📚 Reading Quest
🎣

Before the Water Rises

In a small river village in Laos, eleven-year-old Noy studies by candlelight and fishes with her grandfather. When engineers arrive with plans for a dam that would bring electricity but flood the fields and block the fish, the whole village is divided, and Noy finds herself caught between the people she loves most.

5th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeyVillage · Rivers · Culture2491 wordsAbout 30 minutes

Read it in the app 🚀

In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.

Words to know

reservoir
a large lake made by people, usually by building a dam across a river
migration
the movement of animals from one place to another at certain times of year
turbine
a machine with blades that spin when water or wind pushes them, making electricity
upstream
in the direction a river is coming from
livelihood
the way a person earns the money or food they need to live

Chapter 1: The Trap That Lets Some Go

Every morning before school, Noy and her grandfather walked down to the river with the fish trap.

It was a long basket made of split bamboo, woven so tightly that it looked like a single piece of polished wood. Grandfather had made it himself, the way his own grandfather had taught him. The mouth of the trap was wide, but inside, the bamboo narrowed into a funnel, so a fish could swim in but could not easily find its way out.

What Noy liked best about the trap was a secret only her family knew. Near the back, Grandfather had left the weave a little looser. The gaps were just wide enough for the smallest fish to wriggle through and escape.

"Why do you let them go?" Noy had asked him once, when she was six.

"Because the little ones are next year's dinner," Grandfather had said. "A trap that takes everything is a trap that will someday be empty."

The village of Ban Pak Huay sat on a bend in the river, about a day's drive from the great Mekong. Forty wooden houses stood on stilts above the riverbank, so that in the rainy season, when the river swelled, the water could flow beneath them. Rice paddies stretched along both banks like green mirrors. Behind the village, a hill covered in old trees rose up toward the clouds. That was the spirit forest, where the villagers believed their ancestors watched over them. Nobody cut trees there. Nobody even picked up fallen branches without asking permission first.

The village had no electricity. At night, Noy did her homework by candle, bent so close to the page that her mother scolded her for ruining her eyes. Her older brother Khamla, who was sixteen, had a phone that he charged on a car battery, which he carried to town on his motorbike once a week to recharge at a shop that had a diesel generator rumbling out back. Sometimes Noy rode with him, holding the heavy battery in her lap and feeling every bump in the road.

Khamla wanted to be a mechanic. He talked about it constantly: about engines and pumps and the big repair shops in the capital city, Vientiane. "There's nothing here," he said, at least twice a week. "Just fish and rice and candles. You can't build a future by candlelight."

One morning in the dry season, as Noy and Grandfather were pulling up the trap, they heard an engine on the dirt road. A white truck with a company logo on the door rumbled into the village and stopped by the temple. Three people climbed out: two men in pressed shirts and a young woman carrying a tablet.

They spent all day walking along the river with measuring tools and a small flying drone that buzzed over the water like a giant dragonfly. The children followed them in a crowd, giggling and pointing. Noy followed too, but she did not giggle. She watched the young woman's face as she looked at the river, and there was something on it that Noy did not understand. It looked like admiration. It also looked a little like sorrow.

That evening, the village headman called everyone to the temple.

"These people are engineers," he announced. "They work for a power company. They say they would like to build a dam on our river, five kilometers upstream."

A murmur rushed through the crowd like wind through rice.

Check your understanding

  1. Key details Why does Grandfather leave a looser weave at the back of the fish trap?

    1. To make the trap lighter to carry
    2. Because he ran out of bamboo
    3. So the smallest fish can escape and grow up to be caught later
    4. So the water can drain faster
  2. Inference What does Grandfather's saying, "A trap that takes everything is a trap that will someday be empty," suggest about how he thinks?

    1. He thinks fishing is wrong
    2. He wants to catch as many fish as possible
    3. He thinks about the future and believes people should only take what nature can replace
    4. He doesn't like fish very much
  3. Character How does Khamla feel about life in the village?

    1. He loves it and never wants to leave
    2. He feels it is too limited and dreams of a modern job in the city
    3. He is afraid of the river
    4. He wants to become a fisherman like Grandfather
  4. Vocabulary The dam would be built "upstream." What does upstream mean?

