📚 Reading Quest
🪐

The Knocking Under Europa

Tavi Lindqvist-Okoro lives in a research station buried under twenty kilometers of ice on Europa, a moon of Jupiter, where a dark ocean hides beneath the frozen crust. When strange knocking sounds start coming through the station walls and the deep drill keeps being damaged, the adults think something out there is attacking them. Tavi isn't so sure. Told by Tavi and by the creatures in the dark water, this is a story about listening before you fight.

4th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonSci-Fi · Ocean · Polar2207 wordsAbout 30 minutes

Read it in the app 🚀

In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.

Words to know

hydrophone
a microphone that records sounds underwater
pressure
a pushing force; deep underwater or under ice, the pressure is enormous
communicate
to share information or feelings with someone
Europa
one of Jupiter's moons, covered with ice that hides an ocean beneath
vent
an opening in the seafloor where hot water and minerals pour out

Chapter 1: Tavi

There are three hundred and nine steps from my bunk to the observation window, and I have counted every one.

Halcyon Station is not very big. It's a cluster of round metal rooms connected by tunnels, hanging in the dark ocean like a bunch of grapes, twenty kilometers under the ice of Europa. Europa is one of Jupiter's moons. From space, it looks like a cracked white marble. Underneath its frozen shell, though, there's an ocean, a real one, deeper than any ocean on Earth, with twice as much water as all of Earth's oceans put together. Nobody had ever seen it until twelve years ago, when the first robot submarine melted its way down through the ice and sent back pictures.

Now there are forty-one people living down here. I'm the only kid.

My mother, Commander Ingrid Lindqvist, is in charge of the station. My father, Dr. Emeka Okoro, is a biologist. He came here to find life. So far, he's found it: tiny, see-through shrimp-like things that swim around the hot vents on the seafloor, where warm water bubbles up through cracks in the rock. Bacteria that eat minerals instead of sunlight. Pale, ribbon-like creatures as long as your arm, which pulse with blue light. Everyone on Earth went wild when he announced it. Life on another world.

But nothing big. Nothing smart.

At least, that's what we thought until the knocking started.

It began three weeks ago. I was at the observation window, which is my favorite place on the whole station, looking out at the black water with the floodlights on, when I felt it more than heard it. A deep thud, through the floor. Then another. Then three quick ones in a row, like someone rapping their knuckles on a door.

Thud. Thud. Thud-thud-thud.

Then silence.

I stood there with my heart pounding, waiting for it to come again. The floodlights shone out into the water, lighting up a few drifting specks, and beyond them there was only black, going on forever. Somewhere in that black, something had knocked. I told the night-shift engineer. He said it was probably the ice shifting. Europa's ice creaks and groans all the time, because Jupiter's gravity squeezes the moon like a stress ball. But ice doesn't knock in rhythm. Ice doesn't wait and knock again.

Since then, it has happened every day, sometimes ten times a day. It always comes from the direction of the deep drill. The drill is the station's biggest project: a long tube that goes down into the seafloor, trying to reach a pocket of hot, mineral-rich water far below, which the scientists think could be where life on Europa first began.

And the drill keeps breaking.

Not just breaking. Something is damaging it. Twice, the engineers have sent a robot down to check, and twice they've found the outside of the drill pipe dented and scratched, as if something has been ramming into it, over and over. Last week, one of the cameras on the drill was knocked clean off.

The adults are nervous. I can tell, because they all start talking in quiet voices the minute I walk into the galley. Last night, through the door of the command room, I heard my mother say: "If something out there is attacking the drill, we need to be ready to defend this station."

And somebody else said: "The sonar pulse. Turn it all the way up. Loud enough to scare off anything that comes near."

My father said, "We don't even know what it is yet."

"Exactly," said my mother. "That's what worries me."

I went back to the observation window and pressed my hand against the cold, thick glass, and I looked out into the dark.

Something was out there. And I didn't think it was angry. I don't know why. I just didn't.

