📚 Reading Quest
🐖

Clementine Will Not Walk

Caleb has six weeks to train his pig, Clementine, for the county fair livestock show. There is just one problem. Clementine is smart, stubborn, and absolutely refuses to walk anywhere she doesn't want to go. With the fair's star showman living right next door, Caleb is about to learn that winning isn't always about the ribbon.

4th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeyFarm Animals · Sports2212 wordsAbout 30 minutes

Read it in the app 🚀

In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.

Words to know

gilt
a young female pig
showmanship
in a livestock show, how well a person handles, guides, and presents an animal
herdsman
a person who cares for farm animals; at fairs, an award for taking the best care of animals
livestock
farm animals such as pigs, cattle, sheep, and goats
overheat
to become dangerously hot

Chapter 1: The Pig with Opinions

Caleb Nakamura had known from the first day that Clementine was going to be trouble. Stubborn trouble.

She was a Hampshire gilt, black all over except for a wide white stripe around her shoulders, like a belt that had slipped. When Caleb picked her out at the farm sale in March, she had been the only piglet in the pen that didn't run away from him. Instead, she had trotted right up, sniffed his shoelaces thoroughly, and then untied one of them with her snout.

"That one," Caleb had said. "She's smart."

"Smart," said his grandmother, who had raised pigs for forty years, "is not always the same as easy."

Now it was June, and the county fair was six weeks away. Clementine weighed almost two hundred pounds. And she had opinions about everything.

She had an opinion about her water bowl, which was that it should be tipped over. She had an opinion about the gate latch, which was that she should be able to open it, and she often could. She had a very strong opinion about mud, which was that there should be more of it, and that she should be in it at all times.

That last one, at least, made sense. Grandma Mae had explained that pigs can't sweat like people do. On hot days, they cool off by lying in mud or water. A pig in the summer sun with no shade and no mud could overheat dangerously fast.

But Clementine's strongest opinion of all was about walking. Specifically, she did not want to do it unless it was her own idea.

This was a problem, because walking was the whole point of the show.

At the county fair, young people from all over the county brought pigs they had raised to the show ring. Each kid carried a thin stick called a show cane. They used it to guide their pig gently around the ring with light taps on the shoulder or side, keeping the animal moving calmly so the judges could see it from every angle. The judges looked at the pig's health and how it moved. And in the showmanship class, they also looked at the kid: how calm they stayed, how well they controlled the pig, and how well they knew their animal.

Caleb had watched the show every summer since he was five. This year, at ten, he was finally old enough to enter.

On the first day of practice, Caleb opened the pen, held out his cane, and gave Clementine a gentle tap on her left shoulder, the signal to turn right.

Clementine looked at him. Then she lay down in the dirt.

Caleb tapped again. Clementine closed her eyes.

He pushed. He pulled. He tried calling her name in his most encouraging voice. Clementine sighed deeply, the sigh of a pig who has been asked to do something very unreasonable, and rolled onto her side.

From across the fence came the sound of someone trying not to laugh.

Caleb turned around. Abby Larsen was leaning on the fence between their two farms, holding the lead rope of a perfect, gleaming, spotted pig.

Abby was twelve. She had won the grand championship in showmanship two years in a row. Her pig walked beside her like a well-trained dog.

"Having trouble?" she asked.

"No," said Caleb.

Clementine snored.

Check your understanding

  1. Key details Why do pigs need mud or water on hot days?

    1. Mud keeps flies away from their food
    2. Pigs can't sweat like people, so they cool off by lying in mud or water
    3. Mud makes their skin shiny for the show
    4. Pigs need to drink muddy water to stay healthy
  2. Vocabulary What does Grandma Mae mean when she says "Smart is not always the same as easy"?

    1. A clever animal may have its own ideas and be harder to control
    2. Smart pigs are easy to train
    3. Caleb should choose a less intelligent pig
    4. Pigs are not very smart
  3. Inference Why does Caleb say "No" when Abby asks if he is having trouble?

    1. He really isn't having any trouble
    2. He is embarrassed and doesn't want the champion to see him struggling
    3. He didn't hear her question
    4. He thinks Abby is asking about something else
  4. Character What can you tell about Clementine from this chapter?

    1. She is shy and afraid of people
    2. She is lazy and never moves at all
    3. She is curious, clever, and stubborn
    4. She is the fastest pig in the county

Chapter 2: Marshmallows and Mistakes

For the next week, things did not get better.

Caleb tried practicing early in the morning, before the heat. Clementine slept through it. He tried practicing in the evening. Clementine wandered off to the mud wallow, and Caleb spent twenty minutes trying to get her out, until he was as muddy as she was.

His older cousin Derek, who was visiting for the summer, suggested pushing her from behind with a board. Caleb tried it. Clementine sat down on the board.

