📚 Reading Quest
☄️

The Comet Hunters

Ezra and his grandmother Bubbe Miriam share a secret hobby: searching the night sky for undiscovered comets. When Ezra spots a faint smudge that isn't on any star map, he has to learn patience, careful checking, and how to handle the moment when the truth turns out to be different from what he hoped.

4th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeyScience · Family1978 wordsAbout 30 minutes

Read it in the app 🚀

In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.

Words to know

comet
a ball of ice and dust that travels around the Sun; when it comes close to the Sun, it can grow a glowing tail
astronomer
a scientist who studies stars, planets, and space
orbit
the curved path an object takes around a star or planet
galaxy
a huge group of billions of stars, like our Milky Way
observatory
a building with telescopes used for studying the sky

Chapter 1: The Smudge Book

Most grandmothers knit or garden. Ezra Cohen's grandmother hunted comets.

Bubbe Miriam lived alone in a small house at the end of a dirt road in the desert, three hours from the nearest city. She said she lived there because the sky was darker there than anywhere else she knew. On a moonless night, the stars were so thick that the Milky Way looked like spilled sugar across the black sky.

On her back porch stood a telescope as tall as Ezra, painted white, with a tube as wide as a dinner plate. Bubbe Miriam had built it herself forty years ago, grinding the mirror by hand over a whole winter.

Ezra stayed with her every summer. And every summer, she taught him a little more.

"A comet," she told him on his first night that year, as they sat on the porch steps waiting for the sky to darken, "is a dirty snowball, left over from when the solar system was born. Most comets live far, far away, out in the cold and dark. But sometimes one gets nudged and starts falling toward the Sun. As it gets closer, the Sun's heat makes the ice turn to gas, and the comet grows a fuzzy glow and a tail."

"And if you find a new one, they name it after you," Ezra said. He knew this part by heart.

"If you are the first to report it, yes." Bubbe Miriam smiled. "I have been looking for forty-one years."

"And you've never found one?"

"Not yet." She didn't sound sad about it. "But I have seen a great many beautiful things while looking."

She handed him a worn black notebook with "SMUDGE BOOK" written on the cover in silver pen.

"Through a telescope, a new comet doesn't look like the pictures in books," she explained. "It looks like a tiny, faint, fuzzy smudge. But many other things look like smudges, too: distant galaxies, clouds of gas, star clusters. Astronomers have already found and mapped thousands of them. So when you see a smudge, you write down exactly where it is, and then you check it against the maps. Almost every time, it is something already known."

"Almost every time," Ezra repeated.

"Almost." Her eyes twinkled.

That night, she showed him how to sweep the telescope slowly across the sky near the horizon, where comets coming toward the Sun often first appear. You moved the telescope a tiny bit, looked carefully, moved it again, looked again. It was slow. It was cold. After an hour, Ezra's neck ached, and he had found three smudges. All three, when they checked the star maps, were galaxies that had been known for over a hundred years.

"Galaxies millions of light-years away," Bubbe Miriam said. "Each one with billions of stars. You saw light tonight that left those stars before there were people on Earth. That is not nothing, Ezra."

Ezra wrote them in the Smudge Book anyway. He had to admit, it was not nothing.

Check your understanding

  1. Key details Why does Bubbe Miriam live at the end of a dirt road in the desert?

    1. Because she doesn't like people
    2. Because houses are cheap there
    3. Because the sky is darker there, which is better for seeing stars
    4. Because she was born there
  2. Vocabulary Based on the story, what is a "comet"?

    1. A shooting star that burns up in the air
    2. A ball of ice and dust that travels around the Sun and can grow a glowing tail
    3. A planet with rings
    4. A kind of telescope
  3. Inference Why does Bubbe Miriam not sound sad that she has never found a comet in forty-one years?

    1. She has given up looking
    2. She doesn't really care about comets
    3. She enjoys the searching itself and all the beautiful things she sees along the way
    4. She is pretending so Ezra won't worry
  4. Main idea What is the main purpose of the Smudge Book?

    1. To draw pictures of the Moon
    2. To record the exact location of every smudge so it can be checked against star maps
    3. To list the names of comets
    4. To write down Ezra's dreams

Chapter 2: Not on the Map

It happened on the ninth night.

It was almost four in the morning. Bubbe Miriam had gone inside to make tea, and Ezra was sweeping the telescope low over the eastern horizon, where the sky was just beginning to turn from black to deep blue.