    1. Under the river
    2. On the other side of the village
    3. In the direction the river is coming from
    4. In the middle of the rice paddies

Chapter 2: Light and Water

The meeting at the temple lasted until long after dark.

The young engineer, whose name was Ms. Vilay, stood in front of the villagers and explained the plan using pictures on her tablet. The dam would be a wall of concrete forty meters high across the river's narrowest point. Behind it, the river would fill up and become a long lake, called a reservoir. Water from the reservoir would rush through tunnels and spin giant turbines, and those spinning turbines would make electricity.

"Enough electricity for thirty thousand homes," Ms. Vilay said. "Including every house in Ban Pak Huay."

Khamla's eyes were shining. Several of the young people near him began whispering excitedly. Electricity meant lights and refrigerators and fans in the hot season. It meant phones that could be charged without a trip to town. It meant, Ms. Vilay said, that the health clinic down the road could keep vaccines cold, and that the school could have computers.

"And the river?" asked Grandfather. He did not raise his voice, but everybody heard him.

Ms. Vilay hesitated. "The reservoir would cover about two hundred hectares of land upstream," she said carefully. "That includes some rice fields belonging to this village. The company would pay for that land, and help families move their fields to new ground."

"And the fish?"

There was a longer pause. "The dam would change the river," she admitted. "Many fish in this river swim upstream every year to lay their eggs. It's called a migration. A dam can block that journey."

The temple went very quiet.

Every family in Ban Pak Huay ate fish. Fish were not just dinner; they were the village's livelihood. Families dried fish and sold them in town. They fermented fish into a salty paste that went into nearly every meal. When the big migration came each year after the first rains, the whole village went down to the river with nets and traps, and there was singing and cooking for days.

"Without the fish," said Grandfather quietly, "what will we eat?"

"With electricity," Khamla said loudly, from the back, "we could buy food. We could have jobs. Grandfather, the world is changing whether we like it or not."

Everyone turned to stare. Noy felt her face grow hot. Khamla had never spoken back to Grandfather in public before.

Grandfather looked at his grandson for a long moment. Then he nodded slowly. "You may be right," he said. "That is why we must think carefully."

On the walk home, Noy carried the candle lantern. Khamla walked ahead with his friends, talking excitedly about computers and motorbike repair shops with real power tools. Grandfather walked slowly beside Noy, leaning on his stick.

"Grandfather," Noy said, "who is right? You or Khamla?"

He was quiet for a while. "When I was a boy," he said at last, "four children in this village died of fever in one rainy season. If the clinic had had cold medicine, maybe they would have lived. So when your brother speaks of electricity, he is not foolish." He stopped and looked out at the dark river, which shone faintly under the stars. "But I have also seen what happens to rivers that are blocked. My cousin lives on a river in the north where they built a dam ten years ago. The fish are mostly gone. The young people have all left for the cities. The village is very quiet now, with bright lights shining in empty houses."

Noy thought about that all night. Bright lights in empty houses. It seemed like the saddest picture she had ever imagined.

But then she thought about Khamla, studying engine manuals by candlelight, squinting until his eyes watered. She thought about the four children who had died of fever. And she didn't know what to think at all.

Check your understanding

  1. Cause and effect How would the dam make electricity?

    1. By burning wood from the spirit forest
    2. By sending water from the reservoir through tunnels to spin turbines
    3. By using solar panels on top of the wall
    4. By catching lightning during storms
  2. Main idea What is the main conflict introduced at the temple meeting?

    1. Whether Noy should go to school in town
    2. The dam would bring electricity and its benefits, but it would flood fields and block the fish the village depends on
    3. Who should be the next village headman
    4. Whether the engineers should be allowed to fly a drone
  3. Inference Why does Grandfather say "You may be right" to Khamla, even after Khamla speaks rudely?

    1. He honestly sees that electricity could help, so he wants to treat the decision seriously
    2. He is too tired to argue
    3. He has decided to vote for the dam
    4. He wants Khamla to stop talking
  4. Vocabulary Grandfather's cousin's village has "bright lights shining in empty houses." What does this image suggest?