At dinner on the eighth night, Caleb poked at his food. "Maybe I should just skip the fair this year," he said. "She's never going to walk."

Grandma Mae put down her fork. "How long have you been asking Clementine to do things your way?"

"A week," said Caleb.

"And how long have you spent learning to do things her way?"

Caleb didn't understand the question.

The next morning, Grandma Mae came out to the pen with him. She didn't bring a cane. She brought a folding chair and a bag of mini marshmallows.

"Sit," she said. "Watch her. Don't ask her to do anything. Just watch."

So Caleb sat, feeling silly, and watched his pig.

He noticed things he had never noticed before. Clementine always went to the same corner first thing in the morning, the one where the sun came over the barn roof. She flicked her ears back when a truck drove by on the road, and she stopped whatever she was doing until it passed. When he moved suddenly, she flinched. But when he moved slowly, she ignored him. And whenever anyone opened the feed bin, from anywhere in the barnyard, her head shot up and her nose began to twitch.

"Pigs have a sense of smell better than a dog's," Grandma Mae said. "Farmers have trained pigs to sniff out mushrooms hidden underground. She knows what's in that bag in your hand already."

Sure enough, Clementine was staring at the marshmallows.

"Now," said Grandma Mae. "Hold one out. Not too close. Let her come to you."

Caleb held out a marshmallow. Clementine considered it. Then she heaved herself up, walked three steps, and took it delicately from his fingers.

"Again," said Grandma Mae. "A little farther this time. And when she comes, tap her shoulder with the cane at the same time. Gently. So she learns that the tap means something good is coming."

It was slow. Some days Clementine would walk ten steps, and some days only two. Some days she was too hot and grumpy to try at all, and on those days, Grandma Mae told Caleb to hose her down and let her rest in the shade instead.

"You can't force a pig," she said. "But if you're patient, you can make her want to."

Little by little, Clementine began to follow the cane. A tap on the left shoulder meant turn right, and a marshmallow. A tap on the right meant turn left, and a marshmallow. Soon Caleb could guide her in a slow circle around the pen.

Abby watched from across the fence sometimes. One evening, she called over, "You're holding the cane too high. Keep it low, near her shoulder, so she can see it out of the corner of her eye."

Caleb tried it. Clementine turned more smoothly.

"Thanks," he said, surprised.

Abby shrugged. "The judges watch your hands, too," she said, and walked back to her barn.

Check your understanding

  1. Cause and effect Why does Grandma Mae tell Caleb to sit and just watch Clementine?

    1. So Caleb can rest after a hard week
    2. So he can learn how Clementine behaves and what she likes before trying to train her
    3. Because Clementine is sick
    4. So Caleb can count how many marshmallows she eats
  2. Sequence What did Caleb try right after practicing early in the morning didn't work?

    1. Pushing her with a board
    2. Practicing in the evening
    3. Using marshmallows
    4. Watching her from a chair
  3. Inference What does Grandma Mae mean by "You can't force a pig. But if you're patient, you can make her want to"?

    1. Pigs will only walk if they are hungry
    2. Caleb should give up and choose a new pig
    3. Patient training with rewards works better than pushing an animal to obey
    4. Pigs are too stubborn to ever be trained
  4. Character Why might Abby's help be surprising to Caleb?

    1. Abby has never shown a pig before
    2. She is his main competition and had laughed at him earlier
    3. Abby is afraid of pigs
    4. Abby doesn't live nearby

Chapter 3: The Hottest Day

The county fair opened on the hottest week of the summer.

By the morning of the swine show, the thermometer on the livestock barn showed a temperature of ninety-four degrees, and it was only ten o'clock. The air under the barn roof was thick with the smells of hay, sawdust, and two hundred animals. Big fans roared at the end of every aisle, and kids were constantly running back and forth with buckets of water and spray bottles.

Caleb had washed Clementine until her black coat gleamed. He had practiced every single day for five weeks. His show shirt was buttoned all the way up, and his number, 37, was pinned to his back.

He was so nervous he thought he might be sick.

"Remember," Grandma Mae said, straightening his collar. "Slow hands. Keep your eyes on the judge, and keep your pig between you and the judge. And take care of her. That's your first job."

Abby came by on her way to the ring. Her spotted pig was named Duchess, and she trotted beside Abby as calmly as if she were out for an afternoon stroll.

"Good luck," Abby said. Then she paused. "It's really hot in that ring. There's no fan in the middle. Watch her breathing."

"Okay," said Caleb, though he wasn't sure what she meant.

When his class was called, Caleb led Clementine into the show ring with eight other kids and their pigs. The ring was a big square of sawdust surrounded by metal panels and bleachers full of people. The judge, a tall woman in a straw hat, stood in the middle with a clipboard.