He moved the telescope a tiny bit. Stars. Moved it again. Stars. Moved it again.

And there it was. A tiny, faint smudge, softer and fuzzier than the stars around it. It looked a little bit like a ball of cotton seen from very far away.

Ezra's heart thumped. He had seen fifty smudges by now. He knew the drill. He carefully read the numbers on the telescope's dials that showed exactly where it was pointing, and wrote them in the Smudge Book with shaking fingers. He drew a little sketch of the smudge and the bright stars around it.

Then he opened the star map on Bubbe Miriam's old laptop and searched for that spot.

Nothing. No galaxy. No cluster. No gas cloud. Just empty sky.

He checked the numbers again. He searched again. Still nothing.

"Bubbe!" he shouted, so loudly that a coyote yipped somewhere in the dark. "BUBBE! Come quick!"

Bubbe Miriam came out with two mugs of tea, took one look at his face, and set them down. She bent over the eyepiece and looked for a long, long time. She didn't say anything. Then she checked his numbers, his sketch, and the map.

"Well," she said quietly. "Well, well."

"Is it a comet? Is it a new comet? Did I find one?" The words tumbled out of Ezra all at once.

Bubbe Miriam straightened up. Her eyes were bright, but her voice was calm and steady.

"It might be," she said. "It is not on the maps. That is a good start. But we are not going to tell anyone yet."

"What? Why not?"

"Because a real scientist," she said, "tries to prove herself wrong before she tells the world she is right."

Ezra stared at her. "Prove myself wrong? But I want to be right!"

"Of course you do. So do I." She put a hand on his shoulder. "But think. What else could this smudge be? Maybe a reflection inside the telescope. Maybe a smudge of dust on the lens. Maybe a comet that someone else already discovered last week, which isn't on this old map yet. Every one of those has happened to astronomers before, including to me."

She looked through the eyepiece one more time.

"A comet moves," she said. "It travels in an orbit around the Sun, so night after night, it slowly drifts across the background of stars. A galaxy or a reflection stays in the same place. So tomorrow night, we look again. If it has moved, we will know much more."

The sky was getting lighter. Soon the smudge faded into the dawn and was gone.

Ezra didn't sleep at all that day. He kept opening the Smudge Book to look at his sketch.

Check your understanding

  1. Sequence What did Ezra do right after he first saw the smudge?

    1. He ran inside to get his grandmother
    2. He reported it to an observatory
    3. He wrote down the telescope's numbers and drew a sketch
    4. He went to bed
  2. Cause and effect Why does Ezra get excited when he checks the star map?

    1. The map shows a famous galaxy at that spot
    2. There is nothing on the map at that spot, so the smudge might be something new
    3. The laptop stops working
    4. The map shows a planet
  3. Inference Why does Bubbe Miriam say she has been fooled by reflections and dust before?

    1. To make Ezra feel bad
    2. Because she has bad eyesight
    3. To show that even experienced astronomers make mistakes, so checking is important
    4. Because her telescope is broken
  4. Key details How will they be able to tell if the smudge is a comet?

    1. It will turn a different color
    2. It will move slowly across the background stars from night to night
    3. It will get brighter every second
    4. It will make a sound

Chapter 3: Three Nights

The next night, Ezra was on the porch before the sun had even finished setting. He paced back and forth. He checked the telescope six times. He asked Bubbe Miriam what time it was so often that she finally hung a clock on the porch railing.

"Patience," she said, "is the most important tool an astronomer has. More important than the telescope."

"I'm being patient," Ezra said, pacing.

At last, a little before four in the morning, the right part of the sky rose above the eastern horizon. Ezra pointed the telescope to the exact numbers he had written down.

The smudge was not there.

His stomach dropped. Had it been a reflection after all?

"Look nearby," Bubbe Miriam said calmly. "If it's a comet, it would have moved."

Ezra moved the telescope very slowly in a small spiral, like his grandmother had taught him. One tiny step. Another. Another.

There. The same soft, fuzzy smudge, just a little way from where it had been the night before.

Ezra let out a whoop. Bubbe Miriam looked, and a slow smile spread across her face. She wrote down the new numbers carefully. Then she took out a ruler and measured the distance between the two positions on her star chart.

"It has moved," she said. "Not a reflection. Not dust. Not a galaxy. Something real, moving through our solar system."

"So it's a comet!"

"It is very likely a comet." She held up one finger. "Now we must check one more thing. Is it a new comet, or one that someone else has already found?"

