📚 Reading Quest
🧪

The Great Science Fair Mix-Up

Zara and Ben are the most competitive kids in Room 12. When their teacher makes them partners for the science fair, they cannot agree on anything. Then their experiment goes wrong in a way nobody expected.

3rd gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxSchool · Science1301 wordsAbout 30 minutes

Read it in the app 🚀

In the app, kids can hear the story read aloud, answer the questions one at a time, practice spelling, and earn stars. Free, no download.

Words to know

competitive
always wanting to win or be the best
hypothesis
a smart guess you can test with an experiment
variable
the one thing you change in an experiment
data
facts and numbers collected to learn something
conclusion
what you decide after looking at the results
collaborate
to work together toward the same goal

Chapter 1: The Worst Partners Ever

Zara Hassan and Ben Kowalski had been rivals since the first day of third grade, when they both reached for the last purple crayon at the same time. Now they were in fourth grade, and nothing had changed.

If Zara read twelve books in a month, Ben read thirteen. If Ben ran the mile in eight minutes, Zara ran it in seven minutes and fifty-nine seconds. They were the two most competitive kids in Room 12, and everyone knew it.

So when Mr. Abara announced the science fair partners, the whole class held its breath.

"Zara Hassan," he read from his list, "you will be working with... Ben Kowalski."

Zara's mouth fell open. Ben slid down in his chair until only his eyes showed above the desk.

"Mr. Abara," said Zara, raising her hand, "I think there's been a mistake."

"No mistake," said Mr. Abara cheerfully. "Real scientists have to work with all kinds of people. Your project is due in three weeks. It should answer a question using the scientific method. That means a question, a hypothesis, an experiment, data, and a conclusion."

At lunch, Zara and Ben sat across from each other with their arms crossed.

"We should do a volcano," said Ben. "Baking soda and vinegar. It explodes. Everyone loves it."

"Everyone does a volcano," said Zara. "That's not a question. That's just a mess. We should test whether music helps plants grow."

"Plants?" said Ben. "Plants are boring. They just sit there."

"Volcanoes are babyish."

"Plants are for grandmas."

They glared at each other. Their friend Kenji, who was sitting next to them, quietly picked up his tray and moved to another table.

Check your understanding

  1. Vocabulary Zara and Ben are "the two most competitive kids in Room 12." What does competitive mean?

    1. Very shy and quiet
    2. Always wanting to win or be the best
    3. Good at sharing
    4. Bad at school
  2. Key details What happened on their first day of third grade?

    1. They became best friends
    2. They both reached for the last purple crayon
    3. They got lost on the way to class
    4. They won a science prize
  3. Key details Which is NOT one of the parts of the scientific method that Mr. Abara lists?

    1. A hypothesis
    2. Data
    3. A poster with glitter
    4. A conclusion
  4. Inference Why did Kenji pick up his tray and move to another table?

    1. Zara and Ben's arguing was uncomfortable to sit near
    2. He finished his lunch
    3. He wanted to sit by the window
    4. Mr. Abara called him

Chapter 2: A Compromise

For three days, Zara and Ben argued. They argued in the hallway. They argued at recess. They argued so loudly in the library that Ms. Kim made them sit at separate tables.

On the fourth day, Mr. Abara asked them to stay in at recess.

"I hear the project is going... loudly," he said. "Let me ask you each a question. Ben, why do you want to do a volcano?"

Ben shrugged. "Because it does something. Things happen. It's exciting."

"Zara, why do you want to do plants?"

"Because it's a real experiment," said Zara. "You change one thing and see what happens. That's what science is."

Mr. Abara smiled. "So Ben wants something exciting that reacts, and Zara wants a real experiment with one variable. Is there a project that is both?"

Zara and Ben looked at each other. It was the first time all week they had looked at each other without glaring.

"What if," Ben said slowly, "we used the volcano stuff on plants?"

Zara frowned. Then her eyes widened. "Vinegar is an acid. Baking soda is a base. Some plants like acidic soil, and some don't. We could water plants with different liquids and see which ones grow best!"

"Plain water, vinegar water, and baking soda water," said Ben. "Three groups."

"The variable is the kind of water," said Zara. "Everything else stays the same: same plants, same soil, same sunlight, same amount of water."

"And we measure them every day," said Ben. "With a ruler. And make a graph."

They stopped. They had just agreed on something. It felt strange, like putting on someone else's shoes.

"I think," said Mr. Abara, "you just found a compromise."

Check your understanding

  1. Main idea What is the main idea of this chapter?

    1. Ben and Zara get in trouble at recess
    2. Ben and Zara find a project idea that combines what they both want
    3. Mr. Abara chooses the project for them
    4. Zara decides to do a volcano after all
  2. Vocabulary Zara says "the variable is the kind of water." What is a variable?

    1. The plant that grows tallest
    2. The one thing you change in an experiment
    3. The ruler you use to measure
    4. The final answer
  3. Cause and effect What helped Zara and Ben finally agree?

