📚 Reading Quest
⭐

Four Stars for the Meatloaf

After watching a famous food critic on TV, ten-year-old Dez starts writing star reviews of every dinner his family makes and taping them to the fridge. His reviews are clever, his reviews are funny, and his reviews are about to start a family war. Then Grandma Bisi makes him an offer he cannot refuse: cook one dinner himself, and let the family review him.

4th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeyHumor · Family2032 wordsAbout 30 minutes

Read it in the app 🚀

In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.

Words to know

critic
a person whose job is to judge things like food, books, or movies and share their opinion
review
a piece of writing that tells what someone thinks about something and why
cuisine
a style of cooking from a particular place or culture
scorched
burned on the surface
constructive
helpful and meant to make something better, not just to find fault

Chapter 1: The Critic Is Born

It all started with a man named Montgomery Fitch.

Montgomery Fitch was a food critic on television. He wore a bow tie, raised one eyebrow higher than seemed possible, and visited a different restaurant on every episode of his show, "Fitch Bites." At the end of each meal, he dabbed his mouth with a napkin, stared into the camera, and gave the restaurant a score from one to five stars.

"The soup," he would say, "was as lukewarm as a handshake from a stranger. Two stars."

Dez Adeyemi thought this was the most amazing job in the entire world. You got to eat, and then you got to tell people what you thought. He watched every episode twice.

So on Monday night, when his father set down a dish of Tuesday Surprise Casserole, Dez was ready. (It was called Tuesday Surprise even when it was Monday. That was part of the surprise.)

Dez took a bite. He chewed thoughtfully. He raised one eyebrow, or tried to. Both of them went up.

Then he took out a notebook.

The next morning, a sheet of paper was taped to the refrigerator. In Dez's best handwriting, it said:

"REVIEW: Tuesday Surprise Casserole. Chef: Dad. The noodles were as soft as a wet sock. The cheese on top was crispy, which was the best part. The peas tasted like they had given up on life. TWO STARS."

His father read it while making coffee. He laughed so hard he had to put the pot down.

"A wet sock!" he said. "Where do you get this stuff?"

"Montgomery Fitch," said Dez proudly.

His mother read it next and smiled. His older sister, Tola, read it, rolled her eyes all the way up to the ceiling, and said, "You're so weird."

Dez decided that this was a successful launch.

The reviews kept coming. On Wednesday, his mother made chicken stew, and Dez gave it four stars: "Rich and warm, like a blanket you can eat. Points taken away for one mysterious bone." On Thursday, Tola made grilled cheese sandwiches, and Dez gave them three stars: "The bread was golden. The middle was cold as a winter morning. Did the chef forget to wait?"

Tola tore that one off the fridge and crumpled it into a ball.

"Nobody asked for your opinion," she said.

"A critic doesn't wait to be asked," Dez said, in his best Montgomery Fitch voice. "A critic serves the public."

"The public," said Tola, "would like you to stop."

Dez did not stop. In fact, he got better. He started describing the smell of the food, the color of the sauce, and the way each plate was arranged. He learned new words, such as "aroma" and "texture," and he used them every chance he got. By the end of the week, the fridge was covered in reviews, and Dez had decided that he would be the greatest food critic the world had ever known.

He did not notice that his father had stopped laughing.

Check your understanding

  1. Vocabulary What is a "critic" in this story?

    1. A person who cooks in a restaurant
    2. A person who judges things like food and shares an opinion about them
    3. A person who hosts a cooking competition
    4. A person who delivers food to houses
  2. Key details Why was the dish called "Tuesday Surprise Casserole" even on Monday?

    1. The name being wrong was part of the joke, or "surprise"
    2. Dad made it every Tuesday
    3. Dez's family thought Monday was Tuesday
    4. It was a famous restaurant recipe
  3. Inference What does the last sentence, "He did not notice that his father had stopped laughing," suggest?

    1. Dad has lost his sense of humor
    2. Dez's reviews are starting to hurt Dad's feelings, but Dez hasn't realized it
    3. Dad has a sore throat
    4. Dad agrees that his cooking is terrible
  4. Character How does Tola feel about Dez's reviews?

    1. She thinks they are hilarious
    2. She wants to write reviews too
    3. She is annoyed and wants him to stop
    4. She doesn't notice them

Chapter 2: The One-Star Disaster

The trouble came on the following Monday, when Grandma Bisi arrived from Lagos.

Grandma Bisi was small and round, with a laugh like a trumpet and a suitcase so heavy that it took Dez and his father together to drag it up the stairs. Half of it was clothes. The other half was spices, dried fish, and a bag of special peppers that she said you could not buy in any store in America.

