The City That Forgot the Sun
Deep beneath the mountains lies the city of Undermere, lit by glowing crystals, where everyone knows the surface is a burning wasteland full of monsters. But the crystals are fading, and nobody knows why. High above, a shepherd boy named Arlo has heard his own village's stories about the ghosts who live inside the mountain. When Wren, a crystal-keeper's apprentice, finds a forbidden stairway, the two of them discover that both stories were built on the same old fear.
4th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonFantasy · Caves2335 wordsAbout 30 minutes
In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.
Words to know
- cavern
- a very large cave
- forbidden
- not allowed; against the rules
- ancestors
- family members who lived long ago, before your grandparents
- surface
- the outside or top layer of something; here, the land above the caves
- dim
- not bright; giving only a little light
Chapter 1: Wren
In Undermere, the light comes from the stones.
They grow in the walls of the great cavern like frost on a window: long, six-sided crystals, as thick as your arm, that glow a soft, steady gold. They light the streets and the houses, which are carved straight into the rock. They light the mushroom farms on the lower terraces and the black, still lake at the bottom of the city, where the blind white fish swim. There are no days or nights in Undermere. There is only the glow, and the bells that ring for waking and sleeping.
Wren was the apprentice of the Crystal Keeper, which meant her job was to take care of the stones. Every waking-bell, she climbed the long ladders with old Keeper Hollis, wiping away the dust, checking for cracks, and writing down how bright each crystal was in a heavy leather book.
And every month, the numbers in the book got smaller.
"They're dimming," Wren said one day, as they climbed down from the high wall above the market. "All of them. Keeper, look at the old pages. Fifty years ago, this crystal was a nine. Now it's a five."
Keeper Hollis was very old, with a long white braid and hands that shook a little on the ladder rungs. "I know, child," she said quietly. "My master saw it too. And his master. Every Keeper since the Founding has watched the stones grow dimmer. Slowly. So slowly that ordinary people don't notice. But they're dying."
"Why?"
"Nobody knows." Keeper Hollis looked up at the vast, glowing ceiling of the cavern, so high it was lost in shadow. "Some say the stones are just old. Some say we've angered the mountain. One day, perhaps not in my lifetime, but perhaps in yours, the last one will go out. And then there will be only darkness."
Everyone in Undermere knew the legend of the Founding. Children learned it as soon as they could talk. Three hundred years ago, their ancestors had lived on the surface, up above, in the world of the Burning Eye. The Burning Eye was a terrible fire in the sky that scorched the land and blinded anyone who looked at it. Monsters roamed the surface, huge and cruel, who hunted people for sport. So the ancestors fled into the mountain, down and down, until they found this great cavern and its glowing stones. They sealed the way behind them so the monsters could never follow.
The way up was forbidden. That was the oldest law in Undermere. Nobody even knew where it was anymore.
But Wren had a secret.
Two months ago, while cleaning the oldest crystals in the very back of the Keeper's workshop, she had found a crack in the wall behind a stack of old barrels. Cold air came through it. Air that smelled different from anything in Undermere: sharp and green and strange. And when she shone her lamp into the crack, she saw stone steps, carved by human hands, leading upward into the dark.
She hadn't told anyone. She had been too afraid.
That night, at the sleeping-bell, Wren lay in her bed and looked at the crystal glowing above her door. It was a four now. When she was little, she remembered, it had been a six.
She thought about the steps.
Check your understanding
Key details What lights the city of Undermere?
- Torches and candles
- Holes in the ceiling that let sunlight in
- Glowing gold crystals that grow in the walls of the cavern
- Glowing mushrooms
Main idea What problem does Wren discover in this chapter?
- The crystals that light the city have been slowly dimming for many years, and no one knows why
- The mushroom farms are failing
- Keeper Hollis is sick
- Monsters are trying to get into the city
Vocabulary The way up to the surface was "forbidden." What does forbidden mean?
- Easy to find
- Very old
- Not allowed; against the rules
- Dangerous to climb
Inference Why does Wren think about the steps when she sees that the crystal above her door is dimmer than it used to be?
- She wants to escape her job
- She is beginning to wonder if the answer to the dimming crystals might be found somewhere beyond the forbidden steps
- She thinks the steps lead to more crystals
- She is afraid the monsters will come down the steps
Chapter 2: Arlo
In the village of Highcombe, on the green side of the mountain, everyone knows not to go near the Hollow Rock.