At first, everything went perfectly. Clementine walked. She followed the cane. A tap on the left shoulder, and she turned right. A tap on the right, and she turned left. Caleb kept his cane low and his eyes on the judge, just like he'd practiced. He saw the judge glance at Clementine, and then at him, and nod.

Caleb's heart soared. They were doing it.

Then, after four minutes, Clementine slowed down.

After five minutes, she stopped. Caleb tapped her shoulder. She took two steps and stopped again. Her sides were heaving. She was breathing fast and hard, through her open mouth, and she was swaying a little on her feet.

Caleb remembered Abby's words. Watch her breathing.

Across the ring, the other pigs were still moving. The judge was still watching. If he could just get Clementine around one more time, she might place in the top three. He might win a ribbon.

He looked down at his pig. Clementine looked back up at him with small, tired eyes.

Check your understanding

  1. Key details What advice does Grandma Mae say is Caleb's "first job"?

    1. Winning a ribbon
    2. Smiling at the crowd
    3. Taking care of Clementine
    4. Keeping his shirt clean
  2. Inference Why does Abby warn Caleb to "watch her breathing"?

    1. She wants to distract him so he will lose
    2. She knows the ring is very hot and that pigs can overheat, and fast breathing is a warning sign
    3. She thinks Clementine has a cold
    4. She wants Caleb to count Clementine's breaths for the judge
  3. Main idea What is the main problem at the end of this chapter?

    1. The judge doesn't like Clementine
    2. Caleb forgets how to use the cane
    3. Clementine is overheating, and Caleb must choose between his pig's health and his chance at a ribbon
    4. Abby's pig runs away
  4. Vocabulary "Caleb's heart soared." What does this phrase mean?

    1. His heart was beating too fast because he was sick
    2. He jumped high into the air
    3. He felt a rush of joy and excitement
    4. He was frightened

Chapter 4: The Other Ribbon

Caleb made his choice.

He raised his hand to signal the ring steward, the way Grandma Mae had taught him to do in an emergency. Then he guided Clementine, slowly and gently, out of the line of pigs and toward the gate.

"Number 37 is leaving the ring?" the judge asked.

"She's too hot," Caleb said. His voice shook, but he said it loudly enough to be heard. "I think she's overheating."

The judge looked at Clementine for a moment. Then she nodded. "Go," she said.

Outside the ring, Grandma Mae was already waiting with a bucket and a hose. Abby was there too, holding a wet towel. Together, they led Clementine into the shade under the big fan and sprayed her with cool water, starting at her legs and belly, the way you should with an overheated pig. Not ice-cold water, which can shock their bodies, but cool, steady water.

Caleb knelt beside her, holding the hose, his good show shirt soaking wet. He watched her sides go up and down, up and down. Slowly, very slowly, her breathing slowed. After ten minutes, she closed her mouth. After fifteen, she grunted and flopped over onto her side in the wet sawdust, as if to say that this was a much better idea than walking around in the hot sun.

Caleb let out a breath he hadn't known he was holding. He realized his hands were shaking.

"You did right," said Grandma Mae, putting her hand on his shoulder. "That was a hard thing to do, with everybody watching."

"I didn't even finish," Caleb said. "We could have won something."

"You might have," said his grandmother. "And you might have had a very sick pig. A ribbon doesn't fix that."

Through the fence, Caleb could hear the announcer calling the winners of his class. He didn't listen. He just sat with Clementine, scratching behind her ears, and she grunted softly every time he stopped.

Abby won the grand championship in showmanship for the third year in a row. When she came back to the barn with her purple ribbon, she didn't show it off. Instead, she crouched down next to Caleb and Clementine.

"When I was nine, my first pig overheated in the ring," she said quietly. "I didn't notice in time. I kept going because I wanted to win. She got really sick, and it took her days to get better." Abby looked at the ribbon in her hand. "I noticed you noticing. That's the most important part."

Caleb stared at her. He suddenly understood why she had been watching him all summer, and why she had given him advice over the fence.

On the last day of the fair, the awards were announced in the show barn. Caleb wasn't expecting anything. He was busy refilling Clementine's water bowl, which she immediately tipped over.

Then the announcer read out, "The Herdsman Award for outstanding animal care goes to Caleb Nakamura."

Caleb stood frozen with the empty bowl in his hands. The judge in the straw hat was standing by the microphone. She caught his eye and smiled.

"Any showman can win a ribbon on a cool day," she told the crowd. "But a real stockman knows when to stop. We saw a young man put his animal first on the hottest day of the year. That's what this award is for."

The ribbon was green and white, not purple. But Caleb thought it was the most beautiful ribbon in the whole barn.

Clementine didn't go to market after the fair. Grandma Mae said a pig that smart deserved to stay on the farm, and that someday she might raise piglets of her own. Caleb hung the green ribbon on the gate of her pen, where she could see it.

She untied it with her snout by the next morning.

