The Frogs That Waved
In the cloud forest of Panama, the golden frogs that wave at each other across noisy streams are vanishing, and nobody knows why. Valeria suspects the new hiking tours run by her best friend's father. But as she follows the clues with her uncle, a biologist, she discovers a culprit far smaller and stranger than she imagined, and a hard choice about how to save the frogs that are left.
5th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeyMystery · Rainforest · Animals2574 wordsAbout 30 minutes
In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.
Words to know
- amphibian
- a cold-blooded animal, like a frog or salamander, that usually begins life in water and later lives on land
- fungus
- a living thing, like a mushroom or mold, that feeds on other things; some kinds are too small to see
- culprit
- the person or thing responsible for a crime or a problem
- captivity
- being kept in a protected or closed place instead of living free
- semaphore
- a way of sending signals by moving the arms or hands
Chapter 1: The Missing Wave
Valeria Herrera had seen the golden frogs wave exactly one hundred and twelve times. She kept count in a small green notebook.
The frogs lived along the rushing mountain streams above her village of Valle Verde, high in the cloud forest of Panama. They were small, no longer than her thumb, and bright gold with a few black spots, as though someone had dipped them in paint and flicked a brush at them. They sat on wet rocks beside waterfalls, perfectly still, shining like little coins.
And they waved.
Her uncle Rafa, a biologist who studied frogs and every other kind of amphibian, had explained why. The streams were so loud with rushing water that the frogs couldn't hear each other call. So instead, they used semaphore. A male frog would lift one front foot and slowly rotate it in a circle, like someone waving hello from across a crowded room. Sometimes it meant "This is my rock." Sometimes it meant "Come over here." Valeria liked to think that sometimes it just meant "Hello."
In Valle Verde, the golden frogs were more than animals. They were the symbol of the whole country. They appeared on lottery tickets and in paintings and on the sign at the entrance to the village. Valeria's grandmother told an old story that golden frogs brought good luck, and that anyone who saw one wave would have a happy year.
But this year, the frogs were disappearing.
Uncle Rafa had been counting them for six years. Every month, he and Valeria walked the same stretch of the Río Mariposa, a stream that tumbled down the mountain in a chain of little waterfalls. For the first five years, they had counted between forty and sixty frogs on every visit.
In March, they counted thirty.
In April, they counted fourteen.
In May, on a gray, misty morning, they walked the entire stream from top to bottom and found only six.
Valeria stood on a mossy rock in the middle of the water, looking at the empty spot where a big male frog had waved at her every single month for three years. She had named him Señor Sol. Now his rock was bare.
"Where did they go?" she asked.
Uncle Rafa didn't answer right away. He was crouching at the water's edge, looking at something in the mud. When Valeria came closer, she saw that it was a frog. A golden frog, lying on its back, perfectly still. It was not crushed, not bitten, not injured in any way that she could see. It just looked as though it had stopped.
Uncle Rafa picked it up gently with a pair of tweezers and slipped it into a small plastic bag. His face was very serious.
"Something is killing them," he said.
Valeria felt a chill that had nothing to do with the cold mist. "What?"
"I don't know yet." He sealed the bag. "But I intend to find out."
On the walk back down to the village, they passed a group of tourists coming up the trail. There were about fifteen of them, with bright raincoats, expensive cameras, and muddy hiking boots. They were led by a tall man in a green cap that Valeria recognized at once: Señor Ortiz, the father of her best friend, Joaquín.
Señor Ortiz had started a hiking tour company that spring. "Golden Frog Adventures," it was called. Every day, he led groups of visitors up the streams to see the famous frogs. Business was booming.
"Any frogs today?" Señor Ortiz called cheerfully.
"Six," Uncle Rafa said shortly.
Señor Ortiz's smile faded a little. The tourists walked on, laughing and splashing through the shallow edge of the Río Mariposa in their boots.
Valeria watched them go. The frogs had started disappearing this spring. The tours had started this spring. She remembered what her teacher always said in science class: correlation is not the same as cause. Two things happening together doesn't mean one caused the other.