    1. The houses are being painted
    2. Electricity is dangerous
    3. The village got electricity but lost its people, because the fish and young people left
    4. The houses are haunted

Chapter 3: What the Drone Saw

Over the next weeks, the village split in two.

The younger families mostly wanted the dam. The older families mostly did not. Neighbors who had shared meals for thirty years stopped speaking. At the market, Mrs. Phet refused to sell her vegetables to Mr. Sone because his son had said something rude about the "old people who want to live in the past." Even the children argued on the way to school.

Noy hated it. She felt as if she were being pulled apart, one arm grabbed by Khamla and the other by Grandfather. At dinner, the two of them ate in stiff silence, and her mother sighed into the rice pot. Even the dog seemed to know something was wrong, and it slept under the house instead of on the steps.

Then something happened that she hadn't expected. Ms. Vilay came back to the village alone, without the two men in pressed shirts. She wanted to film the river more carefully with her drone and needed someone to show her the fishing spots. The headman sent Noy, because Noy knew the river better than any other child.

They spent three days together. Ms. Vilay let Noy fly the drone, steering it with a small controller while the screen showed the river from above, curling like a brown ribbon between green fields. Noy had never seen her village from the sky before. It looked so small. And the river looked so long.

On the second day, Noy took her to the deep pool below the rapids, where the big fish rested before leaping upstream during the migration.

"This is where they wait," Noy said. "Grandfather says they gather their strength here."

Ms. Vilay sat down on a rock and was quiet for a long time.

"Can I tell you something?" she said finally. "I grew up in a village like this one. In the south. My father was a fisherman too."

Noy stared at her. "Then why do you build dams?"

Ms. Vilay laughed, but it was not a happy laugh. "Because my village had no electricity, and my mother was very sick, and the nearest hospital was a day away. I decided I would become an engineer and bring light to villages like mine." She picked up a smooth stone and turned it over in her hands. "But every dam I work on, I see a pool like this one, and I think of my father."

"So you're on both sides," Noy said.

"I suppose I am. Most honest people are, about most hard things."

That night, Ms. Vilay showed Noy something on her tablet. It was a drawing of a different kind of dam. This one was lower, only fifteen meters high, and it had a strange staircase built along one side, a series of small stepped pools climbing up beside the wall.

"It's called a fish ladder," Ms. Vilay explained. "The fish can swim up it, pool by pool, and get past the dam. It doesn't work perfectly. Some kinds of fish won't use it. And a lower dam makes less electricity, which means the company makes less money. My bosses don't like it." She hesitated. "But if a village asked for it, if a village made a very strong case, they might have to listen."

Noy looked at the drawing for a long time. She thought of Grandfather's fish trap, with its loose weave at the back. A trap that lets some go.

"It's like a compass," she said slowly. "It doesn't tell you where to go. It just helps you not get lost."

Ms. Vilay smiled. "That's a good way to put it."

Check your understanding

  1. Sequence Which event happens right after Noy takes Ms. Vilay to the deep pool below the rapids?

    1. Mrs. Phet refuses to sell vegetables to Mr. Sone
    2. Ms. Vilay arrives with two men in pressed shirts
    3. Ms. Vilay tells Noy that she grew up in a fishing village
    4. Noy flies the drone for the first time
  2. Character Why does Ms. Vilay feel like she is "on both sides"?

    1. She is being paid by both the village and the company
    2. She became an engineer to help villages like hers, but she also remembers her father's fishing life
    3. She can't decide which village to live in
    4. She wants to trick Noy
  3. Inference Why does Ms. Vilay say a village would have to "make a very strong case" for the fish ladder?

    1. Because fish ladders are illegal
    2. Because her bosses prefer the bigger dam that makes more money, so they would only change if pushed
    3. Because villagers don't understand drawings
    4. Because the fish ladder is very dangerous
  4. Theme How is the fish ladder like Grandfather's fish trap?

