📚 Reading Quest
🌧️

The Weather Thief

In the mountain town of Highmere, rain is bought from the Cloudwrights, sky-merchants who net the clouds and steer them home on great airships. Far below, the valley of Lowen is dying of drought. Ysolde, the daughter of Highmere's Keeper of the Chronicle, has always believed her town's history. Daru, a boy from Lowen, has climbed the mountain to cut the cloud nets. Told from both sides, this is a story about stolen rain, a rewritten history, and what justice costs the people who have been winning.

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonFantasy · Justice2666 wordsAbout 30 minutes

Read it in the app 🚀

In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.

Words to know

chronicle
a written record of events in the order they happened
parched
extremely dry, especially from lack of rain
watershed
an area of land where all the rain drains into the same river or valley
treaty
a formal written agreement between two groups
reparation
making amends for a wrong by giving something back

Chapter 1: Ysolde

In Highmere, it rains every Tuesday and Friday, from the first bell after noon until the fourth. It has rained like that for sixty years. People set their washing by it.

I am Ysolde, and my mother is the Keeper of the Chronicle, which means she guards the great leather book in the Council House where the history of Highmere is written down. I have read it since I was six. I know it better than my own handwriting.

The Chronicle says that, long ago, Highmere was a dry and stony town, high in the Ashfold Mountains, where the clouds blew past without stopping. Our ancestors were poor. Their crops withered. Then, in the Year of the First Bargain, the Cloudwrights came.

The Cloudwrights are sky-merchants. They sail the high winds in great airships of canvas and cedar, trailing nets of silver thread as wide as a field. They catch clouds in those nets, the way fishermen catch fish, and tow them wherever they are paid to. Our ancestors made a bargain with them: Highmere would pay in silver from our mines, and the Cloudwrights would bring us rain. Twice a week, every week, forever.

And so, says the Chronicle, Highmere became green. We built the great reservoir above the town, the Mirrorpool, so still and full it reflects the peaks like glass. We grew apples, barley, roses. Every autumn, we hold the Festival of Rain, when the Cloudwrights' ships drift over the town square and everyone stands with their faces turned up, laughing, as the first drops fall.

The Chronicle also mentions Lowen.

Lowen is the valley below the mountains, on the far side, downstream from us. You can see it from the top of the Bell Tower on a clear day: a long brown smudge, flat and dusty. The Chronicle says the people of Lowen were offered the same bargain as we were, and refused it, because they were too proud or too lazy or too foolish. And so they have had drought ever since. "They chose their fate," my mother once read aloud to me, "and Highmere chose its own."

I remember asking her, when I was small, why we didn't simply share some of our rain with them, since we had so much. She smiled and smoothed my hair. "Because a bargain is a bargain, little cloud," she said. "We paid. They didn't. If we gave rain away to everyone who refused to pay for it, soon there would be none left for anyone." It seemed so sensible. I never asked again.

I believed that. Why wouldn't I? It was in the Chronicle, in ink, in my own mother's keeping.

Then, three nights before this year's Festival of Rain, I caught a boy on the roof of the Cloudwrights' mooring tower with a knife.

It was nearly midnight. I couldn't sleep, so I had climbed to my favorite place, the old stone walkway beside the mooring tower, where the great airships tie up between voyages. The nets hang there, drying, glittering faintly in the moonlight. And there, halfway up the net of the biggest ship, was a thin dark shape, sawing at the silver threads with a blade.

"Stop!" I shouted. "Thief!"

The shape froze. Then it slid down the net, landed on the walkway a few steps from me, and turned. It was a boy, about my age, painfully thin, his face streaked with dust. His eyes were red-rimmed, as if he hadn't slept in days.

"I'm not the thief," he said. His voice was cracked and dry, like the voice of someone who hadn't had enough to drink for a very long time. "You are."

Check your understanding

  1. Key details According to the Chronicle, why does Lowen suffer drought?

    1. The Cloudwrights refused to sell to them
    2. The people of Lowen were offered the bargain and refused it out of pride, laziness, or foolishness
    3. Lowen is too high in the mountains
    4. Highmere declared war on Lowen
  2. Vocabulary Lowen is "downstream" from Highmere. What does downstream mean here?

    1. Lower down in the same flow of water, so water from above would normally reach it
    2. Farther up the mountain
    3. On a different continent
    4. Under the reservoir
  3. Inference Why does Ysolde trust the Chronicle so completely?