Check your understanding

  1. Key details Where is Halcyon Station?

    1. On the surface of Jupiter
    2. On Earth, at the bottom of the Pacific Ocean
    3. In the ocean beneath twenty kilometers of ice on Europa, a moon of Jupiter
    4. On a spaceship orbiting Europa
  2. Vocabulary The station's drill is trying to reach "a pocket of hot, mineral-rich water." What does mineral-rich mean?

    1. Containing a lot of natural substances, like metals and salts, from rocks
    2. Very cold and clean
    3. Owned by wealthy people
    4. Full of fish
  3. Cause and effect Why do the adults think something might be attacking the station?

    1. They saw a giant creature through the window
    2. A crew member was hurt
    3. The knocking comes from the drill, and the drill has been dented, scratched, and had a camera knocked off
    4. The lights keep turning off
  4. Inference What does the last line, "I didn't think it was angry," suggest about Tavi?

    1. She is too young to understand danger
    2. She trusts her own feelings and observations, and she is open to an idea the adults haven't considered
    3. She has seen the creature before
    4. She wants to be the commander

Chapter 2: The Many

We are the Many. We do not have one name. We do not have one body. We are a great net of long, soft bodies, joined together in the warm water above the vents, and we think together, the way a school of fish turns together.

We have lived in the dark for longer than the ice has been thick.

We do not see. There is nothing to see. Instead we listen, and we feel. The water carries every sound, and we feel every sound in our bodies, through the whole net of us. The bubbling of the vents. The click of the little swimmers. The slow, deep groan of the ice far above as Jupiter pulls on it and lets it go, pulls and lets it go, like breathing.

We know this ocean the way you know your own heartbeat.

Then the strangers came.

At first they were only sounds. A strange hum, high and steady, from far above, coming closer. Then a ball of light, which we could feel as warmth on our skins, sinking slowly down, and settling in the water near the vents. Then more humming. Then voices, strange and muffled, through hard walls.

We did not understand them. But we were curious. We came close, and we listened.

Then they began the long pipe.

It went down, down into the seafloor, toward the place we call the Deep Breath. The Deep Breath is a great hollow pocket of hot gas, trapped under the rock, beneath the vents. It is very old. It is very full. It pushes up against the rock above it, always pushing, the way a held breath pushes against your chest. We know never to touch it. Long ago, before the oldest of the Many can remember, a crack opened above a Deep Breath in another part of the ocean, and the gas burst out all at once. The water boiled. The vents broke. Everything nearby was destroyed, every swimmer, every part of the Many that lived there.

And the strangers' pipe was going straight toward it.

We tried to tell them. We came to their hard walls and we knocked, the way they knock: we had heard them inside, striking metal against metal in a pattern, over and over, whenever something was wrong. Three long sounds, then three short ones. We had listened to it many times. It is the sound they make when they are afraid. So we made it too. We said: afraid. Afraid. Danger.

They did not answer.

So we went to the pipe itself. We pushed against it with our bodies, as hard as we could, again and again. We tried to bend it. We tried to stop it. We knocked away one of its little eyes.

The pipe kept going down.

Now, the strangers have started a new sound. A terrible one. A sharp, screaming pulse that tears through the water and through our bodies like fire. It hurts. It hurts so much that the Many must pull back, away from the warm vents, into the cold.

We do not understand why they will not listen.

The Deep Breath is close now. We can feel it, pushing.

Check your understanding

  1. Main idea What is the main thing the reader learns in Chapter 2?

    1. The Many are planning to attack the station
    2. The creatures have been trying to warn the humans that the drill is heading toward a dangerous pocket of gas
    3. The creatures want to steal the drill
    4. The creatures are afraid of light
  2. Cause and effect Why did the Many push against the drill pipe?

    1. They were hungry and thought it was food
    2. They wanted to play with it
    3. They were trying to stop it from reaching the Deep Breath, which could explode and destroy everything nearby
    4. They were angry at the humans
  3. Inference Where did the Many learn the pattern "three long sounds, then three short ones"?