    1. Both are made of bamboo
    2. Both catch as many fish as possible
    3. Both try to take what people need while still leaving a way for fish to survive
    4. Both were invented by Ms. Vilay

Chapter 4: Noy Speaks

The final village meeting was held on the first night of the rainy season. Rain hammered the temple roof so loudly that people had to lean close to hear one another.

The headman explained that the company needed the village's agreement before building could begin. Everyone would vote by raising their hands, and the decision would be final.

Khamla stood up first. He spoke well, Noy thought, better than she had expected. He talked about the clinic and the vaccines, about children studying under real lights, about young people who would not have to leave home to find work. Many people nodded.

Then Grandfather stood. He talked about the migration, about the spirit forest, about his cousin's quiet village in the north. Many other people nodded.

When he sat down, the temple was filled with grumbling and murmuring. It was clear the vote would split the village nearly in half, and whichever side lost would be angry for years.

Noy's heart was pounding so hard it hurt. She had never spoken at a village meeting. Children didn't. But she stood up anyway, and her voice came out small and shaky.

"I don't think Khamla is wrong," she said. "And I don't think Grandfather is wrong."

The murmuring stopped. Everyone turned to stare at her. Noy swallowed and kept going.

"Grandfather taught me to weave the fish trap so that some fish can escape. He says a trap that takes everything will someday be empty." She held up the drawing that Ms. Vilay had given her. "This is a smaller dam, with a fish ladder. It makes less electricity. But it still makes enough for our village and the clinic. And the fish can still climb past it, at least most of them. And the reservoir would be smaller, so it wouldn't cover the spirit forest or most of the rice fields."

She looked at Khamla, then at Grandfather. "I think maybe we don't have to choose between light and fish. Maybe we have to ask for both."

The temple was silent except for the rain.

Then old Mrs. Phet, who had not spoken to Mr. Sone in a month, said loudly, "The child is right." And Mr. Sone, looking surprised, said, "Yes. Yes, she is." And the two of them looked at each other and almost smiled.

The village did not vote for the big dam that night. Instead, they voted to send a letter to the company and to the provincial government, asking for the smaller dam with the fish ladder. Ms. Vilay helped them write it. It took eight months of letters and meetings and arguments before the company finally agreed. Ms. Vilay told Noy afterward that her bosses had grumbled the entire time.

Not everyone was happy. Some of the young people said the smaller dam was a waste. Some of the old people said any dam was too much. The argument did not end; it just grew quieter, like a river after the rains.

Electricity came to Ban Pak Huay two years later. On the first night, every house in the village switched on its lights at the same moment, and the children ran through the lanes cheering. Khamla opened the first motorbike repair shop in the district, with a real electric drill.

But the first thing Noy did with electricity was something no one expected. She plugged in a small reading lamp, sat down at the table with Grandfather, and asked him to teach her, slowly and carefully, how to weave a fish trap.

"Now?" he said, surprised. "With all these new lights, you want to learn the old way?"

"I want to learn both," Noy said.

That season, the fish came up the river as they always had. Fewer than before, the old fishermen said. But they came. Noy watched them leap from pool to pool up the concrete ladder, silver flashes in the brown water, and she decided right then what she would be when she grew up.

An engineer. The kind who builds ladders.

Check your understanding

  1. Character Why is it brave for Noy to speak at the meeting?

    1. Children don't usually speak at village meetings, and she is nervous
    2. She is the headman's daughter
    3. She has to speak in a foreign language
    4. She has been told she will be punished
  2. Cause and effect What happens as a result of Noy's speech?

    1. The village votes for the big dam
    2. The village refuses all dams forever
    3. The village asks the company and government for the smaller dam with a fish ladder
    4. Ms. Vilay loses her job
  3. Inference Why does Noy want to learn to weave a fish trap on the very first night of electricity?

    1. She doesn't like electric lights
    2. She wants to sell traps in town
    3. She wants to keep the old knowledge alive while also enjoying the new changes
    4. Grandfather forces her to learn
  4. Theme What is the main lesson of the story?

