📚 Reading Quest
🕊️

The Pigeons of the Old City

Every evening, Bilal and his grandfather send their flock of homing pigeons wheeling over the rooftops of the old city. But the family is moving to a new flat, and Dada says the birds cannot come. Bilal is sure that if his best pigeon, Sitara, wins the big race home from Multan, everything will change. He is right, but not in the way he expects.

4th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxAnimals · Family · Pets2132 wordsAbout 30 minutes

Read it in the app 🚀

In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.

Words to know

loft
a house or shelter built for pigeons, often on a roof
homing
able to find the way back home from far away
magnetic field
an invisible force around the Earth that makes a compass needle point north
flock
a group of birds that live, fly, or feed together
squab
a very young pigeon that has not yet learned to fly

Chapter 1: The Sky Above the Old City

Every evening, just before the call to sunset prayer, Bilal climbed the narrow stairs of his grandfather's house to the rooftop, and the whole sky over the old city of Lahore opened up like a blue tent.

From up there he could see everything: the minarets of the great mosque, the tangle of electric wires strung between buildings like spiderwebs, the laundry flapping on a hundred other roofs, and the kites that boys flew from the rooftops in spring. Below, in the narrow lanes, there was a never-ending river of noise: rickshaws honking, sellers calling out the prices of oranges, a radio playing old songs.

But on the roof it was quiet, except for the pigeons.

Dada's loft stood in the corner, a wooden house painted green, with a little landing board at the front and rows of nesting boxes inside. Forty pigeons lived there. Some were gray with shining green and purple necks. Some were white as milk. One was the color of cinnamon and had a white star on her forehead.

That was Sitara, which means "star." She was Bilal's favorite, and she was the fastest bird Dada had ever raised.

"Open the door, beta," Dada said, settling onto his wooden stool with a groan. His knees had begun to hurt that winter.

Bilal lifted the latch. The pigeons poured out in a rush of feathers and clapping wings. They rose together, a single flock, and swept in great circles over the rooftops, turning and flashing in the late sunlight, silver then dark then silver again, like a handful of coins thrown into the air.

Dada watched them with his chin tilted up. "Your great-grandfather kept pigeons on this roof," he said. "And his father before him. In the old days, people used pigeons to carry messages, because a pigeon can always find her way home. Kings sent letters tied to their legs. Even in the great wars a hundred years ago, soldiers carried pigeons in baskets. When the radios broke, a pigeon could still get through."

"How do they know the way?" Bilal asked. He had asked before, but he liked to hear the answer.

"Even the scientists are still arguing," said Dada, and his eyes crinkled. "They know some things. A pigeon can feel the Earth's magnetic field, like a tiny compass inside her head. She can use the position of the sun. She remembers rivers and roads and buildings. Some scientists think she can even smell her way, or hear sounds too deep for our ears, like the rumble of the sea or the wind over mountains. Probably she uses all of them together."

The flock swept down, landed on the loft roof in a clatter, and began to waddle inside, one by one. Sitara came last. She always did. She liked to make one extra loop on her own, as if checking that the city was still there.

Then Dada said something that made the evening go cold.

"Bilal. Your father has found a new flat. In the new part of the city, near his office." He paused. "It's on the fourth floor. There's no roof we can use."

Bilal turned. "Then where will the pigeons go?"

Dada looked out over the rooftops for a long time. "They can't come," he said at last.

Check your understanding

  1. Vocabulary The pigeons rose "like a handful of coins thrown into the air." What does this comparison help you picture?

    1. The pigeons are worth a lot of money
    2. The flock flashing silver and dark as it turns in the sunlight
    3. The pigeons are very small and round
    4. The pigeons are falling to the ground
  2. Key details According to Dada, which of these do pigeons use to find their way home?

    1. Maps drawn by their owners
    2. The Earth's magnetic field and the position of the sun
    3. Only their sense of taste
    4. The calls of other birds
  3. Inference Why might Dada wait "a long time" before saying the pigeons can't come?

    1. He has forgotten the question
    2. The news is painful for him too, and he doesn't want to say it
    3. He is counting the pigeons
    4. He thinks Bilal didn't hear
  4. Main idea What problem is introduced at the end of this chapter?

    1. Sitara is sick
    2. The family is moving to a flat where the pigeons cannot live
    3. Dada wants to buy more pigeons
    4. The loft has been damaged

Chapter 2: The Race from Multan

For three days, Bilal barely spoke. He fed the pigeons and cleaned the loft and watched Sitara turn her extra loop over the city. He hated the new flat already, though he had never seen it.