Check your understanding

  1. Cause and effect Why did Caleb lead Clementine out of the ring?

    1. The judge told him to leave
    2. Clementine ran away from him
    3. He saw she was overheating and decided her health mattered more than winning
    4. He was too nervous to keep going
  2. Key details How did they cool Clementine down safely?

    1. They put her in a tub of ice water
    2. They moved her into the shade under a fan and sprayed her with cool water, starting at her legs and belly
    3. They gave her a cold drink of soda
    4. They walked her around the barn quickly
  3. Inference Why had Abby been helping Caleb all summer?

    1. She wanted him to beat her in the show
    2. Grandma Mae paid her to help
    3. She had made a painful mistake with her own pig and wanted to help him avoid it
    4. She wanted to buy Clementine
  4. Theme What is the most important lesson of this story?

    1. Winning a ribbon is the only goal of a livestock show
    2. Caring for others, even when it costs you something, matters more than winning
    3. Pigs are too stubborn to show at fairs
    4. You should never take advice from your competition

Spelling words

These 12 words all appear in the story.

  • stubborn
  • county
  • judges
  • shade
  • nervous
  • patient
  • marshmallow
  • ribbon
  • temperature
  • gentle
  • championship
  • practiced

Writing prompt

In the show ring, Caleb chose to take care of Clementine instead of trying to win. Was that the right choice? Explain your opinion with at least two reasons from the story. Then describe what you might have done in his place.

Reading skills practiced

Key details, Vocabulary, Inference, Character, Cause and effect, Sequence, Main idea, Theme.

Answer key for grown-ups
  1. Pigs can't sweat like people, so they cool off by lying in mud or water Without shade and mud, a pig can overheat.
  2. A clever animal may have its own ideas and be harder to control Clementine's cleverness makes her stubborn.
  3. He is embarrassed and doesn't want the champion to see him struggling Clementine is clearly refusing to walk, but he won't admit it.
  4. She is curious, clever, and stubborn She unties shoelaces, opens gates, and walks only when it's her idea.
  5. So he can learn how Clementine behaves and what she likes before trying to train her She asks how long he has spent learning to do things Clementine's way.
  6. Practicing in the evening Clementine wandered to the mud wallow in the evening.
  7. Patient training with rewards works better than pushing an animal to obey She uses marshmallows and gentle taps to make walking something good.
  8. She is his main competition and had laughed at him earlier He says "Thanks" in surprise because she is the champion.
  9. Taking care of Clementine She reminds him before he enters the ring.
  10. She knows the ring is very hot and that pigs can overheat, and fast breathing is a warning sign She mentions there is no fan in the middle of the ring.
  11. Clementine is overheating, and Caleb must choose between his pig's health and his chance at a ribbon Clementine is breathing hard and swaying while Caleb hopes to win.
  12. He felt a rush of joy and excitement Things were going well, and he felt thrilled.
  13. He saw she was overheating and decided her health mattered more than winning He tells the judge, "I think she's overheating."
  14. They moved her into the shade under a fan and sprayed her with cool water, starting at her legs and belly Ice-cold water can shock a pig's body, so they used cool water.
  15. She had made a painful mistake with her own pig and wanted to help him avoid it She tells him about her first pig getting sick.
  16. Caring for others, even when it costs you something, matters more than winning Caleb gives up his chance at a ribbon to protect Clementine and is honored for it.

More 4th grade stories

🦉

Night Shift at the Animal Hospital

Priya's aunt runs a wildlife hospital, and for one week of summer Priya gets to help on the night shift. She expects cute baby animals. Instead she meets a furious owl,…

4th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeyAnimals · Science16 questions
🦀

The Salt Marsh Mystery

Something is drowning the carrots on Gran Ruth's farm by the sea. The neighbors blame bad luck, and a developer wants to buy the land cheap. Theo and his cousin Wren…

4th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeyFarm · Mystery16 questions
🚁

The Drone Delivery Disaster

In the year 2061, the village of Little Hapton gets its very first delivery drones, and Jun can't wait to program them. But on launch day, the drones start dropping…

4th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeyScience Fiction · Village16 questions
🏃

The Dropped Baton

Lena is the fastest runner at Oakfield School, and she knows it. When she is put on a relay team with three slower kids, she decides to win the district race by…

4th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeySports · Friends16 questions
🛶

The Floating Library

When the only bridge to Reedwater Island washes away in a flood, the island's children are cut off from the town library for the whole summer. Nadia and her grandfather…

4th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeyVillage · Community16 questions
☄️

The Comet Hunters

Ezra and his grandmother Bubbe Miriam share a secret hobby: searching the night sky for undiscovered comets. When Ezra spots a faint smudge that isn't on any star map,…

4th gradeLevel 3 · Mighty MonkeyScience · Family16 questions