📚 Reading Quest
🕰️

The Leaning Clock Tower

The old clock tower in the plaza of San Isidro has leaned a little for two hundred years. But this spring it is suddenly leaning more every week, cracks are racing up its walls, and the town council wants to tear it down. Camila and her friend Rafa set out to discover what is pulling the tower toward the ground, and the answer is hiding somewhere nobody thought to look: underneath their feet.

5th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxMystery · Architecture · Friends2576 wordsAbout 30 minutes

Read it in the app 🚀

In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.

Words to know

foundation
the strong base under a building that holds it up
subsidence
the slow sinking of the ground, often because water or soil underneath has been removed
groundwater
water stored underground in soil and rock
plumb line
a string with a weight at the bottom, used to check whether something is perfectly upright
clay
a fine, sticky soil that shrinks when it dries out and swells when it gets wet

Chapter 1: The Clock That Stopped

The clock on the tower in the plaza of San Isidro had kept time for two hundred and eleven years. It had survived three earthquakes, two floods, and one very determined pigeon who had built a nest in the gears in 1974. But on the first Monday in April, at exactly 4:17 in the afternoon, it stopped.

Camila Ortiz noticed because she was sitting on the fountain in the plaza eating a mango on a stick, waiting for her grandfather. She glanced up to check the time, and then glanced up again, because the big iron minute hand hadn't moved.

Then she noticed something else. The tower looked more crooked than usual.

Everyone in San Isidro knew the clock tower leaned. It always had, just slightly, toward the east, the way an old man leans on a cane. Tourists liked to take photographs of themselves pretending to hold it up. But today, Camila was almost sure the lean was worse. The top of the tower seemed to hang over the bakery across the street.

Her grandfather, Abuelo Teo, came limping across the plaza. He had been a bricklayer for fifty years. He had helped repair the tower after the earthquake of 1985, and he liked to say that he knew every brick in it by name.

Camila pointed. "Abuelo. Is it leaning more?"

Abuelo Teo stopped and looked up. He looked for a long time. Then, without a word, he reached into his pocket and pulled out a piece of string with a small brass weight tied to the end. A plumb line. He held it up at arm's length, so that the string hung straight down beside the edge of the tower, and squinted.

"Yes," he said quietly. "It's leaning more."

By the end of the week, everyone in town was talking about it. Long, thin cracks had appeared in the plaster on the tower's west side, zigzagging up from the ground like lightning. A chunk of decorative stone fell from the top and smashed on the pavement, missing a delivery man by less than a meter. The police put yellow tape around the tower, and the town council called an emergency meeting.

The mayor, Señora Villalobos, spoke first. "The tower is unsafe," she said. "The town engineer says it could fall. We have two choices. We can spend a great deal of money to try to save it, money we don't really have. Or we can take it down, carefully, before it falls on someone."

The room erupted. Some people shouted that the tower was the heart of San Isidro. Others shouted that the town couldn't even afford to fix the potholes on Calle Hidalgo. A shopkeeper said that tourists only came to San Isidro to see the tower. A mother said she didn't care about tourists; she cared about her children walking past it to school.

The council decided to vote in three weeks, after the engineer finished her report.

Camila walked home with her grandfather in silence. She could tell he was upset. His jaw was tight, and he kept glancing back at the tower.

"Abuelo," she said finally. "Why is it leaning more now? It's been standing for two hundred years. What changed?"

"That," said Abuelo Teo, "is exactly the right question. And nobody at that meeting asked it."

That night, Camila called her best friend, Rafa Mendoza. Rafa lived above his family's hardware store on the plaza. He was the smartest person she knew, and the most annoying, because he always wanted to see evidence before believing anything.

"I want to investigate the tower," she said. "Find out why it's leaning. Before they knock it down."

"The engineer is already doing that," said Rafa.

"The engineer is checking whether it's safe," said Camila. "Not why it's sinking. Those are different questions."

There was a pause on the line.

"Okay," said Rafa. "That's actually a good point. I'm in."

Check your understanding

  1. Key details What did Abuelo Teo use to check whether the tower was leaning more?

    1. A camera and a measuring tape
    2. A ladder and a level
    3. A plumb line, a string with a small weight on the end
    4. An old photograph of the tower
  2. Main idea What are the two choices the mayor describes at the council meeting?