On the third night, they observed it again. It had moved again, in the same direction, by about the same amount. Now they had three positions. Bubbe Miriam showed Ezra how three positions could be used to estimate the comet's path. They worked on it together at the kitchen table until sunrise, with pencils and graph paper and the old laptop.

Then Bubbe Miriam opened a website run by an international group of astronomers that keeps track of every comet discovery in the world. She typed in their measurements. She pressed Enter.

The screen loaded.

Ezra leaned so close that his nose almost touched the screen.

A line of text appeared: "Possible match: Comet C/2061 P2 (Okonkwo-Lindqvist). Reported 6 days ago."

Ezra read it three times. The room was very quiet.

"Someone already found it," he said. His voice cracked. "Six days ago. Six days."

Check your understanding

  1. Vocabulary What does Bubbe Miriam mean when she says "patience is the most important tool"?

    1. Astronomers need patients in hospitals
    2. Waiting calmly and carefully is more important than any equipment
    3. A tool called a "patience" is used in telescopes
    4. Astronomers should work quickly
  2. Cause and effect Why can't Ezra find the smudge in the same spot on the second night?

    1. It was cloudy
    2. The telescope was broken
    3. It had moved, because comets travel along an orbit
    4. He used the wrong numbers
  3. Inference Why do they need three positions instead of just two?

    1. Because three is a lucky number
    2. Three positions help confirm the direction and estimate the comet's path
    3. Because the website requires exactly three
    4. So they can stay up later
  4. Character How does Ezra feel when he reads the message on the screen?

    1. Relieved
    2. Bored
    3. Deeply disappointed
    4. Angry at his grandmother

Chapter 4: Six Days

Ezra went out to the porch and sat on the steps with his chin in his hands. The sun was coming up over the desert, turning the rocks pink and gold. He didn't feel like looking at it.

After a while, Bubbe Miriam came out with two fresh mugs of tea and sat down beside him. She didn't say anything for a long time. They just watched the light spread across the sand.

"Six days," Ezra said finally. "If I'd been looking at that part of the sky a week earlier, it would have had my name on it."

"Yes," said Bubbe Miriam. "That's true."

He had expected her to say something comforting, like "You'll find another one." But she just sipped her tea.

"Does it make you sad?" he asked. "Forty-one years and nothing?"

She thought about it. "When I was young, it did. I thought finding a comet was the only thing that mattered. Then one night, after about ten years of looking, I realized something." She turned the mug in her hands. "I had seen thousands of galaxies. I had watched a star explode in a far-off galaxy. I had seen Saturn's rings with my own eyes and the Moon pass in front of Jupiter. I had learned how to build a telescope, how to measure the sky, how to be patient, and how to check my own work. I had become, without noticing, an astronomer."

She looked at him. "Ezra, think about what you did this week. You found a faint object that most people would never notice. You recorded it correctly. You checked it against the maps. You proved it wasn't a reflection or a galaxy. You measured its motion over three nights and helped calculate its path. That is exactly what the two astronomers who discovered it did. You did real science. The only difference is six days."

Ezra was quiet. He thought about the smudge, drifting slowly through the stars, a dirty snowball falling toward the Sun for the first time in maybe a million years. And he had seen it. He had followed it. He had understood it.

"Can I still report our measurements?" he asked slowly. "Would that help anyone?"

Bubbe Miriam smiled widely. "It would. Every measurement from a different place on Earth helps astronomers figure out the comet's orbit more exactly. Your observations would become part of the official record."

That morning, they submitted their three measurements. A week later, an email arrived from the international comet center. It said: "Thank you for your observations of C/2061 P2. Your positions were accurate and have been included in the updated orbit calculation." At the bottom was a list of observers from around the world. Near the end, it said: "M. Cohen and E. Cohen, private observatory, desert, USA."

Ezra printed it out and taped it inside the cover of the Smudge Book.

On his last night of the summer, he and Bubbe Miriam watched the comet together one more time. It had grown brighter, and now, if you looked carefully, you could see a faint, wispy tail stretching away from the Sun.

"Will you keep looking?" Ezra asked. "For your own comet?"

"Of course," said Bubbe Miriam. "And so will you, I think."

Ezra opened the Smudge Book to a fresh page and pointed the telescope toward the eastern horizon.

"Yes," he said. "I think I will."