Then, on Thursday, Mr. Rashid from the pigeon club came by with news. The big spring race was in two weeks. The birds would be driven in a truck to the city of Multan, more than three hundred kilometres away, and released together at dawn. The first bird to fly home to its own loft would win.

Bilal ran to find Dada. "Sitara can win," he said, breathless. "And if she wins, everyone will see how special she is. Then Abbu will have to find a way to keep her. He'll have to!"

Dada studied him for a moment. He seemed about to say something, and then he only nodded. "Then we train," he said.

Training a homing pigeon, Bilal discovered, takes patience more than anything else. A pigeon does not know how to come home from Multan on the first day. She has to learn the world bit by bit, like a child learning the streets around her house before she is allowed to walk across town.

So every morning before school, Bilal and his cousin Hamza took Sitara and six other birds in a basket on the back of Hamza's motorbike. The first day they released them just two kilometres from home, beside the canal. The birds rose, circled twice, and flew straight back. The next day, they went five kilometres. Then ten. Then twenty, out past the edge of the city, where green fields of wheat stretched to the horizon.

Each time, Bilal watched the birds circle above him, figuring out which way was home. Then, as if someone had whispered the answer, they all turned at once and shot away.

"How do they decide?" Hamza asked, squinting up.

"Nobody knows exactly," said Bilal, feeling proud to know even that much. "It's like a puzzle they solve with their whole bodies."

Dada could not come on these trips. Bilal noticed now how slowly his grandfather climbed the stairs to the roof each evening, holding the rail with both hands, stopping halfway to breathe. Once, Bilal found him sitting on the top step, rubbing his knees, with the loft door still closed and the pigeons fluttering inside, impatient.

"Why didn't you call me?" Bilal asked.

"You were doing your homework," said Dada. "I'm not so old that I can't climb some stairs." But he let Bilal help him up.

On the morning of the race, Mr. Rashid's truck carried Sitara away to Multan in a basket with forty other birds from all over the old city. Bilal did not sleep the night before. In the morning, he and Dada sat on the roof with a thermos of sweet tea and a pair of binoculars and waited.

Three hundred kilometres, Bilal thought. Over farms and villages and the wide brown river. No one to show her the way.

Check your understanding

  1. Cause and effect Why does Bilal want Sitara to win the race?

    1. He wants the prize money for a new bicycle
    2. He hopes it will convince his father to find a way to keep the pigeons
    3. He wants to beat his cousin Hamza
    4. Mr. Rashid promised him a new pigeon
  2. Sequence How does Bilal train Sitara to fly home from far away?

    1. He sends her straight to Multan on the first day
    2. He releases her a little farther from home each time
    3. He shows her a map of Pakistan
    4. He lets her follow a truck home
  3. Inference What is Bilal beginning to notice about Dada in this chapter?

    1. Dada no longer loves the pigeons
    2. Dada wants to move to the new flat
    3. Climbing to the roof is becoming very hard for Dada
    4. Dada is angry with Bilal for racing Sitara
  4. Character Why does Dada say "I'm not so old that I can't climb some stairs"?

    1. He is proud and does not want Bilal to worry about him
    2. He is angry that Bilal is lazy
    3. He is telling a joke about pigeons
    4. He wants to go on the training trips

Chapter 3: The Storm

The first birds were expected around noon, if the wind was kind. But the wind was not kind.

At ten o'clock, a dark wall of cloud rose in the southwest, the direction of Multan. By eleven, the air smelled of dust and rain. Then the storm arrived: a hot, howling wind full of sand that turned the sky the color of weak tea, followed by rain that came down so hard it bounced off the rooftops.

Bilal and Dada huddled under the little tin roof beside the loft. Dada had his hand on Bilal's shoulder. Neither of them said what they were both thinking: somewhere out there, Sitara was flying into that.

The storm lasted two hours. When it finally rolled away to the north, the air was washed clean, and the city sparkled. Bilal stood at the edge of the roof with the binoculars pressed to his eyes until they ached.

At three o'clock, a bird appeared over the mosque, but it flew on, to a loft three streets away. At three-twenty, two more passed by. By five o'clock, the club's phone calls said that eleven birds had already come home, and the race was won by a gray cock bird belonging to a man near the railway station.

Sitara had not come home.

"She's lost," Bilal whispered. "Or she's hurt. Or a hawk..." He couldn't finish.

"Pigeons are tougher than they look," said Dada. "In a storm like that, a wise bird lands and waits. Then she has to find her way again, once the sky has changed. Give her time."

Bilal sat with him until it was dark. Sitara did not come.