    1. Spend a lot of money to try to save the tower, or carefully take it down before it falls
    2. Close the plaza or move the bakery
    3. Repair the potholes or fix the clock
    4. Ask tourists to pay or ask the state for help
  3. Inference Why does Abuelo Teo say "nobody at that meeting asked" the right question?

    1. Because he wasn't allowed to speak at the meeting
    2. Because everyone argued about what to do with the tower, but no one tried to find out why it had suddenly started to lean
    3. Because the mayor didn't know how to measure the tower
    4. Because the meeting ended too early
  4. Character What does Rafa's response on the phone show about him?

    1. He is lazy and doesn't want to help
    2. He believes everything Camila says
    3. He is careful and logical, but willing to change his mind when he hears a good reason
    4. He is afraid of the tower

Chapter 2: Three Suspects

They started the next morning, a Saturday, at the hardware store. Rafa had made a chart on a large piece of cardboard with the heading POSSIBLE CAUSES. Like a detective, he called them suspects.

"Suspect number one," he said, tapping the cardboard with a marker. "The new parking garage."

Construction had started last autumn on a three-story parking garage two blocks east of the plaza. For months, huge machines had pounded steel beams deep into the ground. The thumping could be heard all over town.

"Vibrations," said Rafa. "The pounding could shake the ground and loosen the foundation."

"Suspect number two," said Camila, taking the marker. "Weather. Last year was the driest year in San Isidro in a century. Maybe the ground dried out."

"And suspect number three," said Rafa, lowering his voice, "the old canal."

Every kid in San Isidro had heard the legend. Long ago, before the Spanish arrived, the town had been an island in a great shallow lake. People had traveled by canoe along canals. When the lake was drained centuries later, the canals were filled in and built over. According to the story, one canal ran directly under the plaza, and on quiet nights you could still hear water flowing beneath the stones.

"That's a ghost story," said Camila.

"It's a ghost story," Rafa agreed. "But the part about the lake is true. My teacher said so. This whole valley used to be underwater."

They investigated suspect number one first. They walked to the parking garage and looked at it from behind the fence. But the construction had finished in February. The machines were gone. The tower had only started leaning faster in March.

"The timing's wrong," said Rafa, crossing it out. "And besides, if vibrations from the east were the problem, why are the biggest cracks on the west side?"

Camila hadn't thought of that. She stared at him.

"The cracks on the west side are stretching cracks," Rafa explained. "If the tower is tipping toward the east, the west side is being pulled apart. So the tower is tipping toward something on the east side. Or sinking more on that side."

"Toward the bakery," said Camila.

"Toward the bakery," said Rafa. "Or whatever is beyond it."

For suspect number two, they went to the library and found old weather records. It had been dry last year, very dry. But there had been droughts before, in 1950 and 1977 and 1998, and the tower hadn't moved much in any of those years. Rafa put a question mark next to WEATHER.

Then they went to see Abuelo Teo, who was sitting in his courtyard surrounded by potted geraniums. Camila asked him about the old canal.

Her grandfather laughed. "The ghost water? I used to tell your mother that story when she was small." Then his face grew thoughtful. "But you know, when we repaired the tower in 1985, we dug down beside the foundation. Under the stones and the old bricks, there was a thick layer of gray clay. Wet, heavy, sticky clay. We called it lake mud. It was soft as butter." He shook his head. "The tower stands on that."

"Is that bad?" asked Camila.

"Clay is a strange material," said her grandfather. "When it's full of water, it's thick and heavy, and it holds things up well enough. But when it loses water, it shrinks. It gets smaller. And whatever is sitting on it sinks."

Rafa had gone very still. "So if the clay under the east side of the tower is losing water..."

"The east side sinks," said Camila. "And the tower tips toward the east."

"But where's the water going?" said Rafa. "It hasn't rained much. But it didn't rain much in 1977 either."

That evening, as they walked home past the bakery, Camila noticed something she had seen a hundred times without paying attention. Behind the bakery, on the next street, there was a long white building with a sign that said AGUA PURA DEL VALLE — Pure Valley Water. It was a bottling factory. Trucks loaded with plastic bottles of drinking water rumbled out of its gates all day long.

The factory was new. It had opened last summer.

And it was directly east of the tower.