    1. They heard the humans make that pattern inside the station whenever something was wrong, and they copied it
    2. It is the Many's own ancient song
    3. The vents make that sound naturally
    4. Tavi taught it to them
  4. Inference The author shows the same events from two viewpoints: the humans' and the Many's. What does this help the reader understand?

    1. That the humans are evil
    2. That the same actions can mean completely different things depending on who is looking, and misunderstanding can lead to harm
    3. That the Many are smarter than humans
    4. That the drill is not important

Chapter 3: Tavi

The sonar pulse started on Tuesday, and on Tuesday the knocking stopped.

All the adults were relieved. "It worked," said the engineer, Mr. Brennan, in the galley. "Scared them off." People laughed and clapped him on the back.

I didn't feel relieved. I felt sick. Because I had been at the observation window when the pulse started, and I'd seen the water outside go wild for a second, a ripple of blue light flickering away into the darkness like a thousand people running out of a room.

That night, I couldn't sleep. I kept hearing the knocking in my head. Thud. Thud. Thud-thud-thud.

Then I sat straight up in my bunk.

Three long. Three short.

I knew that pattern.

I got up and ran all three hundred and nine steps, in my socks, to the station's emergency locker by the docking bay. On the inside of the locker door, there's a laminated card with the station's emergency signals. I'd had to memorize them on my first day here. If the radio fails, if the power goes out, you bang on the nearest pipe with a wrench. One long, one short means "come here." Two long means "all clear."

Three long, three short means DANGER. GET OUT.

And every time there was a drill, an emergency practice, the engineers banged that pattern on the pipes all over the station, again and again, so everyone could hear it.

The creatures had been listening.

I ran to my father's lab. He was still awake, bent over his screens, looking tired. I told him everything, so fast he had to make me start over twice. Then he pulled up the hydrophone recordings, the underwater microphones that record every sound outside the station, and played the knocking from the last three weeks.

Thud. Thud. Thud-thud-thud.

My father went very quiet.

"It's the emergency signal," he said slowly. "Not almost. Exactly. The same rhythm. The same timing." He looked at me. "Tavi, they're not attacking. They're copying us. They're saying the only thing they've heard us say."

"They're saying danger," I said. "It's a warning. They're trying to communicate with us. But about what?"

We looked at each other. Then, at the same moment, we both turned to the screen that showed the drill.

It was four hundred meters into the seafloor now, and still going. The drill pipe was sending back readings every few seconds: temperature, rock type, pressure.

My father zoomed in on the pressure reading. It was rising. Not slowly, the way it should, a little more with every meter. It was climbing fast. Faster every minute.

"There's something down there," my father whispered. "Something under enormous pressure, right below the drill. Gas, maybe. A pocket of it." He was already on his feet. "If the drill breaks into it..."

He didn't finish. He didn't have to.

We ran together to the command room, where my mother was on the night shift.

Check your understanding

  1. Sequence What did Tavi do right after she recognized the knocking pattern?

    1. She told her mother
    2. She ran to the emergency locker to check the card of signals
    3. She turned off the sonar pulse
    4. She went back to sleep
  2. Character Why does Tavi feel sick when everyone else is relieved?

    1. She ate too much in the galley
    2. She saw the creatures flee in pain and suspected the sonar was hurting something that wasn't really dangerous
    3. She is afraid of the engineer
    4. She wanted the knocking to continue for fun
  3. Vocabulary Dr. Okoro says the knocking matches "not almost. Exactly." Why is this important?

    1. An exact match means the creatures deliberately copied the humans' signal, which shows they are intelligent and trying to communicate
    2. It means the recording is broken
    3. It means the humans made the sounds themselves
    4. It shows the creatures like music
  4. Inference Why does the pressure reading make Tavi's father so alarmed?

