📚 Reading Quest
🥚

The Great Egg Drop

Cormac Doyle is sure he can build a machine that will carry a raw egg safely off the school roof. His partner Aisling is sure he is going to make a mess. Between a jelly cushion, a runaway umbrella, and one very unlucky cup of tea, they are both right, and they learn that a broken egg can still teach you something.

4th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxHumor · School · Science2024 wordsAbout 30 minutes

Read it in the app 🚀

In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.

Words to know

gravity
the force that pulls things toward the ground
air resistance
the push of air against something moving through it, which slows it down
crumple zone
a part built to squash on purpose so that the thing inside is protected
prototype
a first model of an invention, built to test the idea
impact
the moment when one thing hits another

Chapter 1: An Egg Named Gerald

On the first Monday of March, Ms. Okafor stood at the front of Room 9 in Saint Brendan's School holding a single brown egg as though it were a crown jewel.

"This," she said, "is your next experiment."

Twenty-six pupils leaned forward. Cormac Doyle leaned forward the most. He was a boy built entirely out of enthusiasm, with hair that refused to lie flat and a habit of saying "Easy!" before anybody had finished explaining anything.

"In three weeks," Ms. Okafor went on, "Mr. Brennan, our caretaker, will carry your machines up to the flat part of the school roof. He will drop them, one at a time, onto the car park below. That is a fall of about nine metres. Each machine will carry one raw egg. If the egg survives, you pass. If the egg survives and your machine is the lightest, you win the Golden Spatula."

She held up a kitchen spatula that someone had spray-painted gold. It glittered. Cormac's eyes glittered back.

"Easy!" he said.

"You will work with a partner," said Ms. Okafor, and read out the pairs. Cormac's partner was Aisling Ní Bhriain.

Aisling sat by the window and spoke so quietly that most of the class had forgotten what her voice sounded like. She owned four notebooks, each a different color, and she wrote down the weather every morning just because she liked to know. When Cormac dragged his chair over to her desk with a loud scrape, she moved her pencil case two centimetres to the left, as if making room for a small storm.

"Right," said Cormac. "I've already got it. We build a giant mattress. Like a bouncy castle, but for an egg. We fill it with marshmallows."

"Marshmallows," Aisling repeated.

"Thousands of them."

Aisling opened her green notebook. On the first page she wrote, in small, neat letters: Problem: an egg falls 9 metres. What actually breaks it?

"Gravity breaks it," said Cormac. "Obviously."

"Gravity makes it fall," said Aisling. "That's not quite the same thing. The egg doesn't break while it's falling. It breaks when it stops."

Cormac opened his mouth to argue, found that he had nothing to argue with, and closed it again.

Ms. Okafor gave each pair a box of six eggs for testing. Cormac immediately drew a face on one of them with a felt-tip pen: two dots, a curly mustache, and a worried mouth.

"This is Gerald," he announced. "Gerald is going to fly."

Aisling looked at Gerald's worried mouth. She thought Gerald probably knew something Cormac didn't.

Check your understanding

  1. Character Which words best describe Cormac at the start of the story?

    1. Shy and careful
    2. Eager and overconfident
    3. Bored and lazy
    4. Mean and bossy
  2. Key details What is the prize for the lightest machine that keeps its egg safe?

    1. A gold medal
    2. A day off school
    3. The Golden Spatula
    4. A box of marshmallows
  3. Inference When Aisling moves her pencil case "as if making room for a small storm," what is the author suggesting?

    1. Aisling is afraid of bad weather
    2. Cormac is loud and energetic, and Aisling expects him to be a lot to handle
    3. The classroom window is open
    4. Aisling wants to leave the room
  4. Main idea What important idea does Aisling write in her notebook?

    1. Marshmallows are the softest thing in the world
    2. Eggs are stronger than people think
    3. The egg breaks not while falling but when it suddenly stops
    4. The roof is too high for the experiment

Chapter 2: The Jelly Incident

Cormac did not give up on big ideas. He simply had new ones.

On Tuesday he arrived with a plan for a cushion made of jelly. "Strawberry," he explained. "Wobbly things are soft. Soft things are safe. We set the egg inside a big bowl of jelly, like a fly in amber."

"Flies in amber are dead," Aisling pointed out.

"Different situation," said Cormac.

They tested it on Wednesday at lunchtime, dropping it from the top of the climbing frame, which Aisling had measured at exactly two metres. Before the drop, she wrote the height, the weight of the jelly, and the time in her notebook. Cormac counted down from ten in a dramatic voice that attracted a crowd of younger children.