That night, Bilal lay in bed and listened to the house. He heard his parents talking quietly in the kitchen about the move, about boxes and moving vans. And he heard something else: Dada climbing the stairs to the roof, very slowly, one step at a time, stopping, starting again. Going up in the dark to leave the loft door open, in case a tired bird came home in the night.

Bilal got up and followed him. He found his grandfather on the landing, halfway up, gripping the rail. His face was gray with pain.

"Dada!"

"I'm fine," Dada said, but he didn't stand up.

Bilal sat down beside him on the step. And for the first time, he understood. The problem wasn't the new flat. Even if they stayed in this house forever, Dada couldn't keep climbing these stairs, twice a day, every day, to care for forty birds. The roof was getting too high for him. The move wasn't taking the pigeons away from Dada. In a way, it was taking Dada away from the stairs.

"I'll open the loft," Bilal said quietly. "You go to bed."

Check your understanding

  1. Cause and effect Why is Sitara late coming home from Multan?

    1. She stopped to eat in a farmer's field
    2. She flew to the wrong loft on purpose
    3. A powerful storm swept across her path
    4. Mr. Rashid forgot to release her
  2. Key details Who won the race?

    1. Sitara
    2. Hamza's pigeon
    3. A gray bird belonging to a man near the railway station
    4. Mr. Rashid's pigeon
  3. Inference What does Bilal realize when he finds Dada on the stairs?

    1. Dada wants to sell the pigeons for money
    2. The stairs, not just the move, are the real reason Dada can no longer care for the birds
    3. Dada has given up on Sitara
    4. Bilal's parents are angry with Dada
  4. Character What does Dada's climb in the dark show about him?

    1. He is careless about his health
    2. He cares deeply for the birds, even when it causes him pain
    3. He doesn't trust Bilal to do it
    4. He cannot sleep because of the storm

Chapter 4: Two Small Birds

Sitara came home on the third morning.

Bilal was on the roof before school, scattering grain, when he heard the clap of wings and looked up. A cinnamon-colored bird with a white star on her forehead was circling the old city, low and slow, as if checking that it was still there. She made her extra loop. Then she dropped onto the landing board, ruffled her feathers, and walked into the loft as if she had just popped out to the market.

Her wing feathers were ragged and there was dust in her eyes, but she was whole. She had flown three hundred kilometres through a storm and found her way home. Bilal sat down right there on the roof and laughed until he cried.

She hadn't won. It didn't matter at all.

That afternoon, Bilal went downstairs and sat beside Dada, who was resting with his legs on a cushion.

"I've been thinking," Bilal said. "About Zainab."

Zainab lived next door. She was eleven, and she had spent half her childhood leaning over the low wall between the two rooftops, watching the pigeons, asking a hundred questions. Her family was staying in the old city. Her roof touched theirs.

"She knows every bird's name," Bilal said. "She helped me clean the loft when I had a fever. If we gave her the flock, they'd stay right here. They'd still fly over the same mosque and the same rooftops. Their home wouldn't change. And we could visit them."

It was the hardest thing he had ever said out loud. He thought of Sitara's star, and of the empty sky over the new flat. But he also thought of the stairs.

Dada was quiet for a long time. Then he reached out and took Bilal's hand.

"Your great-grandfather would be proud of you," he said. "A real pigeon keeper thinks about what the birds need. Not only about what he wants."

Then he smiled, a slow, sly smile. "But I have an idea too. Do you know why a homing pigeon comes back to one particular loft?"

"Because it's home," said Bilal.

"Because it's where she grew up," said Dada. "A grown bird will always fly back to the place she first learned. But a squab, a very young bird who has never flown outside, can learn a new home. If she grows up somewhere else, that place becomes her home instead."

Sitara had laid two eggs that spring. The squabs were a week old now, two fuzzy yellow lumps in a nest box.

So on moving day, two baskets rode in the back of the van. One held Dada's pots and pans. The other held two tiny pigeons and their nest. On the balcony of the new flat, fourth floor, Bilal and his father built a small green loft with a landing board, where Dada could sit in a chair and watch without climbing a single step.

The squabs grew. When they were ready, Bilal opened the little door, and they flew, short wobbly circles at first, then wider ones, out over the new part of the city with its glass towers and straight, wide roads. Then they turned, solved the puzzle with their whole bodies, and came home to the balcony.

On Fridays, Bilal took the bus back to the old city and climbed the narrow stairs with Zainab. Together, they opened the green loft and watched the flock pour into the sky, silver then dark then silver again. And every time, a cinnamon bird with a white star on her head made one extra loop on her own, as if checking that the whole city, old and new, was still there.