Check your understanding

  1. Vocabulary Rafa calls the possible causes "suspects." Why does he use this word?

    1. Because he thinks a person pushed the tower
    2. Because he is investigating the tower like a detective investigates a crime, by testing each possible cause
    3. Because the police asked him to help
    4. Because the parking garage was built illegally
  2. Cause and effect Why does Rafa cross out the parking garage as a suspect?

    1. The garage was built far away on the other side of town
    2. The workers told him they were careful
    3. The construction ended before the tower began leaning faster, and the cracks don't match vibrations from the east
    4. The garage is too small to cause any problems
  3. Inference Why does Camila feel a jolt when she notices the bottling factory?

    1. She is thirsty and wants a drink
    2. She realizes the factory is new, opened just before the tower started leaning, and is located on the side the tower is tipping toward
    3. She thinks the factory is ugly
    4. Her grandfather once worked there
  4. Key details What did Abuelo Teo find under the tower in 1985?

    1. An old canoe from the lake
    2. A secret tunnel
    3. A thick layer of soft, wet gray clay
    4. Solid rock

Chapter 3: Water Under the Plaza

Camila and Rafa spent the next week learning everything they could about water bottling factories. It turned out that most of them don't get water from rivers or lakes. They pump it up from deep underground, using wells that reach down into the groundwater.

Rafa found the factory's permit on the town website. The factory had permission to pump three hundred thousand liters of groundwater every day.

"Three hundred thousand liters," Camila read aloud. "That's... how much is that?"

Rafa did the math on a napkin. "About two Olympic swimming pools every week," he said. "Every single week. Out of the ground under our town."

They found something else too. A scientist at a university in the capital had written an article about cities around the world that were sinking. When too much groundwater is pumped out of soft clay soil, the article said, the clay dries and compresses, and the ground above it sinks. Scientists called it subsidence. Some parts of Mexico City had sunk more than ten meters in a hundred years for exactly this reason. Its great cathedral, built on old lake clay, had tilted so badly that engineers had to work for years to straighten it.

"That's it," said Camila. "That's our answer."

"That's a theory," said Rafa. "We don't have evidence yet."

Camila wanted to scream. But she knew he was right. If they told the council the factory was sinking the tower, the factory would just say they were children making wild guesses.

"So how do we prove it?" she asked.

They thought about it for two days. The answer came from Abuelo Teo.

"The old well," he said. "In the courtyard of the church, behind the tower. Nobody has used it in fifty years, but it's still there, under an iron cover. When I was a boy, you could see the water about four meters down."

The church caretaker, a tired-looking man named Don Efraín, let them lift the cover after they promised not to fall in. Rafa tied a small flashlight to a long tape measure and lowered it slowly into the darkness. The well was lined with old stones, cool and smelling of moss.

Four meters. Five meters. Eight meters. Ten.

At twelve and a half meters, the flashlight finally touched water.

Abuelo Teo stared down the well. "Twelve meters," he said slowly. "In my whole life, I have never seen it lower than five."

But Rafa still wasn't satisfied. "It's been a dry year," he said. "Maybe the water would have dropped anyway."

Camila had an idea. "The factory closes on Sundays," she said. "My cousin works there. If the factory is pulling the water down, then the water should rise when it stops pumping."

So they measured the well every few hours, from Saturday evening until Monday morning. Rafa recorded every number in his notebook. On Saturday night, the water was at twelve and a half meters. By Sunday afternoon, after the pumps had been off for a day, it had risen to eleven meters. On Monday morning, an hour after the factory opened, it had dropped back to twelve.

Rafa looked at the numbers for a long time. Then he looked up at Camila with an expression she had never seen on his face before. It was the look of someone who was completely, absolutely convinced.

"Now," he said, "we have evidence."

Check your understanding

  1. Sequence What did Camila and Rafa do right after Rafa said "That's a theory"?

    1. They went to the council meeting
    2. They talked to the factory manager
    3. They thought about how to prove it, and Abuelo Teo suggested measuring the old well
    4. They measured the tower with a plumb line
  2. Cause and effect According to the scientist's article, why does ground sink when too much groundwater is pumped out?

    1. The clay dries out and compresses, so the ground above it sinks
    2. Earthquakes get stronger without water
    3. Water pipes burst and wash the soil away
    4. Trees die and their roots stop holding the soil
  3. Inference Why is measuring the well over a weekend such a clever experiment?