The jelly hit the ground like a pink water balloon. It exploded in every direction. A first-class pupil named Rory got some in his ear. Gerald, astonishingly, was fine, sitting in the middle of the splatter with his worried mustache.

"SUCCESS!" yelled Cormac.

Aisling knelt and weighed the remains of the jelly in a bag. Then she wrote a number and frowned.

"It worked," she said. "But it weighs nearly two kilos. The winner has to be the lightest. And Mr. Brennan has to carry it up a ladder."

Cormac's face fell, very slightly. Then it rose again. "Fine. Then we go up instead of down. Parachute!"

This, Aisling had to admit, was a much better idea. She had read that a parachute works because of air resistance. As something falls, air pushes up against it. A small, smooth object slices through the air easily and keeps speeding up. A wide sheet catches a great deal of air and slows down. Skydivers jumping from planes can fall at nearly two hundred kilometres an hour, but once their parachutes open, they land about as gently as if they had jumped off a kitchen chair.

"Exactly," said Cormac, who had not read any of this but was happy to agree. "And I know where to get the biggest parachute in the world."

The biggest parachute in the world turned out to be his granny's golf umbrella, which was striped like a beach ball and roughly the size of a small car.

They tested it on Friday, again from the climbing frame. Cormac taped Gerald's egg cup to the handle and held the open umbrella over his head. There was a gentle breeze.

"Three, two, one, LAUNCH!"

He let go. The umbrella did not fall. It did not do anything an umbrella was supposed to do. A gust of wind caught it, and it sailed sideways across the yard like a striped jellyfish, bounced off the bike shed, rolled over twice, and came to rest upside down in the school pond.

Gerald floated quietly beside it, bobbing among the lily pads. He had survived again.

The crowd of first-class pupils cheered as if they had just seen a magic trick. Mr. Brennan, the caretaker, came out of his shed with a net and an expression that suggested he had worked at Saint Brendan's for a very long time.

Check your understanding

  1. Cause and effect Why does Aisling reject the jelly cushion even though Gerald survived?

    1. The jelly smelled bad
    2. Rory complained about it
    3. It was far too heavy to win or to carry up a ladder
    4. It was the wrong flavor
  2. Vocabulary According to the story, what is "air resistance"?

    1. Wind that blows things sideways
    2. The push of air against a falling object that slows it down
    3. The way air makes eggs float
    4. How fast a skydiver can fall
  3. Inference What does the description of Mr. Brennan's expression suggest about him?

    1. He is angry and will report the children
    2. He has never seen children do experiments before
    3. He has cleaned up after many strange school projects and is not surprised
    4. He wants to win the Golden Spatula himself
  4. Sequence Which of these happened first?

    1. The jelly cushion splattered on the ground
    2. The umbrella landed in the pond
    3. Mr. Brennan came out with a net
    4. Cormac taped the egg cup to the umbrella

Chapter 3: Failure Is Data

On Monday, the second week, Cormac sat at Aisling's desk with his chin in his hands. Other teams were already building neat little boxes and paper cones. Liam and Fatima had a machine made of straws that looked like something from a science museum.

"We're going to lose," Cormac said. "Two tests and both of them were disasters."

"No, they weren't," said Aisling.

He looked at her. It was possibly the most words she had said to him without being asked a question.

She opened the green notebook and turned it around so he could see. Every test was there: the height, the weight, the wind, what happened. Beside the umbrella test she had drawn a small sketch of the umbrella tipping sideways.

"My mum's a scientist," she said. "She studies soil. She says failure is just data you didn't order. The jelly test taught us that soft things work, but heavy things lose. The umbrella taught us that a parachute works, but a huge one gets blown about. So we need something light and soft and a small, steady parachute."

Cormac stared at the notebook for a long moment. "You wrote all that down," he said, "while I was shouting countdowns."

"Somebody had to."

Then she showed him one more page. It was headed Crumple zones. Her uncle, she explained, fixed cars. Modern cars were built with front ends that crumpled on purpose in a crash, like a fist of paper. The crumpling took a fraction of a second longer than a hard stop, and that tiny bit of extra time meant the people inside felt a much gentler jolt.

"So if we can make the egg stop slowly," Aisling said, "even a little bit more slowly, it won't crack."

"Like landing on your feet and bending your knees," Cormac said, "instead of landing stiff."

Aisling blinked. "Yes. Exactly like that."

For the first time, they built something together. Cormac, it turned out, was brilliant with his hands. He could fold paper into shapes that Aisling couldn't even picture. They made a cage of drinking straws with the egg hung in the middle on rubber bands, so that it would bounce instead of smash. Under the cage, they taped a skirt of folded paper cups that would crush on impact like a car's crumple zone. On top, they tied a parachute made from a small bin bag, with a hole cut in the center.