That first night, Dez's father wanted everything to be perfect. He decided to cook Grandma Bisi's favorite dish, jollof rice, which is rice cooked in a spicy tomato sauce until it turns a deep orange-red. It is famous all over West Africa, and every family thinks their own recipe is the best.

Dad had been practicing all week. He chopped onions and peppers. He stirred and tasted. He stirred and tasted again. When he finally set the big pot on the table, the whole kitchen smelled of tomatoes and pepper and smoke.

Dez took one bite and reached for his notebook.

The next morning, the review was on the fridge.

"REVIEW: Jollof Rice. Chef: Dad. The rice was as mushy as oatmeal. The sauce was too salty. The bottom of the pot was scorched. This dish is a disaster. Grandma Bisi's jollof is a million times better. ONE STAR."

Dez was proud of it. It was honest. It was descriptive. It had a comparison. Montgomery Fitch himself could not have done better.

But when his father read it, he did not laugh. He did not say anything at all. He just stood there for a long moment, holding his coffee. Then he took the review down, folded it very small, put it in his pocket, and went to work without eating breakfast.

The kitchen felt very quiet.

"Well," said Tola, "I hope you're happy."

Dez wasn't sure what he was. His stomach felt as if he had swallowed a cold stone.

Grandma Bisi had seen everything. She was sitting at the table with a cup of tea, and she looked at Dez over the top of her glasses for so long that he started to sweat.

"Come here, my critic," she said.

Dez came.

"You know your father practiced that rice for a whole week? He called me three times to ask about my recipe. He wanted to make me feel at home." She sipped her tea. "Was the rice mushy?"

"A little," Dez admitted.

"Was it a disaster?"

Dez looked at his feet. "No," he said. "Not really."

"Hmm." Grandma Bisi set down her cup. "I will make you a deal, Mr. Critic. On Saturday, you will cook dinner for the whole family. By yourself. Any dish you like. Then each of us will write a review and tape it to the refrigerator. That is fair, yes?"

Dez swallowed. He had never cooked anything more complicated than toast.

But a critic could not back down from a challenge. Montgomery Fitch would never back down.

"Fine," he said. "I'll make jollof rice. And it's going to be five stars."

Tola grinned for the first time all week. "Oh," she said. "This is going to be good."

Check your understanding

  1. Cause and effect Why did Dad stop laughing and leave without breakfast?

    1. He was late for an important meeting
    2. Dez's harsh one-star review hurt his feelings after he had worked hard to please Grandma Bisi
    3. He did not like Grandma Bisi's tea
    4. He was angry that the pot was scorched
  2. Vocabulary What does it mean that Dez's stomach felt "as if he had swallowed a cold stone"?

    1. He had eaten too much rice
    2. He was very hungry
    3. He felt a heavy, uncomfortable feeling of guilt
    4. He was sick from the scorched pot
  3. Inference Why does Grandma Bisi ask Dez whether the rice was "a disaster"?

    1. She wants to know if she should cook dinner instead
    2. She wants Dez to admit that his review exaggerated and was unfair
    3. She has never tasted jollof rice before
    4. She agrees that it was a disaster
  4. Sequence What happened right after Dad read the one-star review?

    1. Dez wrote another review
    2. Grandma Bisi cooked dinner
    3. Dad folded the review, put it in his pocket, and went to work
    4. Tola laughed at Dad

Chapter 3: The Chef Is Born

On Saturday morning, Dez stood in the kitchen with an apron tied around him twice and a recipe card in his hand. He had asked Grandma Bisi for her recipe, but she had only laughed.

"My recipe is in my hands, not on paper," she said. "Use the internet. Like your father."

Dez found a recipe. It did not look hard. The ingredients were simple: rice, tomatoes, peppers, onions, oil, spices, broth. Cook everything together. How difficult could it be?

The answer turned out to be "extremely."

First, the onions. Dez had never chopped an onion before, and after the first slice, his eyes were streaming so much that he could not see the cutting board. He had to chop the rest with his eyes closed, which took a long time and was probably not very safe. Grandma Bisi watched from the doorway and said nothing, but Dez noticed she moved the sharpest knife out of his reach.

Next, the sauce. The recipe said to blend the tomatoes and peppers. Dez forgot to put the lid on the blender. For three seconds, the kitchen looked like the scene of a crime. Tomato sauce dripped from the ceiling. It dripped from the cabinets. It dripped from the cat, who left the room with great dignity and did not come back for the rest of the day.

Tola walked in, looked around, and walked straight back out. Dez could hear her laughing all the way up the stairs.

He cleaned up the mess, blended a new batch with the lid on, and finally got everything into the pot: the sauce, the oil, the spices, the rice, and the broth. Then he turned the heat up high, because he was hungry and wanted the rice to be ready faster.