But it was hard not to wonder.
Check your understanding
Key details Why do golden frogs wave instead of calling?
- They have no voices
- The streams are too loud for them to hear each other's calls
- They are trying to scare away birds
- They are copying people
Sequence What happened to the frog count in the Río Mariposa this year?
- It fell from about forty or more to thirty, then fourteen, then six
- It stayed the same as every year
- It rose from six to sixty
- It fell to zero in one month
Inference What does the dead frog's appearance tell Uncle Rafa and Valeria?
- A bird or snake attacked it
- Something invisible or unusual is killing the frogs, since there are no wounds
- The frog was simply very old
- Someone stepped on it
Vocabulary Valeria's teacher says "correlation is not the same as cause." What does this mean?
- If two things happen together, one always causes the other
- Two things happening at the same time doesn't prove that one made the other happen
- Scientists should never study causes
- Tourists always cause problems
Chapter 2: The Prime Suspect
Valeria did not mean to accuse Joaquín's father. In her mind, he was only a suspect, one possibility among many. But it just came out.
They were sitting on the school steps at lunch, sharing a mango, when Joaquín started bragging about how many tourists his father had taken up the mountain that week. Fifty-two. A new record.
"Maybe that's the problem," Valeria said, before she could stop herself.
Joaquín stopped chewing. "What problem?"
"The frogs. They're disappearing. Uncle Rafa found a dead one. And it started the same time your dad's tours started. All those people splashing through the streams, stomping on the rocks..."
Joaquín's face went red. "My dad loves those frogs! That's why he started the tours. So people would see them and care about them!"
"I'm not saying he's doing it on purpose—"
"You're saying he's killing them!" Joaquín stood up and threw the mango pit into the bushes. "My dad quit his job at the bank to start that company. We put all our money into it. And you're going to tell everybody he's a frog murderer?" He stormed off.
Valeria sat alone on the steps, feeling terrible. She hadn't meant to hurt Joaquín. But she couldn't stop thinking about the timing.
That afternoon, she went to Uncle Rafa's small laboratory behind the village health clinic. He was bent over a microscope, peering at a thin slice of something on a glass slide.
"Is it the tourists?" Valeria asked. "Are they stepping on the frogs, or scaring them, or something?"
Uncle Rafa looked up. "What makes you think so?"
Valeria explained her reasoning: the timing, the boots, the splashing. Uncle Rafa listened carefully, nodding.
"That's a reasonable hypothesis," he said. "Good scientists always start with a guess. But then they test it. So let's test it. If the tourists are the cause, what would we expect to see?"
Valeria thought. "The frogs would be dying where the tourists go. But not where they don't go."
"Exactly. So let's check."
That weekend, they hiked far up the mountain to a stream called the Quebrada Escondida, the Hidden Creek. It was so steep and remote that no tour groups ever went there. It took them four hours of climbing through dripping forest, over fallen logs and slippery roots, to reach it.
When they finally arrived, they began to search the rocks.
They found two golden frogs alive. And four dead ones, lying in the shallow water, without a mark on them.
Valeria stared at them. "But no tourists come here."
"No," said Uncle Rafa quietly. "They don't."
Valeria felt a strange mixture of feelings. She was relieved that Joaquín's father probably wasn't to blame. She was ashamed that she had accused him. And she was more frightened than ever, because if it wasn't the tourists, then what was it? What could reach a hidden stream that no person ever visited?
On the long walk home, Uncle Rafa told her something he had been reading about. In other countries, in Australia, in Costa Rica, in parts of South America, scientists had seen the same thing: frogs vanishing from streams all at once, even in perfect, untouched forests. The deaths seemed to move across the land like a slow wave, valley by valley, year by year.
"Like a disease," Valeria said.
Uncle Rafa looked at her sharply. "Yes," he said. "Exactly like a disease."
Check your understanding
Character Why is Joaquín so upset when Valeria mentions the tours?