    1. Mr. Abara asked each of them WHY they wanted their idea
    2. They flipped a coin
    3. Kenji made the choice
    4. They both got tired of arguing
  4. Inference Agreeing "felt strange, like putting on someone else's shoes." What does this mean?

    1. Their feet hurt
    2. Agreeing with each other was unfamiliar and new to them
    3. They traded shoes
    4. They were about to run a race

Chapter 3: Something Is Wrong

Ben's mom drove them to the garden store, where they bought nine small bean plants that were all the same size. They put them in nine identical cups with the same soil. Three cups got a label that said WATER. Three said VINEGAR. Three said BAKING SODA.

Ben's hypothesis was that the baking soda plants would grow the tallest. "Because baking soda is in cake, and cake makes things grow," he said. Zara pointed out that was not how it worked, but she let him write it down. Her hypothesis was that the plain water plants would grow the best.

Every day after school, they measured each plant with a ruler and wrote the data in a notebook. Zara wrote the numbers. Ben drew pictures of each plant. They even started to have fun.

By the end of the first week, something was wrong.

The vinegar plants were turning yellow and drooping. That made sense. Too much acid could hurt them. But the plain water plants were drooping too. And the baking soda plants were the healthiest ones of all.

"That doesn't make sense," said Zara, staring at the notebook. "Plain water should be the best."

"Maybe my hypothesis was right!" said Ben. "Cake power!"

"It's not cake power," said Zara. She frowned and looked at the cups. They were lined up on the windowsill in Ben's kitchen. Then she looked at the window.

"Ben," she said. "Which cups are closest to the heater?"

Ben looked. Right under the windowsill was a big metal heater. The WATER cups and the VINEGAR cups were at the end closest to it. The BAKING SODA cups were at the far end, near a shady corner.

"Oh no," said Ben.

"The heater is drying them out," said Zara. "We didn't keep everything the same. The plants didn't get the same temperature. Our experiment is ruined."

The science fair was in eight days. There was no time to start over.

Check your understanding

  1. Key details What was Ben's hypothesis?

    1. The vinegar plants would grow tallest
    2. The baking soda plants would grow tallest
    3. None of the plants would grow
    4. All the plants would grow the same
  2. Character How have Ben and Zara changed in this chapter?

    1. They are arguing even more
    2. They are working together and even having fun
    3. They stopped doing the project
    4. They each have their own experiment now
  3. Cause and effect Why were the water and vinegar plants drooping?

    1. The plants were the wrong kind
    2. Ben forgot to water them
    3. They were closest to the heater, which dried them out
    4. The baking soda made them sick
  4. Inference Why does Zara say the experiment is "ruined"?

    1. They did not keep everything the same, so the results are not fair
    2. The plants were all dead
    3. Ben spilled the soil
    4. The notebook was lost

Chapter 4: The Best Mistake

That night, Zara could not sleep. She kept thinking about the ruined experiment. They were going to fail. Worse, they were going to fail together.

The next morning, Ben was waiting for her at the school gate. He was holding his notebook with all his plant drawings, and he looked excited.

"I have an idea," he said. "What if we don't hide the mistake? What if the mistake IS the project?"

Zara stared at him. "What do you mean?"

"We found out something real," said Ben. "We found out that heat matters even more than the kind of water. That's a discovery. We just didn't mean to discover it."

Zara thought about it. Slowly, she began to smile. "Real scientists do that," she said. "They write about what went wrong. It helps other scientists not make the same mistake."

They spent the next week working harder than ever. They set up a NEW small test with six plants: three near the heater and three far away, all watered with plain water. Within a few days, the heater plants started drooping and the others stayed green. It proved their idea.

On their poster, they wrote the title in big letters: THE GREAT SCIENCE FAIR MIX-UP: WHAT OUR FAILED EXPERIMENT TAUGHT US. They showed their first experiment, their data, and their graph. They drew a big red arrow pointing to the heater. Then they showed their second test. At the bottom, under CONCLUSION, Zara wrote: "In a fair test, you must keep everything the same except one variable. We learned this the hard way. Temperature affected our plants more than the type of water."

On the day of the fair, the judges stopped at their table for a long time. One judge, a scientist from the university, laughed out loud when she read the title.

"Do you know how many of my own experiments have failed?" she said. "Hundreds. This is what real science looks like."

Zara and Ben did not win first place. A girl named Sophie won for building a water filter out of sand and charcoal. Zara and Ben won second place and a special ribbon that said BEST SCIENTIFIC THINKING.

Walking out of the gym, Ben held up the ribbon. "So," he said. "Who gets to keep it?"

Zara grinned. "We could cut it in half."

"Or," said Ben, "we could do another experiment next year and win two."

They shook hands on it. In Room 12, the war of the purple crayon was finally over.