That was his biggest mistake.

Twenty minutes later, a smell drifted out of the pot. It was not the delicious, smoky smell that Dad's jollof had. It was a sharper, darker smell, like a campfire that has eaten a shoe.

The smoke alarm went off.

Dez grabbed a towel and flapped it at the ceiling. Grandma Bisi opened the windows. Mom came running in from the garden. And the jollof rice, when Dez finally took the lid off, was black on the bottom, crunchy in the middle, and soupy on top, all at the same time.

He stared at it. He had worked on it for three hours. His fingers smelled like onions. His apron was splattered red. His eyes still stung.

And it was terrible.

"Well," said Grandma Bisi gently, coming up behind him. "Now you know."

"Know what?" Dez said. His voice came out wobbly.

"How long it takes. How much you worry. How much you want it to be good, for the people you love." She put a hand on his shoulder. "Every cook in the world knows this feeling. Your father felt it last Monday."

Dez thought about his father standing at the fridge, folding the review into a tiny square.

He suddenly wanted very badly to apologize.

Check your understanding

  1. Main idea What is this chapter mostly about?

    1. Grandma Bisi teaching Dez her secret recipe
    2. Dez discovering how hard it is to cook a meal
    3. The cat getting lost in the house
    4. Tola making fun of Dez for the whole day
  2. Key details What was Dez's "biggest mistake"?

    1. Forgetting the lid on the blender
    2. Chopping onions with his eyes closed
    3. Turning the heat up high so the rice would cook faster
    4. Using the internet for a recipe
  3. Inference Why did Grandma Bisi move the sharpest knife out of Dez's reach?

    1. She needed it to cook her own dinner
    2. She was worried he might hurt himself while chopping with watery eyes
    3. She did not want him to cook at all
    4. She was planning to sharpen it
  4. Character How have Dez's feelings changed by the end of this chapter?

    1. He is more proud of his reviews than ever
    2. He is angry at Grandma Bisi for the challenge
    3. He understands how his father felt and wants to apologize
    4. He has decided to become a chef instead of a critic

Chapter 4: Five-Star Reviews

That evening, the family sat down at the table. In the middle was a bowl of Dez's jollof rice. He had scraped off the black part, but it was still crunchy and soupy and smelled faintly of campfire.

Before anyone could take a bite, Dez stood up.

"Dad," he said, "I'm sorry about my review. Your rice wasn't a disaster. It was a little mushy. But it was way, way better than this." He pointed at the bowl. "And I didn't know how hard it was. I didn't think about how much you'd worked on it. I just wanted to sound like Montgomery Fitch."

His father looked at him for a moment. Then he reached into his pocket and pulled out a small, folded square of paper. He unfolded it slowly. It was the one-star review.

"I kept it," his father said, "because I wanted to remember to use less water next time. You were right about the mushy part." He smiled. "You were wrong about the disaster part."

Dez laughed, a little shakily, and sat down.

Then everybody ate the jollof rice. Nobody said anything mean about it. Grandma Bisi even had seconds, though Dez was fairly sure she did it to be kind.

The next morning, there were four new reviews taped to the refrigerator.

Mom's said: "The rice was crunchy, but the chef was brave. He also cleaned the ceiling, which nobody asked him to do. FOUR STARS."

Dad's said: "Needs lower heat and more patience. Ask me for my water trick. The apology was the best part of the meal. FIVE STARS."

Tola's said: "Honestly? The worst rice I have ever eaten. But the blender thing was the funniest thing I've ever seen, so I'll give it THREE STARS. P.S. The cat is still mad at you."

And Grandma Bisi's said: "The food was one star. The cook was five stars. Next week, I will teach you with my hands. ONE STAR FOR THE RICE, FIVE STARS FOR THE BOY."

Dez read them all twice. He felt warm all the way down to his toes.

He kept writing reviews after that. But they were different. He learned a new word from Grandma Bisi: "constructive." It meant that criticism should help, not hurt. So now, Dez's reviews always started with one thing he truly liked, gave one honest idea to make the dish better, and ended with a compliment for the cook.

"REVIEW: Meatloaf. Chef: Dad. The outside was crispy and the middle was juicy. It could use a little more pepper. Dad, you are getting really good at this. FOUR STARS."

Dad read that one and laughed. Then he took it down from the fridge, very carefully, and put it in a frame.

It is still hanging in the kitchen today, right next to the scorched pot, which Dad says they are keeping forever, as a reminder that every great cook, and every great critic, has to start somewhere.