- He doesn't care about frogs
- He feels she is accusing his father, who loves the frogs and has risked everything on his business
- He wants to start his own tour company
- He thinks Valeria is jealous of him
Cause and effect Why do Valeria and Uncle Rafa hike to the Quebrada Escondida?
- To find a better place for tours
- To test whether frogs are dying even where no tourists go
- To hide from Señor Ortiz
- To collect water samples for the village
Inference Why does Valeria feel "a strange mixture of feelings" at the Hidden Creek?
- She is tired and hungry from the hike
- She is relieved Joaquín's father isn't likely to blame, ashamed she accused him, and scared of the real cause
- She is happy to see live frogs
- She is angry at Uncle Rafa
Vocabulary Uncle Rafa calls Valeria's guess a "hypothesis." Based on the story, what is a hypothesis?
- A proven fact
- A reasonable guess that scientists test
- A type of microscope
- A dangerous disease
Chapter 3: The Invisible Culprit
Uncle Rafa sent samples from the dead frogs to a university laboratory in Panama City. While they waited for the results, Valeria went to find Joaquín.
He was sitting on the wall outside his house, kicking his heels. When he saw her coming, he turned away.
"I came to apologize," Valeria said. "I was wrong. The frogs are dying where the tours don't even go. I'm sorry I accused your dad."
Joaquín turned back slowly. "Really?"
"Really. I jumped to a conclusion before I had evidence. That's the opposite of what a scientist is supposed to do."
Joaquín was quiet for a moment. Then he sighed. "My dad's been really upset," he admitted. "Not about what you said. About the frogs. Every day there are fewer for the tourists to see. Yesterday they didn't find a single one, and people asked for their money back." He looked down. "He's worried the business will fail. But he's more worried about the frogs."
Two weeks later, the results came back.
Uncle Rafa called Valeria and Joaquín into his laboratory. He let them look through the microscope at a thin slice of frog skin. At first, Valeria saw only a blur of pink and gray. Then she noticed tiny round shapes, clustered together like bunches of grapes, buried in the skin.
"What are those?" she whispered.
"That," said Uncle Rafa, "is the culprit. It's a fungus called chytrid. It's far too small to see without a microscope."
He explained. Frogs did something amazing that people didn't: they drank and breathed partly through their skin. The chytrid fungus attacked the skin, making it thick and hard, so that the frog could no longer take in water and salts properly. Eventually, its heart stopped.
"Where did it come from?" Joaquín asked.
"Scientists are still figuring that out," Uncle Rafa said. "But we think it spread around the world over the last century, carried by people moving frogs from place to place, for food and pets and laboratories. Once it reaches a new area, it travels in water, from stream to stream. Animals carry it. Mud carries it. And yes," he said gently, looking at Joaquín, "sometimes people carry it, on muddy boots or wet gear, from one stream to the next without knowing."
Joaquín went pale. "So my dad's tours could be spreading it?"
"They could be helping it move faster, maybe. But it would have arrived anyway. It reached the Hidden Creek without any tourists. The fungus is like a fire that's already burning across the whole region. The tours might be a little extra wind. They didn't light the match."
Valeria looked through the microscope again at those tiny, deadly grape shapes. It seemed impossible that something so small could wipe out something so bright and alive.
"Can we stop it?" she asked.
Uncle Rafa was silent for a long time.
"Not in the wild," he said finally. "Not yet. There's no cure we can spread through a whole forest. The fungus will probably kill nearly every golden frog in this valley within a year or two." He took a deep breath. "But there is one thing we can do. And I want to tell you about it, because I think you'll both have strong feelings, and I want to hear them."
Check your understanding
Key details How does the chytrid fungus kill frogs?
- It poisons the water they live in
- It attacks their skin so they can't take in water and salts, and eventually their hearts stop
- It eats the insects that frogs need to survive
- It makes frogs blind
Character What does Valeria's apology to Joaquín show about her?