    1. She wrote it herself
    2. It is official, written in ink, and kept by her own mother, so she has never had a reason to question it
    3. The Cloudwrights told her it was true
    4. She has visited Lowen and seen it herself
  4. Inference What does the boy mean when he says, "I'm not the thief. You are."

    1. Ysolde has stolen his knife
    2. He believes Highmere is stealing the rain that would naturally fall on Lowen
    3. He is accusing Ysolde of lying
    4. He wants Ysolde to join him

Chapter 2: Daru

She didn't scream for the guards. That surprised me. I had my knife up and I was ready to run, but the girl just stood there in her nightgown and cloak, staring at me.

"What do you mean?" she said. "We bought the rain. Fairly. It's in the Chronicle."

I laughed. It hurt my throat.

My name is Daru. I come from Lowen, from a village called Sefra on the dry bed of what used to be the Lowen River. I walked for nine days to get to Highmere, up the old goat paths, carrying two water skins that were empty by the fifth day. I drank from puddles under rocks. I didn't come to steal anything. I came to cut the nets.

"Fairly," I said. "Do you know where those clouds come from, Highmere girl? The ones the Cloudwrights catch for you every Tuesday and Friday?"

She didn't answer.

"They come from the west, from the sea," I said. "They blow in over the Ashfold peaks, and in the old days, they kept going. Down the far side. Into Lowen. That's how the wind works. The mountains squeeze the rain out of them, and it falls into the valley, and fills the river. My grandmother remembers it. She says the Lowen River was so wide in spring you couldn't throw a stone across it. She says Lowen grew more grain than anywhere in the country."

The girl was frowning now.

"Then the Cloudwrights started catching the clouds before they got over the peaks," I said. "Every cloud Highmere buys is a cloud that would have rained on us. You didn't buy rain from the sky. You bought it from us. You just never asked us."

"That's not..." She stopped. "The Chronicle says Lowen was offered the bargain. And refused it."

"Lowen was offered nothing," I said. "You live upstream. You've never had to think about where the water goes after it leaves you. We think about it every single day." "Lowen had a treaty with Highmere. My grandmother's grandmother signed it. Rain shared equally, the whole watershed, mountain and valley. Highmere broke it."

"That's a lie," she said, but her voice wasn't sure.

I looked at her. She was well fed. Her cheeks were round and pink. She had probably never been thirsty for a single day in her life. I wanted to hate her. I'd been hating Highmere for nine days of walking, every step.

But she looked frightened, and confused, and young. Like me.

"In Sefra," I said, "we've had no harvest for three years. The wells are dry. The goats are dying. My little sister is six, and she has never seen rain. Never. Not once. She asks me what it sounds like." My voice broke and I hated that too. "So I came to cut the nets. If the clouds get free, maybe some of them will drift over the peaks. Maybe one will reach Sefra. Maybe she'll hear it."

The girl was quiet for a long time. Down below us, the airships creaked at their moorings.

"If you cut the nets," she said finally, "the Cloudwrights will just weave new ones. And they'll hunt you. And they'll hang you from the tower, probably." She bit her lip. "And it won't change anything. Highmere will still pay them, and they'll still catch the clouds."

"Then what am I supposed to do?" I said. "Ask nicely?"

She looked at me with an expression I couldn't read.

"You said there was a treaty," she said slowly. "Written down. Signed."

"My grandmother has the Lowen copy. It's falling to pieces. Nobody in Highmere would ever believe it."

"They might," she said, "if it matched ours."

Check your understanding

  1. Character How does Daru feel about Ysolde when he first sees her?

    1. He immediately trusts her
    2. He wants to hate her because she is well fed and from Highmere, but sees that she is young, confused, and frightened like him
    3. He thinks she is a Cloudwright
    4. He is completely indifferent
  2. Cause and effect According to Daru, what caused Lowen's drought?

    1. The Cloudwrights catch the clouds before they cross the peaks, so the rain that once fell on Lowen is sold to Highmere instead
    2. Lowen refused to pay for rain
    3. The Lowen River was dammed by the Cloudwrights
    4. A curse was put on the valley
  3. Inference Why does the author switch to Daru's viewpoint in this chapter?

    1. To make the story shorter
    2. To show the same history from the other side, revealing what Highmere's Chronicle left out
    3. Because Ysolde has left the story
    4. To prove Daru is lying
  4. Main idea What new idea does Ysolde suggest at the end of the chapter?