    1. New technology is always better than old ways
    2. People should never build dams
    3. In hard choices, listening to both sides can lead to solutions that protect more of what people value
    4. Children should make all of a village's decisions

Spelling words

These 12 words all appear in the story.

  • electricity
  • engineer
  • migration
  • village
  • ancestors
  • compass
  • candle
  • reservoir
  • generator
  • upstream
  • argument
  • decision

Writing prompt

The dam would bring good things and bad things to Ban Pak Huay. If you lived in the village, would you vote for the dam? Explain your choice using at least three facts from the story, and explain what you would say to someone who disagreed with you.

Reading skills practiced

Key details, Inference, Character, Vocabulary, Cause and effect, Main idea, Sequence, Theme.

Answer key for grown-ups
  1. So the smallest fish can escape and grow up to be caught later He says, "The little ones are next year's dinner."
  2. He thinks about the future and believes people should only take what nature can replace Leaving young fish means there will still be fish in years to come.
  3. He feels it is too limited and dreams of a modern job in the city He says, "You can't build a future by candlelight."
  4. In the direction the river is coming from Upstream means toward where the river flows from.
  5. By sending water from the reservoir through tunnels to spin turbines Ms. Vilay explains that rushing water spins turbines, which make electricity.
  6. The dam would bring electricity and its benefits, but it would flood fields and block the fish the village depends on Both sides of the dam are laid out: light and power versus fields and fish.
  7. He honestly sees that electricity could help, so he wants to treat the decision seriously He later tells Noy about children who died of fever, showing he understands Khamla's point.
  8. The village got electricity but lost its people, because the fish and young people left It shows a village that gained one thing but lost something important.
  9. Ms. Vilay tells Noy that she grew up in a fishing village At the pool, Ms. Vilay sits quietly and then shares her own story.
  10. She became an engineer to help villages like hers, but she also remembers her father's fishing life Her sick mother made her want electricity, but her fisherman father makes her care about rivers.
  11. Because her bosses prefer the bigger dam that makes more money, so they would only change if pushed She says a lower dam makes less money, and her bosses don't like it.
  12. Both try to take what people need while still leaving a way for fish to survive The trap's loose weave and the ladder both let some fish go free.
  13. Children don't usually speak at village meetings, and she is nervous The story says "Children didn't," and her voice comes out "small and shaky."
  14. The village asks the company and government for the smaller dam with a fish ladder After her speech, Mrs. Phet and Mr. Sone agree, and the village writes a letter asking for the smaller dam.
  15. She wants to keep the old knowledge alive while also enjoying the new changes She says, "I want to learn both."
  16. In hard choices, listening to both sides can lead to solutions that protect more of what people value Noy finds a way to ask for both light and fish instead of choosing one.

More 5th grade stories

🦧

The Orangutan Corridor

Arif's family grows oil palms on the edge of the Borneo rainforest, and money has never been so tight. When a mother orangutan and her baby start crossing their land, a…

5th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeyAnimals · Farm · Rainforest16 questions
⛵

Sailing into the Wind

Kiri has one goal this summer: win the harbor championship in the little dinghy her grandfather once raced. But her new sailing partner, a quiet boy from Sweden, sails…

5th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeySports · Sailing · Friends16 questions
📰

The Last Edition

For 112 years, the Millbrook Courier has printed the news of one small river town. Now Malik's grandmother, its editor, is about to print the very last edition. Malik's…

5th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeyFamily · Newspapers · Mystery16 questions
🏔️

The Ice Tower of Shara

High in the Himalayan mountains of Ladakh, the glacier that waters Dolma's village is shrinking, and every spring the streams arrive later. Her uncle has a wild idea:…

5th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeyCulture · Climate · Nature16 questions
🌰

The Windmill That Ran Dry

Mari's grandfather planted the family's almond orchard forty years ago, when water flowed easily from the ground. Now, in the fourth year of a drought, the trees are…

5th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeyFarm · Family · Climate16 questions
🌊

The Drifting Quarter

In the year 2091, Andrés lives on the oldest platform of a floating city built after the seas rose. Now that platform is cracking, and the city council wants to cut it…

5th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeySci-Fi · Ocean · Climate16 questions