Check your understanding

  1. Key details What did Ezra and his grandmother do with their measurements?

    1. They threw them away
    2. They kept them secret
    3. They submitted them to the international comet center to help calculate the orbit
    4. They sent them to the newspaper
  2. Character What does Bubbe Miriam realize after about ten years of looking for comets?

    1. That she should give up
    2. That she had become a real astronomer and learned and seen many wonderful things along the way
    3. That her telescope was too small
    4. That comets don't exist
  3. Inference Why does Ezra tape the email inside the cover of the Smudge Book?

    1. So he won't lose the comet's name
    2. Because he is proud that his careful work became part of real science
    3. Because his grandmother told him to
    4. To prove he was the discoverer
  4. Theme Which sentence best describes a theme of this story?

    1. Only the first person to discover something matters
    2. Science is too difficult for children
    3. The journey of learning and careful work can matter as much as winning a prize
    4. Comets are dangerous

Spelling words

These 12 words all appear in the story.

  • telescope
  • comet
  • astronomer
  • orbit
  • observations
  • patient
  • discovery
  • galaxy
  • reflection
  • notebook
  • horizon
  • calculate

Writing prompt

Ezra's grandmother says that scientists must "try to prove themselves wrong." What do you think she means? Explain why this is a good habit, and describe a time when checking your work carefully would help you.

Reading skills practiced

Key details, Vocabulary, Inference, Main idea, Sequence, Cause and effect, Character, Theme.

Answer key for grown-ups
  1. Because the sky is darker there, which is better for seeing stars She says the sky is darker there than anywhere else she knows.
  2. A ball of ice and dust that travels around the Sun and can grow a glowing tail Bubbe Miriam calls it "a dirty snowball."
  3. She enjoys the searching itself and all the beautiful things she sees along the way She says she has seen many beautiful things while looking.
  4. To record the exact location of every smudge so it can be checked against star maps Every smudge is written down and checked to see if it is already known.
  5. He wrote down the telescope's numbers and drew a sketch He knew the drill: record the location carefully first.
  6. There is nothing on the map at that spot, so the smudge might be something new The empty spot on the map means the smudge isn't a known object.
  7. To show that even experienced astronomers make mistakes, so checking is important Sharing her own mistakes explains why she wants to wait before telling anyone.
  8. It will move slowly across the background stars from night to night A comet travels in an orbit, so it drifts, while galaxies stay in place.
  9. Waiting calmly and carefully is more important than any equipment Comet hunting requires waiting night after night.
  10. It had moved, because comets travel along an orbit He finds it a little way from where it was the night before.
  11. Three positions help confirm the direction and estimate the comet's path Three points show it moves steadily in the same direction.
  12. Deeply disappointed His voice cracks as he realizes someone found it six days earlier.
  13. They submitted them to the international comet center to help calculate the orbit Their positions were included in the updated orbit calculation.
  14. That she had become a real astronomer and learned and seen many wonderful things along the way She lists all she had seen and learned while searching.
  15. Because he is proud that his careful work became part of real science Even without his name on the comet, his observations counted.
  16. The journey of learning and careful work can matter as much as winning a prize Ezra learns that doing real science was valuable even though he wasn't first.

More 4th grade stories

🦉

Night Shift at the Animal Hospital

Priya's aunt runs a wildlife hospital, and for one week of summer Priya gets to help on the night shift. She expects cute baby animals. Instead she meets a furious owl,…

4th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeyAnimals · Science16 questions
🦀

The Salt Marsh Mystery

Something is drowning the carrots on Gran Ruth's farm by the sea. The neighbors blame bad luck, and a developer wants to buy the land cheap. Theo and his cousin Wren…

4th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeyFarm · Mystery16 questions
🚁

The Drone Delivery Disaster

In the year 2061, the village of Little Hapton gets its very first delivery drones, and Jun can't wait to program them. But on launch day, the drones start dropping…

4th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeyScience Fiction · Village16 questions
🏃

The Dropped Baton

Lena is the fastest runner at Oakfield School, and she knows it. When she is put on a relay team with three slower kids, she decides to win the district race by…

4th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeySports · Friends16 questions
🛶

The Floating Library

When the only bridge to Reedwater Island washes away in a flood, the island's children are cut off from the town library for the whole summer. Nadia and her grandfather…

4th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeyVillage · Community16 questions
🏺

The Glassblower's Apprentice

In a canal town five hundred years ago, twelve-year-old Pietro is apprenticed to the grumpiest glassblower on the island. He sweeps floors, carries sand, and is never…

4th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeyHistory · Village16 questions