The Puffin Counter
Every summer of her life, Sigrun has helped her grandfather count the puffins on the cliffs of tiny Skarvøy island. This summer is her last, because her family is moving to the city. Sigrun has a secret plan to stay. But on the night the young puffins take their first flight, she learns that leaving and staying are not as simple as she thought.
4th gradeLevel 5 · Thunder TigerAnimals · Islands · Family2356 wordsAbout 30 minutes
In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.
Words to know
- puffling
- a baby puffin
- burrow
- a hole or tunnel in the ground that an animal digs to live in
- decline
- a slow drop in number or strength
- fledge
- when a young bird grows its flight feathers and leaves the nest for the first time
- colony
- a large group of the same kind of animal living together in one place
Chapter 1: The Last Count
The island of Skarvøy was so small that you could walk around the whole thing in an afternoon, so steep that the sheep had stronger legs than most people, and so far out in the North Atlantic that on a clear day the horizon was the only neighbor it had. Thirty-one people lived there. Sigrun Joensen was one of them, at least for six more weeks.
On the first morning of June, she climbed the cliff path behind her grandfather, carrying his old green notebook in a plastic bag so the wind wouldn't steal the pages.
"Count with your eyes first," Grandpa Hallvard said, the way he said it every year. "Then with your pencil."
They lay down on their stomachs in the wet grass at the top of the cliff and looked over the edge. Below them, the rock face was alive. Hundreds of puffins stood on narrow ledges and at the mouths of their burrows, black-backed and white-fronted, with their bright orange feet and those enormous striped beaks that always made Sigrun think of clowns dressed for a party.
Puffins spend most of the year far out at sea, floating on the waves, never touching land. But every April they return to the same island, often to the very same burrow, and find the same partner they had the year before. Each pair lays just one egg. When it hatches, the chick, called a puffling, stays hidden underground for about six weeks while its parents fly back and forth from the sea with beakfuls of small silver fish.
Grandpa Hallvard had been counting the Skarvøy puffins every summer for fifty-two years. His notebooks filled a whole shelf in his kitchen. Scientists from the university on the mainland wrote to him every autumn to ask for his numbers.
Sigrun had helped since she was five. She knew how to use the binoculars, how to mark each occupied burrow with a tiny dot on the hand-drawn map, and how to tell a puffin carrying fish from one that was just standing around being handsome.
"Two hundred and twelve on the north ledge," she said finally.
Grandpa wrote it down. He was quiet for a moment. Then he flipped back through the pages and showed her the number from ten years ago, written in the same careful handwriting. Three hundred and ninety.
"Fewer every year," he said. "The sea is getting warmer, and the little fish they eat are moving north to colder water. So the parents have to fly farther to find food." He closed the notebook. "It's a slow decline. You don't notice it one summer to the next. You only see it when you look back."
Sigrun didn't want to talk about decline, or about things getting smaller. That was all anyone talked about on Skarvøy lately. The island school had only four children left, and in August it was closing. That was why her father had taken a job in the city, three hours away by ferry and bus. That was why the boxes were already stacked in their hallway.
"I'm not going," she said to the puffins.
Grandpa didn't answer. He looked out at the sea.
"I mean it," Sigrun said. "I'll live with you. I can help with the count and the sheep. I can do school on the computer. Lots of kids do."
"Have you said this to your parents?"
"Not yet." She pulled at the grass. "I'm working out a plan."
Grandpa Hallvard was quiet for so long that she thought he hadn't heard. Then he said, "Write the number for the south ledge, please," and handed her the pencil, and she knew he had heard every word.
Check your understanding
Key details Why are there fewer puffins on Skarvøy each year?
- People are hunting them
- The cliffs are falling into the sea
- Warmer water is pushing the small fish they eat farther north
- The puffins are moving to the city
Vocabulary Grandpa calls it "a slow decline." What does "decline" mean?
- A sudden storm
- A gradual drop in number
- A kind of seabird
- A climb up a steep cliff
Inference Why does the author include so many facts about puffins in this chapter?
- To fill space before the real story starts
- To help readers understand the puffins' lives so they care about what happens to them and to the island
- To convince readers to keep puffins as pets
- To show that Sigrun doesn't know anything about birds
Inference How do you think Grandpa feels about Sigrun's plan to stay with him?