- She can admit when she was wrong and is willing to make things right
- She is afraid of Joaquín
- She still blames his father
- She wants to join the tour company
Inference What does Uncle Rafa mean when he says the tours "might be a little extra wind" but "didn't light the match"?
- The tours started a forest fire
- The tours might have helped the fungus spread faster, but they did not cause it to arrive
- The tours are the main cause of the frog deaths
- Wind is spreading the fungus
Main idea What is the main discovery in Chapter 3?
- Joaquín's father has been taking frogs home
- The Hidden Creek has been polluted
- An invisible fungus called chytrid is killing the frogs, and it cannot yet be stopped in the wild
- The frogs have moved to a new stream
Chapter 4: The Ark
The plan was called the Frog Ark.
At a research center in the city, scientists had built special rooms with glass tanks, clean water, and misting systems that copied the cool, wet air of the cloud forest. The tanks were kept completely free of chytrid. Frogs living there could survive and breed. The idea was to collect as many of the last golden frogs as possible from the wild and bring them to the ark, where they would be safe, until scientists found a way to fight the fungus. Then, someday, their great-great-grandchildren could be released back into the streams.
"Like Noah," Joaquín said.
"Like Noah," Uncle Rafa agreed. "Except we don't know how long the flood will last. It could be ten years. It could be fifty. It could be forever."
Valeria felt sick. She imagined Señor Sol, or whatever frogs were left, living in a glass box in a building in the city, waving at the walls.
"But that's not living," she said. "They're supposed to be on the rocks, by the waterfalls. That's what makes them golden frogs. If they're in a tank forever, are they even really wild anymore?"
"That's a good question," Uncle Rafa said. "Many scientists ask it. Some think the ark is a mistake. They say we should leave the frogs in the wild and hope a few survive and become resistant to the fungus, the way some animals slowly adapt to diseases. They say taking them away means giving up on the forest."
"And the other scientists?" Joaquín asked.
"The other scientists say that if we leave them, they will almost certainly die out completely. And then there will be nothing left to return, ever. A frog in a tank can't wave on a rock. But a frog that's extinct can't wave at all."
Valeria looked out of the laboratory window at the green mountain, wrapped in its cloud. She thought about her grandmother's story, that anyone who saw a golden frog wave would have a happy year. She thought about the empty rock where Señor Sol had waved.
"I hate it," she said finally. "I hate that it's the only choice. But I think we have to."
Joaquín nodded slowly. "Me too."
In the last week of June, Uncle Rafa, Valeria, Joaquín, and, to everyone's surprise, Joaquín's father, hiked up every stream in the valley one last time. Señor Ortiz had canceled his tours for the month. "No point taking people to see frogs that aren't there," he said. "Better to help save the ones that are."
Before every hike, they stopped to disinfect their boots in a tub of bleach water at the trailhead, so they wouldn't carry the fungus from one stream to the next. Señor Ortiz watched carefully. Later, he built a permanent boot-washing station at the start of every trail, and made every one of his tourists use it.
They searched for three days. On the Río Mariposa, they found two frogs. On the Hidden Creek, one. On the high streams near the ridge, four more. Valeria caught the last one herself, cupping it gently in her hands. It was a male, small and bright, and it felt as light as a leaf.
Seven frogs, from a valley that had once held thousands.
They carried them down the mountain in a cooler lined with damp moss and drove them to the city. At the research center, a scientist in a white coat placed each frog gently into a glass tank filled with clean water, rocks, and ferns.
Valeria hated the idea of captivity for a wild thing. But she pressed her face close to the glass. The little male she had caught sat on a wet rock under a gentle mist. For a while, he did nothing. Then, slowly, he lifted one front foot and turned it in a circle.
He was waving.
There was no other frog in the tank to see him. Maybe he was waving at the glass. Maybe he was waving at the memory of a waterfall. But Valeria decided, right then, that he was waving at her.
She lifted her hand and waved back.
"We'll bring you home," she whispered. "I promise. Someday."