    1. Cutting all the nets at once
    2. Running away to Lowen together
    3. Finding Highmere's own copy of the treaty to prove Daru's version of history is true
    4. Asking the Cloudwrights to stop flying

Chapter 3: Ysolde

The Chronicle is kept in a locked case in the Council House. My mother has the key. I know where she keeps it.

I'm not proud of that. But I had to know.

The next night, I brought Daru through the back door of the Council House, past the sleeping caretaker, into the Chronicle Room. I lit a single candle and opened the great leather book to the Year of the First Bargain.

There it was, the same as always. The Cloudwrights' arrival. The silver. The rain. And then, a few pages later: "In this year the people of Lowen were offered the Bargain, and refused it."

Daru leaned over my shoulder and read it, his lips moving. Then he said, "Look at the pages."

"What about them?"

"Look at the edges. Look at the stitching."

I looked. And then I saw it. Between the page about the First Bargain and the page about Lowen's refusal, there were little ragged stubs in the binding, close to the spine. Three pages had been cut out. Very carefully, with a sharp blade. The page after them had been written in a slightly different ink, a slightly different hand.

My heart was pounding. I turned back, slowly, toward the beginning of the book, to the years before the Cloudwrights came. And there, in the old, faded ink, was an entry I had read a hundred times without ever noticing what it meant.

"In this year the Accord of the Two Waters was signed between Highmere and Lowen, by which the rain of the Ashfold shall be shared by mountain and valley alike, as it has always fallen, for as long as rivers run."

I had read that sentence since I was six. I had thought it was about some old agreement that didn't matter anymore. I had never once asked what happened to it.

The cut pages were where it had been broken.

Someone, sixty years ago, had removed the record of Highmere breaking the treaty, and written in its place a story that blamed Lowen for its own drought. And every Keeper since, including my mother, including me, had read it and believed it. Not because we were wicked. Because it was written down, and it was ours, and it made us the heroes.

"It's true," I whispered. "Everything you said. It's true."

Daru didn't look triumphant. He looked tired.

"I know," he said.

Daru reached out and touched the faded line about the Accord with one dusty finger, very gently, the way you might touch something that belonged to someone who had died.

"My grandmother told me about this," he said. "I thought she was just telling stories. Old people in Sefra are always telling stories about the river. About fish you could catch with your hands. About boats." He took his finger away. "I didn't really believe her either."

I sat down on the floor of the Chronicle Room, among the candle shadows, and I felt something I had never felt before. It was shame, but not only shame. It was the feeling of the ground moving. Every Festival of Rain I had ever danced at. Every apple I had eaten. Every Tuesday and Friday, standing in the square with my face turned up, laughing. All of it had been paid for by a little girl in Sefra who had never heard rain.

"What do we do?" I said.

"I was going to cut the nets," said Daru.

"That won't change anything. You heard me."

"Then what?"

I looked at the cut stubs in the binding. Then at the old entry about the Accord of the Two Waters.

"The Festival is in two days," I said. "The whole town will be in the square. The Council. The Cloudwrights. Everyone." I took a breath. "And it's tradition for the Keeper's daughter to read from the Chronicle."

Check your understanding

  1. Key details What evidence does Ysolde find that the Chronicle was altered?

    1. Three pages were carefully cut out, and the next page was written in different ink and handwriting
    2. The whole book was a forgery
    3. Daru's name was written in it
    4. The Lowen copy was hidden inside it
  2. Vocabulary What was the Accord of the Two Waters?

    1. A trade deal with the Cloudwrights
    2. A treaty between Highmere and Lowen to share the mountain rain equally
    3. A law about the reservoir
    4. A festival song
  3. Inference Why does Ysolde say the Keepers believed the false history "not because we were wicked"?

    1. Because they could not read
    2. Because it was official, it belonged to them, and it made Highmere look heroic, so they never had a reason to question it
    3. Because the Cloudwrights forced them to
    4. Because they had never seen Lowen
  4. Inference What is Ysolde planning when she mentions the festival tradition?

    1. To use her public role of reading from the Chronicle to reveal the truth to the whole town
    2. To cancel the festival
    3. To help Daru cut the nets during the celebration
    4. To run away while everyone is distracted

Chapter 4: Two Waters

Ysolde

The square was full. Lanterns hung from every window, and the Cloudwrights' great ships hovered overhead, their nets bulging with grey clouds, waiting for the signal to release the first festival rain.

I climbed the steps of the Council House with the Chronicle in my arms. My mother stood beside me, smiling, not knowing. I opened the book to the Accord of the Two Waters and read it aloud, in my clearest voice. Then I held up the book and showed the crowd the cut pages.