The Hollow Rock is a huge gray boulder halfway up the slope, where the grass ends and the stones begin. Behind it, there's a crack in the mountainside, black and narrow. On some nights, cold air breathes out of that crack, and it carries strange sounds: faint ringing, like bells very far away, and sometimes a low hum, like a song with no words.
"The Hollow Folk," Arlo's grandmother told him, when he was small. "Ghosts that live in the mountain. Long, long ago, they were a cruel people who lived in these hills, and they did terrible things. So the mountain swallowed them, and now they live inside it, in the dark, forever. If you go too close, they'll reach out and pull you in, and you'll never see the sun again."
Arlo was twelve now, and the village shepherd, and he didn't really believe in ghosts. Mostly. But he still kept his sheep far from the Hollow Rock. Everybody did. It was just what you did.
Then, one morning in early spring, a lamb went missing.
It was a small black lamb with one white ear, born only a week before. Arlo searched the whole hillside. He searched the stream and the stone walls and the gorse bushes. Finally, as the sun was setting, he heard it: a thin, frightened bleating, coming from the direction of the Hollow Rock.
He stood very still for a long time, listening. His heart was pounding. Every story his grandmother had ever told him came rushing back.
But the lamb was crying. And it was his lamb. He was the shepherd.
He walked toward the Hollow Rock.
The lamb was stuck in the crack, wedged between two stones, just inside the black opening. Arlo got down on his knees and reached in. Cold air poured over his arms. He grabbed the lamb and pulled it free, and he was just about to run when he heard something from deep inside the mountain.
Footsteps. Coming up.
And a light. A soft, golden glow, growing brighter, coming up the crack toward him like a rising star.
Arlo couldn't move. He clutched the lamb against his chest.
Then out of the darkness, holding a glowing crystal in one hand, stepped a girl about his own age. She was very pale, as pale as a mushroom, and she was squinting and covering her eyes with her other arm, as if even the dim evening light hurt her. She took one look at him, screamed, and dropped the crystal.
Arlo screamed too.
They stood there for a moment, both screaming, the lamb bleating between them. Then they both stopped.
"Are you a monster?" the girl whispered, staring at him.
"Are you a ghost?" said Arlo.
Check your understanding
Character What does Arlo's decision to go to the Hollow Rock show about him?
- He doesn't care about danger
- He wants to prove the stories wrong
- He is afraid, but his responsibility to his lamb is stronger than his fear
- He is curious about ghosts
Inference How are the Highcombe stories about the Hollow Folk similar to the Undermere stories about the surface?
- Each people believes the other side is dangerous and cruel, and each keeps away out of fear
- Both stories are about sheep
- Both stories say the sun is dangerous
- Both stories are completely true
Cause and effect Why is the girl squinting and covering her eyes?
- She is crying
- She is trying to hide her face
- She has lived her whole life underground, so even dim evening light is painfully bright to her
- She has dust in her eyes
Inference Why is it both funny and important that the two children ask "Are you a monster?" and "Are you a ghost?" at the same time?
- It shows that they are both rude
- It shows that both of them were taught to fear the other, and now they are face to face with an ordinary child
- It shows they speak different languages
- It shows that one of them really is a monster
Chapter 3: Wren and Arlo
It took them almost an hour to stop being afraid of each other.
Wren sat on a rock at the edge of the crack, with her eyes squeezed nearly shut and her cloak pulled over her head like a hood. Arlo sat a careful distance away, holding his lamb. They spoke the same language, though their words sounded a little different, the way water sounds different in a stream and a lake.
Wren told him about Undermere. The glowing stones, the mushroom farms, the black lake, the Founding, the monsters on the surface, the Burning Eye.
Arlo stared at her. "The Burning Eye?" he said. "You mean the sun?"
"Is that what you call it?" Wren peeked out from under her hood at the sky. The sun had set, and the sky in the west was a deep blue going to pink. She had never seen colors like that in her life. "Doesn't it burn you?"
"Only if you lie in it all day," said Arlo. "Then your nose goes red."
Then Arlo told her about Highcombe, and the Hollow Folk, and the ghosts who would pull you into the mountain.
Now Wren stared at him. "We're the ghosts?"
They looked at each other for a long moment. Then they both started to laugh, so hard that the lamb jumped out of Arlo's arms.
That night, Arlo brought her to his grandmother.
Grandmother Bettony was the oldest person in Highcombe, and she knew every story there was. When she saw Wren at her door, pale as milk and squinting, she put down her teacup so fast it spilled. But she let them in. And when Wren told her about the dimming crystals, the old woman went to a chest in the corner and took out a very old book, its pages brown and soft as cloth.