    1. Because the well is easier to reach on weekends
    2. Because Rafa's school is closed on weekends
    3. Because the factory stops pumping on Sundays, so if the water rises when it's off and falls when it's on, the factory must be the cause
    4. Because the weather is always the same on weekends
  4. Character How does Rafa change at the end of this chapter?

    1. He becomes angry with Camila
    2. He decides the ghost story is true
    3. He goes from doubtful to completely convinced, because now he has real evidence
    4. He gives up on the investigation

Chapter 4: Holding Up the Sky

The council meeting was packed. The town engineer, a serious woman named Ingeniera Robles, presented her report first. The old structure had tilted another eleven centimeters in six weeks. At that rate, she said, it could become dangerous within a year. She recommended taking it down.

The mayor asked for comments. Camila's hand shot up before she could lose her nerve.

She and Rafa walked to the front of the room together. Rafa held up the cardboard chart, now covered with crossed-out suspects and arrows. Camila explained everything: the cracks on the west side, the clay under the plaza, the factory directly to the east, the article about subsidence. Then Rafa read the well measurements aloud, number by number, from Saturday to Monday.

When he finished, the room was silent.

Then the manager of the bottling factory stood up. He was a young man in a crisp shirt, and he looked uncomfortable. "This is very interesting," he said. "But these are children with a tape measure. You can't blame a whole company based on a school project."

Ingeniera Robles stood up too. "Actually," she said slowly, "I would like to see those measurements." She took Rafa's notebook and studied it, frowning. "This is a very simple test. But it's a good test." She looked up. "If this is true, then taking down the tower won't solve the problem. If the ground is sinking, it will keep sinking. The bakery will be next. Then the church. Then the houses."

That changed the debate entirely. People who had wanted to tear down the tower to save money suddenly realized that the real cost might be much bigger. People who had wanted to save the tower suddenly realized the factory employed eighty people from San Isidro, including Camila's cousin. Nobody wanted those jobs to disappear.

The arguing went on for two hours. Finally, the council asked the state government to send scientists to study the groundwater properly. Their report came back two months later. It confirmed exactly what Camila and Rafa had found.

In the end, there was a compromise. The factory agreed to cut its pumping in half and to build ponds outside of town where rainwater could soak back down into the ground, refilling what had been taken out. The state paid for engineers to stabilize the tower. They used a method that had saved other leaning towers around the world: they carefully drilled out small amounts of soil from under the high west side, a little at a time, so that the tower slowly settled back toward upright. It took a year and a half.

The tower never stood perfectly straight again. The engineers said it shouldn't. A two-hundred-year-old tower that had leaned all its life might crack if you forced it upright. It just needed to stop sinking.

On the day the scaffolding came down, Abuelo Teo climbed the narrow stairs inside the tower with Camila and Rafa. It took him a long time, and he stopped to rest at every landing. At the top, in the clock room, he showed them the old gears, and the pigeon nest from 1974 that nobody had ever had the heart to remove.

Then he reached into the machinery and set the clock going again.

It was 4:17 in the afternoon. The big iron hand shuddered and moved forward to 4:18.

"You know," said Abuelo Teo, looking out the little window at the plaza far below, "this tower is a lot like me. Old. A bit crooked. Some cracks." He patted the brick wall affectionately. "But there's nothing wrong with leaning. Everything leans a little, after enough years. The important thing is that someone pays attention to why."

Camila looked down at the plaza, at the fountain and the bakery and the people walking past. Somewhere far beneath all of it, she thought, the water was slowly beginning to rise again.

Check your understanding

  1. Cause and effect Why does the engineer's response change the whole debate?

    1. She says the tower is perfectly safe
    2. She realizes that if the ground is sinking, tearing down the tower won't stop the problem, and other buildings will be at risk
    3. She says the factory must close immediately
    4. She says the measurements are fake
  2. Inference Why do the engineers decide not to make the tower perfectly straight?

    1. They ran out of money
    2. The tourists wanted it to stay crooked
    3. Forcing an old tower that has always leaned to stand upright might damage it; it only needs to stop sinking
    4. They couldn't remove any more soil
  3. Theme What does Abuelo Teo mean when he says "The important thing is that someone pays attention to why"?

    1. People should not worry about old buildings
    2. Old people should never lean on canes
    3. Instead of only reacting to problems, people should look for their real causes
    4. Clocks must always be fixed by bricklayers
  4. Main idea How was the problem finally solved?