Then I told them about Sefra.

Daru

I stood at the bottom of the steps, in the crowd, in borrowed clothes. When Ysolde called my name, I climbed up beside her, and I held up my grandmother's copy of the Accord, brown and crumbling, with the same words, the same seals, the same date.

For a long moment, the square was completely silent. I could hear the airships creaking.

Then the shouting started.

Ysolde

Not everyone was angry at us. But many were. A councillor shouted that this was a Lowen trick. A farmer shouted that if Highmere gave up the rain, his orchard would die, and what about his children? A woman near the front yelled at me, "You'd let your own town go dry for strangers?"

Somebody threw a rotten apple. It missed me and hit the Chronicle, and my mother caught her breath as if she had been struck herself. Daru stepped in front of me without a word.

I had thought the truth would be enough. I had imagined everyone gasping and agreeing and putting it right. I was wrong. The truth was only the beginning. The truth meant that Highmere had to give something up, and nobody likes to give things up, even when they were never really theirs.

My mother saved us. She stepped forward, the Keeper of the Chronicle, and took the book from my hands, and looked at the cut pages for a very long time. Then she turned to the crowd.

"I have kept this book for twenty years," she said. "And I have kept a lie in it, without knowing. That is my shame. But if I keep it now that I do know, it becomes my injustice." She closed the book. "The Chronicle will be corrected. Tonight."

Daru

It took months to negotiate. Months of councils and arguments, with Lowen elders climbing the mountain and Highmere councillors walking down into the valley for the first time in sixty years, and coming back with dust in their hair and silence in their mouths.

In the end, it wasn't perfect. Highmere would not give up the rain completely; they said their orchards would die, and that their children had not broken the treaty. Lowen said that sixty years of stolen rain could never be paid back. Both things were true.

So they found something in the middle. The Cloudwrights would release every other cloud they caught. On Tuesdays, Highmere would get its rain. On Fridays, the nets would open above the peaks, and the clouds would drift free, over the mountains, down the far side, the way they had always meant to go. And Highmere would send silver to Lowen every year, to dig new wells, as reparation. Not enough. But something.

Ysolde

Highmere's apple harvest was smaller that year. Some people still won't speak to my mother. The festival was quieter. We used water from the Mirrorpool more carefully. It was harder.

It was also right.

Daru

The first Friday the nets opened, I was home in Sefra. I didn't know if the clouds would make it that far. Nobody did. I sat outside our house with my little sister in my lap, watching the mountains.

In the afternoon, the sky over the Ashfold peaks turned grey. The air changed. It smelled of something I had almost forgotten, something sharp and green.

Then the first drop fell on my sister's hand. She looked at it. Then at me.

Then another, and another, until the dust in the yard was spotted dark, and the sound began: soft, then louder, a drumming on the roof, on the dry ground, on our faces turned up to the sky.

"That's it," I told her. "That's what it sounds like."

Ysolde

A month later, a letter came up the mountain, carried by a Lowen trader. Inside was a drawing done in charcoal by a six-year-old: a little house, a big grey cloud, and lines of rain falling everywhere.

At the bottom, someone had written, in careful letters: "For the Keeper's daughter. From downstream."

I put it in the Chronicle, on the page where the cut stubs used to be. My mother says it's the most important entry in the whole book.

Check your understanding

  1. Sequence Which event happens first in Chapter 4?

    1. Ysolde reads the Accord of the Two Waters aloud and shows the cut pages
    2. The nets open on the first Friday
    3. Daru's sister feels her first raindrop
    4. A drawing arrives from Lowen
  2. Cause and effect Why is the final agreement described as "not perfect"?

    1. Because the Cloudwrights refused to help
    2. Because Highmere would not give up all the rain and Lowen's sixty years of losses could never fully be repaid, so both sides had to accept a compromise
    3. Because Lowen got all the rain
    4. Because Daru was punished
  3. Character What does Ysolde's mother mean when she says that keeping the lie now would "become my injustice"?

    1. She is angry at Ysolde for embarrassing her
    2. Not knowing about the lie was a mistake, but choosing to keep it after learning the truth would make her responsible for the wrong
    3. She wants to keep the old Chronicle exactly as it is
    4. She believes Lowen is lying
  4. Theme Which theme is developed across the whole story?

    1. Magic always solves problems
    2. Whoever has power deserves to keep it
    3. Justice requires facing uncomfortable histories and giving something up, even when the people who benefit did not personally cause the wrong
    4. Cutting the nets was the only solution

Spelling words

These 12 words all appear in the story.