Check your understanding

  1. Inference Why do you think Bilal laughs "until he cried" when Sitara returns?

    1. He is upset that she lost the race
    2. He feels huge relief and joy after days of fear
    3. He thinks her ragged feathers look funny
    4. He is laughing at Zainab
  2. Vocabulary Dada explains that a "squab" can learn a new home. Based on the story, what is a squab?

    1. An adult racing pigeon
    2. A pigeon that has lost a race
    3. A very young pigeon that has never flown outside
    4. A kind of pigeon loft
  3. Cause and effect Why can the two young pigeons make the balcony their home when Sitara cannot?

    1. A pigeon's home is the place she first learns, and the squabs have not learned another place yet
    2. The balcony is closer to Multan
    3. Squabs cannot feel the Earth's magnetic field
    4. Sitara is too old to fly
  4. Theme What is the main lesson of the story?

    1. Winning races is the most important thing
    2. Pets should never be given away
    3. Truly caring for someone means thinking about what they need, not just what you want
    4. Old houses are better than new flats

Spelling words

These 12 words all appear in the story.

  • rooftop
  • loft
  • magnetic
  • compass
  • messages
  • released
  • horizon
  • binoculars
  • stairs
  • feathers
  • minarets
  • patience

Writing prompt

Bilal had to choose between keeping the pigeons for himself and giving them to someone who could care for them. Do you think he made the right choice? Explain your opinion using details from the story, and describe what you might have done.

Reading skills practiced

Vocabulary, Key details, Inference, Main idea, Cause and effect, Sequence, Character, Theme.

Answer key for grown-ups
  1. The flock flashing silver and dark as it turns in the sunlight Coins flash as they spin, just like the pigeons' wings in the light.
  2. The Earth's magnetic field and the position of the sun Dada lists several clues, including magnetism and the sun.
  3. The news is painful for him too, and he doesn't want to say it The pigeons have been in his family for generations.
  4. The family is moving to a flat where the pigeons cannot live The new flat is on the fourth floor with no roof to use.
  5. He hopes it will convince his father to find a way to keep the pigeons He thinks a win will prove how special she is.
  6. He releases her a little farther from home each time Two kilometres, then five, ten, and twenty.
  7. Climbing to the roof is becoming very hard for Dada He sees Dada stopping to breathe and rubbing his knees on the stairs.
  8. He is proud and does not want Bilal to worry about him He brushes off his struggles but still accepts Bilal's help.
  9. A powerful storm swept across her path A storm with dust and rain lasted two hours.
  10. A gray bird belonging to a man near the railway station The club's phone calls announce the winner.
  11. The stairs, not just the move, are the real reason Dada can no longer care for the birds The roof "was getting too high for him."
  12. He cares deeply for the birds, even when it causes him pain He climbs to leave the door open for a tired bird.
  13. He feels huge relief and joy after days of fear Losing the race "didn't matter at all"; she was alive.
  14. A very young pigeon that has never flown outside The squabs are "fuzzy yellow lumps" only a week old.
  15. A pigeon's home is the place she first learns, and the squabs have not learned another place yet Dada says a grown bird always returns to where she first learned.
  16. Truly caring for someone means thinking about what they need, not just what you want Bilal puts the birds' and Dada's needs before his own wishes.

More 4th grade stories

🥚

The Great Egg Drop

Cormac Doyle is sure he can build a machine that will carry a raw egg safely off the school roof. His partner Aisling is sure he is going to make a mess. Between a…

4th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxHumor · School · Science16 questions
🦇

The Bats Under the Bridge

Every summer night, a river of bats pours out from under the old Río Seco bridge. Most people in town would like them gone. When the bridge needs repairs and the town…

4th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxAnimals · Nature · Community16 questions
🔧

The Repair Café

Hana's street in Melbourne throws away a mountain of broken things every month, and the grumpy old man at number 14 never says hello to anyone. Hana has an idea that…

4th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxCommunity · Kindness · Inventions16 questions
☀️

The Sun Oven

Esi and Abena have been best friends since they were babies in Kumasi, Ghana. Together they build a cooker that runs on nothing but sunshine, and it is good enough to…

4th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxFriendship · School · Science16 questions
⚾

The Curveball

In San Pedro de Macorís, the Dominican town famous for baseball players, Yarelis Peña is the only girl on the Cañeros youth team, and she has just learned to throw a…

4th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxSports · Science · Family16 questions
🌾

Stairs to the Sky

Lito's family has farmed the same rice terraces in the mountains of the Philippines for longer than anyone can remember. Lito thinks the terraces are old-fashioned, and…

4th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxFarm · Family · History16 questions