    1. It means the drill is broken
    2. It means the creatures are attacking again
    3. It suggests the drill is about to break into a pocket of high-pressure gas that could burst and endanger the whole station
    4. It means the water is getting colder

Chapter 4: Tavi

My mother listened to the whole thing without saying a word. She watched the pressure numbers climbing on the screen. She listened to the hydrophone recording twice.

Then she did the thing I love most about her. She didn't argue, and she didn't waste a second being embarrassed about being wrong.

"Stop the drill," she said. "Now. Pull it back fifty meters. And shut off that sonar."

The engineers grumbled for about four seconds. Then they saw her face, and they did it.

For a long time, nothing happened. The drill stopped. The sonar fell silent. The station hummed. My father and I stood at the command room screen, watching the pressure reading. It stopped rising. It held. We all started to breathe again.

Then the robot submarine went down to look at the rock below the drill, and what it found made everyone go very quiet. A deep scan showed an enormous hollow pocket, just thirty meters below the end of the drill, packed with gas at a pressure so high that the engineers kept re-checking their numbers because they didn't believe them. If the drill had broken through, the gas would have burst upward all at once. The seafloor would have cracked open. The vents would have been destroyed, and so would every living thing around them.

And Halcyon Station, hanging in the water just above, would have been torn apart.

"They saved us," said my father quietly. "Whatever they are. They knew it was there, and they tried to tell us, and we tried to scare them away."

My mother looked out the command room window at the black water. "Then we owe them an apology," she said. "Does anyone know how to say sorry to an ocean?"

Nobody did. So I tried.

The next morning, I went to the docking bay with a wrench, and I stood by the big pipe that runs out into the water. I thought about it for a long time. Then I banged on the pipe.

Two long.

All clear.

I waited. Nothing. I did it again. Two long. Two long.

Then, through the floor, far away, I felt it. A soft thud. Then another.

Two long.

I don't know how long I stood there, crying, with the wrench in my hand. My father found me there and stood beside me without saying anything, and then he put his arm around me, and we just listened.

That was eight months ago.

The drill is gone now. My mother decided that we would not drill toward the hot pocket ever again. The scientists on Earth argued about it for weeks, but she held firm. Instead, my father has built a new kind of hydrophone, the most sensitive one ever made, and set it down by the vents. Every day, we listen. And every day, we learn a little more of their language: the tapping and the humming and the long, slow pulses of blue light that we can now see, on the cameras, rippling through the great soft net of them in the dark.

We haven't figured out much yet. But we know one more word now. When they're near the station, they tap one long, one short.

Come here.

And every time they do, I go.

Check your understanding

  1. Character What does Commander Lindqvist do that Tavi admires?

    1. She refuses to listen to Tavi
    2. She acts immediately on the new evidence, without arguing or wasting time being embarrassed about being wrong
    3. She blames the engineers
    4. She keeps the sonar on to be safe
  2. Key details What did the robot submarine's scan find?

    1. A hidden creature city
    2. A huge pocket of gas at extremely high pressure just thirty meters below the drill
    3. A crack in the station's walls
    4. Nothing unusual
  3. Inference Why does Tavi bang "two long" on the pipe?

    1. To call the engineers
    2. To test whether the pipe is broken
    3. "Two long" means "all clear," so she is using the humans' own signal to tell the creatures that the danger is over, a kind of apology and thank you
    4. To scare the creatures away
  4. Theme What is the main message of the story?

    1. Before we decide that something unfamiliar is a threat, we should listen carefully, because it may be trying to help us
    2. Scientists should never drill on other planets
    3. Children are always smarter than adults
    4. Loud noises are the best way to stay safe

Spelling words

These 12 words all appear in the story.

  • Europa
  • Jupiter
  • station
  • ocean
  • pressure
  • signal
  • pattern
  • communicate
  • creatures
  • warning
  • hydrophone
  • commander

Writing prompt

The adults on Halcyon Station thought the knocking was an attack, but Tavi discovered it was a warning. Why do you think the adults misunderstood the creatures? Write about a time when someone's actions were misunderstood, and explain how listening carefully could change what happens. Use details from the story.