"My grandmother's grandmother's book," she said. "The old stories. The ones we stopped telling."
She read it aloud by candlelight.
Three hundred years ago, there had been a war in these hills. Armies came from the south, burning villages. Some of the villagers fled into the mountain to hide, deep in the caves, where they found the glowing stones. The people who stayed behind fought, and many of them were lost. When the war finally ended, those on the surface sealed the cave mouth with stones, to keep the armies from finding the hidden ones. And they made up a story to keep their own children away from it: the Hollow Folk. Ghosts. Stay away.
Down below, the people in the caves told their children their own story, to keep them from climbing up while the war still raged: the surface is burning. There are monsters.
"Both stories were meant to keep children safe," said Grandmother Bettony softly. "And then everyone forgot why. They just remembered to be afraid."
Then she turned the page, and read something that made Wren stand up so fast she knocked over her chair.
"The stones that light the caves," the old book said, "drink the sun. Each spring, the Lightbearers carry the smallest stones to the high meadow and leave them three days in the light, and the stones drink, and carry the light back down, and share it with the others."
Wren's hands were shaking. "The crystals," she said. "They need sunlight. That's why they're dying. For three hundred years, nobody has carried them up."
Check your understanding
Sequence Which of these did Wren and Arlo do FIRST?
- They told each other the stories of their own people
- They visited Grandmother Bettony
- They read the old book
- Wren learned that the crystals drink sunlight
Key details According to the old book, why did the people of Undermere first go into the mountain?
- Monsters attacked them
- The sun was too hot
- They were hiding from armies during a war
- They were looking for glowing stones
Theme Grandmother Bettony says, "Everyone forgot why. They just remembered to be afraid." What does this show about stories?
- Stories are always lies
- Stories created for a good reason can outlive their purpose, and the fear they cause can continue long after the danger is gone
- Old books should not be trusted
- Children should not listen to their grandparents
Cause and effect Why have the crystals been dimming for three hundred years?
- The mountain is angry
- The crystals are simply too old
- They need sunlight to recharge, and since the cave was sealed, no one has carried them up to the sun
- The people of Undermere have been breaking them
Chapter 4: The Lightbearers
The Council of Undermere did not want to believe it.
Wren stood in the Council chamber, with Keeper Hollis beside her, and told them everything: the steps, the surface, the boy and his lamb, the old book. Some of the councilors shouted. Some said she had been tricked by monsters. One said she should be locked away for breaking the oldest law. Wren's legs were shaking so much she had to hold on to the table.
Then Keeper Hollis stood up, slowly, leaning on her cane.
"I have watched the stones die for seventy years," she said, in a voice that carried all the way to the back of the chamber. "My master watched before me. We have tried everything. Prayers. Polishing. New oils for the walls. Nothing has worked. Now a child brings us an answer, and we want to lock her up for it?" She looked around at all of them. "I would rather risk the surface than lose the light. I will carry the first stone myself."
The chamber was silent.
In the end, the Council agreed to one test. Only one. Six small crystals from the dimmest wall in the city, carried up the forbidden staircase to the high meadow, and left in the sun for three days.
Keeper Hollis was too old to climb all the way. So Wren carried them, wrapped in cloth, in a basket on her back. She climbed for half a day, up and up, through the dark and the cold. It was the longest journey anyone in Undermere had made in three hundred years. And at the top, in the gray early morning, Arlo was waiting at the Hollow Rock with a pair of his grandmother's old sun-shades, made of dark glass, and a wide straw hat.
Together they climbed to the high meadow, above the village, where the grass was soft and full of tiny blue flowers. Wren took the six crystals out of the basket. She laid them in a row on a flat warm rock, facing the east. Then she sat beside them, with her hat pulled low and the dark glasses on her face, and she watched the sun come up for the first time in her life.
It was not a Burning Eye. It was not cruel. It came up slowly over the far hills, gold and then white, and the whole sky changed color around it. The light touched the grass, and the grass sparkled with dew. The light touched her face, and it was warm, like a hand.
Wren cried, and didn't know why.
For three days, she and Arlo sat with the crystals while his sheep grazed around them. Wren's eyes slowly grew used to the light. Arlo taught her the names of the birds. She taught him the names of the forty-two kinds of mushrooms that grew in Undermere. They argued about which was better, stars or crystals, and didn't decide.
And on the third evening, when Wren picked up the six crystals to put them back in her basket, they were blazing so brightly that she had to look away. Not gold anymore. White, like little pieces of the sun.