  • drought
  • merchants
  • upstream
  • downstream
  • reservoir
  • bargain
  • ancestors
  • injustice
  • chronicle
  • festival
  • harvest
  • negotiate

Writing prompt

At the end of the story, Highmere agrees to release the clouds every other day. Is this a fair solution, or should Highmere give up more? Take a position, give at least three reasons with evidence from the story, and explain how both Ysolde's and Daru's viewpoints shaped your answer.

Reading skills practiced

Key details, Vocabulary, Inference, Character, Cause and effect, Main idea, Sequence, Theme.

Answer key for grown-ups
  1. The people of Lowen were offered the bargain and refused it out of pride, laziness, or foolishness "They chose their fate," says the Chronicle.
  2. Lower down in the same flow of water, so water from above would normally reach it Lowen sits below Highmere in the same watershed.
  3. It is official, written in ink, and kept by her own mother, so she has never had a reason to question it "It was in the Chronicle, in ink, in my own mother's keeping."
  4. He believes Highmere is stealing the rain that would naturally fall on Lowen The title and his parched voice hint that the clouds once reached his valley.
  5. He wants to hate her because she is well fed and from Highmere, but sees that she is young, confused, and frightened like him "I wanted to hate her... But she looked frightened, and confused, and young. Like me."
  6. The Cloudwrights catch the clouds before they cross the peaks, so the rain that once fell on Lowen is sold to Highmere instead "Every cloud Highmere buys is a cloud that would have rained on us."
  7. To show the same history from the other side, revealing what Highmere's Chronicle left out The shift lets readers see that Highmere's "fair" bargain looks different from below.
  8. Finding Highmere's own copy of the treaty to prove Daru's version of history is true "They might [believe it], if it matched ours."
  9. Three pages were carefully cut out, and the next page was written in different ink and handwriting She sees "ragged stubs in the binding" and "a slightly different ink, a slightly different hand."
  10. A treaty between Highmere and Lowen to share the mountain rain equally It promised rain "shall be shared by mountain and valley alike."
  11. Because it was official, it belonged to them, and it made Highmere look heroic, so they never had a reason to question it She recognizes how comfortable stories can hide injustice.
  12. To use her public role of reading from the Chronicle to reveal the truth to the whole town She notes the whole town will be there and the Keeper's daughter reads aloud.
  13. Ysolde reads the Accord of the Two Waters aloud and shows the cut pages The public reading happens at the festival, before the negotiations and the rain.
  14. Because Highmere would not give up all the rain and Lowen's sixty years of losses could never fully be repaid, so both sides had to accept a compromise "Both things were true. So they found something in the middle."
  15. Not knowing about the lie was a mistake, but choosing to keep it after learning the truth would make her responsible for the wrong She distinguishes between an innocent error and a knowing choice.
  16. Justice requires facing uncomfortable histories and giving something up, even when the people who benefit did not personally cause the wrong Through two viewpoints, a corrected chronicle, and a costly compromise, the story explores fairness across the watershed.

More 5th grade stories

🧠

The Letter in My Handwriting

Ines Albuquerque notices small, strange gaps in her life: an empty hook by the back door, a worn path in the grass, the careful way her family speaks to her. Then she…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonSci-fi · Family16 questions
🧂

A Handful of Salt

In 1930, in the coastal village of Dandi in India, it is against British law for Kamala's family to make salt from the sea at their own doorstep. When word comes that…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonHistory · Justice16 questions
🚛

Forty Centimeters

For six weeks each winter, a road made of frozen lakes and packed snow connects Rae Beaulieu's remote Dene community to the rest of Canada, and her father drives the…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonNature · Exploration16 questions
🤖

The Detective's Assistant

Two days before the regional robotics championship, someone sabotages the Westfield Middle School robot, and Imani Clarke, the sharpest mind in the seventh grade, takes…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonMystery · Friends16 questions
🌲

What the Forest Lends

For three hundred years, the village of Hollin has lived beside the Thornwood under an ancient bargain with the forest's ancient guardian. But the new sawmill is…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonFantasy · Nature16 questions
🐈

The Lynx in Glen Arrin

Lynx have been extinct in Scotland for over a thousand years, until someone secretly releases two into the hills above Fi MacLeod's family sheep farm. When dead lambs…

5th gradeLevel 6 · Super DragonAnimals · Farm16 questions