Reading skills practiced

Key details, Vocabulary, Cause and effect, Inference, Main idea, Sequence, Character, Theme.

Answer key for grown-ups
  1. In the ocean beneath twenty kilometers of ice on Europa, a moon of Jupiter It hangs "in the dark ocean like a bunch of grapes."
  2. Containing a lot of natural substances, like metals and salts, from rocks Minerals come from rocks; the hot water carries them.
  3. The knocking comes from the drill, and the drill has been dented, scratched, and had a camera knocked off The damage looks like something is ramming the drill.
  4. She trusts her own feelings and observations, and she is open to an idea the adults haven't considered She is the only one not assuming the worst.
  5. The creatures have been trying to warn the humans that the drill is heading toward a dangerous pocket of gas The knocking and the ramming were warnings, not attacks.
  6. They were trying to stop it from reaching the Deep Breath, which could explode and destroy everything nearby They remembered what happened when a Deep Breath burst long ago.
  7. They heard the humans make that pattern inside the station whenever something was wrong, and they copied it They tried to "speak" to the humans in the humans' own warning signal.
  8. That the same actions can mean completely different things depending on who is looking, and misunderstanding can lead to harm What looks like an attack to the humans is a desperate warning to the Many.
  9. She ran to the emergency locker to check the card of signals She needed to confirm what "three long, three short" meant.
  10. She saw the creatures flee in pain and suspected the sonar was hurting something that wasn't really dangerous She saw the blue light "running out of a room."
  11. An exact match means the creatures deliberately copied the humans' signal, which shows they are intelligent and trying to communicate Copying a pattern exactly suggests understanding, not random noise.
  12. It suggests the drill is about to break into a pocket of high-pressure gas that could burst and endanger the whole station He doesn't finish his sentence, but the danger is clear.
  13. She acts immediately on the new evidence, without arguing or wasting time being embarrassed about being wrong Admitting a mistake and changing course quickly takes courage.
  14. A huge pocket of gas at extremely high pressure just thirty meters below the drill If the drill had broken through, the gas would have burst upward.
  15. "Two long" means "all clear," so she is using the humans' own signal to tell the creatures that the danger is over, a kind of apology and thank you She speaks to them in the one shared language they have.
  16. Before we decide that something unfamiliar is a threat, we should listen carefully, because it may be trying to help us The "attack" was a warning, and listening saved everyone.

More 4th grade stories

🐻‍❄️

The Bear in the Shed

In a small town on the shore of a frozen bay, Eli Spence's mother works on the polar bear patrol. When a hungry young bear wanders into town, Eli knows exactly why she…

4th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonAnimals · Polar16 questions
🐶

The Dog Who Ran for Mayor

Every summer, the tiny village of Tuckett's Landing elects an honorary mayor, and every vote costs a dollar for the volunteer fire department. Rosa Delgado enters her…

4th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonHumor · Village16 questions
🔋

The Second-Best Invention

Hana Sato and Dev Raman have been rivals since second grade, and this year only one of them can win the city's Young Inventors Fair. Hana is building a pill box for her…

4th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonFriends · Inventors16 questions
🛷

The Dog at the Front

Josie Peter has trained all winter for the Junior Taiga Sled Dog Race, a sixty-mile run along a frozen river in Alaska. She is sure that her lead dog, Moss, can carry…

4th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonSports · Polar16 questions
🥔

The Potato That Makes You Cry

High in the Andes mountains of Peru, Wayra's grandmother grows more than sixty kinds of potatoes on ancient stone terraces, while Wayra's father grows just one kind,…

4th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonFarm · Culture · Ancient Civilizations16 questions
🧭

The Snowdrifts Point Home

In a small Inuit town in the Canadian Arctic, Leah Akavak's grandfather keeps asking her to describe the ice, the sky, the snow. She thinks it is a teaching game, and…

4th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonCulture · Polar · Family16 questions