She carried them down the staircase, with Arlo walking beside her as far as the bottom step. When she placed the first one in the dimmest wall of Undermere, beside the market, the light spread from it into the crystals around it, slowly, like warmth spreading through cold hands. By the next waking-bell, the whole wall was glowing. People came out of their houses and stood in the street and stared.
Keeper Hollis wrote in the leather book, in big shaking letters: NINE.
Now, every spring, the Lightbearers climb the staircase. Not just Wren. Dozens of them, young and old, carrying the dim stones up to the high meadow, where the people of Highcombe bring them bread and cheese and wide straw hats. Some of the Undermere children have started to stay a few extra days, to learn about sheep. Some of the Highcombe children have gone down to see the black lake and the white fish.
Grandmother Bettony has started telling a new story to the little ones in the village. It's about two frightened peoples who forgot why they were afraid, and two children who remembered.
Wren says it's a little exaggerated. Arlo says it isn't nearly exaggerated enough.
Check your understanding
Character What does Keeper Hollis's speech to the Council show about her?
- She is brave and wise enough to value the truth and the city's future more than an old law
- She doesn't care about the rules
- She wants to take credit for Wren's discovery
- She is afraid of the surface
Vocabulary Wren had expected the sun to be a "Burning Eye," but instead it was "warm, like a hand." What does this comparison show?
- The sun was too hot to bear
- The sun felt gentle and comforting, not cruel and dangerous like the old stories said
- Someone touched her face
- The sun was very small
Inference Why does Wren cry when she sees the sunrise, without knowing why?
- Her eyes hurt from the light
- She is overwhelmed by its beauty and by realizing how much her people lost by being afraid for three hundred years
- She is homesick
- She is scared of Arlo
Theme Which statement best expresses the theme of the story?
- Fantasy creatures always live underground
- Fear that is passed down without understanding can keep people apart, but courage and curiosity can bring them back together
- Crystals are more beautiful than stars
- It is always wrong to follow old laws
Spelling words
These 12 words all appear in the story.
- crystals
- cavern
- legend
- forbidden
- staircase
- shepherd
- glowing
- ancestors
- monsters
- sunlight
- journey
- mountain
Writing prompt
Both Undermere and Arlo's village told frightening stories about each other that were not true. Why do you think people created and kept these stories? Explain how the stories once helped and later harmed both peoples, using evidence from the story.
Reading skills practiced
Key details, Main idea, Vocabulary, Inference, Character, Cause and effect, Sequence, Theme.
Answer key for grown-ups
- Glowing gold crystals that grow in the walls of the cavern "In Undermere, the light comes from the stones."
- The crystals that light the city have been slowly dimming for many years, and no one knows why The numbers in the Keeper's book keep getting smaller.
- Not allowed; against the rules It was the oldest law in Undermere.
- She is beginning to wonder if the answer to the dimming crystals might be found somewhere beyond the forbidden steps The fading light pushes her toward the secret she has been afraid to explore.
- He is afraid, but his responsibility to his lamb is stronger than his fear "But the lamb was crying. And it was his lamb. He was the shepherd."
- Each people believes the other side is dangerous and cruel, and each keeps away out of fear Undermere fears surface monsters; Highcombe fears mountain ghosts.
- She has lived her whole life underground, so even dim evening light is painfully bright to her In Undermere there is no sun, only the soft crystal glow.
- It shows that both of them were taught to fear the other, and now they are face to face with an ordinary child The moment reveals how silly and alike their fears are.
- They told each other the stories of their own people They talked and laughed before going to Arlo's grandmother.
- They were hiding from armies during a war The real history was replaced by frightening stories.
- Stories created for a good reason can outlive their purpose, and the fear they cause can continue long after the danger is gone The warnings kept children safe in wartime, but later only kept the peoples apart.
- They need sunlight to recharge, and since the cave was sealed, no one has carried them up to the sun The old book explains that the stones "drink the sun."
- She is brave and wise enough to value the truth and the city's future more than an old law She offers to carry the first stone herself.
- The sun felt gentle and comforting, not cruel and dangerous like the old stories said The comparison shows how wrong the frightening story was.
- She is overwhelmed by its beauty and by realizing how much her people lost by being afraid for three hundred years Strong, mixed feelings can bring tears even when we can't name them.
- Fear that is passed down without understanding can keep people apart, but courage and curiosity can bring them back together The two children's friendship heals a three-hundred-year-old fear.