Check your understanding

  1. Inference Why had Dad kept the one-star review in his pocket all week?

    1. He wanted to show it to Dez's teacher
    2. He was planning to throw it away later
    3. He wanted to remember the useful advice in it, even though it hurt his feelings
    4. He forgot to take it out of his jacket
  2. Vocabulary Grandma Bisi teaches Dez the word "constructive." Which of these is a constructive review?

    1. "This was the worst pizza ever. Zero stars."
    2. "The crust was crispy. Next time, try a little more sauce."
    3. "I don't want to talk about it."
    4. "Whatever. It was fine."
  3. Key details What do Dez's new reviews always include?

    1. Only the worst part of the meal
    2. A comparison to Montgomery Fitch
    3. Something he liked, one honest idea to improve, and a compliment for the cook
    4. A list of all the ingredients
  4. Theme What is the main lesson of this story?

    1. Food critics should never be honest
    2. Only grown-ups should cook dinner
    3. We can be honest and still be kind, especially when we understand how hard others have worked
    4. Television shows are always a bad influence

Spelling words

These 12 words all appear in the story.

  • critic
  • casserole
  • opinion
  • delicious
  • refrigerator
  • ingredients
  • recipe
  • disaster
  • scorched
  • smoke
  • compliment
  • honestly

Writing prompt

Dez learned that there is a difference between being honest and being unkind. Write a review of a meal, a book, a game, or a movie. Include at least one thing you liked, one thing that could be better, and reasons for each. Then explain how you tried to be both honest and kind.

Reading skills practiced

Vocabulary, Key details, Inference, Character, Cause and effect, Sequence, Main idea, Theme.

Answer key for grown-ups
  1. A person who judges things like food and shares an opinion about them Montgomery Fitch tastes food and gives it a star rating.
  2. The name being wrong was part of the joke, or "surprise" The story says, "That was part of the surprise."
  3. Dez's reviews are starting to hurt Dad's feelings, but Dez hasn't realized it At first Dad laughed, but now something has changed.
  4. She is annoyed and wants him to stop She crumples one up and says nobody asked for his opinion.
  5. Dez's harsh one-star review hurt his feelings after he had worked hard to please Grandma Bisi He had practiced the rice all week to make her feel at home.
  6. He felt a heavy, uncomfortable feeling of guilt The comparison shows how bad he feels after seeing his father's reaction.
  7. She wants Dez to admit that his review exaggerated and was unfair Dez admits, "Not really."
  8. Dad folded the review, put it in his pocket, and went to work He left without saying anything.
  9. Dez discovering how hard it is to cook a meal Every step of the cooking goes wrong, and Dez realizes how much work it is.
  10. Turning the heat up high so the rice would cook faster The high heat scorched the bottom of the pot.
  11. She was worried he might hurt himself while chopping with watery eyes Dez was chopping with his eyes closed.
  12. He understands how his father felt and wants to apologize He remembers his father folding the review and "wanted very badly to apologize."
  13. He wanted to remember the useful advice in it, even though it hurt his feelings He says he wanted to use less water next time.
  14. "The crust was crispy. Next time, try a little more sauce." Constructive criticism helps make something better.
  15. Something he liked, one honest idea to improve, and a compliment for the cook He follows a kinder, more helpful pattern.
  16. We can be honest and still be kind, especially when we understand how hard others have worked Dez learns that criticism should help, not hurt.

More 4th grade stories

🦉

Night Shift at the Animal Hospital

Priya's aunt runs a wildlife hospital, and for one week of summer Priya gets to help on the night shift. She expects cute baby animals. Instead she meets a furious owl,…

4th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeyAnimals · Science16 questions
🦀

The Salt Marsh Mystery

Something is drowning the carrots on Gran Ruth's farm by the sea. The neighbors blame bad luck, and a developer wants to buy the land cheap. Theo and his cousin Wren…

4th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeyFarm · Mystery16 questions
🚁

The Drone Delivery Disaster

In the year 2061, the village of Little Hapton gets its very first delivery drones, and Jun can't wait to program them. But on launch day, the drones start dropping…

4th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeyScience Fiction · Village16 questions
🏃

The Dropped Baton

Lena is the fastest runner at Oakfield School, and she knows it. When she is put on a relay team with three slower kids, she decides to win the district race by…

4th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeySports · Friends16 questions
🛶

The Floating Library

When the only bridge to Reedwater Island washes away in a flood, the island's children are cut off from the town library for the whole summer. Nadia and her grandfather…

4th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeyVillage · Community16 questions
☄️

The Comet Hunters

Ezra and his grandmother Bubbe Miriam share a secret hobby: searching the night sky for undiscovered comets. When Ezra spots a faint smudge that isn't on any star map,…

4th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeyScience · Family16 questions