Check your understanding

  1. Key details What was Ben's new idea?

    1. To start a totally new volcano project
    2. To give up and not go to the fair
    3. To make the mistake the main part of their project
    4. To hide the dead plants
  2. Key details What did their second test prove?

    1. Plants near the heater drooped, while plants far away stayed green
    2. Vinegar is good for plants
    3. Baking soda makes plants grow tall
    4. Plants grow better in the dark
  3. Vocabulary Under CONCLUSION, Zara wrote what they learned. What is a conclusion?

    1. The first step of an experiment
    2. A list of materials
    3. What you decide after looking at the results
    4. A guess before you start
  4. Inference Why did the judge from the university laugh when she read the title?

    1. She thought the poster was silly and bad
    2. She recognized that real scientists have failed experiments too
    3. She did not understand it
    4. She was laughing at a joke from another table
  5. Theme What is the MOST important message of the story?

    1. Volcano projects are the best
    2. Competition is always bad
    3. Mistakes can lead to learning, and working together makes us stronger
    4. Never put plants near a heater

Spelling words

These 12 words all appear in the story.

  • science
  • experiment
  • partners
  • hypothesis
  • variable
  • measure
  • plants
  • conclusion
  • competitive
  • volcano
  • vinegar
  • discovery

Writing prompt

Zara and Ben learned that a failed experiment can still teach you something. Describe an experiment you would like to try. What is your question, and what do you predict will happen?

Reading skills practiced

Vocabulary, Key details, Inference, Main idea, Cause and effect, Character, Theme.

Answer key for grown-ups
  1. Always wanting to win or be the best The examples show it: each always tries to beat the other, by one book or one second.
  2. They both reached for the last purple crayon Their rivalry started when they both reached for the last purple crayon.
  3. A poster with glitter Mr. Abara lists a question, a hypothesis, an experiment, data, and a conclusion.
  4. Zara and Ben's arguing was uncomfortable to sit near Zara and Ben were glaring and trading insults, so Kenji got away from the arguing.
  5. Ben and Zara find a project idea that combines what they both want They combine Ben's exciting chemicals with Zara's real experiment and find a compromise.
  6. The one thing you change in an experiment A variable is the one thing you change. Everything else stays the same.
  7. Mr. Abara asked each of them WHY they wanted their idea When Mr. Abara asked why, they saw that both of their reasons could fit in one project.
  8. Agreeing with each other was unfamiliar and new to them They had always disagreed, so agreeing felt unusual, like shoes that do not feel like yours.
  9. The baking soda plants would grow tallest Ben guessed baking soda plants would grow tallest, "because baking soda is in cake."
  10. They are working together and even having fun Zara writes the numbers, Ben draws pictures, and they start to have fun together.
  11. They were closest to the heater, which dried them out The water and vinegar cups were next to the heater. The heat dried them out.
  12. They did not keep everything the same, so the results are not fair A fair test changes only one variable. The heater added a second difference, temperature.
  13. To make the mistake the main part of their project Ben said, "What if the mistake IS the project?"
  14. Plants near the heater drooped, while plants far away stayed green The second test had heater plants and far-away plants with the same water. The heater ones drooped.
  15. What you decide after looking at the results A conclusion is what you figure out at the end after studying your data.
  16. She recognized that real scientists have failed experiments too She said hundreds of her own experiments failed. She liked that they were honest.
  17. Mistakes can lead to learning, and working together makes us stronger Zara and Ben learned from their mistake and became a team. That is the heart of the story.

More 3rd grade stories

🐝

The Bee Hotel

For her science project, Ruby wants to help bees. But she learns that most bees don't live in hives or make honey at all. They live alone, in tiny tunnels. So Ruby…

3rd gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxNature · Science16 questions
♟️

The Chess Champion

Oliver always loses at everything. Then, after school one day, he sees the quiet custodian, Mr. Abara, playing chess alone. Mr. Abara offers to teach him. Soon Oliver…

3rd gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxSchool · Friends16 questions
🐈

The Lighthouse Kitten

Nora spends the summer with her aunt, the keeper of an old lighthouse on a rocky island. When a tiny kitten appears on the rocks during a storm warning, Nora must be…

3rd gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxAnimals · Adventure17 questions
🦉

The Not-So-Haunted Bookshop

Everyone on Harbor Street says the old bookshop is haunted. Customers hear hooting, scratching, and thumps in the night, and books fall off the shelves by themselves.…

3rd gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxMystery16 questions
🐢

The Desert Tortoise

Diego thinks the Arizona desert is empty and boring. Then, on a hot road, he finds a desert tortoise in danger. To help it, he has to learn how anything can survive in…

3rd gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxAnimals · Nature16 questions
🥔

Potatoes on Mars

In the year 2089, eleven-year-old Kaia lives in Red Rock Colony on Mars. Her job is to help in the greenhouse, where the colony grows its food. When a dust storm knocks…

3rd gradeLevel 4 · Swift FoxSci-fi · Science16 questions