- He is thrilled and agrees right away
- He has heard her but has doubts he isn't ready to say out loud
- He thinks she is joking
- He is angry with her for wanting to stay
Chapter 2: The First Puffling
Sigrun's plan had three parts. Part one was to prove she was useful. Part two was to prove she could do her schoolwork alone. Part three was to convince her parents, which was the part she didn't like to think about.
So all through June and July, she worked. She got up early to help Grandpa with the sheep. She finished every lesson in the math workbook her teacher had given her for summer. She helped Mrs. Poulsen at the shop stack cans and helped old Jens mend the nets at the harbor. Every evening, she went up to the cliffs with Grandpa and wrote down the numbers.
Her mother noticed. "You're everywhere at once these days," she said one evening, packing dishes into a cardboard box.
"I like being busy," said Sigrun, which was only part of the truth.
The plan was going well until the night Sigrun found her five-year-old self in the notebook.
She was looking for an old number on the shelf in Grandpa's kitchen and pulled out a notebook from six summers ago. On one page, among the neat columns, was a drawing in fat green crayon. It was a puffin with a very large head and very small wings, and next to it, in wobbly letters, she had written SIGRUN SAW A PUFFLING.
She remembered it like it had happened yesterday.
It had been August, the season when the pufflings leave their burrows. Grandpa had woken her up at midnight and carried her, wrapped in a wool blanket, down to the harbor. It was the one week of the year when the young puffins made their first flight. They always flew at night, under the cover of darkness, to escape the gulls. They were supposed to follow the moonlight on the water out to sea.
But some of them got confused by the lights of the village, and instead of flying toward the moon, they flew toward the street lamps and landed on the roads, between the houses, under parked cars.
That night, five-year-old Sigrun had followed Grandpa through the quiet village with a flashlight. They found a puffling huddled against a wall behind the shop. It was gray and fluffy, with a short dark beak and none of the bright colors its parents had. Grandpa scooped it up gently and let Sigrun hold it. It was so light. Its heart was beating against her fingers like a tiny drum.
They carried it to the edge of the harbor, and Grandpa showed her how to toss it upward, firmly but gently, toward the dark sea. The puffling fluttered, dropped, caught the air and flew away over the black water, out toward the place where the moon touched the waves.
"Where will it go?" she had asked.
"Out to sea," said Grandpa. "It won't touch land again for two or three years. And then, if it's lucky, it will come back here. To the place where it began."
Sigrun sat at the kitchen table with the old notebook open in her lap and found that her eyes were wet.
Grandpa came in from the porch. He looked at the crayon puffin over her shoulder and smiled.
"You held it like it was made of glass," he said.
"Grandpa," she said, "please let me stay."
He sat down across from her. He took a long time to answer. When he did, he didn't say yes and he didn't say no.
"Let's get through puffling week first," he said. "Then we'll talk."
Check your understanding
Sequence When did the event with the crayon drawing take place?
- Six summers ago, when Sigrun was five, before the main events of the story
- On the first day of June this year
- The night after the school closed
- After Sigrun moved to the city
Cause and effect Why do some pufflings land in the village instead of flying out to sea?
- They are too weak to fly that far
- Gulls chase them into the village
- The village lights confuse them, and they fly toward the lamps instead of the moonlight on the water
- They are looking for their parents
Inference Why does Sigrun's plan to "prove she was useful" show how she feels?
- She is bored on the island
- She hopes that if she makes herself needed, the adults will let her stay
- She wants to earn money for the city
- She wants to impress her new teacher
Character Why does finding the crayon drawing make Sigrun cry?
- She is embarrassed by her bad drawing
- It reminds her how deeply she belongs to the island, just as she is about to leave it
- She tore the page by accident
- She is angry that Grandpa kept it
Chapter 3: Puffling Week
Puffling week came in the middle of August, three days before the ferry was scheduled to take the Joensen family away.
This year, there was a new problem. The year before, the island council had put up four bright new floodlights at the harbor so the fishing boats could unload safely at night. They were much brighter than the old street lamps. On the first night of puffling week, Sigrun and Grandpa found eleven pufflings on the harbor road, hopping in confused circles under the glaring lights.
On the second night, they found twenty-three.
"The lights are too strong," Grandpa said, holding a box with six frightened pufflings rustling inside. "We need the council to switch them off for the week."
"Then ask them!"