    1. The tower was torn down and replaced
    2. The factory was closed forever
    3. The factory cut its pumping and refilled the ground with rainwater, and engineers stabilized the tower
    4. Camila and Rafa fixed the tower themselves

Spelling words

These 12 words all appear in the story.

  • foundation
  • engineer
  • groundwater
  • crooked
  • measurements
  • suspect
  • investigate
  • structure
  • bricklayer
  • cracks
  • council
  • clay

Writing prompt

The town council argued about whether to tear down the old tower or spend money to save it. Which side would you choose? Use at least two facts from the story to explain your reasons, and explain what the people on the other side might say.

Reading skills practiced

Key details, Main idea, Inference, Character, Vocabulary, Cause and effect, Sequence, Theme.

Answer key for grown-ups
  1. A plumb line, a string with a small weight on the end The string hangs straight down, so he can compare it with the tower's edge.
  2. Spend a lot of money to try to save the tower, or carefully take it down before it falls She says the tower is unsafe and the town must decide whether to save it or remove it.
  3. Because everyone argued about what to do with the tower, but no one tried to find out why it had suddenly started to lean Camila asks what changed, and he says that's exactly the right question.
  4. He is careful and logical, but willing to change his mind when he hears a good reason He questions her at first, then admits "That's actually a good point."
  5. Because he is investigating the tower like a detective investigates a crime, by testing each possible cause Detectives list suspects and rule them out one by one.
  6. The construction ended before the tower began leaning faster, and the cracks don't match vibrations from the east The timing and the location of the cracks don't fit.
  7. She realizes the factory is new, opened just before the tower started leaning, and is located on the side the tower is tipping toward The timing and location both match the clues they've found.
  8. A thick layer of soft, wet gray clay He calls it "lake mud," soft as butter.
  9. They thought about how to prove it, and Abuelo Teo suggested measuring the old well They looked for a way to turn a guess into evidence.
  10. The clay dries out and compresses, so the ground above it sinks This sinking is called subsidence.
  11. Because the factory stops pumping on Sundays, so if the water rises when it's off and falls when it's on, the factory must be the cause Comparing "pumps on" with "pumps off" separates the factory's effect from the dry weather.
  12. He goes from doubtful to completely convinced, because now he has real evidence He insists on evidence the whole time, and finally he has it.
  13. She realizes that if the ground is sinking, tearing down the tower won't stop the problem, and other buildings will be at risk If subsidence is the cause, "the bakery will be next."
  14. Forcing an old tower that has always leaned to stand upright might damage it; it only needs to stop sinking They say a two-hundred-year-old tower "might crack if you forced it upright."
  15. Instead of only reacting to problems, people should look for their real causes He connects the tower's lean to his own age and praises asking why it happened.
  16. The factory cut its pumping and refilled the ground with rainwater, and engineers stabilized the tower The solution was a compromise that protected both jobs and buildings.

More 5th grade stories

🫧

The Great Hiccup Outbreak

When half of Westbrook Elementary starts hiccuping at once, everyone has a cure and everyone is sure theirs is the best. Fifth-grader Priya Raman decides to find out…

5th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxHumor · School · Medicine16 questions
🐑

The Summer Pasture

Every June, Aibek's family drives their sheep, horses, and yaks high into the mountains of Kyrgyzstan to the summer pasture, just as their ancestors did for a thousand…

5th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxFarm · Animals · Mountains · Migration16 questions
🏃🏾‍♀️

Thin Air

Hana has run the highland trails of Ethiopia since she could walk, and she wants nothing more than to win the regional junior race. Then a team of foreign runners…

5th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxSports · Mountains · Health16 questions
🐢

Lights Out on Playa Luna

Every year, sea turtles swim thousands of kilometers to lay their eggs on the beach where Mateo lives in Costa Rica. But this year, bright new lights along the shore…

5th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxOcean · Animals · Migration · Village16 questions
🫒

The Olive Tree on the Balcony

Three years after her family moved from Syria to Canada, eleven-year-old Leila is the one who speaks for everyone: at the bank, at the landlord's office, and now at her…

5th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxCulture · Family · Migration · Health16 questions
🚡

The Cable Car Question

The town of Valbrenna is voting on whether to build a cable car to the top of Monte Corvo, and Nico's class is holding a debate about it. Nico loves the old mountain…

5th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxSchool · Mountains · Friends16 questions