"Why the hole?" Cormac asked.

"I read that a hole lets some air escape straight up, so the parachute doesn't swing from side to side," Aisling said. "It stays steady."

They tested it eleven times from the climbing frame. Each time, Aisling measured. Each time, they changed one small thing: a shorter string, a thinner rubber band, two cups instead of four. By Friday, the machine weighed eighty-four grams, less than a packet of crisps and a sandwich. Gerald had survived every single drop.

"We should give it a name," said Cormac.

"It's a machine," said Aisling. Then she smiled, a small, surprised smile, as though it had escaped without permission. "Fine. You choose."

He called it the Gentle Gerald.

Check your understanding

  1. Theme What does Aisling's mother mean when she says "failure is just data you didn't order"?

    1. Scientists should never fail
    2. Failing means you should quit
    3. Even a failed test gives you useful information you can learn from
    4. Data is more important than people
  2. Cause and effect Why do crumple zones help protect what is inside?

    1. They make the car lighter
    2. They make the stop take a little longer, so the jolt is gentler
    3. They stop gravity from working
    4. They make the car bounce higher
  3. Character How does Cormac change in this chapter?

    1. He becomes even more boastful
    2. He decides to work with a different partner
    3. He starts to listen to Aisling and work with her as a real partner
    4. He stops caring about the contest
  4. Inference Why do you think Aisling's smile "escaped without permission"?

    1. She is trying to trick Cormac
    2. She is starting to enjoy working with Cormac, even though she did not expect to
    3. She thinks the name is silly
    4. She has a toothache

Chapter 4: The Teacup

On the day of the drop, the whole school came out to the car park. The sky was gray and the wind was calm, which Aisling noted down. Mr. Brennan climbed the ladder to the roof with a plastic crate of machines and an expression of great patience.

One by one, the machines fell. A cardboard box landed with a sad crunch. A balloon contraption drifted gracefully for a moment and then burst. Liam and Fatima's straw sculpture bounced three times, and their egg was perfect. The crowd cheered. Their machine weighed ninety-one grams.

"We can beat that," Cormac whispered. He was bouncing on his toes. Aisling was holding her notebook so tightly that the cover bent.

"Number fourteen!" called Mr. Brennan from the roof. "The Gentle Gerald!"

He held it out over the edge and let go.

The little bin-bag parachute opened with a soft snap. The Gentle Gerald sank through the air, steady as a feather, turning slowly. The crowd went quiet. It drifted lower, and lower, and then, at the very last moment, a small breeze came around the corner of the building.

It nudged the parachute sideways, just a little. Just enough.

Beside the door of the school stood Principal Mahony, a tall, serious man who had stepped outside to watch while holding his morning cup of tea. The Gentle Gerald floated past his shoulder and landed, with a soft paper crunch, directly in his teacup.

Tea sloshed over the side. The paper cups crumpled. For three long seconds, nobody moved.

Then Principal Mahony lifted the dripping machine out of his cup with two fingers. He peered inside the straw cage. Hanging in the middle, slightly damp, completely uncracked, was the egg.

"Well," said the principal, "it seems to have survived. Which is more than I can say for my tea."

The car park exploded with laughter. Even Mr. Brennan, up on the roof, was laughing so hard he had to sit down.

The Gentle Gerald weighed eighty-four grams, seven grams less than any other machine with a safe egg. Ms. Okafor presented the Golden Spatula to Cormac and Aisling, and asked them to explain to the class how their design worked.

Cormac looked at Aisling. Two weeks earlier, he would have grabbed the spatula and given a speech about marshmallows. Now he simply stepped back and nodded at her, the way a goalkeeper nods at a teammate taking the penalty that matters most. Aisling looked at the crowd and turned pink. Then she took a breath and explained, in a small but steady voice, about gravity and air resistance and the hole in the parachute and the crumple zone and the rubber bands. People leaned in to hear her. When she finished, they clapped.

"And the teacup?" asked Ms. Okafor, her eyes twinkling.

"That," said Cormac, "was not in the plan. But Aisling wrote down the wind speed, so next time, we'll know."

That afternoon, they hung the Golden Spatula above Aisling's desk. Underneath it, Cormac taped the very first egg, empty now, with its curly felt-tip mustache and its worried mouth. Somebody had added a tiny paper medal.

Aisling opened a new notebook, a purple one, and wrote on the first page: Next experiment. Partner: Cormac.