That night, she opened her green notebook and wrote the number 113. Then, underneath, she wrote something else: "This is not the end of the count."
Years later, Valeria would become a scientist herself, working in a laboratory just like her uncle's, searching for a way to beat the chytrid fungus. She would spend long nights at the microscope, testing ideas that failed and failed again. But on the wall above her desk, she would always keep that page from her notebook, so that she would never forget why.
Check your understanding
Vocabulary The frogs are moved into "captivity" in the Frog Ark. What does captivity mean here?
- Being set free in a new forest
- Being kept in a protected, closed place instead of living free
- Being sold as pets
- Being studied and then released the same day
Key details What is one argument against the Frog Ark mentioned in the story?
- It is too expensive to build
- Taking the frogs away may mean giving up on wild frogs slowly adapting and surviving in the forest
- The frogs will grow too large in tanks
- The fungus lives in the tanks
Character How does Señor Ortiz respond once he understands the problem?
- He keeps running tours and ignores the fungus
- He cancels his tours to help collect frogs and builds boot-washing stations
- He blames Uncle Rafa for the frogs dying
- He moves his family away from the valley
Theme What does Valeria's note, "This is not the end of the count," suggest about the story's message?
- Valeria has given up hope for the frogs
- Counting is the most important part of science
- Even when a loss is painful, hope and hard work can keep a cause alive for the future
- Valeria will always have exactly 113 waves in her notebook
Spelling words
These 12 words all appear in the story.
- amphibian
- suspect
- microscope
- fungus
- evidence
- culprit
- captivity
- apologize
- disinfect
- cloud
- accuse
- scientist
Writing prompt
Uncle Rafa decided to take the last golden frogs out of the wild and into the Frog Ark. Some people thought this was wrong. Explain both sides of the argument, and then say what you would have done, using at least three details from the story.
Reading skills practiced
Key details, Sequence, Inference, Vocabulary, Character, Cause and effect, Main idea, Theme.
Answer key for grown-ups
- The streams are too loud for them to hear each other's calls Uncle Rafa explains that the rushing water drowns out their calls.
- It fell from about forty or more to thirty, then fourteen, then six March was thirty, April fourteen, and May only six.
- Something invisible or unusual is killing the frogs, since there are no wounds The frog was "not crushed, not bitten, not injured," which makes the cause mysterious.
- Two things happening at the same time doesn't prove that one made the other happen The tours and the disappearing frogs began at the same time, but that alone doesn't prove the tours are to blame.
- He feels she is accusing his father, who loves the frogs and has risked everything on his business Joaquín says his father quit his bank job and put all their money into the company.
- To test whether frogs are dying even where no tourists go If frogs die where no tourists visit, then tourists can't be the only cause.
- She is relieved Joaquín's father isn't likely to blame, ashamed she accused him, and scared of the real cause Her guess was wrong, which brings relief, shame, and new fear all at once.
- A reasonable guess that scientists test He says, "Good scientists always start with a guess. But then they test it."
- It attacks their skin so they can't take in water and salts, and eventually their hearts stop Frogs absorb water through their skin, and the fungus makes it thick and hard.
- She can admit when she was wrong and is willing to make things right She says she jumped to a conclusion before she had evidence and apologizes.
- The tours might have helped the fungus spread faster, but they did not cause it to arrive The fungus reached places without tours, so the tours only possibly sped it up.
- An invisible fungus called chytrid is killing the frogs, and it cannot yet be stopped in the wild Under the microscope, Valeria sees the fungus that is the true culprit.
- Being kept in a protected, closed place instead of living free The frogs will live in glass tanks at the research center.
- Taking the frogs away may mean giving up on wild frogs slowly adapting and surviving in the forest Some scientists believe leaving frogs in the wild could let some become resistant.
- He cancels his tours to help collect frogs and builds boot-washing stations He helps save the frogs and makes his tourists disinfect their boots.
- Even when a loss is painful, hope and hard work can keep a cause alive for the future She keeps counting toward the day the frogs return, and later works to make it happen.