"I did. Two of them say the boats need the lights. The meeting to vote on it is tomorrow evening." He rubbed his tired eyes. "And there's something else, Sigrun. I'm seventy-four. I can't walk the harbor all night, every night, for a week. Not anymore. My knees won't let me."
Sigrun looked at him in the harsh white light. She had never thought of her grandfather as old. He had always been the person who carried her down the cliff path and lifted the heavy nets. But now she saw how slowly he was walking, and how he leaned on the harbor wall when he thought she wasn't watching.
The next evening, her parents held a goodbye supper at the community hall. Almost the whole island came. There were fish cakes and rhubarb cake, and old Jens played the accordion, and everyone kept hugging Sigrun and telling her how much they would miss her.
And right in the middle of it, Sigrun realized the council meeting was happening in the room next door.
She slipped out of the party, opened the door and walked into the meeting. Five grown-ups at a long table turned to stare at her.
"Excuse me," she said, and her voice shook. "I want to talk about the harbor lights."
She had not planned a speech. But she had Grandpa's notebooks in her head. She told them how many pufflings they had found on the roads in two nights. She told them that every puffling that didn't make it to sea was one less puffin to come back to an island that was already losing them. She told them that the decline was slow, the kind of change you only see when you look back. And then she said the thing she hadn't planned to say at all.
"My grandfather has been doing this for fifty-two years. But he can't walk the harbor all night anymore, and I'm leaving on Saturday. So if you don't turn off the lights, I don't know who's going to pick them up."
Nobody spoke for a long moment. Then Mrs. Poulsen, who ran the shop and sat on the council, said slowly, "The boats could use their own deck lights for one week. My husband managed it for thirty years."
The vote was four to one. The floodlights would be dimmed for the rest of puffling week, every week, every August.
When Sigrun walked back into the party, her grandfather was standing by the door. He had heard everything through the wall. He didn't say anything. He just put his hand on her head, the way he used to when she was small, and left it there.
Check your understanding
Main idea What is this chapter mostly about?
- The goodbye party and the food that was served
- Sigrun convincing the council to dim the harbor lights so the pufflings can find the sea
- Old Jens playing the accordion
- Grandpa's knees getting worse
Cause and effect Why are more pufflings landing on the harbor road this year?
- There are more puffins on the island than before
- The council put up bright new floodlights at the harbor
- The moon is not shining this year
- The gulls are chasing them
Inference Why is it important that Sigrun notices Grandpa leaning on the harbor wall?
- It shows that the wall is about to fall down
- It shows her that her grandfather is getting older and cannot do everything he used to
- It means he is hiding from someone
- It shows he doesn't want to help the pufflings
Character What does Sigrun's choice to leave her own party show about her?
- She doesn't like parties
- She cares more about protecting the pufflings than about being the center of attention
- She wants to get away from her parents
- She is angry at the islanders
Chapter 4: Where It Began
On the last night of puffling week, Sigrun and Grandpa sat on the harbor wall together under a sky full of stars. The floodlights were dark. The moon laid a silver road across the water, and in the quiet, every few minutes, they heard a soft flutter as a puffling launched from the cliffs and flew straight out along the path of light.
They had found only two pufflings on the roads that night. Both of them were safely out at sea.
"So," said Grandpa. "We said we'd talk after puffling week."
Sigrun's heart sank. She had been dreading this. She had also been thinking hard for three days, and something inside her had gradually changed, so slowly that she hadn't noticed until now. Like a decline. Or maybe the opposite of one.
"I want to stay," she said. "I still want to. But I don't think I should."
Grandpa waited.
"Mom and Dad need me too," she said slowly. "And there's no school here. And you can't..." She stopped, because she didn't want to say it.
"I can't take care of an eleven-year-old and a hundred sheep and my knees all at once," Grandpa finished for her. "No. I can't. I'm sorry, little puffin."
Then he told her something she had never known.
"When I was twelve," he said, "Skarvøy had no school at all. My parents sent me to the mainland to live with my aunt. I cried the whole way on the boat. I was sure I was losing the island forever." He smiled at the dark water. "I came home every summer. I counted puffins every summer. When I grew up, I came back to stay. It was still mine. A place you love doesn't stop being yours when you leave it."
"But who will do the count?" Sigrun asked. "When you can't anymore?"
Grandpa reached into his coat and pulled out a brand-new notebook, still in its plastic wrapping. It was green, exactly like his. On the first page, he had written in his careful handwriting: SKARVØY PUFFIN COUNT. RECORDER: SIGRUN JOENSEN.