Then, after a moment, she added a second line: Bring a spare cup of tea.

Check your understanding

  1. Cause and effect What caused the Gentle Gerald to land in the principal's teacup?

    1. Mr. Brennan threw it too hard
    2. The parachute did not open
    3. A small breeze pushed the parachute sideways at the last moment
    4. Cormac aimed it at the principal on purpose
  2. Key details By how much did the Gentle Gerald beat the next-lightest machine with a safe egg?

    1. Two grams
    2. Seven grams
    3. Ninety-one grams
    4. Eighty-four grams
  3. Inference Why does Cormac let Aisling explain the design to the class?

    1. He knows she understands the science best and deserves the credit
    2. He has forgotten how it works
    3. He is too embarrassed about the tea
    4. Ms. Okafor told him he was not allowed to speak
  4. Theme Which lesson fits this story best?

    1. Loud people always win
    2. Never try anything that might fail
    3. Patient testing and real teamwork can turn mistakes into success
    4. Science is too serious to be funny

Spelling words

These 12 words all appear in the story.

  • experiment
  • parachute
  • gravity
  • resistance
  • scientist
  • caretaker
  • measured
  • partner
  • crumpled
  • cushion
  • quietly
  • disasters

Writing prompt

Cormac thought a bigger, flashier design would win, but Aisling believed in testing small ideas first. Whose way of working do you think is better for solving a problem? Use at least two events from the story to support your answer.

Reading skills practiced

Character, Key details, Inference, Main idea, Cause and effect, Vocabulary, Sequence, Theme.

Answer key for grown-ups
  1. Eager and overconfident He says "Easy!" before he even hears the whole plan.
  2. The Golden Spatula Ms. Okafor holds up a spatula painted gold.
  3. Cormac is loud and energetic, and Aisling expects him to be a lot to handle The storm is a comparison for Cormac's noisy arrival.
  4. The egg breaks not while falling but when it suddenly stops She separates the fall from the moment of impact.
  5. It was far too heavy to win or to carry up a ladder She weighs it and finds it is nearly two kilos.
  6. The push of air against a falling object that slows it down A wide sheet catches more air and slows down more.
  7. He has cleaned up after many strange school projects and is not surprised "A very long time" hints that he has seen it all before.
  8. The jelly cushion splattered on the ground The jelly test was on Wednesday; the umbrella test was on Friday.
  9. Even a failed test gives you useful information you can learn from The failed jelly and umbrella tests helped them design something better.
  10. They make the stop take a little longer, so the jolt is gentler The extra fraction of a second makes the stop less sudden.
  11. He starts to listen to Aisling and work with her as a real partner He studies her notebook and connects her idea to bending your knees.
  12. She is starting to enjoy working with Cormac, even though she did not expect to Her surprise shows that the partnership has become fun for her.
  13. A small breeze pushed the parachute sideways at the last moment A breeze came around the corner of the building.
  14. Seven grams It weighed eighty-four grams; Liam and Fatima's weighed ninety-one.
  15. He knows she understands the science best and deserves the credit He looks at her first, showing he respects what she did.
  16. Patient testing and real teamwork can turn mistakes into success Their failures, notes, and teamwork led to the winning design.

More 4th grade stories

🕊️

The Pigeons of the Old City

Every evening, Bilal and his grandfather send their flock of homing pigeons wheeling over the rooftops of the old city. But the family is moving to a new flat, and Dada…

4th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxAnimals · Family · Pets16 questions
🦇

The Bats Under the Bridge

Every summer night, a river of bats pours out from under the old Río Seco bridge. Most people in town would like them gone. When the bridge needs repairs and the town…

4th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxAnimals · Nature · Community16 questions
🔧

The Repair Café

Hana's street in Melbourne throws away a mountain of broken things every month, and the grumpy old man at number 14 never says hello to anyone. Hana has an idea that…

4th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxCommunity · Kindness · Inventions16 questions
☀️

The Sun Oven

Esi and Abena have been best friends since they were babies in Kumasi, Ghana. Together they build a cooker that runs on nothing but sunshine, and it is good enough to…

4th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxFriendship · School · Science16 questions
⚾

The Curveball

In San Pedro de Macorís, the Dominican town famous for baseball players, Yarelis Peña is the only girl on the Cañeros youth team, and she has just learned to throw a…

4th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxSports · Science · Family16 questions
🌾

Stairs to the Sky

Lito's family has farmed the same rice terraces in the mountains of the Philippines for longer than anyone can remember. Lito thinks the terraces are old-fashioned, and…

4th gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxFarm · Family · History16 questions