a lever that trips a spring and closes the shutters "No electricity. Nothing to break."
- A powerful storm with strong winds and heavy rain In Samar, typhoons come every year and can flood houses.
- She realizes that someone else may have gotten rich and famous from her great-grandmother's invention Benjamin Cruz got the patent, but the drawings are Lola Pilar's.
- The answer is complicated, and the letters may explain something that is hard to say out loud Her silence suggests there is more to the story.
- That Pilar was turned away because she was a woman, and she chose to let her brother patent her invention so it could succeed and pay for her daughters' education The letters tell the story behind the patent in Pilar's own words.
- The officials and factory manager would not take her seriously because she was a woman without a husband or diploma They told her to "send your brother" and to "go home to your children."
- Even though the world will not know she invented it, she wants proof, for herself, that it was hers It's a private reminder of the truth she gave away in public.
- So the reader hears Pilar's real thoughts and feelings at the time, which are different from what Mara assumed The letters give a second viewpoint, from the past.
- She is first sad, then angry, then even angrier about the unfairness "The first time, I cried. The second time, I got angry."
- Lola Nena became a doctor in America, and the family's later education and home followed "That's how we're all here."
- She realizes that Benjamin kept his promise, and that the real unfairness came from the people who refused to listen to Pilar Lola Pilar's question makes her think more carefully about who was truly to blame.
- The respect and opportunities that men were given at that time, which opened doors that were closed to her A "key" here is a metaphor for access.
- She wanted to protect her daughter, the only woman in her medical school class, from people who would use the story against her "I did not want my name in the newspaper. I wanted hers on a diploma."
- Benjamin wrote a letter saying "The rain latch belongs to my sister Pilar" Benjamin wrote it before he died; his granddaughter found it later.
- People still judge an idea by who says it instead of by the idea itself, which is the same unfairness that hurt her in 1961 The comment is both funny and a bit sad.
- Sacrifice and unfairness can both be true in the same story, and telling the whole truth honors everyone in it The second statue honors Pilar without tearing down Benjamin.