"You will," he said. "Every summer, when you come back. I'll do the June count. You'll do August. When I'm too old for June, you'll do that too. The scientists don't care where you live the rest of the year. They only care that someone keeps looking."
Sigrun held the notebook against her chest.
"And during the year," Grandpa added, "you'll tell the children in the city about this place. Most of them have never seen a puffin. Somebody has to tell them why the lights should go dark in August."
On Saturday morning, the ferry left Skarvøy at seven o'clock. Sigrun stood at the back rail with her parents and watched the island grow smaller and smaller, a dark green shape with white birds wheeling above its cliffs. Her grandfather stood at the end of the harbor wall, waving his cap.
She felt sad, and she felt hopeful, and she felt something else she didn't have a name for, all tangled together like the nets old Jens mended at the harbor. But she didn't cry. She thought about the puffling she had held when she was five, flying away over the black water.
It hadn't been losing the island. It had been beginning.
When the island finally slipped below the horizon, Sigrun opened the new notebook to the second page and, in careful handwriting, wrote: DAY ONE. Everything that happens next is part of the count.
Check your understanding
Vocabulary Something inside Sigrun had "gradually changed." What does "gradually" mean?
- Suddenly and loudly
- Slowly, a little at a time
- Angrily
- By accident
Inference Why does Grandpa tell Sigrun about leaving the island when he was twelve?
- To make her feel guilty for wanting to stay
- To show her that leaving doesn't have to mean losing the island, because he left and came back
- To explain why he dislikes the mainland
- To prove that he was braver than she is
Theme Which sentence BEST states a theme of the story?
- Small islands should be abandoned
- Children should always get what they want
- Leaving a place you love can be a new beginning, not only a loss, if you stay connected to it
- Puffins are more important than people
Inference How does the author connect Sigrun to the puffling she held when she was five?
- They both have orange feet
- Like the puffling, Sigrun must leave the place where she began, with the hope of returning one day
- They are both afraid of the dark
- Neither of them can fly
Spelling words
These 12 words all appear in the story.
- island
- burrow
- decline
- notebook
- binoculars
- flashlight
- beginning
- harbor
- gradually
- cardboard
- horizon
- accordion
Writing prompt
Sigrun's grandfather says that "a place you love doesn't stop being yours when you leave it." Do you agree? Use details from the story and from your own life to explain your answer.
Reading skills practiced
Key details, Vocabulary, Inference, Sequence, Cause and effect, Character, Main idea, Theme.
Answer key for grown-ups
- Warmer water is pushing the small fish they eat farther north Grandpa explains that the parents have to fly farther to find food.
- A gradual drop in number The number fell from 390 to 212 over ten years.
- To help readers understand the puffins' lives so they care about what happens to them and to the island The facts explain the counting and the changes that matter to the characters.
- He has heard her but has doubts he isn't ready to say out loud He is silent for a long time and changes the subject.
- Six summers ago, when Sigrun was five, before the main events of the story The notebook was from six summers ago, a flashback to her childhood.
- The village lights confuse them, and they fly toward the lamps instead of the moonlight on the water Pufflings are supposed to follow the moonlight but the lamps lead them astray.
- She hopes that if she makes herself needed, the adults will let her stay Her busy work is part one of her plan to stay on Skarvøy.
- It reminds her how deeply she belongs to the island, just as she is about to leave it The memory of the puffling connects her love of the island to her fear of leaving.
- Sigrun convincing the council to dim the harbor lights so the pufflings can find the sea Sigrun speaks at the meeting and the council votes to dim the lights.
- The council put up bright new floodlights at the harbor The new floodlights are much brighter than the old street lamps.
- It shows her that her grandfather is getting older and cannot do everything he used to She realizes for the first time that he is old.
- She cares more about protecting the pufflings than about being the center of attention She chooses the meeting over her own goodbye party.
- Slowly, a little at a time It changed so slowly she didn't notice until now.
- To show her that leaving doesn't have to mean losing the island, because he left and came back His story shows the island stayed his even after he left.
- Leaving a place you love can be a new beginning, not only a loss, if you stay connected to it The ending compares Sigrun to the puffling flying out to sea and coming back.
- Like the puffling, Sigrun must leave the place where she began, with the hope of returning one day Grandpa said the puffling would come back "to the place where it began," and Sigrun's leaving is called "beginning."